[Federal Register Volume 61, Number 120 (Thursday, June 20, 1996)] [Notices] [Pages 31521-31522] From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov] [FR Doc No: 96-15688] ----------------------------------------------------------------------- DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY [Docket No. RM96-5-001] Gas Pipeline Facilities and Services on the Outer Continental Shelf--Issues Related to the Commission's Jurisdiction Under the Natural Gas Act and the Outer Continental Shelf Lands Act; Order Dismissing Requests for Rehearing Issued: June 14, 1996. On February 28, 1996, the Commission issued a Statement of Policy (policy statement) in this proceeding which reviewed issues concerning the status, scope and effect of its regulation of gathering and transportation on the Outer Continental Shelf (OCS).\1\ The policy statement articulated, clarified and, to some extent, modified the criteria the Commission will use to determine whether pipeline facilities located on the OCS have a primary function of gathering or transmission. Specifically, the Commission added a new factor to its existing primary function test for facilities located in water depths of 200 meters or more. The Commission stated that such facilities would be presumed to have a primary purpose of gathering up to the point or points of potential connection with the interstate pipeline grid. From that point on, the Commission would continue to apply the existing primary function test. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\ 74 FERC para. 61,076 (1996), 61 FR 8611 (March 5, 1996). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Four parties filed requests for rehearing and/or clarification or reconsideration.\2\ As discussed below, the Commission will dismiss the requests for rehearing, reconsideration or clarification. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \2\ They are: BP Exploration & Oil, Inc. (BP), Columbia Gas Transmission Corporation and Columbia Gulf Transmission Company (Columbia) (filing jointly), the Interstate Natural Gas Association of America (INGAA), and Williams Field Services Group, Inc. and Transcontinental Gas Pipe Line Corporation (Williams) (filing jointly). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Summary of the Requests The following issues were raised by one or more of the parties in their requests for rehearing, reconsideration and/or clarification. The parties seek assurance that the Commission in the policy statement did not intend to create a presumption that all facilities located in water depths of less than 200 meters are transmission. They contend that the ``bright line'' test or new factor added to the primary function test for deep water facilities is inconsistent with Commission policy as articulated in Amerada Hess Corporation (Amerada Hess).\3\ Additionally, some parties argue that any presumption or bright line test is inconsistent with EP Operating Co. v. FERC,\4\ which mandates a case-by-case application of the physical factors of the primary function test. Some parties note that many certificated offshore facilities are not necessarily transmission facilities and that the Commission did not scrutinize the function of such facilities when certificating them. Thus, these parties argue that the Commission has no rational basis for determining that pipelines are transmission facilities because of their proximity to certificated interstate pipelines when the ``in-proximity'' facilities may be misfunctionalized. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \3\ 52 FERC para. 61,268 (1990). In Amerada Hess, the Commission stated it would consider the changing technical and geographic nature of exploration and production offshore when applying the primary function test to offshore facilities. Amerada Hess provided for a ``sliding scale'' approach where facilities with increasing length and diameters could still be classified as gathering where these physical factors are a function of the distance from shore and of the water depth of production areas. \4\ 876 F. 2d 46 (5th Cir. 1989). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- The parties also contend that the distinction between deep and shallow-water facilities articulated in the policy statement results in determinations of primary function based on a pipeline's vintage (older offshore pipelines tend to be in shallower waters and were certificated) or geographical location, rather than on the physical factors applied in the traditional primary function test. Other parties express concern that the new approach outlined in the policy statement will result in the Commission's giving undue weight to certain factors of the primary function test, such as size, operating pressure and central point in the field, when attempting to determine the function of facilities located in shallower water. They posit that this occurred in Shell Gas Pipeline Company,\5\ where the Commission applied the approach outlined in the policy statement for the first time. Overemphasizing these factors for offshore facilities, they argue, is inconsistent with Amerada Hess and subsequent cases where the sliding scale approach was used. Additionally, they argue that the new approach can result in a single line being considered both gathering and transmission, which would be arbitrary and capricious. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \5\ 74 FERC para. 61,219 (1996). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Some parties are primarily concerned that the policy statement did not resolve issues related to whether there is a level playing field for regulated and unregulated offshore pipelines. Columbia argues that the Commission erred by not deciding to regulate all offshore pipelines under the Outer Continental Shelf Lands Act and by leaving a dual regulatory scheme in place. Further, Columbia asserts that the Commission erred by not initiating a generic production area rate design proceeding to address the issues raised by the commenters in this proceeding. INGAA maintains that the ability of interstate pipelines to utilize alternative ratemaking approaches does not solve the problems of the dual regulatory scheme, and that the Commission erred in the policy statement by so suggesting. Finally, clarification is sought that the policy statement was intended to provide guidance and not intended to have the force and effect of a rule. Discussion The purpose of the policy statement in this proceeding was to provide the natural gas industry with guidance by stating the criteria the Commission will use to determine the function of offshore pipelines, especially new facilities constructed in deep water producing areas. A policy statement is not a rule, and generally objections to such a statement are not directly reviewable.\6\ Rather, such review must await implementation of the policy in a specific case.\7\ Therefore, the Commission declines to consider at this time the issues raised in the requests for [[Page 31522]] rehearing, reconsideration or clarification, but will consider such issues and arguments in the specific cases where the policy is applied. In this regard, we note that many of the issues raised in the requests for rehearing in this proceeding are raised in the rehearing requests filed in Shell Gas Pipeline Company.\8\ Therefore, we are dismissing the requests for rehearing, reconsideration or clarification filed in this proceeding. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \6\ See, eg., Alternatives to Traditional Cost-of-Service Ratemaking for Natural Gas Pipelines, 75 FERC para. 61,024 (1996). \7\ See American Gas Association v. FERC, 888 F. 2d 136 (D.C. Cir. 1989). \8\ Supra. note 5. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- By the Commission. Linwood A. Watson, Jr., Acting Secretary. [FR Doc. 96-15688 Filed 6-19-96; 8:45 am] BILLING CODE 6717-01-M
Document
Gas Pipeline Facilities and Services on the Outer Continental ShelfIssues Related to the Commission's Jurisdiction Under the Natural Gas Act and the Outer Continental Shelf Lands Act; Order Dismissing Requests for Rehearing
[Federal Register Volume 61, Number 120 (Thursday, June 20, 1996)] [Notices] [Pages 31521-31522] From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [ www.gpo....
Legal Citation
Federal Register Citation
Use this for formal legal and research references to the published document.
61 FR 31521
Web Citation
Suggested Web Citation
Use this when citing the archival web version of the document.
“Gas Pipeline Facilities and Services on the Outer Continental ShelfIssues Related to the Commission's Jurisdiction Under the Natural Gas Act and the Outer Continental Shelf Lands Act; Order Dismissing Requests for Rehearing,” thefederalregister.org (June 20, 1996), https://thefederalregister.org/documents/96-15688/gas-pipeline-facilities-and-services-on-the-outer-continental-shelfissues-related-to-the-commission-s-jurisdiction-under.