The Bureau of Land Management (BLM) is amending its right-of- way regulations to update the linear right-of-way rent schedule in 43 CFR parts 2800 and 2880. The rent schedule co...
The Bureau of Land Management (BLM) is amending its right-of-way regulations to update the linear right-of-way rent schedule in 43 CFR parts 2800 and 2880. The rent schedule covers most linear rights-of-way granted under Title V of the Federal Land Policy and Management Act of 1976, as amended (FLPMA), and Section 28 of the Mineral Leasing Act of 1920, as amended (MLA). Those laws require the holder of a right-of-way grant to pay annually, in advance, the fair market value to occupy, use, or traverse public lands for facilities such as power lines, fiber optic lines, pipelines, roads, and ditches.
Section 367 of the Energy Policy Act of 2005 (the Act) directs the Secretary of the Interior to update the per acre rent schedule found in 43 CFR 2806.20. The Act requires that the BLM revise the per acre rental fee zone value schedule by state, county, and type of linear right-of-way use to reflect current land values in each zone. The Act also requires the Secretary of Agriculture (Forest Service) to make the same revisions for rights-of-way on National Forest System (NFS) lands.
DATES:
This final rule is effective December 1, 2008.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
For information on the substance of the final rule, please contact Bil Weigand at (208) 373-3862 or Rick Stamm at (202) 452-5185. For information on procedural matters, please contact Ian Senio at (202) 452-5049. Persons who use a telecommunications device for the deaf (TDD) may call the Federal Information Relay Service (FIRS) at 1-800-877-8339 to contact the above individuals during business hours. FIRS is available twenty-four hours a day, seven days a week, to leave a message or question with the above individuals. You will receive a reply during normal business hours.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
I. Background
II. Final Rule as Adopted and Response to Comments
III. Procedural Matters
I. Background
Statutory:
Section 367 of the Act, entitled “Fair Market Value Determinations for Linear Rights-of-Way Across Public Lands and National Forests,” directs the Secretary of the Interior to: (1) Update 43 CFR 2806.20, which contains the per acre rent schedule for linear rights-of-way; and (2) Revise the per acre rental fee zone value schedule by state, county, and type of linear right-of-way uses to reflect current values of land in each zone. In addition, pursuant to section 367(a) and (b), the Secretary of Agriculture is adopting BLM's rent schedule in 43 CFR subpart 2806, as updated by Section 367, for linear rights-of-way granted, issued, or renewed for use of National Forest System lands under Title V of FLPMA or Section 28 of the MLA.
Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking:
The BLM published an advance notice of proposed rulemaking (ANPR) in the
Federal Register
on April 27, 2006 (71 FR 24836). The comment period for the ANPR ended on May 30, 2006. The purpose of the ANPR was to encourage members of the public to provide comments and suggestions to help with updating the BLM's and the Forest Service's (FS) rent schedule, as described in the Act. The BLM received ten responses to the ANPR, including comments on six specific questions posed there. The BLM utilized the comments received from the ANPR extensively in the development of the proposed and final rule.
Proposed Rule:
The BLM published a proposed rule in the
Federal Register
on December 11, 2007 (72 FR 70376). The comment period for the proposed rule ended on February 11, 2008. The purpose of the proposed rule was to provide members of the public an opportunity to comment on the BLM's proposal to update the linear rent schedule, as described in the Act. The BLM received twelve responses to the proposed rule, including comments on six specific questions posed there. The BLM utilized the comments received on the proposed rule extensively in the development of the final rule.
Previous (1987) Linear Rent Schedule:
On July 8, 1987, and September 30, 1987, the BLM published regulations establishing rent schedules for linear rights-of-way granted under Section 28 of the MLA and Title V of FLPMA (52 FR 25818 and 52 FR 36576). The FS used these same schedules to charge rent for rights-of-way across NFS lands. The update to these previous schedules contained in this final rule also affects the FS and users of NFS lands.
The 1987 rent schedule was developed to set fair market rent and minimize the need for individual real estate appraisals for each right-of-way requiring rent payments, as well as to avoid the costs, delays, and unpredictability of the appraisal process in reasonably setting fair market rent.
The 1987 rent schedule established eight fee zones based on the distribution of average land values by county in Puerto Rico and in each of the states, except Alaska and Hawaii. (The 1987 rent schedule did not apply to Alaska and Hawaii; however, the rent schedule in this final rule applies to all 50 states and the commonwealth of Puerto Rico. Linear right-of-way rental fees in Alaska were previously determined on a case-by-case basis based on local market values. There are no linear rights-of-way in Hawaii currently administered by either the BLM or the FS). Under the 1987 regulations, a county was assigned to one of the eight zone values, based on average land values in the county: lower-value counties were assigned lower-numbered zones. The eight zone values contained in the 1987 schedule were set at $50, $100, $200, $300, $400, $500, $600, and $1,000 per acre. A county's zone value was translated into a per acre zone rent by use of the adjustment formula described below. To calculate the annual right-of-way rental payment, the zone rent was multiplied by the total acreage within the right-of-way. The formula for zone rent was:
The zone value term in the formula was the land value that was established for each of the eight zones. The zone values established in 1987 were never updated, although it is generally recognized that land values increased significantly in most areas from 1987 to the present.
The impact adjustment term (or encumbrance factor) in the formula reflected the differences in land-use impacts between: (1) Oil, gas, and other energy-related pipelines, roads, ditches, and canals; and (2) Electrical transmission and distribution lines, telephone lines, and non-energy related pipelines. Energy-related pipelines and roads were considered as having a greater surface disturbance impact on the land, and were adjusted to 80 percent of the zone value. Electrical transmission and distribution lines, phone lines, and non-energy related pipelines with a smaller area of disturbance were adjusted to 70 percent of the zone value.
( printed page 65041)
The Treasury Security term in the formula reflected a reasonable rate of return to the United States for the use of the land within the right-of-way. The 1987 regulations were based on a rate of return of 6.41 percent for a 1-year Treasury Security.
The zone rent was adjusted annually by the change in the Gross Domestic Product, Implicit Price Deflator index.
BLM Right-of-Way Program and Revenues:
The BLM administers 96,000 rights-of-way, of which 66,000 are authorized under FLPMA and 30,000 are authorized under the MLA. However, only 48,600 are subject to a rental payment. Wyoming and New Mexico together account for slightly more than 30,000 of the rights-of-way subject to rent. The BLM collected approximately $20.6 million in right-of-way rental receipts for fiscal year 2007. This total includes receipts from both linear and site-type rights-of-way. Seventy-seven percent of all right-of-way rent receipts were collected by five BLM State Offices. These five State Offices and the revenues collected are listed in Table 1.
Table 1—Right-of-Way Rental Receipts for “Top Five” BLM State Offices
State office
Total rental
receipts
(FY 2007)
Nevada
$4,386,150
Wyoming
4,086,382
California
3,210,892
New Mexico
2,669,556
Arizona
1,408,414
Total
15,761,394
Rent receipts from communication uses, which have their own rent schedule, totaled approximately $5 million, while receipts from other site-type rights-of-way, which normally require an appraisal to determine rent, and/or initial ad hoc billings, totaled approximately $9 million.
In fiscal year 2007, the BLM collected $6.5 million total rent for 12,545 linear rights-of-ways using the previous schedule. Of this amount, only 133 bills (for $52,400) were for rental payment periods (the length of time for which the holder is paying rent) of less than 1 year. The largest number of bills (5,864) was issued for one-year rental payment periods. The rent collected from these one-year bills totaled $4,781,000 ($815 per bill) and included approximately $852,000 for linear rights-of-way located in high value areas, such as in Clark County, Nevada, near the city of Las Vegas. The rent for these bills was generated using a similar methodology as the linear rent schedule, but was calculated using higher land values supported by appraisal data (used to develop “unique zones” with annual per acre rent values ranging from $280 to $6,000). Another 4,993 bills were issued for $133,172, covering a 5-year rental payment period. The average 5-year bill totaled $27, or less than $6 per bill on an annual basis. Lastly, a total of $89,000 was billed for rental payment periods of between 6 and 30 years.
To summarize, in fiscal year 2007 the BLM collected a total of $20.6 million in right-of-way rent receipts, but of that only $5.6 million was calculated using the previous Per Acre Rent Schedule. Another $852,000 was calculated using similar methodology as the Per Acre Rent Schedule, but was calculated using higher land values (unique zones) supported by appraisal data. In addition, over half of all bills generated for linear right-of-way grants in fiscal year 2007 were for multi-year periods of 2 years or more.
Interagency Coordination:
The United States Department of Agriculture, Forest Service (FS), will adopt without rulemaking the revisions to the linear right-of-way rent schedule at 43 CFR 2806.20 promulgated by the BLM through this final rule. To enhance consistency between the BLM and the FS, the FS has indicated that it will incorporate some of the procedural or otherwise nonsubstantive changes into its directive system. The FS will be publishing a notice of its adoption of BLM's rental schedule pursuant to this rule and its incorporation of other changes in subpart 2806.
II. Final Rule as Adopted and Response to Comments
Part 2800 Rights-of-Way Under FLPMA
The BLM is amending the Per Acre Rent Schedule in its right-of-way regulations in 43 CFR parts 2800 and 2880. The rent schedule covers most linear rights-of-way granted under Title V of FLPMA and Section 28 of the MLA. These laws require the holder of a right-of-way grant to pay annually, in advance, the fair market value to occupy, use, or traverse public lands for facilities such as power lines, fiber optic lines, pipelines, roads, and ditches.
As mentioned above, the Act directs the Secretary of the Interior to update the per acre rent schedule in the BLM's previous regulations at 43 CFR 2806.20. The Act specifically requires that the BLM revise the per acre rental fee zone value schedule by state, county, and type of linear right-of-way use to reflect current land values in each zone. The Per Acre Rent Schedule applies to linear rights-of-way the BLM issues under 43 CFR parts 2800 and 2880. So as not to be redundant, we discuss the components and application of the rent schedule primarily in part 2800 and will not repeat those discussions in part 2880. However, we will note any differences in part 2880 that are necessary based upon specific statutory provisions of the MLA.
In addition to revising the Per Acre Rent Schedule, the final rule makes minor amendments to parts 2800 and 2880 to bring the previous regulations into compliance with the statutory rent schedule changes. Finally, there are a number of minor corrections and changes in the final rule that are not directly related to the rent schedule. These changes are limited in scope and address trespass and the new rental payments, land status changes, annual rental payments, MLA hardship provisions, and reimbursements of monitoring costs and processing fees. These latter items correct some errors in the previous regulations and clarify others. This final rule:
(1) Makes clear that the rent exemptions listed in section 2806.14 do not apply if the applicant/holder is in trespass;
(2) Provides that only the Per Acre Rent Schedule will be used to determine rent for linear right-of-way grants, unless the land encumbered by the grant is to be transferred out of Federal ownership;
(3) Provides for an annual rent payment term when the annual rent for non-individuals is $500 or more;
(4) Provides for a one-time rent payment for grants and easements when the land encumbered by the grant or easement is to be transferred out of Federal ownership;
(5) Provides for a limited phase-in provision to all holders for calendar year 2009, and, a possible additional phase-in period upon revision of the rent schedule under sections 2806.22(b) and 2885.19(a);
(6) Revises section 2920.6 to require reimbursement of processing and monitoring costs under sections 2804.14 and 2805.16 for applications for leases and permits issued under Title III of FLPMA;
(7) Amends section 2920.8(b) to assess a non-refundable processing fee and monitoring fee under sections 2804.14 and 2805.16 for each request for renewal, transfer, or assignment of a lease or easement;
(8) Amends sections 2805.11(b)(2) and 2885.11(a) so that all grants, except those issued for a term of 3 years or less and those issued in perpetuity under
( printed page 65042)
FLPMA, expire on December 31 of the final year of the grant; and
(9) Amends sections 2805.14(f) and 2885.12(e) to make it clear that you may assign your grant, without the BLM's prior written approval, if your authorization so provides.
We received many comments on the proposed rule that addressed issues common to both the part 2800 and part 2880 regulations. So as not to be redundant, we address the comments only in the section they pertain to in the part 2800 regulations. Comments that specifically address the part 2880 regulations are discussed in that section of the preamble.
Subpart 2805—Terms and Conditions of Grants
The BLM is making two minor amendments in 2 sections in subpart 2805, which addresses the terms and conditions of FLPMA right-of-way authorizations.
Section 2805.11 What does a grant contain?
Previous section 2805.11(b)(2) stated that all grants, except those issued for a term of less than 1 year and those issued in perpetuity, expire on December 31 of the final year of the grant. The BLM uses the calendar year, not the fiscal year or the anniversary date, to establish the rental period for grants. Expiration of grants on December 31 allows for consistency and ease of administration, because after the initial billing period only full calendar years are included in subsequent billing periods. However, the BLM often issues short-term right-of-way grants for 3 years or less to allow the holder to conduct temporary activities on public land. Previous section 2806.23(b) and final section 2806.24(c) both explain that the BLM considers the first partial calendar year in the rent payment period to be the first year of the rental term. Therefore, under previous section 2805.11(b)(2), a 3-year grant actually had a term period of 2 years plus the time period remaining in the calendar year of issuance. A 2-year grant had a term period of 1 year plus the time period remaining in the calendar year of issuance. Depending on when the grant was issued, the actual term could have been just over 2 years for a 3-year grant and could have been just over 1 year for a 2-year grant. Under the final rule, all grants, except those issued for a term of 3 years or less and those issued in perpetuity, expire on December 31 of the final year of the grant. The changes to this section allow holders to use short-term grants for the full period of the grant. For example, if a 3-year grant is issued under the final rule on October 1, 2008, it would expire on September 30, 2011, instead of December 31, 2010, under the previous rule. If a 2-year grant is issued under the final rule on October 1, 2008, it expires on September 30, 2010, instead of December 31, 2009, under the previous rule. In most cases, the BLM would assess a one-time rental bill for the term of the grant, which would reduce any administrative impact which might otherwise result from this change. We received no comments on the proposed changes to this section, and the final rule adopts the proposed section without change.
Section 2805.14 What rights does a grant convey?
Previous section 2805.14(f) stated that you had a right to assign your grant to another, provided that you obtained the BLM's prior written approval. The BLM proposed adding the phrase “unless your grant specifically states that such approval is unnecessary” at the end of this sentence to indicate that BLM's prior written approval may be unnecessary in certain cases. In most cases, assignments would continue to be subject to the BLM's written approval. However, with this change, the BLM could amend existing grants to allow future assignments without the BLM's prior written approval. This may be especially important to the future administration of a grant when the land encumbered by a grant is being transferred out of Federal ownership, and there is a request to convert an existing grant to an easement or a perpetual grant under section 2807.15(c). We received no comments on the proposed changes to this section and the final rule adopts the proposed section without change.
Subpart 2806—Rents
Sections 2806.10 through 2806.16 of subpart 2806 contain general rent provisions that apply to grants. No changes were proposed to these general provisions except to section 2806.14.
Section 2806.14 Under what circumstances am I exempt from paying rent?
Previous section 2806.14 identified those circumstances where a holder or facility is exempt from paying rent. None of the previous circumstances change under the final rule. We have, however, added a provision (final section 2806.14(b)) that states that the exemptions in this section do not apply if you are in trespass. The addition of this provision makes it clear that the penalties specified in subpart 2808—Trespass, which include the assessment of rent for use of the public land, and possible additional penalties based upon the rent value, apply to all entities in trespass, even those entities that may otherwise be exempt from paying rent under section 2806.14. This is consistent with how trespass penalties are assessed under current policy, and provides for consistency with similar provisions in subpart 2888—Trespass. Current section 2888.10(c) states that the BLM will administer trespass actions for MLA grants and temporary use permits (TUPs) as set forth in sections 2808.10(c) and 2808.11, except that the rental exemption provisions of part 2800 do not apply to grants issued under part 2880. Adding a new provision at section 2806.14(b) makes it clear that the rental exemption provisions do not apply to trespass situations covered under subpart 2808, as they likewise do not apply to trespass situations covered under subpart 2888. The final rule removes the existing phrase “except that the rental exemption provisions of part 2800 (section 2806.14) do not apply to grants issued under this part” from section 2888.10(c), because the cross reference is no longer necessary (see preamble discussion for proposed section 2888.10(c)). We received no comments on the proposed changes to this section and the final rule adopts the proposed section without change.
Section 2806.20 What is the rent for a linear right-of-way grant?
This section explains that the BLM will use the Per Acre Rent Schedule, except as described in section 2806.26, to calculate annual rent for linear right-of-way grants. The per acre rent from the schedule (for all types of linear right-of-way facilities regardless of the granting authority, e.g., FLPMA, MLA, and their predecessors) is the product of 4 factors: The per acre zone value multiplied by the encumbrance factor multiplied by the rate of return multiplied by the annual adjustment factor. The following discussion explains how the BLM adjusted these factors in the previous and proposed Per Acre Rent Schedule to arrive at the Per Acre Rent Schedule in the final rule, including the determination of per acre land values by county, as directed by the Act.
Use of a Schedule
Section 367 of the Act directs the Secretary of the Interior to “revise the per acre rental fee zone value schedule by State, county, and type of linear right-of-way use to reflect current values of land in each zone.” Therefore, the final rule retains the use of a schedule
( printed page 65043)
and no alternative rental fee options were considered.
County Land Values—Use of Published Data
In the 1987 rent schedule, the average per acre land value for each county was based upon a review of the typical per acre value for the types of lands that the BLM and the FS had allocated to various utility and right-of-way facilities. These values were mapped, reviewed, and adjusted, resulting in the placement of each county (except Coconino County, Arizona, which was split by the Colorado River) in one of eight zones ranging in value from $50 to $1,000 per acre.
In the ANPR, the BLM requested comments regarding what available published information, statistical data, or reports the BLM should use to update the current linear right-of-way rental fee zone values. The BLM stated in the ANPR that it was considering using existing published information or statistical data for updating the rent schedule, such as information published by the National Agricultural Statistics Service (NASS). The NASS publishes two reports:
(1) The Census of Agriculture, published every 5 years (NASS Census); and
(2) The annual Land Values and Cash Rents Summary (Annual Report).
The NASS Census provides average per acre land and building values by county, or other geographical areas, for each state. The land values are reported individually for cropland (including irrigated and non-irrigated cropland), woodland, pastureland, and rangeland, and an “other” category that includes non-commercial, non-residential building lots, wasteland, and land with roads and ponds. The average per acre land and building values do not include any value for the crop, forage, or woodland products produced from the land.
The NASS data in the Annual Report, as compared to the data in the NASS Census (see previous paragraph), includes average per acre values for cropland, pastureland, and farm real estate, but only on a regional or statewide basis, and not on a countywide basis. Another difference between the Annual Report and the NASS Census is the absence of any data for Alaska, Hawaii, and Puerto Rico in the Annual Report. You can find more detailed information about the NASS Census and the Annual Report at the NASS Web site at:
www.nass.usda.gov/index.asp.
The BLM received four comments in response to our request in the ANPR for comment on the use of available published information. One commenter said that the NASS data is appropriate. Two commenters recommended using the NASS Census of Agriculture (5-year census) for county-level data. One commenter stated that the NASS data seems appropriate for updating the schedule, so long as agricultural uses are not reflected in the land values used.
In the development of the proposed rule, the BLM generally agreed with the commenters on the ANPR that supported the use of the NASS Census data to determine the average per acre value for each county, except for the commenter that supported its use so long as agricultural uses are not reflected in the land values used. The NASS publishes average per acre land and building values, by state and county, each 5-year period in its NASS Census report. The most recent county values are from the 2002 NASS Census, which was published in June 2004. The next NASS Census report will provide 2007 data, and it is due to be published in June 2009. However, the NASS county per acre land and building value data is reflective of the types of agricultural uses generally occurring in that county, including land value data reported for cropland (including irrigated and non-irrigated cropland), woodland, pastureland, and rangeland, and an “other” category that includes non-commercial, non-residential building lots, wasteland, and land with roads and ponds. Land administered by the BLM and FS have many of the same agricultural values (grazing, commercial timber production, woodland and vegetative sales (Christmas trees, firewood, mushrooms, pine nuts, seed crops from native species, etc.). The average per acre land and building values do not include any value for the crop, forage, or woodland product produced from the land. In the proposed rule, we further explained that other Federal and state agencies regularly use the NASS Census data when it is necessary to obtain average per acre land value for a particular state or county. In addition, Congress specifically endorsed the use of this data for rental determination purposes when it passed the “National Forest Organizational Camp Fee Improvement Act of 2003” (Pub. L. 108-7) (16 U.S.C. 6231). This law established a formula for determining rent for organizational camps located on NFS lands by applying a 5 percent rate of return to the average per acre land and building value, by state and county, as reported in the most recent NASS Census. That law also provided for a process to update the per acre land values annually based on the change in per acre land value, by county, from one census period to another. The law does not mandate the use of zones or a schedule, which eliminates the need for an annual index adjustment to keep the schedule or zones current. However, the range between the high and low county values which results from using the components mandated under Public Law 108-7, including the use of a 100 percent encumbrance factor, is significantly greater than the range between the high and low zone values which result from using the components established under either the proposed or final rule.
The proposed rule used the entire average per acre land and building value (by state and county) from the 2002 NASS Census to place the county or geographical area into the proper zone value in the rent schedule. We used the entire average per acre land and building value to be consistent with how Congress used the same data in determining annual per acre rent for organizational camps located on NFS lands as described above. We also used the entire per acre land and building value from the NASS Census because both BLM and FS lands have many of the same agricultural values reflected in the NASS Census data.
The BLM received several comments on the proposed rule's use of the entire average per acre land and building value (by state and county) from the NASS Census to place the county or geographical area into the proper zone value in the rent schedule. The majority of the commenters stated that the average per acre land and building value should be reduced to remove land with buildings or other improvements, but offered no recommendations on how this should be accomplished. Some of the commenters stated that irrigated cropland should also be removed from the average per acre land and building value, pointing out that in most cases the average per acre value of irrigated land is significantly higher than non-irrigated land. These commenters recommended reducing the average per acre land and building value in the NASS Census by 50 percent, but offered no data to support a 50 percent reduction, except to state that lands administered by the BLM and FS are not used for irrigated cropland production, nor do they contain rural farm buildings, and therefore, the average per acre land and building value should be reduced by at least 50 percent.
We agree that the average per acre land and building value for each county should be reduced by an amount that
( printed page 65044)
reflects the value of irrigated cropland and land encumbered by buildings because BLM- and FS-administered lands do not include these land categories. The BLM consulted with officials from the NASS on an appropriate methodology to arrive at this figure. The NASS advised us that this calculation can be accomplished by comparing the total value of irrigated acres and acres in the “other” category, to the total value of all farmland acres. In 2002, there were a total of 938,300,000 acres of rural farmland, composed of 434,200,000 acres of cropland (50,300 acres irrigated); 395,300,000 acres of pasture/rangeland (5,000,000 acres irrigated); 75,900,000 acres of woodland; and 32,900,000 acres in an “other” category (roads, ponds, wasteland, and land encumbered by non-commercial/non-residential buildings). In 2007, the average per acre value of all land in all categories equaled $2,160 for a total farm real estate value of $2,026,728,000,000. This compares to an average per acre land value of $4,736 for all irrigated cropland (a total value of $261,900,000,000 for the 55.3 million acres of irrigated cropland) or approximately 12.9 percent of the total value of all farmland. Thus, to eliminate the irrigated cropland value from the average per acre land and building value of each county, a 13 percent reduction is necessary.
To determine a similar value for the “building” component of the average per acre land and building value is more difficult, since only the total number of acres in the “other” category is known (32.9 million acres, which includes acres encumbered by roads, ponds, non-commercial/non-residential buildings, and wastelands). In addition, unlike the average per acre values that have been determined by NASS for pastureland/rangeland ($1,160), all cropland ($2,700), irrigated cropland ($4,736) and all farm real estate ($2,160), the average per acre value for the “other” category is not available. However, since the lands in this category are basically non-productive, their average per acre value is likely less than the average per acre value for pastureland/rangeland ($1,160). Even so, if all 32.9 million acres were valued at $1,160 per acre, the total value of all lands in the “other” category would equal $38,164,000,000, or less than 2 percent of the total value of all farm real estate. If all lands in the “other” category are valued the same as irrigated cropland ($4,736), their total value would still only be 7.7 percent of all farm real estate. Therefore, in the final rule we reduced the average per acre land and building value by 20 percent (a 13 percent reduction for all irrigated acres and a 7 percent reduction for all lands in the “other” category which includes all improved land or land encumbered by buildings) to eliminate the value of all land that could possibly be encumbered by buildings or which could possibly have been developed, improved, or irrigated.
One commenter suggested that the value for non-irrigated cropland should also be deleted from the average per acre land and building value because of its commercial nature and its dissimilarity to public and NFS lands. The BLM disagrees with this comment. In the 2007 Annual Report, the NASS provided the average value per acre of non-irrigated land in 20 states, including most of the states in the west with large acreages of public and NFS lands, except for the states of Arizona and Nevada where there is very little cropland that is not irrigated. The average value per acre of non-irrigated land is $1,963, and the average value per acre of pasture land in these same 20 states (excluding Arizona and Nevada) is $1,976. If the average per acre pastureland values were included for Arizona and Nevada, the average value per acre of pasture land for all 22 states is $1,926. Thus, there is little difference in the mid-western and western states between the average per acre values of non-irrigated cropland and pastureland/rangeland. In the eastern United States, Federal land holdings, including NFS lands, have largely been acquired from the private sector (primarily farm real estate) and would likely fall into the same land categories covered by the NASS Census. As a result, no further reductions to the average per acre land and building value (other than the 20 percent reduction discussed above for irrigated lands and buildings) are made in the final rule.
In the ANPR the BLM requested comments regarding whether the proposed Per Acre Rent Schedule should split some states and counties into more than one zone. The BLM received three ANPR comments addressing whether some counties should be split into more than one zone. One commenter said that any consideration of splitting states or counties into more than one zone should involve discussions with stakeholders. One commenter said that zones smaller than a single county may lead to undue administrative burden for the BLM (establishing boundaries and collecting data). For very high-valued lands, rent could be based on 25 percent of the assessed value, according to one commenter. Alternatively, high-valued BLM lands could be sold or exchanged. One commenter said that wide variations in land values within a state or county may require applying the zone methodology at the sub-state or sub-county level. In the proposed rule, the BLM did not split any county into more than one zone because there was no published data, easily obtainable, that would support making such a split. We received one comment on the proposed rule suggesting that multiple zones be established where land values vary greatly within a single county. However, the commenter did not indicate how such variations in land values could be easily obtained or identified within each county entity. The BLM believes that it is not possible to make easy or accurate determinations of variations in land values within each county, and therefore the final rule does not split any county into more than one zone.
The BLM also requested in the ANPR comments regarding whether the proposed Per Acre Rent Schedule should apply to Alaska. One commenter stated that the new linear right-of-way rent schedule should apply to public and NFS lands in Alaska if similar published data for land values is available for Alaska as for the lower 48 states and the data produces a reasonable per acre rental value. As a result, we proposed that the schedule apply to Alaska since the NASS Census does include average per acre land and building values for 5 Alaska areas: Fairbanks; Anchorage; Kenai Peninsula; Aleutian Islands; and Juneau. These NASS data produce a reasonable per acre rental value and are comparable to the per acre rental values from contracted appraisals and/or local rent schedules now in effect in some BLM and FS offices. The NASS Census data does not define the actual boundaries for the 5 areas, and therefore we specifically asked for comments to assist the BLM and the FS in determining and identifying the on-the-ground area to be included in each of the 5 Alaska areas in the NASS Census. For example, the NASS Census average per acre land and building value for the Fairbanks “area” could be used for all public lands administered by the BLM Fairbanks District Office and the NASS Census average per acre land and building value for the Anchorage “area” could apply to all public lands administered by the BLM Anchorage District Office, and so forth. Another approach, which both the BLM and the FS prefer, would be to identify specific geographic or management areas and apply the most appropriate per acre land and building value from the 5 Alaska NASS Census areas to the BLM/FS identified
( printed page 65045)
geographic or management areas based on similar landscapes and/or similar average per acre land values. The proposed rule stated that the FS planned to use the NASS census data for the Kenai Peninsula for all NFS lands in Alaska, except for NFS lands located in the Anchorage and Juneau areas. For NFS lands located in the Municipality of Anchorage, the NASS Census data for the Anchorage area would apply. For NFS lands in the downtown Juneau area (Juneau voting precincts 1, 2, and 3), the NASS Census data for the Juneau area would apply.
The BLM received 2 comments on how the NASS Census data should be applied to public and NFS lands in Alaska. Both commenters generally supported the methodology of the proposed per acre rent schedule (with minor exceptions), but varied slightly in the geographical application of the five NASS Census areas for Alaska. One commenter agreed with the proposal of using the NASS Census data for the Kenai Peninsula for all NFS lands in Alaska, except for NFS lands located in the Anchorage and Juneau area. The commenter stated that for NFS lands located in the Municipality of Anchorage, the NASS Census data for the Anchorage area should apply, and for NFS lands in the downtown Juneau area, the NASS Census data for the Juneau area should apply. For the BLM, the commenter proposed that the NASS Census data for the Kenai Peninsula (Zone 4) apply to all public lands within the BLM Anchorage District boundaries, except for public lands in the Anchorage (Zone 6 in the proposed rule; Zone 5 in the final rule due to the 20 percent reduction in the average per acre land and building value—see discussion above), Juneau (Zone 11), and the Aleutian Island Chain (Zone 1) areas. The commenter said that for public lands located in the Municipality of Anchorage, the NASS Census data for the Anchorage area (Zone 5 in the final rule) should apply and for public lands in the downtown Juneau area (Juneau voting precincts 1,2, and 3), the NASS Census data for the Juneau area (Zone 11) should apply. For public lands in the Aleutian Island Chain, the NASS Census data for the Aleutian Islands Area (Zone 1) should apply. In addition, the NASS Census data for the Fairbanks Area (Zone 3) should apply to all public lands within the BLM Fairbanks District boundaries. The commenter stated that these zone definitions and values would be consistent with both the suggestion in the proposed rule and the general fee schedule previously developed by the Appraisal Services Directorate (ASD), Alaska, for the BLM and the United States Fish and Wildlife Service. The BLM agrees with the commenter's suggestions because these zone definitions and values closely match previous rent schedules/values developed by the ASD for these same geographical areas. Therefore, in the final rule the BLM will apply the NASS Census data for Alaska to the geographical and administrative areas as follows:
Aleutian Islands Area—all lands within the Aleutian Islands Chain—Zone 1;
Fairbanks Area—all lands within the BLM Fairbanks District boundaries—Zone 3;
Kenai Peninsula Area—all lands within the BLM Anchorage District boundaries excluding the Aleutian Islands Chain, the Anchorage Area, and the Juneau Area—Zone 4;
Anchorage Area—all lands within the Municipality of Anchorage—Zone 5; and
Juneau Area—all lands within downtown Juneau (Juneau voting precincts 1, 2 and 3)—Zone 11.
The second commenter, while disagreeing with some of the individual elements in the formula, stated that the rent formula, when taken as a whole, is well structured and should be extended, as described, to Alaska. This commenter did note, however, that the 2002 appraisal completed for the Trans-Alaska Pipeline System (TAPS) right-of-way set a $391 per acre land value for Federal lands north of the Yukon River and suggested that the BLM use this as justification to place these lands into Zone 2 instead of Zone 3, as proposed. We do not dispute the per acre value of Federal lands north of the Yukon River as determined by the 2002 TAPS appraisal. We do, however, note that in arriving at an annual per acre rental value for these lands, the 2002 TAPS appraisal utilized an encumbrance factor of 100 percent (later reduced to approximately 86.49 percent) and an 8 percent rate of return. When taken together, these components of the TAPS appraisal produced an annual per acre rental value of approximately $31 (later reduced to $27) for Federal lands north of the Yukon River and an average per acre rental value of approximately $35 (later reduced to $30) for all Federal lands along the TAPS corridor. In comparison, the proposed rent schedule would have generated an annual per acre rental value of $32.35 in 2002, while the final rule would have generated $26.35. Therefore, the BLM agrees with the commenter, that while issue can be taken with individual elements of the final per acre rent schedule, when taken as a whole, the schedule is well constructed and produces a reasonable per acre rent for all zones. In the final rule, the TAPS will be assessed Zone 3 rates for all public land acres within the BLM Fairbanks District boundaries, and Zone 4 rates for all public land and NFS land acres within the BLM Anchorage District boundaries and the Chugach National Forest.
Puerto Rico, which has no public lands administered by the BLM, is not divided into counties. However, the NASS publishes average farmland values for the entire Commonwealth of Puerto Rico. The proposed rule stated that the FS planned to use the NASS average farmland values ($5,866 per acre in 2002) for linear right-of-way authorizations located on NFS lands in Puerto Rico. The BLM included this same amount ($5,866 per acre in 2002) for Puerto Rico in the proposed rule for use by the BLM in the event that the BLM were to issue and administer future linear authorizations in Puerto Rico (for example, a MLA grant which involved lands administered by two or more Federal agencies could be issued/administered by the BLM). We received no comments on this issue and made no changes to the final rule.
Per Acre Zone Values
The 1987 linear rent schedule contained eight separate zones representing average per acre land value from $50 per acre to a $1,000 per acre. The schedule contained two zones with a $50 range, five zones with a $100 range, and one zone with a $400 range. All the counties in the 48 contiguous states, except one, and Puerto Rico were in one of the eight zones based on their estimated average per acre land value. The lone exception was Coconino County, Arizona, where the area north of the Colorado River was in one zone, and the area south of the river was in a different zone.
In the ANPR, the BLM requested comments regarding the appropriate number of rental zones for the revised rent schedule, and received three comments. One commenter said that the number of zones (8) in the current schedule is sufficient. Two commenters said that the number of zones should not be changed, unless the NASS Census data indicates the need for a change.
In the proposed rule, the number of zones was increased from the previous 8 to 12 in order to accommodate the range of 3,080 county land values contained in the NASS Census. For the same reason, it was necessary to increase the dollar value per zone. In
( printed page 65046)
the 2002 NASS Census, the county land and building value per acre ranged from a low of $75 to a high of $98,954. To accommodate such a wide range in average per acre land values, the BLM proposed 2 zones with $250 increments, 3 zones with $500 increments, 1 zone with a $1,000 increment, 1 zone with a $2,000 increment, 1 zone with a $5,000 increment, 2 zones with $10,000 increments, 1 zone with a $20,000 increment, and 1 zone with a $50,000 increment (see Table 2—Zone Thresholds).
Table 2—Zone Thresholds
Zone
2002 county land and building value
Zone 1
$1 to $250.
Zone 2
$251 to $500.
Zone 3
$501 to $1,000.
Zone 4
$1,001 to $1,500.
Zone 5
$1,501 to $2,000.
Zone 6
$2,001 to $3,000.
Zone 7
$3,001 to $5,000.
Zone 8
$5,001 to $10,000.
Zone 9
$10,001 to $20,000.
Zone 10
$20,001 to $30,000.
Zone 11
$30,001 to $50,000.
Zone 12
$50,001 to $100,000.
The proposed rule's zones accommodate the per acre land and building values of 100 percent of the total number of counties in the 2002 NASS Census (see Table 3). As land values increase or decrease, it may be necessary to adjust the number of zones and/or the dollar value per zone. The proposed rule allowed adjustments to the number of zones and/or the dollar value per zone after the publication of every other NASS Census (once each ten-year period). The adjustments must accommodate 100 percent of the county per acre land and building values reflected in the 5-Year Census. In the proposed rule, the BLM specifically asked for comments on whether 100 percent of the counties should be covered by the per acre rent schedule.
The BLM received several comments that supported the number of zones, the zone values, and the placement of all NASS counties within the appropriate zone value. One commenter encouraged the BLM and the FS to verify that the zone values reflect actual undeveloped, non-irrigated land values in rural areas of the country adjacent to the public and NFS lands, to ensure that the land values within each zone are appropriate, and the zones assigned to different counties are accurate. We believe that we have addressed this concern by removing all irrigated land and land encumbered by buildings from the calculation of land value and reducing the average per acre land and building values by 20 percent from those shown in the proposed rule. Even with this reduction, we do not believe that the number of zones or the zone values require adjustment. There are still several counties that would fall into Zone 12, even with the 20 percent reduction.
Another commenter suggested that the BLM should discard the zone brackets entirely and use the actual NASS Census land and building value for each county. The BLM considered this option in the development of the proposed rule, but did not believe it conformed to the Congressional mandate provided in Section 367 of the Act to revise the existing schedule by state, county, and type of uses to reflect current land values in each zone. The commenter also suggested that in lieu of using the actual NASS Census value for each county, the BLM should utilize the midpoint of the zone value to base its calculations instead of the upper limit value of each zone. Again, the BLM considered this option in the development of the proposed rule, but did not adopt it because this calculation change would have been significantly different from the methodology used in the previous schedule (which utilized the upper zone amount and not the midpoint in making the per acre rental calculations) and its use would have generated significantly lower per acre rent amounts, while land values have generally increased. As a result, we made no adjustments to the number of zones in the final rent schedule, the zone amounts, or the methodology used
( printed page 65047)
in the calculation of the per acre rent for each zone.
The 2002 NASS Census per acre land and building value for each county (or similar area) and the corresponding zone number in the Per Acre Rent Schedule (based on 80 percent of the 2002 NASS Census per acre land and building value for each county) are listed for informational purposes at the end of this final rule. Most of the areas subject to the Per Acre Rent Schedule are called “counties.” Exceptions include Alaska “areas,” the “Commonwealth” of Puerto Rico, and Louisiana “parishes.” To make the terminology uniform in this rule, all such areas are referred to as counties.
Encumbrance Factor
The BLM proposed an encumbrance factor (EF) of 50 percent for all types of linear right-of-way facilities. This is a change from the previous rule where the EF for roads and energy-related pipelines and other facilities was 80 percent and the EF for telephone and electrical transmission facilities was 70 percent. The proposed change is the result of public comments on the ANPR, a review of industry practices in the private sector, and a review of the Department of the Interior (DOI) appraisal methodology for right-of-way facilities located on Federal lands.
The EF is a measure of the degree that a particular type of facility encumbers the right-of-way area or excludes other types of land uses. If the EF is 100 percent, the right-of-way facility (and its operation) is encumbering the right-of-way area to the exclusion of all other uses. The land use rent for such a facility would be calculated on the full value of the subject land (annual rent = full value of land X rate of return). If the EF is 40 percent, the right-of-way facility (and its operation) is only partially encumbering the right-of-way area so that other uses could co-exist alongside the right-of-way facility. The land use rent for such a facility would be calculated on only 40 percent of the full value of the subject land (annual rent = full value of land × 40 percent × rate of return).
Two comments received on the ANPR on this topic suggested that an EF could be as low as 10-15 percent if the right-of-way facility is located on undevelopable terrain; a 25 percent EF be used for a transmission line that does not affect development of land (“set-back areas”); a 50 percent EF be used if development is restricted, but not prohibited, or if other land uses are still possible; and a 70 percent EF be used if development or other uses are severely restricted. Another ANPR commenter stated that the EF should be lowered to 25-50 percent for power lines, because in the private sector, an electrical utility typically makes a one-time payment of 50 percent fair market land value for a perpetual easement, allowing other use(s) within the corridor as long as the use(s) do not interfere with the power line. The commenter also stated that most of the uses that the BLM authorizes can also be conducted within a power line corridor without interfering with the power line and without restricting the additional use. One ANPR commenter encouraged the BLM to use a lower EF than 70 percent, based on common real estate practice relating to utility easements. The commenter stated that when utilities negotiate the purchase price for easements on private land, they typically apply a factor of 50 percent or less to the fee simple value of the land involved, to reflect that the utility easement is less than fee ownership and has a reduced impact. This commenter further stated that the BLM should use a 50 percent or lower encumbrance (impact adjustment) factor and should allow a right-of-way applicant to demonstrate that an even lower impact factor should apply.
In preparing the proposed rule, the BLM reviewed several appraisal reports (prepared by the DOI's Appraisal Services Directorate) for right-of-way facilities located on Federal lands. These appraisal reports showed an EF ranging from 25 percent (for buried telephone lines) to 100 percent (for major oil pipelines and electrical transmission lines). The BLM also reviewed one appraisal report that was prepared by a contractor for the BLM. The contractor did an independent solicitation of industry practices regarding this factor and again found anecdotal evidence that EFs vary from 25 percent to 100 percent, with 50 to 75 percent being the most common. One holder provided anecdotal evidence that its company typically used a 40 percent EF for buried facilities and a 60 percent EF for above ground facilities when negotiating land use rental terms for its facilities across private lands. One BLM grant-holder contracted with a private appraisal firm to determine an appropriate EF for a major pipeline and found that a 75 percent EF is fairly typical for major projects. Finally, our review showed that many state and Federal agencies have established an EF by statute or by policy, usually in the 70 percent to 100 percent range. In the proposed rule, the BLM specifically asked for comments regarding the proposed use of a 50 percent EF, especially since this was a reduction from the 80 percent and 70 percent EFs used in the previous per acre rent schedule.
We received many comments on the proposed rule supporting the reduction of the EF to 50 percent from the 80 percent and 70 percent in the previous per acre rent schedule. A few commenters specifically stated that the EF should be limited in all cases to no higher than 50 percent. One commenter stated that the BLM has traditionally appraised the acquisition of non-exclusive road easements (the equivalent of a BLM right-of-way) using a 50 percent encumbrance factor and that a maximum 50 percent EF should be used whether or not the EF is applied to the upper limit of each zone value or the mid-point value of each zone. One commenter suggested that the EF should be reduced to as little as 10 percent, arguing that a transmission facility located on public lands devalues the land much less than would an easement on private land and that the rights obtained under a grant are also less than those obtained under an easement. Another commenter, while supporting an EF of 50 percent, believed that the final rule should provide holders the option to seek lower EFs via an appraisal. In addition, one commenter suggested that the EF be reduced below 50 percent in those cases where a new right-of-way is granted within an existing road right-of-way or patent reservation for roads or utility purposes.
The BLM agrees with the commenters that state that there are situations and circumstances where an EF of less than 50 percent may be appropriate, whether due to the type of facility, the rights obtained or granted, the impact of the facility on the land, or the co-location of multiple facilities within the same utility corridor. However, there is convincing evidence of situations where an EF greater than 50 percent is warranted. In fact, for large right-of-way facilities, such as interstate pipelines and electrical transmission lines greater than 138 kilovolts in size, the annual rent or one-time easement payment is typically determined using 100 percent of the land value (100 percent EF). These major right-of-way facilities not only encumber the greatest number of acres, but can have significant and continuing impacts on public land resources, including impacts to visual, open space, wildlife, vegetative, cultural, recreation, and other public land resources. In addition to the documented cases cited above supporting EFs greater than 50 percent, two articles published in a professional right-of-way journal also show that a 50
( printed page 65048)
percent EF is indicative of a balanced-use by both the land owner and right-of-way/easement holder (see Donald Sherwood, Easement Valuation,
Right-of-Way Magazine, May/June 2006 at 33). More telling are several quotes from utility company officials stating that the typical amount of compensation for permanent easements is 50 percent of the underlying land value, but that this amount can increase up to 100 percent depending on the size of the transmission line or right-of-way facility being sited (see William R. Lang and Brett A. Smith, Valuing a Gas Pipeline Easement,
Right-of-Way Magazine, September/October 1998 at 32). The BLM recognizes that the EF is closely related to the type of right-of-way facility authorized, as well as how it is operated and administered. However, to assign a specific EF for each type of facility, or type of terrain, or to allow the holder the option of completing an appraisal that may establish a lower EF would be counter-productive to the purpose of using a schedule in the first place, i.e., administrative simplicity and the cost savings that a schedule provides to both the BLM and the applicant/holder in determining rent for right-of-way facilities on public lands. (We note that under this final rule the holder has the option to complete an appraisal report to determine one-time rent for perpetual grants or easements under sections 2806.25, 2806.26, and 2885.22. In these cases, involving lands to be transferred out of Federal ownership, the appraisal report could establish an EF lower than 50 percent (see section 2806.25(d)). In determining an appropriate EF for the final rule, the BLM has also given consideration to the fact that the BLM grants rights-of-way for a specified term, usually 20 to 30 years and that the rights granted are subject to renewal, relinquishment, abandonment, termination, or modification during the term of the grant. We also recognize that the grants issued for right-of-way facilities are non-exclusive, i.e., the BLM reserves the right to authorize other uses within a right-of-way area, as long as the uses are compatible. Given these considerations, and the research and analysis cited above, along with consideration of public comments and published information, the BLM has determined that a 50 percent EF is a reasonable and appropriate component for use in the rent formula for linear right-of-way facilities located on public lands.
Rate of Return
The rate of return component used in the Per Acre Rent Schedule reflects the relationship of income to property value, as modified by any adjustments to property value, such as the EF discussed above. The BLM reviewed a number of appraisal reports that indicated that the rate of return for land can vary from 7 to 12 percent, and is typically around 10 percent. These rates take into account certain risk considerations,
i.e., the possibility of not receiving or losing future income benefits, and do not normally include an allowance for inflation. However, a holder seeking a right-of-way from the BLM must show that it is financially able to construct and operate the facility. In addition, the BLM can require surety or performance bonds from the holder to ensure compliance with the terms and conditions of the authorization, including any rental obligations. This reduces the risk and should allow the BLM to use a “safe rate of return”
e.g., the prevailing rate on insured savings accounts or guaranteed government securities that include an allowance for inflation.
The rate of return for the previous rent schedule was 6.41 percent, which was the 1-year Treasury Securities “Constant Maturity” rate for June 30, 1986. In response to the ANPR, two commenters stated that this rate of return is an acceptable rate of return for right-of-way uses on public lands. Another ANPR commenter stated that the Treasury-bill (T-bill) rate of 6.41 percent in the current rent schedule is not unreasonably high given current T-bill rates around 5 percent. This commenter also stated that an annual adjustment of the T-bill rate would lead to uncertainty in rental fees, which would have a negative impact on utilities and customers, and duplicates the changes reflected in the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) index. Land values tend to move opposite to the T-bill rate, the commenter noted, so including this update in the formula would lead to overly-large rental rates. According to this commenter, a better approach would be to use the 10-year average of the 1-year T-bill rates. Three commenters supported updating the rate of return annually, using some multi-year average of the 1-year T-bill rates. The ANPR commenters said that this approach would provide for a current rate of return, while avoiding abrupt changes.
Given the above considerations, the BLM proposed that an initial rate of return based on the 10-year average (1992-2001) of the U.S. 30-year Treasury bond yield rate would be reasonable since most right-of-way authorizations are issued for a term of 30 years. The BLM chose the 10-year period from 1992-2001 since it was the 10-year period immediately preceding the establishment of the 2002 base rent schedule. The “initial” rate in the proposed rule (6.47 percent) would have been effective through 2011, and then would have adjusted automatically to the then-existing 10-year average (2002-2011) of the U.S. 30-year Treasury bond yield rate. This method of establishing the rate of return eliminates a “one-point-in-time” high or low rate with a rate that reflects an average over the preceding decade. The proposed rule would have allowed for use of the 10-year average of the U.S. 20-year Treasury bond yield rate if the 30-year U.S. Treasury bond yield rate were not available. In the proposed rule, the BLM specifically asked for comment regarding the method that we proposed to establish the initial rate of return and how we proposed to update it every ten years.
We received several comments in support of the proposed 6.47 percent rate of return and the use of the 10-year average of the U.S. 30-year Treasury bond yield rate to establish the initial rate of return. However, two commenters suggested using more current rates: One recommended using the one-year Treasury bill rate, while the other recommended using the most current 30-year Treasury bond yield. The BLM agrees that we should use the most current rates, so that the rate of return reflects the most recent value of money, but a 10-year average is more appropriate than a rate selected from one point in time. As a result, in the final rule, the BLM revised the rate of return downward from 6.47 percent (the 10-year average from 1992 to 2001 of the 30-year Treasury bond yield) to 5.27 percent, which is the most current 10-year average (1998-2008) of the 30-year and 20-year Treasury bond yield rate.
The BLM also agrees with the commenter who stated that a periodic adjustment of the T-bill rate, as proposed in section 2806.22(c), would lead to uncertainty in rental fees, which would have a negative impact on utilities and customers and duplicate the changes reflected in the GDP index. The commenter stated that land values tend to move in opposite directions to the T-bill rate, so including this variable in the formula could lead to overly-large rental rate increases when compared to other economic forces, instead of reflecting current land values as directed by the Act. The BLM agrees and since the rate of return is established by this rule, we will not adjust the 5.27 percent rate of return in the final rule except through new rulemaking.
( printed page 65049)
2002 (Base Year) Per Acre Rent Schedule
Based upon the above discussion establishing the final per acre zone values, encumbrance factor, and rate of return, the Per Acre Rent Schedule for the base year, calendar year 2002, is shown in Table 4:
Table 4—2002 Per Acre Rent Schedule
County zone number and per acre zone value
Encumbrance factor
(percent)
Rate of return
(percent)
Per acre rent for all types of linear right-of-way facilities issued under either FLPMA or MLA or their predecessors. To be adjusted annually for changes in the IPD-GDP
Zone 1 $250
50
5.27
$6.59
Zone 2 $500
50
5.27
13.18
Zone 3 $1,000
50
5.27
26.35
Zone 4 $1,500
50
5.27
39.53
Zone 5 $2,000
50
5.27
52.70
Zone 6 $3,000
50
5.27
79.05
Zone 7 $5,000
50
5.27
131.75
Zone 8 $10,000
50
5.27
263.50
Zone 9 $20,000
50
5.27
527.00
Zone 10 $30,000
50
5.27
790.50
Zone 11 $50,000
50
5.27
1,317.50
Zone 12 $100,000
50
5.27
2,635.00
As discussed above, the most recent NASS Census data available is for calendar year 2002 and those data, in conjunction with the final per acre zone values, encumbrance factor, and rate of return, are used to develop the initial or base Per Acre Rent Schedule. In summary, final section 2806.20 explains that the base 2002 Per Acre Rent Schedule will be adjusted annually in accordance with section 2806.22(a) and revised at the end of each 10-year period (starting with the base year of 2002) in accordance with section 2806.22(b). These adjustments to the 2002 Per Acre Rent Schedule, as well as the Per Acre Rent Schedule for calendar years 2008 through 2015, are discussed below.
Section 2806.20 further explains that counties (or other geographical areas) would be assigned to an appropriate zone under section 2806.21. The reference to proposed section 2806.22(c) has been removed from final section 2806.20 because proposed section 2806.22(c) has not been adopted in the final rule. Proposed section 2806.22(c) allowed for the rate of return to be adjusted at the end of each 10-year period. In the final rule, the rate of return will remain at 5.27 percent unless revised through new rulemaking. The reasons for this change are provided in the “Rate of Return” section above, as well as in final section 2806.22 below.
Finally, section 2806.20 explains that you may obtain a copy of the current Per Acre Rent Schedule from any BLM state or field office or by writing: Director, BLM, 1849 C St., NW., Mail Stop 1000 LS, Washington, DC 20240. The BLM also posts the current rent schedule on the BLM Homepage on the Internet at
www.blm.gov.
Because current schedules are easily available, the BLM does not intend to publish an updated Per Acre Rent Schedule each year in the
Federal Register
.
Section 2806.21 When and how are counties or other geographical areas assigned to a County Zone Number and Per Acre Zone Value?
This section explains that counties (or other geographical areas) are assigned a county zone number and per acre zone value in the Per Acre Rent Schedule based upon 80 percent of their per acre land and building value published in the Census of Agriculture by the NASS (see discussion above regarding this 80 percent figure). The initial assignment of counties to the zones will cover years 2006 through 2010 of the Per Acre Rent Schedule and is based on data contained in the most recent NASS Census (2002). We use the year 2006 as the initial year for the assignment of counties because it takes 18 months for the NASS to compile and publish Census data, and in the final rule we provide 18 months of advanced notice prior to any possible re-assignment of counties using new NASS Census data (for a total of 3 years). Therefore, the initial assignment of counties based on the 2002 NASS Census data could not have occurred until 2006. For example, San Juan County, New Mexico, has a 2002 NASS Census per acre land and building value of $324. Since 80 percent of this amount ($259) falls between $251 and $500, San Juan County is assigned to Zone 2 on the Per Acre Rent Schedule for the 5-year time period from 2006 through 2010. This section also explains that subsequent re-assignments of counties are possible every 5 years (2011, 2016, 2021, 2026, and so forth) following the publication of the NASS Census.
As discussed previously, we received many comments requesting a reduction in the NASS Census per acre land and building value. However, several commenters also stated that the re-assignment of counties each five-year period with less than one year's notice would expose utility and pipeline companies to frequent and potentially unpredictable fee adjustments. Other commenters stated that utility companies needed more advance notice of any re-assignment of counties to new zones on the rent schedule than the proposed rule allowed (less than one year) to allow adequate planning, budgeting, and recovery of costs associated with potentially large fee increases. The BLM agrees with the commenters that it is reasonable to allow additional time between the publication of the NASS Census data and any re-assignment of counties to their proper rental zones to allow companies to adjust budgets and recover
( printed page 65050)
costs associated with the increases. We considered several time periods (from 1 to 5 additional years) and concluded that 1 additional year is sufficient advance notice to plan, budget, and recover any additional costs associated with the re-assignment of counties. As a result, we used the year 2006 as the initial year for the assignment of counties based on the 2002 NASS Census data (see above discussion). Likewise, the next scheduled NASS Census will be for calendar year 2007, but the data will not be published until approximately June 2009. Any re-assignment of the counties under the proposed rule would have occurred in rental year 2010. However, in the final rule, the re-assignment of counties will occur in year 2011, providing a full 18 months of notice as compared to only 6 months of advance notice under the proposed rule. For example, if 80 percent of the average per acre land and building value of San Juan County stays between $251 and $500 in the 2007 NASS Census, San Juan County would remain in Zone 2 on the Per Acre Rent Schedule for calendar years 2011 through 2015. However, if 80 percent of the average per acre land and building value were to drop to $240, San Juan County would be re-assigned to Zone 1 on the Per Acre Rent Schedule for calendar years 2011 through 2015, instead of calendar years 2010 through 2014, as proposed. Likewise, if 80 percent of the average per acre land and building value were to increase to $640, San Juan County would be re-assigned to Zone 3 on the Per Acre Rent Schedule for calendar years 2011 through 2015.
In summary, we revised proposed section 2806.21 in the final rule to account for the assignment of counties into the zones on the linear rent schedule based on 80 percent of the average per acre land and building value contained in the NASS Census, instead of 100 percent. In addition, the re-assignment of counties to the zones in the per acre rent schedule has been delayed by one year (as discussed above) to provide adequate time for holders to budget and recover any additional costs that may result from being placed into a higher zone based upon new NASS Census data each five-year period.
The adjusted 2002 NASS Census per acre land and building value for each county and the corresponding zone number in the Per Acre Rent Schedule (based on 80 percent of the NASS Census data) are listed for informational purposes at the end of this final rule.
Section 2806.22 When and how does the Per Acre Rent Schedule change?
This section explains that the BLM will adjust the per acre rent in section 2806.20 for all types of linear right-of-way facilities in each zone each calendar year based on the average annual change in the Implicit Price Deflator-Gross Domestic Product (IPD-GDP) for the 10-year period immediately preceding the year that the NASS Census data becomes available. For example, the average annual change in the IPD-GDP from 1994 to 2003 (the 10-year period immediately preceding the year (2004) that the 2002 NASS Census data became available) is 1.9 percent. This annual adjustment factor is applied to years 2006 through 2015 of the Per Acre Rent Schedule to coincide with the time periods that counties are assigned a county zone number and per acre zone value in the Per Acre Rent Schedule based first on the 2002 NASS Census data (2006-2010) and secondly, on the 2007 NASS Census data (2011-2015). Likewise, the average annual change in the IPD-GDP from 2004 to 2013 (the 10-year period immediately preceding the year (2014) when the 2012 NASS Census data will become available) will be applied to years 2016 through 2025 of the Per Acre Rent Schedule. The annual price index component used in the Per Acre Rent Schedule allows the rent per acre amount to stay current with inflationary or deflationary trends. If the rent schedule were not based on the “zone” concept, where county per acre land values were placed into a corresponding zone value, the price index adjustment would not be necessary, assuming the county per acre land values were kept current. However, since the Act directs the BLM to “revise the per acre rental fee zone value schedule by state, county, and type of linear right-of-way use to reflect current values of land in each zone,” the final rule retains the zone concept as well as the annual price index adjustment.
The previous Per Acre Rent Schedule was adjusted annually by the change in the IPD-GDP index from the second quarter to the second quarter. From the initial rent schedule in 1987 to the rent schedule for 2007, the change in the IPD-GDP index increased the rent per acre amounts by 62.2 percent. In comparison, the Consumer Price Index—for all Urban Consumers (CPI-U) index increased 85.8 percent for the same period. Because the growth rate for the IPD-GDP is generally less than that for the CPI-U, one ANPR commenter suggested using half of the CPI-U index rather than the current 100 percent of the IPD-GDP as the CPI-U is more easily available. The commenter said that halving the CPI-U number is in line with the lesser IPD-GDP and allows for a normalization of the annual index adjustment while still allowing for increases with inflation.
Two ANPR commenters stated that the payment due date (January 1) comes less than one month after the payment amount is announced in December. The commenters recommended using an earlier-published index than the current one (July of each year). Another ANPR commenter stated that the IPD-GDP is reported as a national number only and does not reflect any potential regional changes in the price level.
In the proposed rule, we chose the CPI-U because it is one of the most common indexes used by economists and the Federal Government to reflect inflationary and deflationary trends in the economy as a whole. It is also one of the most recognizable and familiar indexes to the American consumer and it can be easily obtained from published sources by both Federal agencies and the American public.
The BLM received several comments on the proposed use of the CPI-U index instead of the IPD-GDP. Nearly all commenters on the proposed rule supported the continued use of the IPD-GDP instead of the CPI-U index. Two commenters stated that the CPI-U only measures inflation felt by consumers and does not include price inflation for other parts of the economy. The commenters stated that the IPD-GDP reflects a much broader range of inflation and is more appropriate to track increases in land values. In addition, several commenters stated that holders whose rental obligations exceed several million dollars annually must have more advance notice (or predictability) of their obligations for proper planning, budgeting, and recovery of these fees.
The BLM made two changes in the annual index adjustment factor from the proposed rule to the final rule. First, we changed the annual index adjustment factor from the CPI-U to the IPD-GDP because we agree with some of the commenters that the IPD-GDP index tracks increases in land values as well as, if not better than, the CPI-U. For example, in the last 5 years when land values have risen nearly 80 percent nationally, the IPD-GDP (which normally lags behind the CPI-U) has increased slightly more than the CPI-U (14 percent to 13.6 percent, respectively). In addition, the IPD-GDP tracks a broader range of economic indicators than does the CPI-U, and is just as easy to track on an annual basis as the CPI-U. Secondly, in order to
( printed page 65051)
provide the predictability requested by several commenters (and which the BLM agrees is necessary), we changed how the annual index factor is calculated and how it is applied in the final rent schedule. In the final rule the annual index adjustment is based on the average annual change in the IPD-GDP for the 10-year period immediately preceding the year (2004) that the 2002 NASS Census data became available (or 1.9 percent). This figure (1.9 percent) can then be applied for calendar years 2006 through 2015 to provide the predictability in the rent schedule requested by many of the commenters. The BLM will recalculate the annual index adjustment in 2014 based on the average annual change in the IPD-GDP from 2004 to 2013 (the 10-year period immediately preceding the year (2014) when the 2012 NASS Census data will become available) and will apply it to years 2016 through 2025 of the Per Acre Rent Schedule to provide the predictability requested by many of the commenters. In summary, these changes provide the predictability advocated by several commenters and uses an index that better reflects changing land values and other broad indicators of economic trends.
Table 5 shows how the IPD-GDP index has been applied to the 2002 “Base Year” rent schedule (see Table 4) and subsequent years through 2007 to arrive at the final Per Acre Rent Schedules for years 2008 through 2015 (see Table 6). Table 5 is included here only to show how the final Per Acre Rent Schedule (Table 6) was developed. The BLM will not use the per acre rent values shown in Table 5 for any rent calculation purposes. (Rent paid for years 2002-2007 under the previous schedule would not be recalculated using the rates in Table 5).
Table 5—2002-2007 Per Acre Rent Schedules
County zone number and per acre zone value
2002 per acre rent
(base year)
2003 per acre rent (2.1 percent IPD-GDP increase from preceding year)
2004 per acre rent (2.9 percent IPD-GDP increase from preceding year)
2005 per acre rent (3.2 percent IPD-GDP increase from preceding year)
2006 * per acre rent (1.9 percent IPD-GDP increase—average annual increase from 1994-2003)
2007 per acre rent (1.9 percent IPD-GDP increase—average annual increase from 1994-2003)
Zone 1 $250
$6.59
$6.73
$6.92
$7.14
$7.28
$7.42
Zone 2 $500
13.18
13.45
13.84
14.28
14.56
14.83
Zone 3 $1,000
26.35
26.90
27.68
28.57
29.11
29.67
Zone 4 $1,500
39.53
40.36
41.53
42.85
43.67
44.50
Zone 5 $2,000
52.70
53.81
55.37
57.14
58.22
59.33
Zone 6 $3,000
79.05
80.71
83.05
85.71
87.34
89.00
Zone 7 $5,000
131.75
134.52
138.42
142.85
145.56
148.33
Zone 8 $10,000
263.50
269.03
276.84
285.69
291.12
296.65
Zone 9 $20,000
527.00
538.07
553.67
571.39
582.24
593.31
Zone 10 $30,000
790.50
807.10
830.51
857.08
873.37
889.96
Zone 11 $50,000
1,317.50
1,345.17
1,384.18
1,428.47
1,455.61
1,483.27
Zone 12 $100,000
2,635.00
2,690.34
2,768.35
2,856.94
2,911.22
2,966.54
* Counties are assigned to appropriate zones for calendar years 2006-2010 based upon 2002 NASS Census Data (80% of average per acre land and building value).
We use 2002 as the base year, or beginning point, for the final rent schedule because the most recent NASS Census data is for 2002. The annual index adjustment for calendar years 2003 through 2005 is based on the previous year's change in the IPD-GDP, i.e., 2.1 percent, 2.9 percent, and 3.2 percent, respectively. However, in order to provide the predictability suggested by some commenters and as explained above, the annual index adjustment for calendar years 2006 through 2015 is based on the average annual change in the IPD-GDP for the 10-year period immediately preceding the year (2004) that the 2002 NASS Census data became available, or 1.9 percent. We can therefore extend the Per Acre Rent Schedule into the future through calendar year 2015 as shown in Table 6.
Table 6—2008-2015 Per Acre Rent Schedules
County zone number and per acre zone value
2008 * per acre rent (1.9 percent IPD-GDP increase—average annual increase from 1994-2003)
2009 per acre rent (1.9 percent IPD-GDP increase—average annual increase from 1994-2003)
2010 per acre rent (1.9 percent IPD-GDP increase—average annual increase from 1994-2003)
2011 ** per acre rent (1.9 percent IPD-GDP increase—average annual increase from 1994-2003)
2012 per acre rent (1.9 percent IPD-GDP increase—average annual increase from 1994-2003)
2013 per acre rent (1.9 percent IPD-GDP increase—average annual increase from 1994-2003)
2014 per acre rent (1.9 percent IPD-GDP increase—average annual increase from 1994-2003)
2015 per acre rent (1.9 percent IPD-GDP increase—average annual increase from 1994-2003)
Zone 1 $250
$7.56
$7.70
$7.85
$8.00
$8.15
$8.30
$8.46
$8.62
Zone 2 $500
15.11
15.40
15.69
15.99
16.30
16.61
16.92
17.24
Zone 3 $1,000
30.23
30.80
31.39
31.99
32.59
33.21
33.84
34.49
Zone 4 $1,500
45.34
46.21
47.08
47.98
48.89
49.82
50.76
51.73
Zone 5 $2,000
60.46
61.61
62.78
63.97
65.19
66.42
67.69
68.97
Zone 6 $3,000
90.69
92.41
94.17
95.96
97.78
99.64
101.53
103.46
Zone 7 $5,000
151.15
154.02
156.94
159.93
162.96
166.06
169.22
172.43
Zone 8 $10,000
302.29
308.03
313.89
319.85
325.93
332.12
338.43
344.86
Zone 9 $20,000
604.58
616.07
627.77
639.70
651.85
664.24
676.86
689.72
Zone 10 $30,000
906.87
924.10
941.66
959.55
977.78
996.36
1,015.29
1,034.58
( printed page 65052)
Zone 11 $50,000
1,511.45
1,540.17
1,569.43
1,599.25
1,629.64
1,660.60
1,692.15
1,724.30
Zone 12 $100,000
3,022.90
3,080.34
3,138.86
3,198.50
3,259.27
3,321.20
3,384.30
3,448.60
* Counties are assigned to appropriate zones for calendar years 2008-2010 based upon 2002 NASS Census Data (80% of average per acre land and building value).
** Counties are re-assigned to appropriate zones for calendar years 2011-2015 based on 2007 NASS Census Data (80% of average per acre land and building value).
The annual index adjustment will then be recalculated in 2014 and each subsequent 10-year period based on the average annual change in the IPD-GDP for the 10-year period immediately preceding the year (2014, 2024, 2034, etc.) when the NASS Census data becomes available. For example, the annual index adjustment will next be recalculated in 2014 (when the 2012 NASS Census data becomes available) based on the average annual change in the IPD-GDP from 2004 to 2013 (the 10-year period immediately preceding the year (2014) when the 2012 NASS Census data becomes available) and will be applied annually to the Per Acre Rent Schedules for calendar years 2016 through 2025. In the event that the NASS Census stops being published, or is otherwise unavailable, then the only changes to the rent schedule will be the annual index adjustment (see section 2806.22(a)) until a new rent schedule is developed through rulemaking.
Section 2806.22 also explains that the BLM would review the NASS Census data from the 2012 NASS Census, and each subsequent 10-year period, and if appropriate, revise the number of county zones and the per acre zone value. Any revision must include 100 percent of the number of counties and listed geographical areas for all states and the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico and must reasonably reflect their average per acre land and building values (less the 20 percent reduction) contained in the NASS Census. The BLM may revise the number of zones and the per acre zone value in the 2002 base Per Acre Rent Schedule (section 2806.20(a)) following the publication of the 2012 NASS Census. Since the 2012 NASS Census data will not be available until early to mid 2014, based on current timeframes, any revision would be applicable to the calendar year 2016 rent schedule. Although the NASS Census occurs at 5-year intervals, the revision of the number of zones and the per acre zone value will occur each 10-year period after publication of the NASS Census data in 2012, 2022, 2032, and so forth. Based on historic trends in average per acre land values, the BLM does not foresee that it would be necessary to revise the Per Acre Rent Schedule after each NASS Census period. The BLM finds, however, that it would likely be necessary to revise the Per Acre Rent Schedule after every other NASS Census period (each 10-year period) in order to keep the schedule current with existing per acre land values.
The one-year delay (2016) in implementing the revised rent schedule based on data from the 2012 NASS Census is a change from the proposed rule, which stated that the revised schedule would be effective in calendar year 2015. We revised the final rule to provide holders with more notice and time to plan, budget, and recover potentially significant rent increases resulting from the revisions to the rent schedule at 10-year intervals. The one-year delay to 2016 in implementing the revised rent schedule based on data from the 2012 NASS Census is also consistent with the one-year delay in the reassignment of counties potentially made each 5 years after the availability of the NASS Census data. The re-assignment of counties will be effective for calendar years 2011, 2016, 2021, 2026, and so forth (see the discussion for section 2806.21).
We also revised final section 2806.22 by deleting proposed paragraph (c) which would have adjusted the rate of return after each 10-year period. We removed this provision based on the need (as expressed by several commenters) to provide greater predictability of future rental amounts and to ensure that future adjustments are primarily based on changes in land values and not other economic factors (see the discussion under “Rate of Return”).
The adjustments provided by this section will keep the Per Acre Rent Schedule current relative to average per acre land value as directed by the Act. In addition, since the adjustments provide one additional year of advance notice on county re-assignments (each 5-year period), and one additional year of advance notice on the revision of the number of zones and zone values (each 10-year period), the changes should not be either burdensome to administer or surprising in their outcome.
Section 2806.23 How will BLM calculate my rent for linear rights-of-way the Per Acre Rent Schedule covers?
Final section 2806.23(a) explains that (except as provided by sections 2806.25 and 2806.26) the BLM calculates rent by multiplying the rent per acre for the appropriate county (or other geographical area) zone from the current schedule by the number of acres (as rounded up to the nearest tenth of an acre) in the right-of-way area that fall in each zone and multiplying the result by the number of years in the rental payment period. The final rent calculation methodology is identical to the proposed methodology except for changing the phrase “rental period” to “rental payment period” (the length of time for which the holder is paying rent) to make the rule clearer. An example explaining how the methodology will be applied follows: An existing pipeline right-of-way in New Mexico occupies 0.74 acres of public land in McKinley County and 4.8 acres of public land in San Juan County. The 2002 NASS Census indicates that the average per acre land and building value for McKinley County is $75 (Zone 1 on the Per Acre Rent Schedule ($75 × .80 = $60)) and $324 for San Juan County (or Zone 2 ($324 × .80 = $259) on the Per Acre Rent Schedule). The per acre rent value for calendar year 2008 for Zone 1 is $7.56 and for Zone 2 it is $15.11. The 2008 annual rent for the portion of the
( printed page 65053)
right-of-way in Zone 1 (McKinley County) is $6.05 (0.74 acres (rounded up to 0.8 acres) multiplied by $7.56 = $6.05). The 2008 annual rent for the portion of the right-of-way in Zone 2 (San Juan County) is $72.53 (4.8 acres multiplied by $15.11 = $72.53). The total 2008 rent for the entire grant would be $78.58. Regardless of whether the holder is an individual or business entity, given that the annual rent is $100 or less, the holder can only pay for the entire remaining term of the grant, or pay rent at 10-year intervals, not to exceed the term of the grant (see section 2806.24).
Final section 2806.23(b) provides for the phase-in of the initial implementation of the Per Acre Rent Schedule by reducing the 2009 per acre rent by 25 percent. Lastly, this section explains that if the BLM has not previously used the rent schedule to calculate your rent, we may do so after giving you reasonable written notice.
We received two comments on this proposed section. Both commenters suggested that we include the word “payment” when referring to the “rental period” in section 2806.23(a) so that the phrase reads “rental payment period” to denote the length of time for which the holder is paying rent. The commenters stated that some holders may confuse the phrase “rental period” to be the term of the grant instead of the length of time for which the holder is paying rent. We agree that this change improves clarity and have made this change in the final rule.
We received no other comments on this section, but we did request comments in the proposed rule at section 2885.20 on the need for a phase-in provision for FLPMA and MLA grants. As a result of those comments (see discussion for section 2885.20(b)), we have added final section 2806.23(b) which provides for a phase-in of the initial implementation of the Per Acre Rent Schedule by reducing the 2009 per acre rent by 25 percent. In calendar year 2009, all holders will pay 75 percent of the scheduled rental rates, and thereafter, 100 percent of the scheduled rental rates.
The BLM does not expect the rental increases to be financially burdensome for most holders. We believe that several provisions added to the final rule (an additional 1-year advance notice of potentially large rental increases, reducing the NASS Census land and building value for each county by 20 percent, reducing the rate of return by 18.5 percent (from 6.47 percent to 5.27 percent), reducing the threshold from $1,000 to $500 for payment of annual rent instead of 10-year rental payments, and waiving 25 percent of the calendar year 2009 rental rates for all authorization holders), in conjunction with the more flexible rent payment options described in final sections 2806.24 and 2885.21, as well as the existing hardship provision found at section 2806.15(c), will provide appropriate relief from any large, unexpected increases in rent payments that are due to implementation of the revised linear rent schedule.
Section 2806.24 How must I make rental payments for a linear grant?
Final section 2806.24(a) explains that for linear grants, except those issued in perpetuity, you must make either nonrefundable annual payments or a nonrefundable payment for more than 1 year, as follows:
(1)
One-time payments.
You may pay in advance the total rent amount for the entire term of the grant or any remaining years.
(2)
Multiple payments.
If you choose not to make a one-time payment, you must pay according to one of the following methods:
(i)
Payments by individuals.
If your annual rent is $100 or less, you must pay at 10-year intervals, not to exceed the term of the grant. If your annual rent is greater than $100, you may pay annually or at 10-year intervals, not to exceed the term of the grant. For example, if you have a grant with a term of 30 years, you may pay in advance for 10 years, 20 years, or 30 years, but not 15 years.
(ii)
Payments by all others.
If your annual rent is $500 or less, you must pay rent at 10-year intervals, not to exceed the term of the grant. If your annual rent is greater than $500, you may pay annually or at 10-year intervals, not to exceed the term of the grant.
Final section 2806.24(a) replaces the rent payment options in previous section 2806.23(a). Previously, only individual grant-holders with annual rent in excess of $100 had the option to pay their rent annually or at multi-year intervals of their choice. All other grant holders had to pay a one-time rent payment for the term of the grant or pay rent at 10-year intervals not to exceed the term of the grant. These provisions were incorporated in the 2005 regulations to help reduce or eliminate costs associated with the billing and collection of annual rent to both the BLM and the holder. However, many holders pointed out that making rent payments, especially for existing grants, for 10- to 30-year terms (100 years for grants issued in perpetuity) can be an extreme financial hardship, especially for small business entities operating on limited annual budgets.
For FLPMA authorizations, the BLM has some ability to address these issues under the “undue hardship” provisions in current section 2806.15(c), but this process can be burdensome on the holders, requires approval of the appropriate BLM State Director, and is not available to holders of MLA authorizations. Several holders of MLA authorizations pointed out that the annual rent payment for some of their grants exceed $10,000, and in at least one case, the annual rent is in excess of $100,000, which would have required them to make minimum rent payments between $100,000 and $1,000,000 for a 10-year rental payment period. These holders have suggested that corporations and business entities be given rent payment options similar to those of individuals, except with a higher annual rental threshold of $500 or $1,000, instead of the $100 threshold available to individual holders.
Three commenters on the ANPR said they supported flexible term-payment schedules (annual payments, 5-year payments, 10-year payments) for all authorizations, especially those with annual rent greater than $500. Several commenters said that the BLM should include a 3- to 6- year phase-in period, along with more flexible rent payment periods, in order to provide relief from a large or unexpected increase in individual rental payments. One commenter on the proposed rule supported the rent payment periods as proposed, while one commenter said that the $1,000 threshold is too high and should be set no higher than $500. The commenter stated that there are more and more “other than individuals” entities that are very small operations for which the proposed regulations can cause a financial hardship. The BLM agrees that the $1,000 threshold may be excessive for some small business holders who would have to pay nearly $10,000 (for a 10-year period) if their annual bill were just less than $1,000. By reducing the threshold to $500, the maximum 10-year bill would be $4,990, an amount that may cause less financial hardship to small business operators. Therefore, in the final rule the $1,000 threshold for payment of annual rent has been reduced to $500. This change should have positive impacts to small businesses that may not have the necessary capital to make long-term rental payments.
In summary, under final section 2806.24(a), the holder retains the option to pay rent for the entire term of the grant, except for grants issued in perpetuity. No changes in rent payment
( printed page 65054)
options are made for those holders who are considered “individuals” with the exception that if the annual rent is greater than $100, you may pay annually or at 10-year intervals, not to exceed the term of the grant. The final rule eliminates the option for individuals with annual rent greater than $100 to pay at multiple-year intervals of their choice. An “individual” does not include any business entity, e.g., partnerships, corporations, associations, or any similar business arrangements. However, the BLM agrees that “non-individuals” need to have more flexible rent payment options, especially those holders whose annual rent payment is in excess of $500. Under the final rule, when this threshold is met, the holder (non-individual) has the option to pay its rent on an annual basis, or at 10-year intervals, not to exceed the term of the grant. For example, the holder of a 25-year grant (a grant issued on May 25, 2005, for a 25-year period would expire on December 31, 2029) whose annual rent is $2,000 would have the option upon grant issuance to make annual payments of $2,000 plus annual index adjustments (the initial rent period would be for a 7-month period or a rent payment of $1,166.67). The holder could also choose to make a payment in advance for 10 years (total payment of $19,166.67 (9 years + 7 months); for 20 years (total payment of $39,166.67 (19 years + 7 months); or for the entire 25 years (total payment of $49,166.67 (24 years + 7 months), but not for any other multi-year period. If the holder's annual rent is $500 or less, the holder (non-individual) must pay rent at 10-year intervals, not to exceed the term of the grant. If rent is not paid for the full term, subsequent rental payments will be based on the changes to the rental schedule as described in section 2806.21 (the re-assignment of counties each 5-year period) and section 2806.22 (the annual CPI-U index adjustment and/or the adjustment to the number and value of rental zones each 10-year period), but the $100 and $500 thresholds used to determine the eligibility for annual payments by individuals and business entities, respectively, will not be adjusted.
Final section 2806.24(b) explains that for linear grants issued in perpetuity (except as noted in sections 2806.25 and 2806.26), you must make either nonrefundable annual payments or a nonrefundable payment for more than 1 year, as follows:
(1)
Payments by individuals.
If your annual rent is $100 or less, you must pay at 10-year intervals, not to exceed 30 years. Under this provision, you have the option to pay for a 10-year term, a 20-year term, or a 30-year term. No other terms are available. If your annual rent is greater than $100, you may pay annually or at 10-year intervals (10-year term, 20-year term, or 30-year term), not to exceed 30 years. Again, no other terms are available.
(2)
Payments by all others.
If your annual rent is $500 or less, you must pay rent at 10-year intervals, not to exceed 30 years. Under this section, you have the option to pay for a 10-year term, a 20-year term, or a 30-year term. No other terms are available. If your annual rent is greater than $500, you may pay annually or at 10-year intervals (10-year term, 20-year term, or 30-year term), not to exceed 30 years. No other terms are available.
Final section 2806.24(b) replaces previous section 2806.23(c), which gave non-individual holders of a perpetual grant only one rent payment option, that is, a one-time payment based on the annual rent (either determined from the Per Acre Rent Schedule or from an appraisal) multiplied by 100. Holders (non-individuals) of perpetual grants had no other option under previous rules but to pay a one-time payment that many found to be burdensome. Under the 1987 regulations (43 CFR 2803.1-2(a)), holders of grants, including perpetual grants, paid either annually or for a 5-year period, but could not make a one-time payment. This was especially problematic when public land encumbered by a perpetual grant was transferred out of Federal ownership. The 2005 regulations provided for the one-time payment option (see section 2806.23(c)), but did not offer other rent payment options, which are necessary for proper administration of those perpetual grants already in existence prior to 2005, and which encumber land that the BLM intends to administer. Although the term of a FLPMA grant can be any length, it is the BLM's policy to adhere strictly to the factors listed in current section 2805.11(b) to establish a reasonable term. The factors that must be considered in establishing a reasonable term include the: (1) Public purpose served; (2) Cost and useful life of the facility; (3) Time limitations imposed by licenses or permits required by other Federal agencies and state, tribal, or local governments; and (4) Time necessary to accomplish the purpose of the grant. The BLM's own land use planning horizon is generally only 20 to 30 years, so it is seldom in the public interest to issue land use authorizations which exceed this horizon. In addition, the term of MLA grants cannot exceed 30 years (see current section 2885.11(a)).
Although the BLM now rarely issue grants in perpetuity, except when the land encumbered by the grant is being transferred out of Federal ownership (see final section 2806.25), we must still be able to effectively administer grants that were issued in perpetuity under prior authorities (generally pre-FLPMA authorities and the MLA prior to 1973). Holders of these grants have requested flexible rent payment options. Final section 2806.24(b) provides rent payment options which are deemed necessary for proper administration of perpetual grants when the land is not being transferred out of Federal ownership. In addition, final sections 2806.25 and 2806.26 allow you to make a one-time payment for perpetual grants and perpetual easements, respectively, when the land encumbered by the grant or easement is being transferred out of Federal ownership.
We received two comments of support for the rent payment options in proposed section 2806.24(b). However, a third commenter suggested that holders of perpetual grants should always have the option to make a one-time payment, even if the encumbered land is not being transferred out of Federal ownership. The BLM disagrees with this suggestion because a one-time rental payment for a perpetual grant is not significantly greater (in some cases it could even be less) than a one-time payment for a grant with a term of 30 years. Therefore, it is not in the public's interest, in the case of Federally-owned land, to forfeit possible future revenues for uses (the siting of right-of-way facilities on public land) that may ultimately extend beyond a 30-year time period. These subsequent rental receipts will far exceed the administrative costs of issuing a new rental bill each 30-year period and will continue to provide needed revenues to the U.S. Treasury, and to state and local governments (who receive 50 percent of MLA rental receipts). Final section 2806.24(b) is the same as proposed.
Final section 2806.24(c) is also the same as proposed section 2806.24(c) and previous section 2806.23(b), which explains that the BLM considers the first partial calendar year in the initial rent payment period to be the first year of the term. The BLM prorates the first year rental amount based on the number of months left in the calendar year after the effective date of the grant. We received no comments on this section and it remains as proposed.
( printed page 65055)
Section 2806.25 How may I make rental payments when land encumbered by my perpetual linear grant (other than an easement issued under § 2807.15(b)) is being transferred out of Federal ownership?
Final section 2806.25 explains how you may make one-time rental payments for your perpetual linear grant (other than an easement issued under section 2807.15(b) (see section 2806.26)) when land encumbered by your grant is being transferred out of Federal ownership. Section 2806.25(a) explains that if you have an existing perpetual grant (whether issued under FLPMA or its predecessors) and the land your grant encumbers is being transferred out of Federal ownership, you may make a one-time rental payment. You are not required to make a one-time rental payment, but if you choose to do so, the BLM will determine your one-time payment for a perpetual right-of-way grant by dividing the current annual rent for the subject property by an overall capitalization rate calculated from market data. Under this calculation, the overall capitalization rate is the difference between a market yield rate and a percent annual rent increase as described in the formula below. The formula for this calculation is: One-time rental payment = annual rent/(Y−CR), where:
(1) Annual rent = current annual rent applicable to the subject property from the Per Acre Rent Schedule;
(2) Y = yield rate (rate of return) from the Per Acre Rent Schedule (5.27 percent); and
(3) CR = annual percent change in rent as determined by the most recent 10-year average of the difference in the IPD-GDP Index from January of one year to January of the following year.
Section 2806.25(b) explains how you must make a one-time payment for term grants converted to a perpetual grant under section 2807.15(b). If the land your grant encumbers is being transferred out of Federal ownership and you request a conversion of your term grant to a perpetual right-of-way grant, you will be required to make a one-time rental payment in accordance with section 2806.25(a).
Section 2806.25(c) explains that in paragraphs (a) and (b) of this section, the annual rent is determined from the Per Acre Rent Schedule (see section 2806.20(c)) as updated under section 2806.22. However, the per acre zone value and zone number used in this annual rental determination will be based on the per acre zone value from acceptable market information or an appraisal, if any, for the land transfer action and not the county average per acre land and building value from the NASS Census. This section also explains that you may submit an appraisal report on your own initiative in accordance with paragraph (d).
Section 2806.25(d) explains that when no acceptable market information is available or when no appraisal has been completed for the land transfer action or when the BLM requests it, you must prepare an appraisal report in accordance with Federal appraisal standards.
Section 2806.25 is a new section that explains how one-time rental payments will be determined for perpetual grants (other than an easement issued under section 2807.15(b)) when the land your grant encumbers is being transferred out of Federal ownership. It is important to note that you are under no obligation to make a one-time rental payment for your existing perpetual grant when the land your grant encumbers is being transferred out of Federal ownership. If you have an existing term or perpetual grant and you have made either annual or multi-year payments under section 2806.24, and the land your grant encumbers is to be transferred out of Federal ownership, and you choose not to make a one-time rental payment to the BLM, you would negotiate future rental payments for your grant with the new land owner at the appropriate time. However, if you desire to make a one-time payment to the BLM prior to the transfer of the land, and you have an existing perpetual grant, section 2806.25(a) allows the BLM to determine the one-time rental payment by dividing the current annual rent for the subject property by an overall capitalization rate calculated from market data. Under this calculation, the overall capitalization rate is the difference between a market yield rate and a percent annual rent increase as described in the formula below. The formula for this calculation is: One-time rental payment = annual rent/(Y−CR), where:
(1) Annual rent = current annual rent applicable to the subject property from the Per Acre Rent Schedule;
(2) Y = yield rate (rate of return) from the Per Acre Rent Schedule (5.27 percent); and
(3) CR = annual percent change in rent as determined by the most recent 10-year average of the difference in the IPD-GDP Index from January of one year to January of the following year.
For example, if the most recent 10-year average of the difference in the IPD-GDP index from January of one year to January of the following year is 1.27 percent, and since the rate of return is a standard 5.27 percent, then the overall capitalization rate is 4.0 percent (5.27 − 1.27 = 4.0). The one-time rental payment for a perpetual right-of-way grant with an annual rent of $36.63 would be determined by dividing the annual rent ($36.63) by the overall capitalization rate (.04), or $915.75. This methodology of calculating rent is known as the income capitalization approach.
In the proposed rule, the BLM also considered other methods to determine a one-time rental payment, including an administrative approach similar to previous section 2806.23(c)(1), where a one-time payment is determined by multiplying the annual rent by 100. Under this approach, a one-time payment for the same right-of-way grant described above with an annual rent payment of $36.63 would be $3,663 ($36.63 multiplied by 100), instead of $915.75. While this approach was reasonable when using the previous per acre rent schedule, it would have generated an excessively high one-time payment when using current land values as directed by the Act. The BLM also considered using a discounted cash flow (DCF) method to calculate the present value of the projected annual rent payments over a 100-year term, assuming annual rent payments are made in advance. The DCF approach would generate a one-time payment similar to the income capitalization approach. In the above example, a one-time rental payment using the DCF method for the same annual rent payment figure of $36.63 would be $953.24 compared to $915.75 using the income capitalization approach. In general, the DCF formula is more complex and prone to rounding inconsistencies, as compared to the income capitalization formula, which is fairly straightforward and simple to use.
The BLM received only a few comments on proposed section 2806.25(a). Most commenters supported the income capitalization approach to determine the one-time rent payment for perpetual grants as reasonable. However, two commenters stated that the “Income Approach” for valuing land is not typically used or allowed under standard appraisal practices. The BLM disagrees with the latter comments since rental receipts for right-of-way uses (especially rental receipts that are specifically based on rural land values as is the case of the Per Acre Rent Schedule) are an acceptable indicator of land values under Federal appraisal standards.
Given the above considerations, the BLM believes that the income capitalization approach is the most reasonable methodology for converting an annual rent payment (with an annual
( printed page 65056)
adjustment factor) to a one-time payment for a perpetual term. The only variable in the final formula is the annual percent change in rent, which could be determined on a case-by-case basis. However, to provide some certainty, and since the Per Acre Rent Schedule already utilizes this component, the BLM believes that using a 10-year average of the annual difference in the IPD-GDP index will normalize this variable and avoid either abnormally high or low values that can result from using a one point-in-time figure. Other than changing the annual index from the CPI-U to the IPD-GDP, to be consistent with the annual indexing used in the final Per Acre Rent Schedule, the only other change to paragraph (a) is the method used to determine the yield rate (or “Y” in the formula). In the proposed rule, the yield rate would have been determined by the most recent 10-year average of the annual 30-year Treasury Bond Rate as of January of each year. In the final rule, the yield rate (Y) used in the income capitalization formula in sections 2806.25(a) and 2885.22(a) is a constant 5.27 percent, again to be consistent with the constant rate of return utilized in the final Per Acre Rent Schedule. As such, the rate of return will not be adjusted in this formula except by new rulemaking, or whenever a separate appraisal report is completed and approved by the BLM under paragraph (d) of this section.
Section 2806.25(b) addresses the situation where there is an existing term grant and you ask BLM to convert it to a perpetual FLPMA grant under final section 2807.15(b). If you make this request, the BLM will treat it as an application for an amendment under current section 2807.20. If the BLM approves your request to change the term of your grant, the BLM will determine the mandatory one-time rental payment as explained in paragraph (a) of this section. We received no comments on this paragraph and made no changes to the final rule, except to change the reference to section 2807.15(c) to 2807.15(b) because of the consolidation of proposed paragraph (c) with existing paragraph (b).
Section 2806.25(c) provides that if the land your grant encumbers is being transferred out of Federal ownership and you have a perpetual grant and have requested a one-time rental payment, or you have requested the BLM to amend your grant to a perpetual grant and seek a one-time rental payment, the BLM would base the per acre zone value and zone number used in the annual rental determination on the per acre land value from the market information or appraisal report used for the land transfer action and not the county average per acre land and building value from the NASS Census. The BLM believes that when the land a grant encumbers is being transferred out of Federal ownership, the most accurate and current market data should be used to determine the one-time rental payment. For example, for Clark County, Nevada, 80 percent of the average per acre land and building value from the 2002 NASS Census is $2,854 (Zone 6 on the 2002 Per Acre Rent Schedule or $79.05 per acre rent). If an appraisal report for a competitive sale concluded that the 2002 average per acre land value is instead $175,000 per acre, then the annual per acre rent would be $2,635 (or Zone 12 on the per acre rent schedule). The BLM would not use the actual appraised per acre value or the actual per acre sale value to determine the annual per acre rent, but instead would use the actual appraised per acre value to determine the appropriate zone number on the Per Acre Rent Schedule. The zone number then determines the appropriate per acre rent under final section 2806.25. A few commenters suggested that holders should always have the option to conduct their own appraisal under section 2806.25(d). The BLM agrees with these comments and has therefore revised final section 2806.25(c) to specify that holders may prepare their own appraisal report under section 2806.25(d).
Section 2806.25(d) explains that when no acceptable market information is available, and no appraisal has been completed for the land transfer action, or when the BLM requests it, you must prepare an appraisal report, at your expense, in accordance with Federal appraisal standards. The BLM will only require you to prepare an appraisal report when other acceptable market data is not available. If you must provide an appraisal report, the DOI's Appraisal Policy Manual, dated October 1, 2006, sets forth the DOI's appraisal policies. Addendum Number 3 to DOI's Appraisal Policy Manual specifically provides guidance concerning land valuation, alternative methods of valuation, and appraisal reports prepared by third (i.e., non-Federal) parties. It is the DOI's policy that all valuation services (whether performed by DOI appraisers or by non-DOI appraisers providing valuation services under a DOI contract or on behalf of a private third party, such as a right-of-way holder) must conform to the current Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP) and the current Uniform Standards for Federal Land Acquisitions (USFLA).
If you have provided an appraisal report, the BLM State Director will refer it to the DOI's Appraisal Services Directorate (ASD). The ASD will review the appraisal report to determine if it meets USPAP and USFLA standards and advise the BLM State Director accordingly. If these standards are met, the BLM State Director will then use the data in the appraisal report to determine the zone value and zone number used in the calculation of the one-time rent payment provided by paragraphs (a) and (b). However, if your appraisal report uses a different EF or yield rate from those in the formula in section 2806.25(a) or section 2885.22(a), then the actual per acre land value as determined by the appraisal report must be used in the determination of the one-time rent payment, even if it exceeds the highest per acre land value from the rent schedule.
The BLM specifically requested comments on whether an appraisal report, if required, should also address the appropriate EF, in addition to determining per acre land values. The EF from an appraisal report could be different from the 50 percent used in the Per Acre Rent Schedule, depending on the type of facility being authorized (see EF discussion earlier in the preamble). The rate of return (5.27 percent—see Table 4) could also change, if the one-time rental payment for a perpetual grant were determined on a case-by-case basis under final paragraph 2806.25(d). For example, if the average per acre land and building value from the NASS Census is $700 (Zone 3 on the 2002 Per Acre Rent Schedule or $26.35 per acre rent) and an appraisal report concluded that the 2002 per acre land value is instead $400 per acre (Zone 2 or a $13.18 per acre rent), but the appraisal report determines that the EF is 85 percent, then the annual per acre rent would equal $17.92 ($400 multiplied by .85 multiplied by 5.27 percent). Similar variations in the final per acre rent value could also occur if the appraisal report were to determine a higher or lower rate of return. In the above example, if the appraisal report determined that the per acre land value is $400, the EF is 85 percent, and the rate of return is 8 percent (instead of 5.27 percent), then the annual per acre rent would equal $27.20 ($400 multiplied by .85 multiplied by 8.0 percent). Once the annual rent is calculated, then the one-time payment would then be determined under section 2806.25(a).
The BLM received several comments on paragraph (d) of this section. Most
( printed page 65057)
advocated that the holder always have the opportunity to conduct an appraisal report under this paragraph, and that the appraisal report consider all factors in arriving at a one-time rental payment. Some commenters also advocated the use of appraisal reports, but with limits on the amount of the EF, i.e., the EF should never exceed 50 percent. Another commenter asked whether the BLM, in lieu of an appraisal report, would be able to utilize a process to determine per acre land values similar to that used in lower value Federal land acquisitions, known as waiver valuations.
Final section 2806.25(d) specifies that when no acceptable market information is available and no appraisal report has been completed for the land transfer action or when the BLM requests it, you must prepare an appraisal report using Federal appraisal standards that explains how you estimated the land value per acre, the rate of return, and the EF. The final rule places no restrictions on the amount of the EF or the rate of return, but will let the market conditions set these amounts (e.g., comparable sales data), which in turn determines the annual rent value and/or the one-time rental payment. The proposed rule would have mandated that the yield rate be determined by using the 10-year average of the most recent 30-year Treasury Bond rate. In the final rule, the yield rate will be determined by current market conditions as documented in the appraisal report. To place arbitrary and artificial limits on any of the market conditions used to determine a fair market value rent would be in violation of Federal appraisal standards (see Addendum Number 3 to DOI's Appraisal Policy Manual).
The BLM will use the final Per Acre Rent Schedule to determine rent for all linear facilities (except as provided by sections 2806.25, 2806.26, and 2885.22), even when those facilities occupy minimal acreage on low value land. We do not foresee any case where “waiver valuations” would be appropriate for use in determining rent for linear facilities, as suggested by one commenter, although this process is available to BLM offices to determine (minimum) rental values for non-linear facilities located on small and/or low valued acreages (see section 2806.50).
Sections 2806.25(c) and (d) replace sections 2806.20(c) and (d) of the previous regulations which allowed the BLM to use an alternate means to compute your rent, if the rent determined by comparable commercial practices or by an appraisal would be 10 or more times the rent from the schedule. We made these changes in the final rule to comply with the Act, which requires the BLM to use a Per Acre Rent Schedule based upon land values to determine rent for linear right-of-way grants located on public land.
Section 2806.26 How may I make rental payments when land encumbered by my perpetual easement issued under § 2807.15(b) is being transferred out of Federal ownership?
Section 2806.26(a) addresses the situation where there is an existing term or perpetual grant and you ask BLM to convert it to a perpetual easement as provided by section 2807.15(b). If you make this request, the BLM will treat it as an application for an amendment under current section 2807.20. Under the final rule, if the BLM approved your request to convert your term or perpetual grant to a perpetual easement, the BLM will use the appraisal data from the DOI's Appraisal Services Directorate for the land transfer action (i.e., direct or indirect land sales, land exchanges, and other land disposal actions) and other market information to determine the one-time rental payment for perpetual easements.
Section 2806.26(b) explains that when no appraisal or acceptable market information is available for the land transfer action or when the BLM requests it, you must prepare a report required under section 2806.25(d). A new addition to this paragraph in the final rule allows you to submit an appraisal report on your own initiative in accordance with section 2806.25(d).
Section 2806.26 is a new section made necessary by the BLM's recent policy to provide for perpetual easements to existing right-of-way holders who want to convert their term or perpetual grant to an easement when the land their grant encumbers is to be transferred out of Federal ownership under section 2807.15(b). The BLM has worked closely with its right-of-way customers and holders to develop an easement document (and policy) similar to the easement document that a utility company might acquire across private land. Under this policy, easements (similar to easements that utility companies would acquire for similar purposes across private land) will only be issued to you when land your grant encumbers is to be transferred out of Federal ownership. Since in these cases the BLM will not administer the easement (because the land your easement encumbers will no longer be public land), the BLM believes that the one-time payment should be determined by an appraisal or acceptable market information used to determine the per acre land value for the land disposal action. The one-time rental payment determined in this manner will reflect the value of the rights transferred to you based upon similar transactions in the private sector, and may or may not be the same as a one-time payment for a perpetual grant determined under section 2806.25(b).
In the proposed rule, the BLM asked for specific comments on the need for perpetual easements when encumbered lands are to be transferred out of Federal ownership as well as whether the BLM has authority to issue a term easement under the MLA in those circumstances when encumbered land is to be transferred out of Federal ownership.
The term “right-of-way” is defined by FLPMA (43 U.S.C. 1702(f)) to include easements, leases, permits, or licenses to occupy, use, or traverse public lands granted for the purposes listed in Title V of FLPMA. Most grants that the BLM issues under FLPMA are set forth on standard form 2800-14 and denoted “Right-of-Way Grant/Temporary Use Permit.” These grants are not regarded as easements by the agency, absent some indication to the contrary. Section 506 of FLPMA, 43 U.S.C. 1766, however, clearly contemplates the issuance of easements and provides that any effort to suspend or terminate these instruments be accompanied by the procedural safeguards of 5 U.S.C. 554. On the other hand, the provisions of the MLA at 30 U.S.C. 185 do not expressly authorize the grant of easements, unlike FLPMA's provisions at 43 U.S.C. 1702(f), 1761(a), and 1766. Both statutes do provide for the procedural safeguards of 5 U.S.C. 554 in the event of suspension or termination of the authorization. However, under the MLA the procedural safeguards of 5 U.S.C. 554 apply to all grants (see 43 U.S.C. 185(o)(1)), whereas, under FLPMA, these safeguards only apply to those authorizations considered to be easements (43 U.S.C. 1766).
Several commenters stated that permanent easements are necessary to protect their facilities when encumbered lands are transferred out of Federal ownership. Other commenters cited instances where the new land owner demanded unreasonable compensation for continued use of the right-of-way area, which may then affect delivery costs, as well as increase product costs to the end users. Commenters also stated that “easements” are “understood” in the private sector and that there is an enormous body of case law on the application and interpretation of easements, while a BLM right-of-way grant is an oddity that is often misunderstood by the private
( printed page 65058)
sector. The same commenter said that the ability to have an easement rather than a BLM grant will greatly simplify management of the facility by all parties in the long run.
Many commenters on the proposed rule also supported the conversion of existing term grants to term or permanent easements under the MLA. Commenters stated that the issuance of a “term easement” is consistent with the current definition of “grant” found at 43 CFR 2881.5 (“Grant means any instrument or authorization the BLM issues under section 28 of the MLA * * * to use Federal lands to construct, operate, maintain, or terminate a pipeline”). Furthermore, the commenters stated that the BLM has existing policy allowing for MLA “term easements” and the final rule should support and endorse this policy. One commenter also stated that the one-time rent payment for a “term easement” issued under the MLA should be determined by an appraisal or market data for the land transfer action, similar to the one-time payment for a FLPMA easement described under section 2806.26.
The BLM agrees with most of the commenters regarding their desire to be able to convert existing grants to permanent and term easements when land encumbered by their FLPMA grant is transferred out of Federal ownership. However, in the final rule we have limited this section to the determination of one-time rental payments for easements issued under the FLPMA, and not the MLA. We made this decision because the term “right-of-way” is defined by FLPMA (43 U.S.C. 1702(f)) specifically to include “easements” (as well as leases, permits, or licenses) to occupy, use, or traverse public lands granted for the purposes listed in Title V of FLPMA, while the provisions of the MLA at 30 U.S.C. 185 do not expressly authorize the grant of easements, and limit the term of any grant to 30 years or less. In addition, none of the commenters provided legal support for the issuance of term easements under Section 28 of the MLA. The BLM also disagrees that the definition of “grant” found at 43 CFR 2881.5 (“Grant means any instrument or authorization the BLM issues under section 28 of the MLA * * * to use Federal lands to construct, operate, maintain, or terminate a pipeline”) is sufficient basis by itself for the issuance of “term easements” because “easements” are not specifically provided for in Section 28 of the MLA.
In summary, final section 2806.26(a) is the same as proposed, except for revising the paragraph cited in section 2807.15 from paragraph (c) in the proposed rule to paragraph (b) in the final rule. Section 2806.26(b) also remains the same as proposed, except the final rule specifically allows holders to submit an appraisal report on their own initiative under section 2806.25(d). We made this change to be consistent with similar changes made in section 2806.25(c).
Subpart 2807—Grant Administration and Operation
The BLM is proposing changes to the section of this subpart that deals with administration and operation of grants.
Section 2807.15 How is grant administration affected if the land my grant encumbers is transferred to another Federal agency or out of Federal ownership?
This section explains how grant administration is affected if the land your grant encumbers is transferred to another Federal agency or out of Federal ownership.
Final section 2807.15(a) explains that if there is a proposal to transfer the land your grant encumbers to another Federal agency, the BLM may, after reasonable notice to you, transfer administration of your grant for the lands the BLM formerly administered to another Federal agency, unless doing so would diminish your rights. If the BLM determined your rights would be diminished by such a transfer, the BLM can still transfer the land, but retain administration of your grant under existing terms and conditions.
We proposed no changes to section 2807.15(b), but we have revised it in the final rule based upon several comments that the content and formatting of proposed paragraphs (b) and (c) were confusing. Final section 2807.15(b) is revised to incorporate the intent of proposed paragraph (c). Final section 2807.15(b) explains that the BLM will provide reasonable notice to you if there is a proposal to transfer the land your grant encumbers out of Federal ownership. If you request it, the BLM will negotiate new grant terms and conditions with you. This may include increasing the term of your grant to a perpetual grant or providing for an easement. These changes become effective prior to the time the land is transferred out of Federal ownership. The BLM may then, in conformance with existing policies and procedures:
(1) Transfer the land subject to your grant. In this case, administration of your grant for the lands the BLM formerly administered is transferred to the new owner of the land;
(2) Transfer the land, but the BLM retains administration of your grant; or
(3) Reserve to the United States the land your grant encumbers, and the BLM retains administration of your grant.
Proposed section 2807.15(c) explained that if there is a proposal to transfer the land your grant encumbers out of Federal ownership, you may negotiate new grant terms and conditions with the BLM. This may include increasing the term of your grant, should you request it, to a perpetual grant or providing for an easement. These changes would become effective prior to the time the land is transferred out of Federal ownership. The proposed rule also removed from section 2807.15(c) the cross-reference to previous section 2806.23(c), which specified how you made rental payments for perpetual grants. The BLM received several comments stating that this paragraph appears to replace existing paragraph 2807.15(b). However, the proposed rule did not remove or replace paragraph 2807.15(b). One commenter stated that the proposed section 2807.15(c) does not require the BLM to provide written notice to the grant holder of a land transfer under paragraph (c) as does paragraph (b). The commenter stated that notification should be required under both situations. Two commenters stated that holders should be given at least 60 days advance written notice while another commenter recommended at least 180 days of advance notice. Two commenters provided alternative language to combine previous paragraph (b) and proposed paragraph (c) of section 2807.15 into a new paragraph 2807.15(b). Proposed paragraph (d) would then become final paragraph (c). The recommended language submitted by these commenters to replace previous paragraph (b) and proposed paragraph (c) with a combined paragraph (b) primarily states that the BLM must provide written notification of at least 60 days prior to any proposed transfer date so that new grant terms and conditions can be negotiated. In addition, any new grant terms and conditions negotiated must be comparable to those normally found in an easement or other similar document used for utility facilities on private lands.
The BLM agrees with the commenters that proposed section 2807.15(c) is confusing because we failed to state that the action discussed in (c) would actually occur after the reasonable notification period specified in paragraph (b) and prior to the 3 options specified in paragraph (b) for
( printed page 65059)
completing the land transaction. We have therefore combined proposed paragraph (c) with previous paragraph (b) as explained above. This assures that reasonable notice is provided to all holders of a pending land transfer action and allows, at the holder's request, the conversion of existing FLPMA term grants to perpetual grants or easements. The land transfer action is then completed by:
(1) Transferring the land subject to your grant. In this case, administration of your grant for the lands the BLM formerly administered is transferred to the new owner of the land;
(2) Transferring the land, with the BLM retaining administration of your grant; or
(3) Reserving to the United States the land your grant encumbers, and with the BLM retaining administration of your grant.
We did not adopt the specific language submitted by the two commenters for paragraph (b) because we do not agree that a certain number of days be specified in the rule, since each land transaction will be governed by its own timeline. However, the final rule does specify that reasonable notice will be provided to the holder so that any amended application to an existing grant may be completed prior to the transfer of land out of Federal ownership. We also did not adopt the language submitted for paragraph (b) because it failed to include the three alternatives (see previous paragraph above) for treating encumbrances when land is transferred out of Federal ownership.
Proposed section 2807.15(d) explained that you and the new owner of the land may agree to negotiate new grant terms and conditions at any time after the land encumbered by your grant is transferred out of Federal ownership. In the final rule, proposed paragraph (d) is renumbered as final paragraph (c) because, as discussed above, we incorporated proposed paragraph (c) into final paragraph (b). No other changes were made to this section.
Part 2880—Rights-of-Way Under The Mineral Leasing Act
Subpart 2885—Terms and Conditions of MLA Grants and TUPs
This final rule revises 5 existing sections of this subpart and adds 2 new sections.
Section 2885.11 What terms and conditions must I comply with?
Final section 2885.11(a) explains that all grants, except those issued for a term of 3 years or less, will expire on December 31 of the final year of the grant. Previous section 2885.11(a) stated that all grants with a term of 1 year or longer would terminate on December 31 of the final year of the grant. This correction allows short-term grants and TUPs to expire on the day before their anniversary date. This revision also provides the holder of a 3-year grant or TUP with a full 3-year term to conduct activities authorized by the short-term right-of-way grant or TUP, instead of the 2 full years plus the partial first year under the previous section. Final section 2885.21(c) explains that the BLM considers the first partial calendar year in the initial rent payment period to be the first year of the term. Therefore, a 3-year grant or TUP, issued under the previous regulations, had a term period of 2 years plus the time period remaining in the calendar year of issuance. A 2-year grant or TUP had a term period of 1 year plus the time period remaining in the calendar year of issuance. Depending on when the grant or TUP was issued, the actual term could have been just over 2 years for a 3-year grant or TUP and could have been just over 1 year for a 2-year grant or TUP. Under the final rule, all grants and TUPs, except those issued for a term of 3 years or less expire on December 31 of the final year of the grant or TUP. The changes to this section allow the holder to use short-term grants and TUPs for the full period of the grant. For example, if a 3-year grant or TUP is issued under the final rule on October 1, 2008, it terminates on September 30, 2011, instead of December 31, 2010, under the previous rule. If a 2-year grant or TUP is issued under the final rule on October 1, 2008, it terminates on September 30, 2010, instead of December 31, 2009, under the previous rule. In most cases, the BLM will assess a one-time rental bill for the term of the grant, which reduces any administrative impact which might otherwise result from this revision. This change is also consistent with final section 2805.11(b)(2). Please refer to the preamble discussion for final section 2805.11(b)(2) for further information on this revision. We received no comments on the proposed changes to this section and the final rule adopts the proposed section without change.
Section 2885.12 What rights does a grant or TUP convey?
Prior section 2885.12(e) stated that you have a right to assign your grant or TUP to another, provided that you obtain the BLM's prior written approval. The BLM added the phrase “unless your grant or TUP specifically states that such approval is unnecessary” to this section to indicate that the BLM's prior written approval may be unnecessary in certain cases. In most cases, assignments continue to be subject to the BLM's written approval. However, with this change, the BLM can amend existing grants and TUPs to allow future assignments without the BLM's prior written approval. This may be especially important to the future administration of a grant when the land encumbered by a grant or TUP is being transferred out of Federal ownership, and there is a request to increase the term of your grant or TUP under section 2886.15(b). We received one comment that specifically supported this change. The final rule adopts the proposed section without change.
Section 2885.19 What is the rent for a linear right-of-way grant?
Final section 2885.19 replaces previous section 2885.19. Final section 2885.19(a) explains that the BLM will use the Per Acre Rent Schedule to calculate the rent. In addition, paragraph (a) explains that counties (or other geographical areas) will be assigned to a county zone number and per acre zone value based upon 80 percent of their per acre land and building value published in the NASS Census. The initial assignment of counties to the zones covers years 2006 through 2010 of the Per Acre Rent Schedule, and is based upon data contained in the most recent NASS Census (2002). Subsequent assignments of counties will occur every 5 years following the publication of the NASS Census. Paragraph (a) further explains that the Per Acre Rent Schedule will be adjusted periodically as follows:
(1) The BLM will adjust the per acre rent in section 2885.19(b) for all types of linear right-of-way facilities in each zone each calendar year based on the average annual change in the IPD-GDP for the 10-year period immediately preceding the year that the NASS Census data becomes available. For example, the average annual change in the IPD-GDP from 1994 to 2003 (the 10-year period immediately preceding the year (2004) that the 2002 NASS Census data became available) is 1.9 percent. This annual adjustment factor is applied to years 2006 through 2015 of the Per Acre Rent Schedule. Likewise, the average annual change in the IPD-GDP from 2004 to 2013 (the 10-year period immediately preceding the year (2014) when the 2012 NASS Census data will become available) will be applied to years 2016 through 2025 of the Per Acre Rent Schedule.
(2) The BLM will review the NASS Census data from the 2012 NASS
( printed page 65060)
Census, and each subsequent 10-year period, and as appropriate, revise the number of county zones and the per acre zone values. Any revision will include 100 percent of the number of counties and listed geographical areas for all states and the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico and will reasonably reflect their average per acre land and building values contained in the NASS Census.
The above revision mechanisms replace previous paragraphs (b) and (c) of section 2885.19.
Final section 2885.19(b) replaces previous section 2885.19(d) and explains that you may obtain a copy of the current Per Acre Rent Schedule from any BLM state or field office or by writing to the BLM and requesting a copy. The BLM also posts the current rent schedule on the BLM Homepage on the Internet at
www.blm.gov.
The Per Acre Rent Schedule (and its various components) referred to in this section is the same as found in final sections 2806.20, 2806.21, and 2806.22. The BLM received several comments on the components of the Per Acre Rent Schedule in proposed sections 2806.20, 2806.21, and 2806.22. Based on those comments, counties will be assigned to a zone in the Per Acre Rent Schedule based on 80 percent of the average per acre land and building value as found in the NASS Census instead of 100 percent of that value. The rate of return will be a constant 5.27 percent which is the 10-year average of the 30-year Treasury Bond yield from 1998-2008. In addition, the annual index adjustment will be based on the average annual change in the IPD-GDP instead of the annual change in the CPI-U. No change was made in how the BLM will revise the Per Acre Rent Schedule each 10 years other than delaying its effectiveness by 1 year. The comments to proposed sections 2806.20, 2806.21, and 2806.22 and the BLM's response to those comments (as reflected in final sections 2806.20, 2806.21 and 2806.22) are applicable to this section as well and are discussed in greater detail above.
Section 2885.20 How will BLM calculate my rent for linear rights-of-way the Per Acre Rent Schedule covers?
Final sections 2885.20(a) and (c) are similar to and replace previous sections 2885.20(a) and (b), respectively. Final section 2885.20(a) explains that, except as provided by section 2885.22, the BLM calculates your rent by multiplying the rent per acre for the appropriate county (or other geographical area) zone from the current schedule by the number of acres (as rounded up to the nearest tenth of an acre) in the right-of-way or TUP area that fall in each zone multiplied by the number of years in the rental payment period (the length of time for which the holder is paying rent). The final rent calculation methodology is identical to the previous rent calculation methodology; only the components (average per acre land values, county zones, the EF, and rate of return) have been revised. Please refer to the preamble discussion for section 2806.23(a) for details and examples of how this process works. Final section 2885.20(c) explains that if the BLM has not previously used the rent schedule to calculate your rent, we may do so after giving you reasonable written notice. Except for a minor edit, we made no substantive changes to these two sections from what was proposed.
Final section 2885.20(b) provides for the phase-in of the initial implementation of the Per Acre Rent Schedule by reducing the 2009 per acre rent by 25 percent, and by providing a limited 2-year phase-in period as the result of revisions to the rent schedule under section 2885.19(a)(2) if payment of the new rent causes the holder undue hardship and it is in the public interest to approve the phase-in period.
In the ANPR and the proposed rule, the BLM specifically requested comments on whether any phase-in provision is necessary, and if so, what alternative information, including holder qualifications or thresholds other than the percentage increase, might the BLM use to support a longer phase-in period, or to support a phase-in model that specifically addresses financial hardship due to potentially large rental increases. The BLM received 6 comments in response to the ANPR which generally supported a phase-in provision. Three commenters said that any rental increases greater than $1,000 should be phased-in over 5 years. One commenter said that a 6-year phase-in period would be appropriate for all rental increases. The commenter suggested no change for the first year, followed by five 20 percent annual increases. One commenter supported a phase-in period and potential relief from increased payment amounts, but offered no specific options.
In the proposed rule, the BLM proposed a limited one-time, 2-year phase-in provision which would provide the holders of MLA authorizations hardship provisions similar to those currently available to holders of FLPMA authorizations. The proposed MLA phase-in provision would only apply in situations where rent is paid on an annual basis, and the increase in the rental fee is so substantial (500 percent or greater increase) that payment of the new rental amount would likely cause undue financial hardship.
Almost all commenters on the proposed rule stated that some type of phase-in provision is necessary for all authorization holders in order to allow sufficient time to absorb the additional fee increases. One commenter said that the lack of a comprehensive phase-in provision for holders of FLPMA authorizations was the most unreasonable element of the proposed rule. Many commenters supported a 5- or 6-year phase-in period, and one commenter proposed limiting potential fee increases each year to no more than 10 percent of the initial per acre rental rate at the time the grant was issued. One commenter said that it was critical that the new rates not be implemented prior to January 2009.
The BLM does not agree with the commenters that a specific long-term phase-in provision is always necessary or reasonable when implementing a new or revised rent schedule, especially when other existing avenues to mitigate large rental increases are available to most holders. Under current section 2806.15(c), the BLM State Director may waive or reduce your rent payment, if the BLM determines that: (1) Paying the full rent for your FLPMA grant will cause you undue hardship; and (2) it is in the public interest to waive or reduce your rent. However, this provision has never been available to holders of MLA authorizations, nor was it included in the proposed rule. To provide some relief for MLA holders, final section 2885.20(b)(1) provides for a phase-in of the initial implementation of the Per Acre Rent Schedule by reducing the 2009 per acre rent by 25 percent. A similar provision has been added for holders of FLPMA grants at section 2806.23(b). In calendar year 2009, all holders will pay 75 percent of the scheduled rental rates, and thereafter, 100 percent of the scheduled rental rates.
Final section 2885.20(b)(2) will allow a 2-year phase-in period to holders of MLA grants if, as the result of any revisions made to the Per Acre Rent Schedule under section 2885.19(a)(2), the payment of the new annual rental amount would cause a specific MLA holder undue hardship and it is in the public interest to approve the phase-in. Holders of FLPMA grants have the same opportunity for a similar phase-in provision under existing section 2806.15(c).
The phase-in provision in final section 2885.20(b)(2), however, is limited only to MLA holders that qualify as small business entities (as that term is defined by the Small
( printed page 65061)
Business Administration (SBA) regulations). It is estimated that only 5.3 percent of existing MLA grantees may be eligible for SBA programs (see 70 FR 21056). In addition, the two-year phase-in period will only be available once each 10-year period when revisions are made to the Per Acre Rent Schedule under section 2885.19(a)(2). Final section 2885.19(a)(2) provides for the revision of the rent schedule (including the number of county zones and the per acre zone values) based upon the NASS Census data from the 2012 NASS Census and each subsequent 10-year period. Therefore, the earliest year that final section 2885.20(b)(2) (the MLA phase-in provision based on hardship) will be available for use is 2016, since the 2012 NASS Census data will not be available until 2014 and any revised rent schedule based upon the 2012 NASS Census data will not be implemented until 2016 (see preamble discussion for section 2806.22). After 2016, final section 2885.20(b)(2) will not be available for use again until 2026, and then not until 2036, and so forth.
In addition to meeting the above criteria, the holder must also prove that payment of the new annual rental amount would cause undue hardship, that is, be such an expense that payment would cause the holder significant difficulty in the continued near-term operation of the subject business or right-of-way facility. Undue hardship is not shown by allegations of financial difficulty, but requires proof that the holder would suffer significant financial difficulty, i.e., severe, unique, or extraordinary difficulty, in the continued near-term operation of the subject business or right-of-way facility. The determination of undue hardship must therefore be made on a case by case basis. The BLM will require the holder to submit information which supports the claim of undue hardship. At a minimum, this information must include a credit bureau report and a financial statement. In addition, the holder must submit information that clearly documents the holder's financial capability to pay the full rental amount due in year two of the phase-in period, if approved. The BLM State Director makes the determination that undue hardship exists based upon a financial analysis of the information submitted which supports the undue hardship claim. If the BLM State Director finds that undue hardship exists and that an additional phase-in is in the public interest, payment of the amount in excess of the previous year's rent will be phased-in by equal increments over a 2-year period. In addition, the BLM will adjust the total calculated rent for year 2 of the phase-in period by the annual index provided by section 2885.19(a)(1).
The BLM believes that many of the concerns expressed by commenters regarding the lack of a comprehensive phase-in provision in the proposed rule have thus been addressed in the final rule by providing more advance notice of potentially large rental increases, reducing the NASS Census land and building value for each county by 20 percent, reducing the rate of return by 18.5 percent (from 6.47 percent to 5.27 percent), reducing the threshold from $1,000 to $500 for payment of annual rent instead of 10-year rental payments, and by waiving 25 percent of the calendar year 2009 rental rates for all authorization holders. These actions combined have eliminated the need for a 5-or 6-year phase-in period because the amount of the increase in rent receipts has been significantly reduced in the final rule. Holders will save nearly $10 million (or 54 percent) when comparing the rates/phase-in provisions contained in the proposed rule with the rates/phase-in provisions contained in the final rule (using actual acres billed for calendar year 2007). The proposed rates would have generated a total of $18,570,871 in 2007 if all acres were billed annually. Under the final rule, including the initial, one-time, 25 percent phase-in provision in rental rates, total rental receipts drop to $8,635,023. Without the initial, one-time, 25 percent phase-in provision, the total rental receipts would have been $11,512,757, or a 38 percent reduction in rental receipts from the proposed rule.
The BLM does not agree with the commenter that proposed limiting potential fee increases each year to no more than 10 percent of the initial per acre rental rate at the time the grant was issued. First, once the final schedule is implemented, increases in rent will be limited to the change in the annual IPD-GDP adjustment (which has historically averaged around 2 to 3 percent). Every 5 years, holders could experience additional rent increases because of the re-assignment of counties to new zones on the rent schedule. However, holders will have approximately 18 months of advance notice to prepare for any potential increases. Thus, most annual rent increases will be significantly less than 10 percent and holders will have adequate notice to prepare for any major increases that might result from counties being assigned to new rental zones based on new NASS Census data.
Secondly, the BLM believes it would be an extreme administrative burden to cap potential annual rent increases at 10 percent per authorization, as this commenter suggested, because grants are always subject to amendments and assignments that can affect the acres subject to rent. It would be very difficult and expensive for the BLM to adequately administer these potential changes and limit rent increases only in response to adjustments in the rent schedule itself, as compared to actual changes in the number of acres billed for that authorization from year to year.
Lastly, the BLM partially agrees with the commenter that said it was critical that the new rates not be implemented prior to January 2009. All existing grants should be billed on the calendar year basis and not their anniversary date. Therefore, the earliest the new rent schedule will apply to existing grants is January 2009, which is consistent with the suggestion of this commenter. However, if the new rent schedule becomes effective in calendar year 2008, the initial rent for new authorizations will be determined in accordance with the new rent schedule, even if the issuance date of the new grant is prior to January 2009.
The BLM does not expect the rental increases to be financially burdensome for most holders. The changes made in the Per Acre Rent Schedule in the final rule represent a permanent reduction of nearly 40 percent over the proposed rates (reducing the NASS Census land and building value for each county by 20 percent and reducing the rate of return by 18.5 percent (from 6.47 percent to 5.27 percent)). We believe that these changes, along with an additional 1-year advance notice of potentially large rental increases, reducing the threshold from $1,000 to $500 for payment of annual rent instead of 10-year rental payments, and by waiving 25 percent of the calendar year 2009 rental rates for all authorization holders, in conjunction with the more flexible rent payment options described in final sections 2806.24 and 2885.21, will provide appropriate relief from any large, unexpected increases in rent payments that are due to implementation of the revised linear rent schedule.
Section 2885.21 How must I make rental payments for a linear grant or TUP?
Final section 2885.21(a) explains that for TUPs you must make a one-time nonrefundable payment for the term of the TUP. For grants, except those that have been issued in perpetuity, you must make either nonrefundable annual payments or a nonrefundable payment for more than 1 year, as follows:
( printed page 65062)
(1)
One-time payments.
You may pay in advance the total rent amount for the entire term of the grant or any remaining years;
(2)
Multiple payments.
If you choose not to make a one-time payment, you must pay according to one of the following methods:
(i)
Payments by individuals.
If your annual rent is $100 or less, you must pay at 10-year intervals not to exceed the term of the grant. If your annual rent is greater than $100, you may pay annually or at 10-year intervals, not to exceed the term of the grant. For example, if you have a grant with a remaining term of 30 years, you may pay in advance for 10 years, 20 years, or 30 years, but not any other multi-year period.
(ii)
Payments by all others.
If your annual rent is $500 or less, you must pay rent at 10-year intervals, not to exceed the term of the grant. If your annual rent is greater than $500, you may pay annually or at 10-year intervals, not to exceed the term of the grant.
Final section 2885.21(a) replaces the rent payment options in previous section 2885.21(a). The primary difference is that under final section 2885.21(a), individuals who hold a grant with an annual rent greater than $100 would have the option to pay annually or at 10-year intervals, not to exceed the term of the grant. For example, if you have a grant with a term of 30 years, you may pay in advance for 10 years, 20 years, or 30 years, but not any other multi-year period. Previously, individuals that held a grant with an annual rent greater than $100 would have had the option to pay annually or for any multi-year period. The BLM made this change to make the rent payment options for individuals consistent with those available to non-individuals, except for the annual threshold levels of $100 and $500, respectively. If rent is not paid for the full term, subsequent rental payments will be based on the changes to the rental schedule as described in section 2885.19 (the annual CPI-U index adjustment; the re-assignment of counties each 5-year period; and/or the adjustment to the number and value of rental zones each 10-year period), but the $100 and $500 thresholds used to determine the eligibility for annual payments by individuals and business entities, respectively, will not be adjusted.
Final section 2885.21(b) explains how you must make rent payments for perpetual grants issued prior to November 16, 1973, except as provided by final section 2885.22(a). Previous section 2885.21 did not recognize that MLA grants issued prior to November 16, 1973, could have been issued for any term period, including a perpetual term. Under the MLA, grants issued after November 16, 1973, have a maximum term of 30 years. We added final section 2885.21(b) to explain that if you have an existing perpetual grant, you must make either nonrefundable annual payments or a nonrefundable payment for more than 1 year, as follows:
(1)
Payments by individuals.
If your annual rent is $100 or less, you must pay at 10-year intervals, not to exceed 30 years. If your annual rent is greater than $100, you may pay annually or at 10-year intervals, not to exceed 30 years.
(2)
Payments by all others.
If your annual rent is $500 or less, you must pay rent at 10-year intervals, not to exceed 30 years. If your annual rent is greater than $500, you may pay annually or at 10-year intervals, not to exceed 30 years.
Final section 2885.21(c) is nearly identical to previous section 2885.21(b). This section explains that the BLM considers the first partial calendar year in the initial rental payment period to be the first year of the term. The BLM prorates the first year rental amount based on the number of months left in the calendar year after the effective date of the grant.
Please refer to the preamble discussion for final section 2806.24 for an explanation of the revisions to this section and examples of various rent payment periods, as well as a discussion of any comments received on this section and the BLM's response to those comments.
Section 2885.22 How may I make rental payments when land encumbered by my term or perpetual linear grant is being transferred out of Federal ownership?
Final section 2885.22 explains how you would make one-time rental payments for your term or perpetual linear grant when land encumbered by your grant is being transferred out of Federal ownership.
Final section 2885.22(a) explains how the BLM would determine a one-time rent payment for perpetual MLA grants issued prior to November 16, 1973, when land encumbered by your grant is being transferred out of Federal ownership. If you have a perpetual grant and the land your grant encumbers is being transferred out of Federal ownership, you may choose to make a one-time rental payment. The BLM will determine the one-time payment for perpetual right-of-way grants by dividing the current annual rent for the subject property by an overall capitalization rate calculated from market data. The overall capitalization rate is the difference between a market yield rate and a percent annual rent increase as described in the formula below. The formula for this calculation is: One-time payment = annual rent/(Y−CR), where:
(1) Annual rent = current annual rent applicable to a subject property from the Per Acre Rent Schedule;
(2) Y = yield rate (rate of return) from the Per Acre Rent Schedule (5.27 percent); and
(3) CR = annual percent change in rent as determined by the most recent 10-year average of the difference in the IPD-GDP Index from January of one year to January of the following year.
The annual rent will be determined from the Per Acre Rent Schedule (see section 2885.19(b)), as updated under section 2885.19(a)(1) and (2). However, as final section 2885.22(b) explains, the per acre zone value and zone number used in the annual rental determination is based on the per acre value from acceptable market information or an appraisal, if any, for the land transfer action and not the county average per acre land and building value from the NASS Census. You may also submit an appraisal report on your own initiative under section 2806.25(d).
One commenter recommended that if the BLM uses the appraised land value (as provided by final section 2885.22(b)) to determine the appropriate zone on the rent schedule, then the formula to determine the one-time rent payment, as determined under final section 2885.22(a), should be modified to use the yield rate (Y) rather than the yield rate less the annual percent change in rent (CR). The formula would then be: one-time rent payment = Annual Rent/Y; rather than the one-time payment = Annual Rent/(Y−CR). The commenter said that this change is necessary to avoid the situation where the one-time payment under the appraisal method is greater than the one-time payment under the yield method. The commenter said that the change in the annual index is not necessary since the appraisal method already reflects the current land values for the purposes of calculating the one-time payment. The BLM understands the basis for this comment, but disagrees that it would be an appropriate change to make in this instance. The commenter claims that if appraisal data is used to assign land to a zone on the Per Acre Rent Schedule, then the annual rent adjustment index (CR in the formula) should be excluded from the formula when determining one-time rent. We disagree because the Per Acre Rent Schedule is still being
( printed page 65063)
used to establish the annual per acre rental value and the annual adjustment factor is an inherent component of the schedule. For example, if appraisal data were to be used each 5-year period to re-assign counties to their appropriate zones on the rent schedule, the annual adjustment factor (the annual percent change in rent as determined by the most recent 10-year average of the difference in the IPD-GDP Index from January of one year to January of the following year) would still be applied to determine subsequent year's per acre rent value and would continue until the next appraisal. In situations where the rent schedule is not used in any way to determine the one-time rental payment (such as for easements pursuant to section 2806.26) it might be appropriate to exclude the annual adjustment factor from the above formula, but only if the appraisal report did not provide for an annual adjustment factor. In this circumstance, the Per Acre Rent Schedule (and its various components, including the annual adjustment factor) is still used to determine the annual per acre rent value, which in turn, is used in the income capitalization formula to determine the one-time rent payment.
Final section 2885.22(c) explains that, when no acceptable market information is available and no appraisal has been completed for the land transfer action, or when the BLM requests it, you must prepare an appraisal report as required under section 2806.25(d) of this chapter. We received one comment on this section stating that holders should always have the opportunity to submit their own appraisal report to determine one-time rent for perpetual right-of-way grants when land encumbered by the grant is transferred out of Federal ownership. We agree with the commenter (see discussion for section 2806.25(c) for rationale) and allow for this in the final rule (see section 2885.22(b)). Otherwise, final section 2885.22(c) is the same as proposed.
Section 2885.22(d) is new to the final rule, and explains how rent for a term grant is determined when the land encumbered by the grant is being transferred out of Federal ownership. This section also explains that the amount determined must not exceed the one-time rent payment for a perpetual grant as determined under paragraphs (a) and (b). The BLM added this paragraph to the final rule based upon a comment that stated that in a rare occurrence, the one-time rent payment for term grants could exceed the one-time payment for a perpetual grant. The BLM agrees that, although unlikely, this could occur, but only when one-time rents are being calculated for MLA grants under this section. This situation could not occur for FLPMA authorizations since the holder always has the option of obtaining a perpetual grant, nor would it occur for rents calculated under section 2885.21, since term and perpetual grants are treated equally under that section.
Please refer to the preamble discussion for final section 2806.25 for additional details regarding one-time rent payments for perpetual grants when the land your grant encumbers is being transferred out of Federal ownership.
Subpart 2886—Operations on MLA Grants and TUPs
The BLM is amending one section of this subpart which deals with administration and operations of grants and TUPs.
Section 2886.15 How is grant or TUP administration affected if the BLM land my grant or TUP encumbers is transferred to another Federal agency or out of Federal ownership?
This section explains how grant administration is affected if the BLM land your grant or TUP encumbers is transferred to another Federal agency or out of Federal ownership. We proposed no changes to previous paragraphs (a) and (b) of this section. However, previous paragraph (c) was split into proposed paragraphs (c) and (d) to make it clearer.
Although we proposed no changes to section 2886.15(b), we have revised it in the final rule based upon several comments that the proposed formatting of paragraphs (b) and (c) was extremely confusing. We therefore combined proposed paragraph (c) with previous paragraph (b) as follows. Final section 2886.15(b) has been revised to incorporate the intent of proposed paragraph (c) and explains that the BLM will provide reasonable notice to you if there is a proposal to transfer the land your grant or TUP encumbers out of Federal ownership. Furthermore, if you request, the BLM will negotiate new grant or TUP terms and conditions with you. This may include increasing the term of your grant to a 30-year term or replacing your TUP with a grant. These changes, if any, become effective prior to the time the land is transferred out of Federal ownership. The BLM may then, in conformance with existing policies and procedures:
(1) Transfer the land subject to your grant or TUP. In this case, administration of your grant or TUP for the lands the BLM formerly administered is transferred to the new owner of the land;
(2) Transfer the land, but the BLM retains administration of your grant or TUP; or
(3) Reserve to the United States the land your grant or TUP encumbers, and the BLM retains administration of your grant or TUP.
The above changes provide assurance that reasonable notice will be given to all holders of a pending land transfer action and allows, at the holder's request, the opportunity to negotiate new grant or TUP terms and conditions with the BLM. This may include increasing the term of a grant to a 30-year term or replacing a TUP with a grant. Please refer to the preamble discussion in section 2806.26 for the comments received on the issuance of term easements under MLA and the rationale for not providing for term easements in this section. Please refer to the preamble discussion in section 2807.15 above for the comments received on proposed sections 2807.15 and 2886.15 and the rationale for the changes described herein.
Proposed section 2886.15(d) explained that you and the new owner of the land may agree to negotiate new grant terms and conditions at any time after the land encumbered by your grant or TUP is transferred out of Federal ownership. In the final rule, proposed paragraph (d) is renumbered as final paragraph (c) because we incorporated proposed paragraph (c) into final paragraph (b) as discussed above. No other changes were made to this section.
Subpart 2888—Trespass
This rule revises one section of this subpart which pertains to trespass.
Section 2888.10 What is trespass?
Final section 2888.10 is identical to previous section 2888.10 except for a minor edit to paragraph (c). Final section 2888.10(c) does not include the previous reference in section 2888.10 that the rental exemption provisions of part 2800 do not apply to grants issued under this part. This reference is no longer necessary because we added language to final section 2806.14(b), which explains that the rent exemptions listed in final section 2806.14 do not apply if you are in trespass. This includes trespass actions covered under final section 2888.10. Please refer to the preamble discussion for final section 2806.14(b) for further details on the reasons for this change.
( printed page 65064)
Part 2920—Leases, Permits, and Easements
Subpart 2920—Lease, Permits, and Easements: General Provisions
The rule amends two sections of this subpart, which addresses fees and reimbursement of costs.
Section 2920.6 Reimbursement of Costs
Previous section 2920.6(b) has been amended by deleting from the second sentence the phrase “except that any permit whose total rental is less than $250 shall be exempt from reimbursement of costs requirements.” Final section 2920.6(b) explains that the reimbursement of costs for authorizations issued under part 2920 will be in accordance with sections 2804.14 and 2805.16, which provide for the reimbursement of processing and monitoring costs. Previously, any permit whose total rent was less than $250 would have been exempt from reimbursement of processing and monitoring costs.
Section 2920.8 Fees
Previously, section 2920.8(b) provided that each request for renewal, transfer, or assignment of a lease or easement be accompanied by a non-refundable processing fee of $25. Also, the authorized officer could waive or reduce this fee for requests for permit renewals that could be processed with a minimal amount of work. Final section 2920.8(b) amends the previous section by making each request for renewal, transfer, or assignment of a lease or easement subject to both a non-refundable processing and monitoring fee determined under section 2804.14 and section 2805.16. The second sentence of the previous section, which allowed the authorized officer to waive or reduce this fee for permit renewals, is also deleted because fees for actions processed with a minimal amount of work are accounted for in current sections 2804.14 and 2805.16. These revisions are corrections to the 2005 right-of-way rule, which established a schedule for processing and monitoring fees for applications and grants issued under parts 2800, 2880, and 2920. These revisions are necessary to provide the correct cross references to the appropriate processing and monitoring fees found in sections 2804.14 and 2805.16 for actions taken under part 2920.
In accordance with the criteria in Executive Order 12866, this rule is not a significant regulatory action. The Office of Management and Budget makes the final determination as to its significance under Executive Order 12866.
a. This rule does not have an annual effect of $100 million or more on the economy. It will not adversely affect in a material way the economy, productivity, competition, jobs, the environment, public health or safety, or State, local, or tribal governments or communities. A cost-benefit and economic analysis has not been prepared. However, the following economic analysis and calculations supports this conclusion.
Estimated Economic Effects.
The rule could potentially increase rental revenues collected by the BLM and, conversely, increase costs to grant holders, by an estimated average of $14.7 million each year (plus annual IPD-GDP adjustments).
Background
The definition of the baseline is an important step in evaluating the economic effects of a regulation. The baseline is taken to be the regulations previously in place. A baseline assumption is that under the status quo, right-of-way activity on Federal lands would continue at least at current levels. Given that the final rule incorporates many suggestions received from industry on the ANPR and the proposed rule, continued right-of-way activity on Federal lands seems a reasonable assumption.
Current Right-of-Way Activity
In 2007 the BLM administered 12,500 rights-of-way subject to linear rent, held by over 1,600 entities, covering approximately 373,000 acres in 15 states. Some right-of-way holders have a single grant, while others hold hundreds of individual grants. Individual right-of-way holdings may be as small as 0.01 acre or larger than 22,000 acres. The top 18 grant-holders (by acreage) account for more than one-half of the total acreage. Eighty percent of the total right-of-way acreage is held by about 4 percent of all grant-holders, while the smallest 1,000 grant-holders account for less than 1 percent of total right-of-way acreage. The breakdown by rental payments is similar to the breakdown by acreage.
Original Rent Schedule
The original 1987 rent schedule was intended to reduce the need for individual appraisals, establish consistent rationale for determination of rental, reduce the differences between procedures used by the FS and the BLM, resolve conflicts which led to numerous appeals of rental determinations, and reduce both government and industry administrative costs. The right-of-way rental rates assessed in 2007 were derived from the 1987 rule's schedule, presented in Tables 7 and 8.
Table 7—Previous per Acre Rent Schedule for electric transmission and distribution lines, telephone lines, non-energy related pipelines, and other linear rights-of-way.
Previous Rule
[1987 Zone Value × 70% × 6.41% × Annual Change in IPD-GDP (+62% 1987-2007)]
Zone
1987 zone value
2007 actual zone rent
Zone 1
$50
$3.65
Zone 2
100
7.28
Zone 3
200
14.60
Zone 4
300
21.90
Zone 5
400
29.20
Zone 6
500
36.49
Zone 7
600
43.81
Zone 8
1,000
72.97
Table 8—Previous per Acre Rent Schedule for oil, gas, and other energy-related pipelines, roads, ditches, and canals.
Previous Rule
[1987 Zone Value × 80% × 6.41% × Annual Change in IPD-GDP (+62% 1987-2007)]
Zone
1987 zone value
2007 actual zone rent
Zone 1
$50
$4.17
Zone 2
100
8.32
Zone 3
200
16.71
Zone 4
300
25.00
Zone 5
400
33.39
Zone 6
500
41.70
Zone 7
600
50.03
Zone 8
1,000
83.40
Zone rent for 2007 is based on zone rent for 1987. Zone rent per acre for 1987 is found by determining the correct zone for a right-of-way, then multiplying the zone value (i.e., the upper bracket for land values per acre within a zone) by the EF (70 percent for electric and telephone lines; 80 percent for energy-related pipelines and roads) and the return on investment (6.41 percent). This 1987 zone rent is converted to 2007 zone rent using the change in the IPD-GDP between 1987
( printed page 65065)
and 2007 (approximately a 62 percent increase).
Final Rent Schedule
The zone brackets in the schedule in this final rule are set to accommodate all U.S. counties and the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, based upon 80 percent of their average per acre land and building value published in the most recent NASS Census. The average per acre land and building values for the 3,080 counties identified in the NASS Census range from a low of $75 to a high of nearly $100,000. Table 9 shows the zone brackets for the 12 zones in the final rule.
Table 9—Rental Zones, Based on 2002 NASS Census Average per Acre County Land and Building Values
2002 Land and building values
Zone
$1 to $250
Zone 1
$251 to $500
Zone 2
$501 to $1,000
Zone 3
$1,001 to $1,500
Zone 4
$1,501 to $2,000
Zone 5
$2,001 to $3,000
Zone 6
$3,001 to $5,000
Zone 7
$5,001 to $10,000
Zone 8
$10,001 to $20,000
Zone 9
$20,001 to $30,000
Zone 10
$30,001 to $50,000
Zone 11
$50,001 to $100,000
Zone 12
For the BLM's purposes, each of the 3,080 counties identified in the NASS Census is assigned to a zone, based on 80 percent of the average per acre land and building value as determined by the most recent NASS Census. At the time of this final rule, the most current NASS Census provides 2002 data. The next NASS Census will provide 2007 data, and is due to be published in 2009.
Determining Right-of-Way Rent
Annual right-of-way rent for 2002 is based on the following factors:
1. Schedule zone, determined by 80 percent of the county's 2002 average per acre land and building value;
2. EF (set at 50 percent for all linear rights-of-way);
3. Government's rate of return, set at the average of the 30-year Treasury bond rate, taken over the 10 years from 1998 to 2008; and
4. Total acreage within the right-of-way area.
The zone rent is adjusted annually by the change in the Gross Domestic Product, Implicit Price Deflator index.
Table 10 shows the right-of-way rent per acre for each zone for the 2002 base rent year. The annual per acre rent in this table is determined by multiplying the county zone value (upper limit) by the EF and the rate of return. The EF is a measure of the degree that a particular type of facility encumbers a right-of-way area or excludes other types of land uses and is set at 50 percent. The rate of return represents the return the Government could reasonably expect for the use of public assets, and is set at the average of the 30-year Treasury bond taken over the previous 10 years from 1998 to 2008 or 5.27 percent. Table 5 also displays the per acre rent values for each county zone for the 2002 base year and each subsequent year after application of the annual index.
Table 10—2002 Base Year—per Acre Rent Schedule
Zone number
Maximum zone value
Right-of-way
annual
rental rate*
Zone 1
$250
$6.59
Zone 2
500
13.18
Zone 3
1,000
26.35
Zone 4
1,500
39.53
Zone 5
2,000
52.70
Zone 6
3,000
79.05
Zone 7
5,000
131.75
Zone 8
10,000
263.50
Zone 9
20,000
527.00
Zone 10
30,000
790.50
Zone 11
50,000
1,317.50
Zone 12
100,000
2,635.00
* Per acre right-of-way rent for one year calculated assuming a 50 percent EF and 5.27 percent rate of return.
The total amount a right-of-way grant holder is billed also depends on the number of acres within the right-of-way area that fall within each zone and the years in the rent payment period. Once the per-acre rent has been determined for a particular right-of-way, this amount is multiplied by the total acreage in the right-of-way, and by the number of years in the rent payment period.
Phase-In Provision
The BLM has added an initial phase-in provision for all holders.. The BLM will phase-in the initial implementation of the Per Acre Rent Schedule by reducing the 2009 per acre rent by 25 percent. In calendar year 2009, all holders will pay 75 percent of the scheduled rental rates, and thereafter, 100 percent of the scheduled rental rates. An additional 2-year phase-in period may be granted to holders of MLA grants if, as the result of any revisions made to the Per Acre Rent Schedule under section 2885.19(a)(2), the payment of the new annual rental amount would cause a specific holder undue hardship and it is in the public interest to approve the phase-in. However, only holders of MLA grants that qualify as a small business entity (as that term is defined by the Small Business Administration regulations) will be eligible for this additional phase-in period. Holders of FLPMA grants have the same opportunity for a similar phase-in provision under existing section 2806.15(c).
Estimated Impacts of the Final Schedule
The increase in rental fees could have potential impacts on all holders of right-of-way grants, as well as the energy industry and, ultimately, energy consumers. To the extent that right-of-way grant-holders continue to maintain facilities on public land whose value has increased since 1987, there will also be an increase in rental fees to the U.S. Treasury. Some of the increase in fees may be passed on to energy consumers in the form of higher utility bills, but we expect that if there is any increase, as explained below, it will be minimal.
Tierney and Hibbard (2006) conducted a study (see Tierney, S.F., and Hibbard, P.J., 2006, Energy Policy Act Section 1813 Comments: Report of the Ute Indian Tribe of the Uintah and Ouray Reservation for Submission to the U.S. Departments of Energy and Interior, Boston, MA) of the contribution of right-of-way costs to end-user energy prices, finding that:
1. Right-of-way costs in general are a minor component of regulated electric transmission and gas transportation rates, regardless of how land value changes by location or with time;
2. When viewed from the perspective of end-use consumer prices, the costs to acquire rights-of-way are de minimis; and
3. In the case of gas markets and competitive electricity markets, changes to right-of-way costs generally affect commodity supplier profits, not retail prices.
Based on this analysis, there will likely be no significant impact on consumers as a result of the changes this rule makes to previous regulations.
Estimated Costs Under the Final Schedule
The expected response to an increase in a good's price is a decrease in the quantity demanded of that good. Thus, if the net effect of the rule is to raise a right-of-way grant holder's full cost of maintaining a right-of-way on public land, it would be reasonable to predict a decrease in the number of right-of-way applications. Nevertheless, given the finding by Tierney and Hibbard (2006) that right-of-way costs in general (not
( printed page 65066)
restricted to Federal lands) are a minor portion of total energy transportation costs, no significant decrease in energy right-of-way activity is expected. The BLM also believes for the same reasons that no significant decrease in non-energy right-of-way activity would occur due to the increase in right-of-way costs.
Assuming that right-of-way activity is relatively insensitive to the rental fee, it is possible to estimate the payments that would have been due to the BLM (U.S. Treasury) in FY 2007 had the final schedule been in effect. The following analyses are based on data from the BLM's automated lands billing system (Land and Realty Authorization Module).
In 2007, the BLM issued bills for 12,545 linear right-of-way grants. Approximately half of these bills were for rent payment periods of 5 years or more. The total amount billed for these linear grants was $6.5 million. Had these rights-of-way been paid under the new schedule (for the same rent payment periods), the total collected would have been $14 million, an increase of approximately $7.5 million, or 115 percent. The BLM expects that it will continue to issue approximately the same number of bills for the same number of annual authorizations each year, while the number of bills for multi-year rental payments will continue to decline. It is expected that those authorizations with annual rental payments in excess of $500 will continue to be billed on an annual basis, although the holder has the option to pay for 10-year terms or the entire term of the grant. Under the final rule, the holder will have to pay for a minimum 10-year period if the annual rental payment is $500 or less for a non-individual or $100 or less for an individual. Under the 1987 regulations, the maximum rental payment term was 5 years. The 2005 rule required the holder to pay for the term of the grant, or at 10-year intervals, unless the holder was an individual whose annual rent was greater than $100, in which case, annual payments could have been made.
Table 11 lists the 15 states and the total linear right-of-way acreage within each state that was billed for rent in 2007. If this acreage (373,000) were billed on just an annual basis, the total rent assessed using the previous Per Acre Rent Schedule and previous regulations would be $5.1 million. If this same acreage were assessed annual rent in 2007 using the Per Acre Rent Schedule of this final rule, the total rent would have been $11.5 million, an increase of $6.4 million. Changes in rental payments are due in large part to changes in land values underlying the rights-of-way that have occurred since the previous per acre rent schedule was implemented in 1987. According to the 2006 NASS annual report, between 1987 and 2002, U.S. per acre farm real estate values increased by 102 percent on average. Table 11 shows an increase in annual rent payments of 126 percent. However, if the $11.5 million in 2007 rent receipts were reduced by 11 percent (the percent change in the annual index factor (IPD-GDP) between 2002 and 2007) to $10.2 million, the increase in annual rent payments is 101 percent, or nearly identical to the change in land values in the United States from 1987 to 2002.
The 2007 NASS annual report shows an additional 79 percent increase in U.S. per acre farm real estate values from 2002 to 2007. We expect rent receipts to increase proportionately in 2011, which will be the year that the counties are re-assigned to their proper zone on the Per Acre Rent Schedule based upon 80 percent of their per acre land and building value from the 2007 NASS Census. As mentioned previously, the 2007 NASS Census data will not be available until June 2009 and will not be used to re-assign the counties to their appropriate rent zone until 2011.
Table 11—Linear Right-of-Way Acres by State: Previous and Final Rent for 2007
State
Acres
1 Year rental
(previous rates)
1 Year rental
(final rates)
Percentage
increase
AZ
25,972.55
$482,096.84
$1,405,313.66
191.50
CA
43,461.11
796,888.69
3,079,639.74
286.46
CO
18,223.78
315,362.80
600,722.06
90.49
ID
22,114.09
351,734.14
949,494.24
169.95
MT
4,908.93
72,353.90
66,009.14
−8.77
ND
42.52
353.76
315.50
−10.82
NE
133.73
973.66
994.50
2.14
NM
81,822.40
839,551.79
959,839.30
14.33
NV
63,254.22
1,114,387.79
2,326,616.45
108.78
OR
10,083.36
125,462.21
417,482.76
232.76
SD
119.33
2,611.72
2,573.20
−1.47
TX
81.64
679.24
4,843.70
613.11
UT
18,149.87
186,804.30
431,210.96
130.84
WA
264.49
5,101.85
37,999.03
644.81
WY
84,351.65
794,070.09
1,229,703.20
54.86
Total
372,983.67
5,088,432.78
11,512,757.44
126.25
Table 12 provides the percent change in land values and the percent change in rent receipts for the 15 counties having over 5,000 billed acres in rights-of-way, as of 2007. Taken together, these 15 counties account for over 53 percent of all right-of-way acres billed by the BLM in 2007, and over 55 percent of the rent collected for 2007. San Bernardino County, California (see Table 12), is a good example of how land values in some counties have risen dramatically in the last 20 years. This southern California county had 24,822 acres of public land encumbered by authorized right-of-way facilities that were billed for rent in 2007 using the previous rent schedule. The previous schedule was based on a 1987 land value of $200 per acre for San Bernardino County, meaning that these holdings were valued at a total of $5 million in 1987. Applying the IPD-GDP factor used in the previous schedule increased the value of this land to $7.1 million in 2002. The 2002 NASS land and building data lists San Bernardino County at $2,144 per acre, for a total value of $53.2 million. This data indicates that in this example the Federal Government was
( printed page 65067)
basing linear right-of-way rents on only 13.3 percent of the 2002 land value, largely due to the rapid increase in land values in southern California since 1987. Furthermore, the NASS annual reports show that between 2002 and 2007 farm real estate values have increased an average of 79 percent nationwide. A continued trend of rising real estate values would have led to further undervaluation by the previous schedule. As a result, had the BLM used the Per Acre Rent Schedule of this final rule to assess rent for linear right-of-way acres in San Bernardino County in FY 2007, rental receipts would have increased nearly 300 percent (see Table 12).
In contrast, land values in most counties in New Mexico and Wyoming, where the majority of linear rights-of-way are located, have increased at a much slower rate than the national average. Had the final rent schedule been in effect for 2007, most counties in these 2 states would have experienced only modest increases in rents due, or even decreases. For example, in San Juan County, New Mexico, where between 1987 and 2002 the value of land increased by over 200 percent, rents would have increased by 79 percent. In Sweetwater County, Wyoming, where between 1987 (per BLM's per acre rent schedule) and 2002 (per the NASS Census data) land values have actually fallen, rents would have been almost flat, decreasing by 7 percent. These lower land values in New Mexico and Wyoming would result in only a 14 percent and a 55 percent increase, respectively, in the total rental receipts, statewide, for 2007 (as compared to a 286 percent increase for California and a 126 percent increase for all BLM states) when using the Per Acre Rent Schedule of this final rule as compared with the total rental receipts for 2007 when using the previous Per Acre Rent Schedule (see Table 11).
Table 12—Percent Change in Land Values and Rent Receipts by Counties With 5,000 or More Acres Billed for Right-of-Way Facilities on Public Land in 2007
County
State
Right-of-Way acres
1987
Assigned
land value
2002 NASS Census land value
Percent change in land value
2007
Assessed
rent using
previous
schedule
2007
Assessed
rent using
final
schedule
Percent
increase
in rent
receipts
Sweetwater
WY
28,420
$100
$98
−2
$227,684
$210,877
−7
San Bernardino
CA
24,822
200
2,144
972
377,399
1,472,668
290
San Juan
NM
24,523
100
324
224
202,640
363,679
79
Eddy
NM
21,456
100
255
155
173,465
159,205
−8
Clark a
NV
13,780
50
3,567
7,034
51,676
1,226,454
2273
White Pine
NV
12,458
50
544
988
45,564
184,749
305
Lea
NM
10,215
100
156
56
82,787
75,798
−8
Sublette
WY
9,833
100
733
633
79,966
291,755
265
Maricopa
AZ
9.544
400
3,026
657
284,502
849,455
199
Lincoln
WY
8,362
100
906
806
65,110
248,087
281
Rio Arriba
NM
8,301
200
328
64
138,217
123,101
−11
Carbon
WY
8,073
100
214
114
64,019
59,903
−6
Rio Blanco
CO
6,871
200
669
235
113,709
203,855
79
Fremont
WY
6,167
100
311
211
49,378
45,758
−7
Eureka
NV
5,095
50
230
360
18,691
37,803
102
Subtotal
197,920
107
778
627
1,974,809
5,553,149
181
Clark County Sub-Zones
NV
876
b
14,001
3,567
−75
852,466
77,952
−91
Total
198,796
2,827,275
5,631,101
99
a
Entries for Clark County do not include rights-of-way in Clark County “unique zones.”
b
1987 Assigned Land Value for Clark County “unique zones” is a weighted average across 8 unique zones there.
While the land values in certain counties in New Mexico and Wyoming increased modestly from 1987 to 2002, the land values in Clark County, Nevada, as shown in Table 12, increased dramatically (7,034 percent) during this time period. Much of this increase can be attributed to the tremendous growth rate and demand for undeveloped land in and surrounding Las Vegas, Nevada, the largest city in Clark County as well as the state of Nevada. In recognition of these higher land values in the Las Vegas area, a “unique zone” Per Acre Rent Schedule with 8 zones whose land values ranged from $4,000 to $75,000 per acre was established in 1987 under the 1987 regulations. The annual per acre rent values ranged from approximately $300 to $6,000 (in 2007). The BLM used the “unique zone” Per Acre Rent Schedule (see Section I Background of this preamble for additional information on the “unique zone” Per Acre Rent Schedule) to assess rent ($853,000 in 2007) for approximately 80 right-of-way grants in the Las Vegas area which were issued within the “unique zone” areas prior to 2002. In addition, another 225 rights-of-way were located within the Las Vegas “unique zone” area, but the BLM used the 1987 Per Acre Rent Schedule to determine annual rent for these rights-of-way in accordance with Washington Office Instruction Memorandum 2002-172. Had the BLM used the “unique zone” rates to determine rent for these 225 grants, an additional $2.4 million would have been collected in 2007 (based on an average annual rent payment of $10,663 for each of the 80 right-of-way grants subject to the “unique zone” rates in 2007). So instead of $51,676 in assessed rent for linear rights-of-way in Clark County for 2007, as shown in Table 12, a more appropriate figure for comparison purposes, using the “unique zone” rates for all 305 rights-of-way located within these high land value areas, would have been approximately $3.3 million. Under the Per Acre Rent Schedule of this final rule, that figure would have then decreased to $1.23 million, resulting in a 63 percent decrease in rental receipts, instead of the 2,273 percent increase as shown in Table 12. However, the actual percent increase in rent receipts in Clark County is only 46 percent when total
( printed page 65068)
receipts collected from the previous rent schedules ($904,142) are compared to what would have been collected using the Per Acre Rent Schedule of this final rule for 2007 ($1,304,400).
In summary, the final rule will increase rental revenues collected by the BLM and, conversely, increase costs to grant holders by approximately $6.4 million, based on 2007 billing data. The BLM assessed rent for rights-of-way on 373,000 acres of public land in 2007 (see Table 11). If this acreage had been billed only on an annual basis, the BLM would have assessed rent in the amount of $5,088,433 using the previous Per Acre Rent Schedule. Under the final rule, the BLM would have assessed rent in the amount of $11,512,757 (with no phase-in provision), or an increase of $6,424,325. These increases in rental receipts would have reasonably reflected the increase in land values that also occurred from 1987 to 2002. Likewise, the BLM estimates that the maximum amount that rental receipts will increase under the final rule is an average of $14.7 million each year (plus annual IPD GDP adjustments) when all authorizations and rent payment periods are considered (using 2007 as a sample year). This amount ($14.7 million) is based on average estimated rental receipts of $21 million per year over a 5-year period (2009-2013), less the $6.3 million in actual rental receipts collected in 2007 for all authorizations and rent payment periods billed ($21 million−$6.3 million = $14.7 million).
In addition to revising the previous Per Acre Rent Schedule, the final rule makes minor revisions to parts 2800 and 2880 of the previous regulations so that the final regulations are consistent with the statutory rent schedule changes discussed above. There are also a number of minor corrections and changes made in the final rule that are not directly related to the rent schedule. These changes are limited in scope and address trespass penalties, new rent payment options (including how one-time payments are to be determined for perpetual right-of-way grants and easements), annual rental payments, limited phase-in provisions for all holders, and reimbursements of monitoring costs and processing fees for leases and permits issued under 43 CFR part 2920. These latter items correct some errors in the previous regulations and clarify other regulations. All these changes are within the scope of the BLM's existing authority to administer rights-of-way under the FLPMA and the MLA and will have only minor economic impact.
b. This rule will not create serious inconsistencies or otherwise interfere with other agencies' actions. Since 1987, the BLM and the FS have both used the same Per Acre Rent Schedule to establish rent for linear right-of-way facilities located on public land and NFS land. The Act requires both the BLM and the FS to make the same revisions to the 1987 per acre rental fee zone value schedule by State, county, and type of linear right-of-way use to reflect current values of land in each zone. The BLM has worked closely with the FS in assuring the maximum consistency possible between the policies of the two agencies with respect to approving and administering linear rights-of-way, including the assessment of rent for these facilities. The FS plans to adopt the BLM Per Acre Rent Schedule.
c. The final rule will not materially affect entitlements, grants, user fees, loan programs, or the rights and obligations of their recipients. This rule does increase rental fees, but only in amounts necessary to ensure compliance with the Act. The increases in rental fees will not be retroactive, but they will apply to new authorizations and to existing grant-holders who hold grants subject to rent at the grant's next rental due payment period. Flexible rent payment options and phase-in provisions will significantly reduce any impact that increased rental fees may have on grant-holders. Rent exemption and reduction provisions found in the current rule still apply. However, the final rule makes it clear that if an entity is found to be in trespass on public land, the rental exemptions and/or waiver of rent provisions will not apply to settlement of the trespass action.
d. The final rule will not raise novel legal or policy issues. The Act requires the BLM and the FS to update and revise previous per acre rent schedules to reflect current land values. Both agencies previously collected rental fees for linear rights-of-way using a per acre rent schedule established in 1987. The Act does not specify how to revise the land values or what data should be used. The final rule uses average per acre land and building values published every 5 years in the NASS Census. Other Federal and state agencies regularly use the NASS Census data when necessary to use average per acre land values for a particular State or county. Congress, likewise, endorsed the use of this data for rental determination purposes when it passed the “National Forest Organizational Camp Fee Improvement Act of 2003” (Public Law 108-7) (16 U.S.C. 6231). The BLM believes that the rental fees arrived at by the use of the NASS Census data is the most efficient and reasonable method of revising the previous Per Acre Rent Schedule, as well as meeting other mandates under FLPMA and the MLA that require that the U.S. receive fair market value of the use of the public lands.
Clarity of the Regulations
Executive Order 12866 requires each agency to write regulations that are simple and easy to understand. In the proposed rule, we invited your comments on how to make these regulations easier to understand, including answers to questions such as the following:
1. Are the requirements in the proposed regulations clearly stated?
2. Do the proposed regulations contain technical language or jargon that interferes with their clarity?
3. Does the format of the proposed regulations (grouping and order of sections, use of headings, paragraphing, etc.) aid or reduce their clarity?
4. Would the regulations be easier to understand if they were divided into more (but shorter) sections? (A “section” appears in bold type and is preceded by the symbol “§ ” and a numbered heading, for example: § 2806.20 What is the rent for a linear right-of-way grant?).
5. Is the description of the proposed regulations in the
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION
section of this preamble helpful in understanding the proposed regulations? How could this description be more helpful in making the proposed regulations easier to understand?
We received no specific comments in response to the above 5 questions. However, we received several comments suggesting that we clarify the language in proposed sections 2807.15 and 2886.15, which we have accomplished in this final rule. In addition, one commenter requested clarification of the meaning of the phrase “When no acceptable market information is available” as used in proposed section 2806.25(d) and asked whether the lack of acceptable market data would allow the BLM to utilize a process to determine per acre land values similar to that used in lower value Federal land acquisitions known as “waiver valuations.” We provided that clarification in the preamble discussion to that section.
National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA)
The BLM has determined that this final rule, which primarily updates the previous linear rent schedule, is of an administrative, financial, and/or procedural nature whose environmental effects are too broad, speculative, or
( printed page 65069)
conjectural to lend themselves to meaningful analysis and will later be subject to the NEPA process, either collectively or case-by-case. Therefore, it is categorically excluded from environmental review under section 102(2)(C) of NEPA, pursuant to 516 Departmental Manual (DM), Chapter 2, Appendix 1, Number 1.10. In addition, the final rule does not meet any of the 12 criteria for extraordinary circumstances listed in 516 DM, Chapter 2, Appendix 2. Pursuant to Council on Environmental Quality regulations (40 CFR 1508.4) and the environmental policies and procedures of the Department of the Interior, the term “categorical exclusions” means a category of actions which do not individually or cumulatively have a significant effect on the human environment and that have been found to have no such effect in procedures adopted by a Federal agency and for which neither an environmental assessment nor an environmental impact statement is required.
We have also examined this rule to determine whether it requires consultation under Section 7 of the Endangered Species Act (ESA) (16 U.S.C. 1532). The ESA requires an agency to consult with the Fish and Wildlife Service or National Marine Fisheries Service to insure that any action it authorizes, funds, or carries out is not likely to jeopardize the continued existence of any listed species or result in the destruction or adverse modification of critical habitat.
We have determined that this rule will have no effect on listed or proposed species or on designated or proposed critical habitat under the ESA and therefore consultation under section 7 of the ESA is not required. Our determination is based in part on the fact that nothing in the rule changes existing processes and procedures that ensure the protection of listed or proposed species or designated or proposed critical habitat. Existing processes and procedures have been in effect since BLM promulgated right-of-way regulations in 1979-80. Any further compliance with the ESA will occur when an application for a right-of-way is filed with the BLM.
Regulatory Flexibility Act
Congress enacted the Regulatory Flexibility Act of 1980 (RFA), as amended, 5 U.S.C. 601-612, to ensure that Government regulations do not unnecessarily or disproportionately burden small entities. The RFA requires a regulatory flexibility analysis if a rule would have a significant economic impact, either detrimental or beneficial, on a substantial number of small entities. The BLM has estimated that approximately 18 percent of all applicants and grantees (approximately 5 percent of MLA applicants and grantees and approximately 23 percent of FLPMA applicants and grantees) may qualify as small entities. As discussed above, rental fees, in most cases, are not a significant cost for the industries affected, including small entities.
Table 13 shows the small business size standards for industries that may be affected by these rules. This table lists industry size standards for eligibility for Small Business Administration (SBA) programs from SBA regulations (see 13 CFR 121.201). The SBA size standards are typically stated either as the average number of employees, or the average annual receipts of a business concern. Standards are grouped using the North American Industrial Classification System 2002 (NAICS). This listing is based on descriptions from the U.S. Bureau of the Census 2002 NAICS codes and is not exhaustive.
Table 13—SBA Size Standards for Affected Industries as of July 31, 2006
NAICS code
Description
Size standard
113110
Timber Tract Operations
$6.5 million.
113210
Gathering of forest products
$6.5 million.
113310
Logging
500 employees.
211111
Crude petroleum and natural gas extraction
500 employees.
211112
Natural gas liquid extraction
500 employees.
221111
Hydroelectric power generation
221112
Fossil fuel electric power generation
221113
Nuclear electric power generation
221119
Other electric power generation
221121
Electric Bulk Power Transmission and Control
221122
Electric Power Distribution
Firm, including affiliates, is primarily engaged in generation, transmission, or distribution of electric energy for sale, and total electric output for the preceding fiscal year ≤ 4 million megawatt-hours.
The BLM does not officially track right-of-way costs, but grant holders in 2003 estimated that construction costs for pipeline facilities were between $300,000 (12″ pipeline) and $1.5 million per mile (36″ pipeline); construction costs for rocked logging roads were between $40,000/mile for a ridge top road to $150,000/mile for a full bench road or an average of $70,000/mile for a road through moderate terrain; and construction costs for electric distribution and transmission lines were between $24,000/mile (24kV distribution line) to $1 million/mile (500kV transmission line). Larger projects would typically require more land area to site than minor projects. Since rent is based on the number of acres that the right-of-way facility encumbers, larger projects would involve higher rental payments than would minor projects. However, compared to the cost of constructing a typical right-of-way facility, total rent and the rental fee increases under the final rule are relatively small (see 70 FR 21056 for further information on typical project costs).
( printed page 65070)
Any of the industries listed in Table 13 may hold right-of-way grants with the BLM, under either FLPMA or MLA, as a part of their business practices. For example, bulk electric power transmission firms will use rights-of-way to distribute their electricity. Firms may be eligible for various SBA programs, but the size-limit is specific to each industry, and identified by the industry codes. The limit may be based on gross sales, the number of employees, or other factors. It is estimated that about 5.3 percent (or 1,416 of 26,711) of existing MLA grantees may be eligible for SBA programs and about 22.9 percent (or 14,280 of 62,358) of FLPMA grantees may be eligible for SBA programs (see 70 FR 21056). Whether they choose to join the SBA programs is strictly an individual firm's decision.
The proportion of grantees eligible for SBA programs indicates that there is an opportunity for small businesses in BLM's right-of-way program. However, the burden of increased rental fees will not have a significant economic impact on a substantial number of small entities or fall disproportionately on small businesses. Moreover, any entity that believes that it might be adversely affected by the rental fee increases to its FLPMA right-of-way grant may qualify for a waiver or reduction of rental fees under any of the provisions, including hardship, found at section 2806.15. Therefore, the BLM has determined under the RFA that this final rule does not have a significant economic impact on a substantial number of small entities.
Small Business Regulatory Enforcement Fairness Act (SBREFA)
This rule is not a “major rule” as defined at 5 U.S.C. 804(2). This rule:
a. Does not have an annual effect on the economy of $100 million or more. See the Executive Order 12866 discussion above.
b. Will not result in major cost or price increases for consumers, industries, government agencies, or regions. As discussed above, when compared to the cost of constructing a right-of-way project, the rental fee increases contained in this rule are relatively small and therefore will not cause any major increase in costs or prices. In addition, any applicant or holder of a FLPMA authorization that believes that the rental fee increases will cause difficulty may benefit from the rent waiver or reduction provisions under section 2806.15, especially the hardship provision.
c. Does not have significant adverse effects on competition, employment, investment, productivity, innovation, or the ability of U.S.-based enterprises to compete with foreign-based enterprises. The rule should result in no change in any of the above factors. See the Executive Order 12866 discussion above regarding the economic effects of the rental fee increases. In general, the rental fee increases are small in comparison with the overall costs of constructing, maintaining, operating, and terminating large projects located within right-of-way areas. With the possible exception of MLA grants for pipelines, the projects located on right-of-way grants support domestic, not foreign, activities and do not involve products and services that are exported. The MLA pipelines may transport oil and gas and their related products destined for foreign markets, but the overall increase in rental fees, compared to the cost of, and profits from, running an oil and gas pipeline that would feed into a foreign market, is minimal.
Unfunded Mandates Reform Act
This rule does not impose an unfunded mandate on state, local, or tribal governments, in the aggregate, or the private sector, of $100 million or more per year; nor does this rule have a significant or unique effect on small governments. The rule imposes no requirements approaching $100 million annually on any of these entities. We have already shown, in the previous paragraphs of this section of the preamble, that this rule does not have effects approaching $100 million per year on the economy. Therefore, the BLM is not required to prepare a statement containing the information required by the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act at 2 U.S.C. 1532.
Executive Order 12630, Governmental Actions and Interference With Constitutionally Protected Property Rights (Takings)
The rule does not have takings implications and is not government action capable of interfering with constitutionally protected property rights. A right-of-way application is not private property. The BLM has discretion under the governing statutes to issue a grant or not (see 30 U.S.C. 185(a) and 43 U.S.C. 1761(a)). Once a grant is issued, a holder's continued use of the Federal land covered by the grant is conditioned upon compliance with various statutes, regulations, and terms and conditions, including the payment of rent. Consistent with FLPMA and the MLA, violation of the relevant statutes, regulations, or terms and conditions of the grant can result in termination of the grant before the end of the grant's term. The holder of a grant acknowledges this possibility in accepting a grant. Therefore, the Department of the Interior has determined that the rule will not cause a taking of private property or require further discussion of takings implications under this Executive Order.
The rule will not have a substantial direct effect on the states, on the relationship between the national government and the states, or on the distribution of power and responsibilities among the levels of government. Qualifying states and local governments continue to be exempt from paying rent for a right-of-way grant issued under FLPMA. Therefore, in accordance with Executive Order 13132, the BLM has determined that this rule does not have sufficient Federalism implications to warrant preparation of a Federalism Assessment.
Under Executive Order 12988, we have determined that this rule will not unduly burden the judicial system and that it meets the requirements of sections 3(a) and 3(b)(2) of the Order.
In accordance with Executive Order 13175, we have found that this rule does not include policies that have tribal implications. The BLM may only issue right-of-way grants across public lands that it manages or across Federal lands held by two or more Federal agencies. Indian tribes have jurisdiction over their own lands, subject to the Secretary's trust responsibility. To our knowledge, no Indian tribes are involved in any multi-agency grants.
Executive Order 13211, Actions Concerning Regulations That Significantly Affect Energy Supply, Distribution, or Use
In accordance with Executive Order 13211, the BLM has determined that the final rule is not a significant energy action. The rule is not a significant regulatory action under Executive Order 12866 and is not likely to have a significant effect on energy supply, distribution or use, including a shortfall in supply or price increase. In addition, the rule has not been designated as a significant energy action by the Chief of the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs. However, since the final rent schedule is based on average per acre land values which have generally
( printed page 65071)
increased over the past 20 years, rental receipts are expected to increase in a like proportion, but still remain a minor component of overall costs and/or rates. In addition, the rule preserves existing rental exemption and waiver provisions for holders of FLPMA authorizations, provides an initial phase-in period to all holders, and provides more flexible rent payment options that were lacking in the previous regulation.
In accordance with Executive Order 13352, the BLM has determined that this rule does not impede facilitating cooperative conservation; takes appropriate account of and considers the interests of persons with ownership or other legally recognized interests in land or other natural resources; properly accommodates local participation in the Federal decision-making process; and provides that the programs, projects, and activities are consistent with protecting public health and safety. This rule does not change any provision of the BLM's previous right-of-way rule which facilitates cooperative conservation in the authorization and administration of right-of-way facilities on public lands. The rule maintains all alternatives for maximum protection of right-of-way facilities when the land encumbered by the facilities is proposed for transfer out of Federal ownership. The grant holder will also have the opportunity to negotiate new terms and conditions with the new land owner, if the holder so desires. The rule does not reduce or eliminate any current provision that requires the BLM to coordinate and consult with other affected and/or interested parties in the granting or administering of right-of-way facilities on public land, including the requirements that the BLM places on right-of-way holders to protect public health and safety, as well as public resources and environmental quality.
Paperwork Reduction Act
The Office of Management and Budget has approved the information collection requirements in the final rule under the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995, 44 U.S.C. 3501et seq.,
and has assigned clearance number 1004-0189, which expires on November 30, 2008.
Authors
The principal authors of this rule are Bil Weigand, BLM Idaho State Office, and Rick Stamm, BLM Washington Office, assisted by Ian Senio of BLM's Division of Regulatory Affairs, Washington Office, and Michael Hickey of the Office of the Solicitor.
Public lands, and Reporting and recordkeeping requirements
Dated: October 15, 2008.
C. Stephen Allred,
Assistant Secretary, Land and Minerals Management.
Accordingly, for the reasons stated in the preamble and under the authorities identified below, the BLM amends 43 CFR parts 2800, 2880, and 2920 as set forth below:
PART 2800—RIGHTS-OF-WAY UNDER THE FEDERAL LAND POLICY MANAGEMENT ACT
1. The authority citation for part 2800 continues to read as follows:
(2) All grants, except those issued for a term of 3 years or less and those issued in perpetuity, will expire on December 31 of the final year of the grant.
* * * * *
3. Amend § 2805.14 by revising paragraph (f) to read as follows:
(f) Assign the grant to another, provided that you obtain the BLM's prior written approval, unless your grant specifically states that that such approval is unnecessary.
Subpart 2806—Rents
4. Amend § 2806.14 by redesignating the introductory text and paragraphs (a), (b), (b)(1), (b)(2), (c), and (d) as paragraphs (a) introductory text, (a)(1), (a)(2), (a)(2)(i), (a)(2)(ii), (a)(3), and (a)(4), respectively, and by adding a new paragraph (b) to read as follows:
(a) Except as described in § 2806.26 of this chapter, the BLM will use the Per Acre Rent Schedule (see paragraph (c) of this section) to calculate rent for all linear right-of-way authorizations, regardless of the granting authority (FLPMA, MLA, and their predecessors). Counties (or other geographical areas) are assigned to an appropriate zone in accordance with § 2806.21. The BLM will adjust the per acre rent values in the schedule annually in accordance with § 2806.22(a), and it will revise the schedule at the end of each 10-year period in accordance with § 2806.22(b).
(b) The annual per acre rent for all types of linear right-of-way facilities is the product of 4 factors: The per acre zone value multiplied by the encumbrance factor multiplied by the rate of return multiplied by the annual adjustment factor (see § 2806.22(a)).
(c) You may obtain a copy of the current Per Acre Rent Schedule from any BLM state or field office or by writing: Director, BLM, 1849 C St., NW., Mail Stop 1000 LS, Washington, DC 20240. The BLM also posts the current rent schedule on the BLM Homepage on the Internet at
www.blm.gov.
6. Redesignate §§ 2806.21, 2806.22, and 2806.23 as §§ 2806.22, 2806.23, and 2806.24, respectively, and add new § 2806.21 to read as follows:
When and how are counties or other geographical areas assigned to a County Zone Number and Per Acre Zone Value?
Counties (or other geographical areas) are assigned to a County Zone Number and Per Acre Zone Value based upon 80 percent of their average per acre land and building value published in the Census of Agriculture (Census) by the National Agricultural Statistics Service (NASS). The initial assignment of counties to the zones will cover years 2006 through 2010 of the Per Acre Rent Schedule and is based upon data contained in the most recent NASS Census (2002). Subsequent re-assignments of counties will occur every 5 years (in 2011 based upon 2007 NASS Census data, in 2016 based upon 2012 NASS Census data, and so forth)
( printed page 65072)
following the publication of the NASS Census.
7. Revise redesignated § 2806.22 to read as follows:
When and how does the Per Acre Rent Schedule change?
(a) Each calendar year the BLM will adjust the per acre rent values in § 2806.20 for all types of linear right-of-way facilities in each zone based on the average annual change in the IPD-GDP for the 10-year period immediately preceding the year that the NASS Census data becomes available. For example, the average annual change in the IP-GDP from 1994 to 2003 (the 10-year period immediately preceding the year (2004) that the 2002 NASS Census data became available) is 1.9 percent. This annual adjustment factor is applied to years 2006 through 2015 of the Per Acre Rent Schedule. Likewise, the average annual change in the IPD-GDP from 2004 to 2013 (the 10-year period immediately preceding the year (2014) when the 2012 NASS Census data will become available) will be applied to years 2016 through 2025 of the Per Acre Rent Schedule.
(b) The BLM will review the NASS Census data from the 2012 NASS Census, and each subsequent 10-year period, and as appropriate, revise the number of county zones and the per acre zone values. Any revision must include 100 percent of the number of counties and listed geographical areas for all states and the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico and must reasonably reflect the increases or decreases in the average per acre land and building values contained in the NASS Census.
8. Revise redesignated § 2806.23 to read as follows:
How will the BLM calculate my rent for linear rights-of-way the Per Acre Rent Schedule covers?
(a) Except as provided by §§ 2806.25 and 2806.26, the BLM calculates your rent by multiplying the rent per acre for the appropriate county (or other geographical area) zone from the current schedule by the number of acres (as rounded up to the nearest tenth of an acre) in the right-of-way area that fall in each zone and multiplying the result by the number of years in the rental payment period (the length of time for which the holder is paying rent).
(b) The BLM will phase-in the initial implementation of the Per Acre Rent Schedule (see § 2806.20(c)) by reducing the 2009 per acre rent by 25 percent.
(c) If the BLM has not previously used the rent schedule to calculate your rent, we may do so after giving you reasonable written notice.
9. Revise redesignated § 2806.24 to read as follows:
How must I make rental payments for a linear grant?
(a)
Term grants. For linear grants, except those issued in perpetuity, you must make either nonrefundable annual payments or a nonrefundable payment for more than 1 year, as follows:
(1)
One-time payments. You may pay in advance the total rent amount for the entire term of the grant or any remaining years.
(2)
Multiple payments. If you choose not to make a one-time payment, you must pay according to one of the following methods:
(i)
Payments by individuals. If your annual rent is $100 or less, you must pay at 10-year intervals, not to exceed the term of the grant. If your annual rent is greater than $100, you may pay annually or at 10-year intervals, not to exceed the term of the grant. For example, if you have a grant with a remaining term of 30 years, you may pay in advance for 10 years, 20 years, or 30 years, but not any other multi-year period.
(ii)
Payments by all others. If your annual rent is $500 or less, you must pay rent at 10-year intervals, not to exceed the term of the grant. If your annual rent is greater than $500, you may pay annually or at 10-year intervals, not to exceed the term of the grant.
(b)
Perpetual grants. For linear grants issued in perpetuity (except as noted in §§ 2806.25 and 2806.26), you must make either nonrefundable annual payments or a nonrefundable payment for more than 1 year, as follows:
(1)
Payments by individuals. If your annual rent is $100 or less, you must pay at 10-year intervals, not to exceed 30 years. If your annual rent is greater than $100, you may pay annually or at 10-year intervals, not to exceed 30 years.
(2)
Payments by all others. If your annual rent is $500 or less, you must pay rent at 10-year intervals, not to exceed 30 years. If your annual rent is greater than $500, you may pay annually or at 10-year intervals, not to exceed 30 years.
(c)
Proration of payments. The BLM considers the first partial calendar year in the initial rental payment period (the length of time for which the holder is paying rent) to be the first year of the term. The BLM prorates the first year rental amount based on the number of months left in the calendar year after the effective date of the grant.
10. Add new §§ 2806.25 and 2806.26 to read as follows:
How may I make rental payments when land encumbered by my perpetual linear grant (other than an easement issued under § 2807.15(b)) is being transferred out of Federal ownership?
(a)
One-time payment option for existing perpetual grants. If you have a perpetual grant and the land your grant encumbers is being transferred out of Federal ownership, you may choose to make a one-time rental payment. The BLM will determine the one-time payment for a perpetual grant by dividing the current annual rent for the subject property by an overall capitalization rate calculated from market data, where the overall capitalization rate is the difference between a market yield rate and a percent annual rent increase as described in the formula in paragraphs (a)(1), (2), and (3) of this section. The formula for this calculation is: One-time Rental Payment = Annual Rent/ (Y−CR), where:
(1) Annual Rent = Current Annual Rent Applicable to the Subject Property from the Per Acre Rent Schedule;
(2) Y = Yield Rate from the Per Acre Rent Schedule (5.27 percent); and
(3) CR = Annual Percent Change in Rent as Determined by the Most Recent 10-Year Average of the difference in the IPD-GDP Index from January of one year to January of the following year.
(b)
One-time payment for grants converted to perpetual grants under § 2807.15(b). If the land your grant encumbers is being transferred out of Federal ownership, and you request a conversion of your grant to a perpetual right-of-way grant, you must make a one-time rental payment in accordance with § 2806.25(a).
(c) In paragraphs (a) and (b) of this section, the annual rent is determined from the Per Acre Rent Schedule (see § 2806.20(c)) as updated under § 2806.22. However, the per acre zone value and zone number used in this annual rental determination will be based on the per acre land value from acceptable market information or the appraisal report, if any, for the land transfer action and not the county average per acre land and building value from the NASS Census. You may also submit an appraisal report on your own initiative in accordance with paragraph (d) of this section.
(d) When no acceptable market information is available and no appraisal report has been completed for the land transfer action or when the BLM requests it, you must:
(1) Prepare an appraisal report using Federal appraisal standards, at your expense, that explains how you estimated the land value per acre, the
( printed page 65073)
rate of return, and the encumbrance factor; and
(2) Submit the appraisal report for consideration by the BLM State Director with jurisdiction over the lands encumbered by your authorization.
How may I make rental payments when land encumbered by my perpetual easement issued under § 2807.15(b) is being transferred out of Federal ownership?
(a) The BLM will use the appraisal report for the land transfer action (i.e., direct or indirect land sales, land exchanges, and other land disposal actions) and other acceptable market information to determine the one-time rental payment for a perpetual easement issued under § 2807.15(b).
(b) When no acceptable market information is available and no appraisal report has been completed for the land transfer action or when the BLM requests it, you must prepare an appraisal report as required under § 2806.25(d). You may also submit an appraisal report on your own initiative in accordance with § 2806.25(d).
Subpart 2807—Grant Administration and Operation
11. Amend § 2807.15 by revising paragraph (b) and paragraph (c) to read as follows:
How is grant administration affected if the land my grant encumbers is transferred to another Federal agency or out of Federal ownership?
* * * * *
(b) The BLM will provide reasonable notice to you if there is a proposal to transfer the land your grant encumbers out of Federal ownership. If you request, the BLM will negotiate new grant terms and conditions with you. This may include increasing the term of your grant to a perpetual grant or providing for an easement. These changes, if any, become effective prior to the time the land is transferred out of Federal ownership. The BLM may then, in conformance with existing policies and procedures:
(1) Transfer the land subject to your grant or easement. In this case, administration of your grant or easement for the lands BLM formerly administered is transferred to the new owner of the land;
(2) Transfer the land, but BLM retains administration of your grant or easement; or
(3) Reserve to the United States the land your grant or easement encumbers, and BLM retains administration of your grant or easement.
(c) You and the new land owner may agree to negotiate new grant terms and conditions any time after the land encumbered by your grant is transferred out of Federal ownership.
PART 2880—RIGHTS-OF-WAY UNDER THE MINERAL LEASING ACT
12. The authority citation for part 2880 continues to read as follows:
(e) Assign the grant or TUP to another, provided that you obtain the BLM's prior written approval, unless your grant or TUP specifically states that such approval is unnecessary.
(a) The BLM will use the Per Acre Rent Schedule (see paragraph (b) of this section) to calculate the rent. Counties (or other geographical areas) are assigned to a County Zone Number and Per Acre Zone Value based upon 80 percent of their average per acre land and building value published in the NASS Census. The initial assignment of counties to the zones in the Per Acre Rent Schedule for the 5-year period from 2006 to 2010 is based upon data contained in the most recent NASS Census (2002). Subsequent assignments of counties will occur every 5 years following the publication of the NASS Census. The Per Acre Rent Schedule is also adjusted periodically as follows:
(1) Each calendar year the BLM will adjust the per acre rent values in §§ 2806.20 and 2885.19(b) for all types of linear right-of-way facilities in each zone based on the average annual change in the IPD-GDP for the 10-year period immediately preceding the year that the NASS Census data becomes available. For example, the average annual change in the IPD-GDP from 1994 to 2003 (the 10-year period immediately preceding the year (2004) that the 2002 NASS Census data became available) is 1.9 percent. This annual adjustment factor is applied to years 2006 through 2015 of the Per Acre Rent Schedule. Likewise, the average annual change in the IPD-GDP from 2004 to 2013 (the 10-year period immediately preceding the year (2014) when the 2012 NASS Census data will become available) will be applied to years 2016 through 2025 of the Per Acre Rent Schedule.
(2) The BLM will review the NASS Census data from the 2012 NASS Census, and each subsequent 10-year period, and as appropriate, revise the number of county zones and the per acre zone values. Any revision must include 100 percent of the number of counties and listed geographical areas for all states and the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico and must reasonably reflect the increases or decreases in the average per acre land and building values contained in the NASS Census.
(b) You may obtain a copy of the current Per Acre Rent Schedule from any BLM State Office or field office or by writing: Director, BLM, 1849 C St., NW., Mail Stop 1000 LS, Washington, DC 20240. The BLM also posts the current rent schedule on the BLM Homepage on the Internet at
www.blm.gov.
How will the BLM calculate my rent for linear rights-of-way the Per Acre Rent Schedule covers?
(a) Except as provided by § 2885.22, the BLM calculates your rent by multiplying the rent per acre for the appropriate county (or other geographical area) zone from the current schedule by the number of acres (as rounded up to the nearest tenth of an acre) in the right-of-way or TUP area that fall in each zone and multiplying the result by the number of years in the rental payment period (the length of time for which the holder is paying rent).
(b) Phase-in provisions:
(1) The BLM will phase-in the initial implementation of the Per Acre Rent Schedule (see § 2885.19(b)) by reducing the 2009 per acre rent by 25 percent.
(2) If, as the result of any revisions made to the Per Acre Rent Schedule under § 2885.19(a)(2), the payment of your new annual rental amount would cause you undue hardship, you may qualify for a 2-year phase-in period if you are a small business entity as that term is defined in Small Business
( printed page 65074)
Administration regulations and if it is in the public interest. The BLM will require you to submit information to support your claim. If approved by the BLM State Director, payment of the amount in excess of the previous year's rent may be phased-in by equal increments over a 2-year period. In addition, the BLM will adjust the total calculated rent for year 2 of the phase-in period by the annual index provided by § 2885.19(a)(1).
(c) If the BLM has not previously used the rent schedule to calculate your rent, we may do so after giving you reasonable written notice.
How must I make rental payments for a linear grant or TUP?
(a)
Term grants or TUPs.
For TUPs you must make a one-time nonrefundable payment for the term of the TUP. For grants, except those that have been issued in perpetuity, you must make either nonrefundable annual payments or a nonrefundable payment for more than 1 year, as follows:
(1)
One-time payments.
You may pay in advance the total rent amount for the entire term of the grant or any remaining years.
(2)
Multiple payments.
If you choose not to make a one-time payment, you must pay according to one of the following methods:
(i)
Payments by individuals.
If your annual rent is $100 or less, you must pay at 10-year intervals not to exceed the term of the grant. If your annual rent is greater than $100, you may pay annually or at 10-year intervals, not to exceed the term of the grant. For example, if you have a grant with a remaining term of 30 years, you may pay in advance for 10 years, 20 years, or 30 years, but not any other multi-year period.
(ii)
Payments by all others.
If your annual rent is $500 or less, you must pay rent at 10-year intervals, not to exceed the term of the grant. If your annual rent is greater than $500, you may pay annually or at 10-year intervals, not to exceed the term of the grant.
(b)
Perpetual grants issued prior to November 16, 1973.
Except as provided by § 2885.22(a), you must make either nonrefundable annual payments or a nonrefundable payment for more than 1 year, as follows:
(1)
Payments by individuals.
If your annual rent is $100 or less, you must pay at 10-year intervals, not to exceed 30 years. If your annual rent is greater than $100, you may pay annually or at 10-year intervals, not to exceed 30 years.
(2)
Payments by all others.
If your annual rent is $500 or less, you must pay rent at 10-year intervals, not to exceed 30 years. If your annual rent is greater than $500, you may pay annually or at 10-year intervals, not to exceed 30 years.
(c)
Proration of payments.
The BLM considers the first partial calendar year in the initial rental payment period (the length of time for which the holder is paying rent) to be the first year of the term. The BLM prorates the first year rental amount based on the number of months left in the calendar year after the effective date of the grant.
18. Redesignate §§ 2885.22, 2885.23, and 2885.24 as §§ 2885.23, 2885.24, and 2885.25, respectively, and add new § 2885.22 to read as follows:
How may I make rental payments when land encumbered by my term or perpetual linear grant is being transferred out of Federal ownership?
(a)
One-time payment option for existing perpetual grants issued prior to November 16, 1973.
If you have a perpetual grant and the land your grant encumbers is being transferred out of Federal ownership, you may choose to make a one-time rental payment. The BLM will determine the one-time payment for perpetual right-of-way grants by dividing the current annual rent for the subject property by an overall capitalization rate calculated from market data, where the overall capitalization rate is the difference between a market yield rate and a percent annual rent increase as described in the formula in paragraphs (a)(1), (2), and (3) of this section. The formula for this calculation is: One-time Payment = Annual Rent/(Y−CR), where:
(1) Annual Rent = Current Annual Rent Applicable to the Subject Property from the Per Acre Rent Schedule;
(2) Y = Yield Rate from the Per Acre Rent Schedule (5.27 percent); and
(3) CR = Annual Percent Change in Rent as Determined by the Most Recent 10-Year Average of the difference in the IPD-GDP Index from January of one year to January of the following year.
(b) In paragraph (a) of this section, the annual rent is determined from the Per Acre Rent Schedule (see § 2885.19(b)), as updated under § 2885.19(a)(1) and(2). However, the per acre zone value and zone number used in this annual rental determination will be based on the per acre land value from acceptable market information or an appraisal report, if any, for the land transfer action and not the county average per acre land and building value from the NASS Census. You may also submit an appraisal report on your own initiative in accordance with § 2806.25(d) of this chapter.
(c) When no acceptable market information is available and no appraisal report has been completed for the land transfer action, or when the BLM requests it, you must prepare an appraisal report as required under § 2806.25(d) of this chapter.
(d)
Term Grant.
If the land your grant encumbers is being transferred out of Federal ownership, you may pay in advance the total rent amount for the entire term of the grant or any remaining years. The BLM will use the annual rent calculated from the Per Acre Rent Schedule multiplied by the number of years in the rent payment period (the length of time for which the holder is paying rent) to determine the one-time rent. However, this amount must not exceed the one-time rent payment for a perpetual grant as determined under paragraphs (a) and (b) of this section.
Subpart 2886—Operations On MLA Grants and TUPs
19. Amend § 2886.15 by revising paragraphs (b) and (c) to read as follows:
How is grant or TUP administration affected if the BLM land my grant or TUP encumbers is transferred to another Federal agency or out of Federal ownership?
* * * * *
(b) The BLM will provide reasonable notice to you if there is a proposal to transfer the BLM land your grant or TUP encumbers out of Federal ownership. If you request, the BLM will negotiate new grant or TUP terms and conditions with you. This may include increasing the term of your grant to a 30-year term or replacing your TUP with a grant. These changes, if any, become effective prior to the time the land is transferred out of Federal ownership. The BLM may then, in conformance with existing policies and procedures:
(1) Transfer the land subject to your grant or TUP. In this case, administration of your grant or TUP for the lands BLM formerly administered is transferred to the new owner of the land;
(2) Transfer the land, but BLM retains administration of your grant or TUP; or
(3) Reserve to the United States the land your grant or TUP encumbers, and BLM retains administration of your grant or TUP.
(c) You and the new land owner may agree to negotiate new grant or TUP terms and conditions any time after the land encumbered by your grant or TUP is transferred out of Federal ownership.
( printed page 65075)
Subpart 2888—Trespass
20. Amend § 2888.10 by revising paragraph (c) to read as follows:
(b)
Processing and monitoring fee.
Each request for renewal, transfer, or assignment of a lease or easement shall be accompanied by a non-refundable processing and monitoring fee determined in accordance with the provisions of §§ 2804.14 and 2805.16 of this chapter.
Note:
The following adjusted 2002 NASS Census table of per acre land and building value and rent schedule zones is printed for information only and will not appear in Title 43 of the Code of Federal Regulations. The 2002 NASS Census per acre land and building value for each county has been reduced by 20 percent. Please see the discussion of section 2806.20 for further explanation. The 20 percent reduction represents the total value of all irrigated acres, plus acres in the “other” category (which includes buildings, roads, ponds, and wasteland) to total farm real-estate value. Counties will be re-assigned to the appropriate rent schedule zone in 2011 based upon the adjusted 2007 NASS Census per acre land and building value.
Adjusted 2002 per Acre Land and Building (L/B) Value and Rent Schedule Zone
State
County
80%—2002
L/B values
Rent schedule
zone
Alabama
Autauga
$1,503
5
Alabama
Baldwin
2,002
6
Alabama
Barbour
958
3
Alabama
Bibb
1,370
4
Alabama
Blount
2,045
6
Alabama
Bullock
1,146
4
Alabama
Butler
1,238
4
Alabama
Calhoun
2,078
6
Alabama
Chambers
795
3
Alabama
Cherokee
1,234
4
Alabama
Chilton
1,437
4
Alabama
Choctaw
1,026
4
Alabama
Clarke
1,042
4
Alabama
Clay
1,112
4
Alabama
Cleburne
1,537
5
Alabama
Coffee
961
3
Alabama
Colbert
1,104
4
Alabama
Conecuh
887
3
Alabama
Coosa
1,080
4
Alabama
Covington
1,293
4
Alabama
Crenshaw
1,064
4
Alabama
Cullman
2,534
6
Alabama
Dale
1,138
4
Alabama
Dallas
938
3
Alabama
DeKalb
1,914
5
Alabama
Elmore
1,574
5
Alabama
Escambia
1,141
4
Alabama
Etowah
2,285
6
Alabama
Fayette
886
3
Alabama
Franklin
1,132
4
Alabama
Geneva
1,210
4
Alabama
Greene
882
3
Alabama
Hale
931
3
Alabama
Henry
959
3
Alabama
Houston
1,074
4
Alabama
Jackson
1,758
5
Alabama
Jefferson
2,086
6
Alabama
Lamar
929
3
Alabama
Lauderdale
1,446
4
Alabama
Lawrence
1,373
4
Alabama
Lee
1,824
5
Alabama
Limestone
1,770
5
Alabama
Lowndes
915
3
Alabama
Macon
1,052
4
Alabama
Madison
1,729
5
Alabama
Marengo
801
3
( printed page 65076)
Alabama
Marion
1,187
4
Alabama
Marshall
2,180
6
Alabama
Mobile
2,689
6
Alabama
Monroe
1,094
4
Alabama
Montgomery
1,558
5
Alabama
Morgan
2,250
6
Alabama
Perry
764
3
Alabama
Pickens
1,002
4
Alabama
Pike
1,138
4
Alabama
Randolph
1,518
5
Alabama
Russell
1,043
4
Alabama
Shelby
2,236
6
Alabama
St. Clair
1,891
5
Alabama
Sumter
814
3
Alabama
Talladega
2,054
6
Alabama
Tallapoosa
1,158
4
Alabama
Tuscaloosa
1,578
5
Alabama
Walker
1,385
4
Alabama
Washington
1,194
4
Alabama
Wilcox
810
3
Alabama
Winston
1,510
5
Alaska
Aleutian Islands Area
86
1
Alaska
Anchorage Area
1,839
5
Alaska
Fairbanks Area
524
3
Alaska
Juneau Area
35,743
11
Alaska
Kenai Peninsula
1,130
4
Arizona
Apache
116
1
Arizona
Cochise
505
3
Arizona
Coconino
129
1
Arizona
Gila
220
1
Arizona
Graham
384
2
Arizona
Greenlee
1,204
4
Arizona
La Paz
503
3
Arizona
Maricopa
2,421
6
Arizona
Mohave
348
2
Arizona
Navajo
143
1
Arizona
Pima
236
1
Arizona
Pinal
984
3
Arizona
Santa Cruz
1,147
4
Arizona
Yavapai
497
2
Arizona
Yuma
3,635
7
Arkansas
Arkansas
1,120
4
Arkansas
Ashley
1,091
4
Arkansas
Baxter
1,358
4
Arkansas
Benton
2,425
6
Arkansas
Boone
1,447
4
Arkansas
Bradley
1,518
5
Arkansas
Calhoun
1,022
4
Arkansas
Carroll
1,336
4
Arkansas
Chicot
937
3
Arkansas
Clark
1,145
4
Arkansas
Clay
1,301
4
Arkansas
Cleburne
1,378
4
Arkansas
Cleveland
1,756
5
Arkansas
Columbia
1,247
4
Arkansas
Conway
1,338
4
Arkansas
Craighead
1,376
4
Arkansas
Crawford
1,406
4
Arkansas
Crittenden
1,032
4
Arkansas
Cross
1,108
4
Arkansas
Dallas
1,043
4
Arkansas
Desha
882
3
Arkansas
Drew
1,004
4
Arkansas
Faulkner
1,458
4
Arkansas
Franklin
1,271
4
Arkansas
Fulton
815
3
Arkansas
Garland
1,808
5
Arkansas
Grant
1,373
4
Arkansas
Greene
1,245
4
Arkansas
Hempstead
1,117
4
Arkansas
Hot Spring
1,242
4
( printed page 65077)
Arkansas
Howard
1,318
4
Arkansas
Independence
994
3
Arkansas
Izard
922
3
Arkansas
Jackson
947
3
Arkansas
Jefferson
973
3
Arkansas
Johnson
1,787
5
Arkansas
Lafayette
854
3
Arkansas
Lawrence
1,020
4
Arkansas
Lee
826
3
Arkansas
Lincoln
917
3
Arkansas
Little River
897
3
Arkansas
Logan
1,218
4
Arkansas
Lonoke
1,111
4
Arkansas
Madison
1,097
4
Arkansas
Marion
1,050
4
Arkansas
Miller
836
3
Arkansas
Mississippi
1,081
4
Arkansas
Monroe
935
3
Arkansas
Montgomery
1,199
4
Arkansas
Nevada
860
3
Arkansas
Newton
1,196
4
Arkansas
Ouachita
1,142
4
Arkansas
Perry
1,418
4
Arkansas
Phillips
836
3
Arkansas
Pike
1,430
4
Arkansas
Poinsett
1,272
4
Arkansas
Polk
1,370
4
Arkansas
Pope
1,557
5
Arkansas
Prairie
996
3
Arkansas
Pulaski
1,414
4
Arkansas
Randolph
1,033
4
Arkansas
Saline
1,914
5
Arkansas
Scott
1,267
4
Arkansas
Searcy
795
3
Arkansas
Sebastian
1,717
5
Arkansas
Sevier
1,358
4
Arkansas
Sharp
818
3
Arkansas
St. Francis
974
3
Arkansas
Stone
810
3
Arkansas
Union
1,710
5
Arkansas
Van Buren
1,140
4
Arkansas
Washington
2,223
6
Arkansas
White
1,269
4
Arkansas
Woodruff
908
3
Arkansas
Yell
1,022
4
California
Alameda
2,230
6
California
Alpine
2,000
5
California
Amador
1,553
5
California
Butte
3,521
7
California
Calaveras
1,433
4
California
Colusa
2,109
6
California
Contra Costa
6,435
8
California
Del Norte
3,433
7
California
El Dorado
2,277
6
California
Fresno
2,890
6
California
Glenn
1,917
5
California
Humboldt
950
3
California
Imperial
2,381
6
California
Inyo
777
3
California
Kern
1,453
4
California
Kings
2,914
6
California
Lake
3,985
7
California
Lassen
555
3
California
Los Angeles
12,435
9
California
Madera
2,496
6
California
Marin
2,926
6
California
Mariposa
804
3
California
Mendocino
1,877
5
California
Merced
3,061
7
California
Modoc
554
3
California
Mono
1,249
4
( printed page 65078)
California
Monterey
2,598
6
California
Napa
15,480
9
California
Nevada
2,734
6
California
Orange
8,529
8
California
Placer
3,879
7
California
Plumas
818
3
California
Riverside
3,864
7
California
Sacramento
3,588
7
California
San Benito
1,502
5
California
San Bernardino
1,715
5
California
San Diego
6,108
8
California
San Francisco
25,791
10
California
San Joaquin
5,338
8
California
San Luis Obispo
2,141
6
California
San Mateo
4,783
7
California
Santa Barbara
2,947
6
California
Santa Clara
2,310
6
California
Santa Cruz
7,468
8
California
Shasta
1,386
4
California
Sierra
1,210
4
California
Siskiyou
1,148
4
California
Solano
3,067
7
California
Sonoma
8,846
8
California
Stanislaus
4,854
7
California
Sutter
3,251
7
California
Tehama
1,326
4
California
Trinity
511
3
California
Tulare
3,159
7
California
Tuolumne
1,331
4
California
Ventura
7,071
8
California
Yolo
2,916
6
California
Yuba
2,755
6
Colorado
Adams
721
3
Colorado
Alamosa
965
3
Colorado
Arapahoe
682
3
Colorado
Archuleta
1,022
4
Colorado
Baca
234
1
Colorado
Bent
256
2
Colorado
Boulder
6,111
8
Colorado
Broomfield*
605
3
Colorado
Chaffee
1,674
5
Colorado
Cheyenne
259
2
Colorado
Clear Creek
1,332
4
Colorado
Conejos
670
3
Colorado
Costilla
401
2
Colorado
Crowley
226
1
Colorado
Custer
1,242
4
Colorado
Delta
1,674
5
Colorado
Denver*
605
3
Colorado
Dolores
757
3
Colorado
Douglas
2,452
6
Colorado
Eagle
1,207
4
Colorado
El Paso
704
3
Colorado
Elbert
555
3
Colorado
Fremont
835
3
Colorado
Garfield
1,034
4
Colorado
Gilpin
2,230
6
Colorado
Grand
965
3
Colorado
Gunnison
1,482
4
Colorado
Hinsdale
2,341
6
Colorado
Huerfano
343
2
Colorado
Jackson
416
2
Colorado
Jefferson
3,917
7
Colorado
Kiowa
246
1
Colorado
Kit Carson
371
2
Colorado
La Plata
816
3
Colorado
Lake
1,105
4
Colorado
Larimer
1,849
5
Colorado
Las Animas
194
1
Colorado
Lincoln
201
1
Colorado
Logan
448
2
( printed page 65079)
Colorado
Mesa
1,141
4
Colorado
Mineral
1,250
4
Colorado
Moffat
333
2
Colorado
Montezuma
413
2
Colorado
Montrose
944
3
Colorado
Morgan
641
3
Colorado
Otero
306
2
Colorado
Ouray
1,204
4
Colorado
Park
627
3
Colorado
Phillips
574
3
Colorado
Pitkin
4,741
7
Colorado
Prowers
334
2
Colorado
Pueblo
393
2
Colorado
Rio Blanco
535
3
Colorado
Rio Grande
1,462
4
Colorado
Routt
1,512
5
Colorado
Saguache
567
3
Colorado
San Juan*
605
3
Colorado
San Miguel
770
3
Colorado
Sedgwick
588
3
Colorado
Summit
1,413
4
Colorado
Teller
1,027
4
Colorado
Washington
334
2
Colorado
Weld
1,103
4
Colorado
Yuma
458
2
Connecticut
Fairfield
20,931
10
Connecticut
Litchfield
6,889
8
Connecticut
Middlesex
9,966
8
Connecticut
New Haven
10,904
9
Connecticut
New London
5,511
8
Connecticut
Tolland
4,532
7
Connecticut
Windham
5,262
8
Delaware
Kent
2,798
6
Delaware
New Castle
4,545
7
Delaware
Sussex
3,161
7
Florida
Alachua
2,578
6
Florida
Baker
3,163
7
Florida
Bay
2,101
6
Florida
Bradford
1,988
5
Florida
Brevard
1,908
5
Florida
Broward
16,338
9
Florida
Calhoun
1,277
4
Florida
Charlotte
1,381
4
Florida
Citrus
1,998
5
Florida
Clay
1,986
5
Florida
Collier
2,128
6
Florida
Columbia
1,212
4
Florida
Dade
7,781
8
Florida
DeSoto
1,932
5
Florida
Dixie
1,442
4
Florida
Duval
4,849
7
Florida
Escambia
1,906
5
Florida
Flagler
1,307
4
Florida
Franklin
932
3
Florida
Gadsden
1,937
5
Florida
Gilchrist
1,858
5
Florida
Glades
1,479
4
Florida
Gulf
1,509
5
Florida
Hamilton
1,135
4
Florida
Hardee
1,873
5
Florida
Hendry
3,077
7
Florida
Hernando
4,074
7
Florida
Highlands
1,805
5
Florida
Hillsborough
4,328
7
Florida
Holmes
1,288
4
Florida
Indian River
2,375
6
Florida
Jackson
1,182
4
Florida
Jefferson
1,480
4
Florida
Lafayette
1,074
4
Florida
Lake
3,432
7
Florida
Lee
2,634
6
( printed page 65080)
Florida
Leon
1,668
5
Florida
Levy
1,519
5
Florida
Liberty
1,093
4
Florida
Madison
1,229
4
Florida
Manatee
2,514
6
Florida
Marion
3,994
7
Florida
Martin
2,083
6
Florida
Monroe
16,556
9
Florida
Nassau
3,818
7
Florida
Okaloosa
2,031
6
Florida
Okeechobee
1,630
5
Florida
Orange
3,145
7
Florida
Osceola
1,352
4
Florida
Palm Beach
2,678
6
Florida
Pasco
3,090
7
Florida
Pinellas
25,386
10
Florida
Polk
2,319
6
Florida
Putnam
1,984
5
Florida
Santa Rosa
2,119
6
Florida
Sarasota
2,396
6
Florida
Seminole
4,910
7
Florida
St. Johns
3,452
7
Florida
St. Lucie
2,591
6
Florida
Sumter
1,924
5
Florida
Suwannee
2,002
6
Florida
Taylor
1,034
4
Florida
Union
1,054
4
Florida
Volusia
3,486
7
Florida
Wakulla
2,313
6
Florida
Walton
1,511
5
Florida
Washington
1,830
5
Georgia
Appling
1,253
4
Georgia
Atkinson
1,135
4
Georgia
Bacon
1,744
5
Georgia
Baker
1,401
4
Georgia
Baldwin
1,875
5
Georgia
Banks
4,026
7
Georgia
Barrow
4,628
7
Georgia
Bartow
2,331
6
Georgia
Ben Hill
1,146
4
Georgia
Berrien
1,344
4
Georgia
Bibb
1,883
5
Georgia
Bleckley
1,318
4
Georgia
Brantley
1,282
4
Georgia
Brooks
1,282
4
Georgia
Bryan
1,350
4
Georgia
Bulloch
1,303
4
Georgia
Burke
1,075
4
Georgia
Butts
1,629
5
Georgia
Calhoun
1,038
4
Georgia
Camden
1,292
4
Georgia
Candler
1,083
4
Georgia
Carroll
3,118
7
Georgia
Catoosa
3,102
7
Georgia
Charlton
1,546
5
Georgia
Chatham
1,650
5
Georgia
Chattahoochee
1,181
4
Georgia
Chattooga
1,359
4
Georgia
Cherokee
6,686
8
Georgia
Clarke
3,274
7
Georgia
Clay
822
3
Georgia
Clayton
4,351
7
Georgia
Clinch
1,354
4
Georgia
Cobb
7,290
8
Georgia
Coffee
1,267
4
Georgia
Colquitt
1,266
4
Georgia
Columbia
3,238
7
Georgia
Cook
1,491
4
Georgia
Coweta
4,432
7
Georgia
Crawford
1,594
5
Georgia
Crisp
1,396
4
( printed page 65081)
Georgia
Dade
1,649
5
Georgia
Dawson
3,659
7
Georgia
Decatur
1,322
4
Georgia
DeKalb
5,182
8
Georgia
Dodge
821
3
Georgia
Dooly
1,043
4
Georgia
Dougherty
1,063
4
Georgia
Douglas
4,642
7
Georgia
Early
1,055
4
Georgia
Echols
1,282
4
Georgia
Effingham
1,392
4
Georgia
Elbert
1,714
5
Georgia
Emanuel
980
3
Georgia
Evans
1,324
4
Georgia
Fannin
2,839
6
Georgia
Fayette
4,005
7
Georgia
Floyd
2,120
6
Georgia
Forsyth
5,986
8
Georgia
Franklin
3,646
7
Georgia
Fulton
4,645
7
Georgia
Gilmer
3,672
7
Georgia
Glascock
1,250
4
Georgia
Glynn
1,443
4
Georgia
Gordon
3,117
7
Georgia
Grady
1,459
4
Georgia
Greene
2,326
6
Georgia
Gwinnett
5,179
8
Georgia
Habersham
4,229
7
Georgia
Hall
4,307
7
Georgia
Hancock
942
3
Georgia
Haralson
2,262
6
Georgia
Harris
1,510
5
Georgia
Hart
2,715
6
Georgia
Heard
1,740
5
Georgia
Henry
3,381
7
Georgia
Houston
1,758
5
Georgia
Irwin
1,134
4
Georgia
Jackson
4,452
7
Georgia
Jasper
1,799
5
Georgia
Jeff Davis
1,207
4
Georgia
Jefferson
1,058
4
Georgia
Jenkins
1,070
4
Georgia
Johnson
1,270
4
Georgia
Jones
1,688
5
Georgia
Lamar
1,960
5
Georgia
Lanier
945
3
Georgia
Laurens
1,087
4
Georgia
Lee
1,235
4
Georgia
Liberty
1,860
5
Georgia
Lincoln
2,126
6
Georgia
Long
1,163
4
Georgia
Lowndes
1,637
5
Georgia
Lumpkin
4,877
7
Georgia
Macon
1,350
4
Georgia
Madison
3,704
7
Georgia
Marion
1,231
4
Georgia
McDuffie
1,593
5
Georgia
McIntosh
1,294
4
Georgia
Meriwether
1,598
5
Georgia
Miller
1,310
4
Georgia
Monroe
1,735
5
Georgia
Montgomery
1,120
4
Georgia
Morgan
2,814
6
Georgia
Murray
2,422
6
Georgia
Muscogee
2,580
6
Georgia
Newton
3,293
7
Georgia
Oconee
3,876
7
Georgia
Oglethorpe
2,662
6
Georgia
Paulding
5,219
8
Georgia
Peach
1,900
5
Georgia
Pickens
4,625
7
( printed page 65082)
Georgia
Pierce
1,230
4
Georgia
Pike
3,001
6
Georgia
Polk
1,918
5
Georgia
Pulaski
1,121
4
Georgia
Putnam
2,178
6
Georgia
Quitman
1,090
4
Georgia
Rabun
4,870
7
Georgia
Randolph
963
3
Georgia
Richmond
2,334
6
Georgia
Rockdale
4,574
7
Georgia
Schley
1,269
4
Georgia
Screven
1,084
4
Georgia
Seminole
1,238
4
Georgia
Spalding
3,675
7
Georgia
Stephens
3,558
7
Georgia
Stewart
1,125
4
Georgia
Sumter
1,137
4
Georgia
Talbot
1,364
4
Georgia
Taliaferro
1,333
4
Georgia
Tattnall
1,590
5
Georgia
Taylor
1,289
4
Georgia
Telfair
1,249
4
Georgia
Terrell
1,085
4
Georgia
Thomas
1,238
4
Georgia
Tift
1,628
5
Georgia
Toombs
1,222
4
Georgia
Towns
3,102
7
Georgia
Treutlen
1,097
4
Georgia
Troup
1,300
4
Georgia
Turner
1,295
4
Georgia
Twiggs
1,161
4
Georgia
Union
4,348
7
Georgia
Upson
1,788
5
Georgia
Walker
2,043
6
Georgia
Walton
5,206
8
Georgia
Ware
1,218
4
Georgia
Warren
1,082
4
Georgia
Washington
1,230
4
Georgia
Wayne
1,435
4
Georgia
Webster
1,144
4
Georgia
Wheeler
971
3
Georgia
White
4,816
7
Georgia
Whitfield
1,968
5
Georgia
Wilcox
1,050
4
Georgia
Wilkes
1,394
4
Georgia
Wilkinson
1,106
4
Georgia
Worth
1,246
4
Hawaii
Hawaii
2,258
6
Hawaii
Honolulu
6,686
8
Hawaii
Kauai
3,191
7
Hawaii
Maui
3,290
7
Idaho
Ada
2,777
6
Idaho
Adams
454
2
Idaho
Bannock
585
3
Idaho
Bear Lake
632
3
Idaho
Benewah
970
3
Idaho
Bingham
921
3
Idaho
Blaine
1,043
4
Idaho
Boise
808
3
Idaho
Bonner
2,327
6
Idaho
Bonneville
1,042
4
Idaho
Boundary
1,913
5
Idaho
Butte
703
3
Idaho
Camas
558
3
Idaho
Canyon
3,375
7
Idaho
Caribou
541
3
Idaho
Cassia
789
3
Idaho
Clark
518
3
Idaho
Clearwater
1,028
4
Idaho
Custer
1,469
4
Idaho
Elmore
575
3
( printed page 65083)
Idaho
Franklin
862
3
Idaho
Fremont
918
3
Idaho
Gem
987
3
Idaho
Gooding
2,028
6
Idaho
Idaho
596
3
Idaho
Jefferson
1,406
4
Idaho
Jerome
1,510
5
Idaho
Kootenai
1,812
5
Idaho
Latah
1,120
4
Idaho
Lemhi
982
3
Idaho
Lewis
664
3
Idaho
Lincoln
754
3
Idaho
Madison
1,826
5
Idaho
Minidoka
1,600
5
Idaho
Nez Perce
682
3
Idaho
Oneida
534
3
Idaho
Owyhee
551
3
Idaho
Payette
1,388
4
Idaho
Power
789
3
Idaho
Shoshone
2,754
6
Idaho
Teton
1,970
5
Idaho
Twin Falls
1,557
5
Idaho
Valley
1,219
4
Idaho
Washington
589
3
Illinois
Adams
1,624
5
Illinois
Alexander
1,044
4
Illinois
Bond
1,682
5
Illinois
Boone
2,739
6
Illinois
Brown
1,330
4
Illinois
Bureau
2,124
6
Illinois
Calhoun
1,246
4
Illinois
Carroll
1,902
5
Illinois
Cass
1,682
5
Illinois
Champaign
2,312
6
Illinois
Christian
2,024
6
Illinois
Clark
1,560
5
Illinois
Clay
1,268
4
Illinois
Clinton
1,973
5
Illinois
Coles
2,173
6
Illinois
Cook
5,029
8
Illinois
Crawford
1,370
4
Illinois
Cumberland
1,698
5
Illinois
De Witt
2,410
6
Illinois
DeKalb
3,007
7
Illinois
Douglas
2,376
6
Illinois
DuPage
4,045
7
Illinois
Edgar
1,873
5
Illinois
Edwards
1,273
4
Illinois
Effingham
1,736
5
Illinois
Fayette
1,371
4
Illinois
Ford
2,086
6
Illinois
Franklin
1,258
4
Illinois
Fulton
1,509
5
Illinois
Gallatin
1,198
4
Illinois
Greene
1,484
4
Illinois
Grundy
2,477
6
Illinois
Hamilton
1,298
4
Illinois
Hancock
2,035
6
Illinois
Hardin
1,389
4
Illinois
Henderson
1,802
5
Illinois
Henry
1,966
5
Illinois
Iroquois
1,922
5
Illinois
Jackson
1,338
4
Illinois
Jasper
1,606
5
Illinois
Jefferson
1,066
4
Illinois
Jersey
1,722
5
Illinois
Jo Daviess
1,752
5
Illinois
Johnson
1,090
4
Illinois
Kane
3,086
7
Illinois
Kankakee
2,250
6
Illinois
Kendall
3,365
7
( printed page 65084)
Illinois
Knox
1,904
5
Illinois
La Salle
2,485
6
Illinois
Lake
3,724
7
Illinois
Lawrence
1,413
4
Illinois
Lee
2,398
6
Illinois
Livingston
2,126
6
Illinois
Logan
2,246
6
Illinois
Macon
2,446
6
Illinois
Macoupin
1,890
5
Illinois
Madison
1,982
5
Illinois
Marion
1,286
4
Illinois
Marshall
2,163
6
Illinois
Mason
1,746
5
Illinois
Massac
1,001
3
Illinois
McDonough
1,798
5
Illinois
McHenry
3,410
7
Illinois
McLean
2,330
6
Illinois
Menard
1,937
5
Illinois
Mercer
1,773
5
Illinois
Monroe
2,034
6
Illinois
Montgomery
1,626
5
Illinois
Morgan
1,920
5
Illinois
Moultrie
2,362
6
Illinois
Ogle
2,505
6
Illinois
Peoria
2,203
6
Illinois
Perry
1,138
4
Illinois
Piatt
2,385
6
Illinois
Pike
1,472
4
Illinois
Pope
924
3
Illinois
Pulaski
1,134
4
Illinois
Putnam
2,310
6
Illinois
Randolph
1,551
5
Illinois
Richland
1,435
4
Illinois
Rock Island
2,114
6
Illinois
Saline
1,230
4
Illinois
Sangamon
2,263
6
Illinois
Schuyler
1,279
4
Illinois
Scott
1,642
5
Illinois
Shelby
1,873
5
Illinois
St. Clair
2,207
6
Illinois
Stark
2,105
6
Illinois
Stephenson
1,910
5
Illinois
Tazewell
2,290
6
Illinois
Union
1,555
5
Illinois
Vermilion
1,974
5
Illinois
Wabash
1,378
4
Illinois
Warren
2,014
6
Illinois
Washington
1,520
5
Illinois
Wayne
991
3
Illinois
White
1,287
4
Illinois
Whiteside
2,032
6
Illinois
Will
3,722
7
Illinois
Williamson
1,609
5
Illinois
Winnebago
2,365
6
Illinois
Woodford
2,394
6
Indiana
Adams
2,304
6
Indiana
Allen
2,679
6
Indiana
Bartholomew
2,366
6
Indiana
Benton
1,995
5
Indiana
Blackford
1,760
5
Indiana
Boone
2,555
6
Indiana
Brown
2,213
6
Indiana
Carroll
2,186
6
Indiana
Cass
1,911
5
Indiana
Clark
2,621
6
Indiana
Clay
1,621
5
Indiana
Clinton
2,182
6
Indiana
Crawford
1,460
4
Indiana
Daviess
1,620
5
Indiana
Dearborn
2,594
6
Indiana
Decatur
2,113
6
( printed page 65085)
Indiana
DeKalb
1,762
5
Indiana
Delaware
2,032
6
Indiana
Dubois
1,853
5
Indiana
Elkhart
3,042
7
Indiana
Fayette
1,834
5
Indiana
Floyd
2,933
6
Indiana
Fountain
1,774
5
Indiana
Franklin
1,993
5
Indiana
Fulton
1,636
5
Indiana
Gibson
1,824
5
Indiana
Grant
2,026
6
Indiana
Greene
1,600
5
Indiana
Hamilton
3,250
7
Indiana
Hancock
2,576
6
Indiana
Harrison
2,054
6
Indiana
Hendricks
2,722
6
Indiana
Henry
2,190
6
Indiana
Howard
2,451
6
Indiana
Huntington
1,994
5
Indiana
Jackson
1,954
5
Indiana
Jasper
1,949
5
Indiana
Jay
2,042
6
Indiana
Jefferson
1,918
5
Indiana
Jennings
1,743
5
Indiana
Johnson
3,021
7
Indiana
Knox
1,725
5
Indiana
Kosciusko
2,176
6
Indiana
LaGrange
2,835
6
Indiana
Lake
2,714
6
Indiana
LaPorte
2,122
6
Indiana
Lawrence
1,260
4
Indiana
Madison
2,253
6
Indiana
Marion
3,530
7
Indiana
Marshall
1,886
5
Indiana
Martin
1,550
5
Indiana
Miami
1,925
5
Indiana
Monroe
1,955
5
Indiana
Montgomery
1,939
5
Indiana
Morgan
2,529
6
Indiana
Newton
1,914
5
Indiana
Noble
2,194
6
Indiana
Ohio
2,610
6
Indiana
Orange
1,521
5
Indiana
Owen
1,625
5
Indiana
Parke
1,641
5
Indiana
Perry
1,447
4
Indiana
Pike
1,641
5
Indiana
Porter
2,520
6
Indiana
Posey
1,790
5
Indiana
Pulaski
1,857
5
Indiana
Putnam
1,941
5
Indiana
Randolph
1,698
5
Indiana
Ripley
2,014
6
Indiana
Rush
2,099
6
Indiana
Scott
1,778
5
Indiana
Shelby
2,241
6
Indiana
Spencer
1,553
5
Indiana
St. Joseph
2,331
6
Indiana
Starke
1,636
5
Indiana
Steuben
1,834
5
Indiana
Sullivan
1,580
5
Indiana
Switzerland
1,951
5
Indiana
Tippecanoe
2,291
6
Indiana
Tipton
2,612
6
Indiana
Union
1,980
5
Indiana
Vanderburgh
2,050
6
Indiana
Vermillion
1,833
5
Indiana
Vigo
1,732
5
Indiana
Wabash
2,032
6
Indiana
Warren
1,956
5
Indiana
Warrick
1,919
5
( printed page 65086)
Indiana
Washington
1,790
5
Indiana
Wayne
1,779
5
Indiana
Wells
1,885
5
Indiana
White
2,028
6
Indiana
Whitley
2,012
6
Iowa
Adair
1,171
4
Iowa
Adams
1,137
4
Iowa
Allamakee
1,219
4
Iowa
Appanoose
741
3
Iowa
Audubon
1,472
4
Iowa
Benton
1,899
5
Iowa
Black Hawk
2,229
6
Iowa
Boone
1,721
5
Iowa
Bremer
2,070
6
Iowa
Buchanan
1,959
5
Iowa
Buena Vista
1,972
5
Iowa
Butler
1,786
5
Iowa
Calhoun
1,968
5
Iowa
Carroll
1,768
5
Iowa
Cass
1,311
4
Iowa
Cedar
1,665
5
Iowa
Cerro Gordo
1,691
5
Iowa
Cherokee
1,819
5
Iowa
Chickasaw
1,735
5
Iowa
Clarke
796
3
Iowa
Clay
1,802
5
Iowa
Clayton
1,522
5
Iowa
Clinton
1,847
5
Iowa
Crawford
1,522
5
Iowa
Dallas
2,030
6
Iowa
Davis
909
3
Iowa
Decatur
756
3
Iowa
Delaware
1,900
5
Iowa
Des Moines
1,773
5
Iowa
Dickinson
1,549
5
Iowa
Dubuque
1,707
5
Iowa
Emmet
1,525
5
Iowa
Fayette
1,728
5
Iowa
Floyd
1,822
5
Iowa
Franklin
1,723
5
Iowa
Fremont
1,288
4
Iowa
Greene
1,674
5
Iowa
Grundy
2,061
6
Iowa
Guthrie
1,450
4
Iowa
Hamilton
1,859
5
Iowa
Hancock
1,676
5
Iowa
Hardin
1,970
5
Iowa
Harrison
1,354
4
Iowa
Henry
1,615
5
Iowa
Howard
1,594
5
Iowa
Humboldt
1,990
5
Iowa
Ida
1,647
5
Iowa
Iowa
1,365
4
Iowa
Jackson
1,479
4
Iowa
Jasper
1,632
5
Iowa
Jefferson
1,194
4
Iowa
Johnson
1,902
5
Iowa
Jones
1,762
5
Iowa
Keokuk
1,215
4
Iowa
Kossuth
1,870
5
Iowa
Lee
1,422
4
Iowa
Linn
2,062
6
Iowa
Louisa
1,720
5
Iowa
Lucas
874
3
Iowa
Lyon
1,885
5
Iowa
Madison
1,406
4
Iowa
Mahaska
1,482
4
Iowa
Marion
1,193
4
Iowa
Marshall
1,607
5
Iowa
Mills
1,442
4
Iowa
Mitchell
1,778
5
( printed page 65087)
Iowa
Monona
1,434
4
Iowa
Monroe
806
3
Iowa
Montgomery
1,136
4
Iowa
Muscatine
1,826
5
Iowa
O'Brien
2,036
6
Iowa
Osceola
1,980
5
Iowa
Page
1,005
4
Iowa
Palo Alto
1,885
5
Iowa
Plymouth
1,814
5
Iowa
Pocahontas
1,902
5
Iowa
Polk
1,725
5
Iowa
Pottawattamie
1,622
5
Iowa
Poweshiek
1,466
4
Iowa
Ringgold
812
3
Iowa
Sac
1,950
5
Iowa
Scott
2,402
6
Iowa
Shelby
1,635
5
Iowa
Sioux
2,124
6
Iowa
Story
1,874
5
Iowa
Tama
1,802
5
Iowa
Taylor
981
3
Iowa
Union
1,047
4
Iowa
Van Buren
976
3
Iowa
Wapello
1,232
4
Iowa
Warren
1,174
4
Iowa
Washington
1,817
5
Iowa
Wayne
801
3
Iowa
Webster
1,765
5
Iowa
Winnebago
1,681
5
Iowa
Winneshiek
1,446
4
Iowa
Woodbury
1,435
4
Iowa
Worth
1,722
5
Iowa
Wright
1,983
5
Kansas
Allen
657
3
Kansas
Anderson
719
3
Kansas
Atchison
846
3
Kansas
Barber
353
2
Kansas
Barton
473
2
Kansas
Bourbon
576
3
Kansas
Brown
931
3
Kansas
Butler
802
3
Kansas
Chase
494
2
Kansas
Chautauqua
428
2
Kansas
Cherokee
774
3
Kansas
Cheyenne
384
2
Kansas
Clark
316
2
Kansas
Clay
726
3
Kansas
Cloud
483
2
Kansas
Coffey
604
3
Kansas
Comanche
326
2
Kansas
Cowley
620
3
Kansas
Crawford
700
3
Kansas
Decatur
388
2
Kansas
Dickinson
533
3
Kansas
Doniphan
1,025
4
Kansas
Douglas
1,608
5
Kansas
Edwards
463
2
Kansas
Elk
397
2
Kansas
Ellis
422
2
Kansas
Ellsworth
414
2
Kansas
Finney
493
2
Kansas
Ford
462
2
Kansas
Franklin
992
3
Kansas
Geary
687
3
Kansas
Gove
359
2
Kansas
Graham
362
2
Kansas
Grant
531
3
Kansas
Gray
633
3
Kansas
Greeley
403
2
Kansas
Greenwood
442
2
Kansas
Hamilton
372
2
( printed page 65088)
Kansas
Harper
498
2
Kansas
Harvey
742
3
Kansas
Haskell
595
3
Kansas
Hodgeman
410
2
Kansas
Jackson
666
3
Kansas
Jefferson
854
3
Kansas
Jewell
525
3
Kansas
Johnson
1,582
5
Kansas
Kearny
383
2
Kansas
Kingman
546
3
Kansas
Kiowe
353
2
Kansas
Labette
597
3
Kansas
Lane
374
2
Kansas
Leavenworth
1,271
4
Kansas
Lincoln
351
2
Kansas
Linn
802
3
Kansas
Logan
334
2
Kansas
Lyon
622
3
Kansas
Marion
585
3
Kansas
Marshall
734
3
Kansas
McPherson
921
3
Kansas
Meade
467
2
Kansas
Miami
1,404
4
Kansas
Mitchell
579
3
Kansas
Montgomery
707
3
Kansas
Morris
506
3
Kansas
Morton
373
2
Kansas
Nemaha
798
3
Kansas
Neosho
610
3
Kansas
Ness
330
2
Kansas
Norton
358
2
Kansas
Osage
719
3
Kansas
Osborne
398
2
Kansas
Ottawa
462
2
Kansas
Pawnee
450
2
Kansas
Phillips
369
2
Kansas
Pottawatomie
578
3
Kansas
Pratt
506
3
Kansas
Rawlins
333
2
Kansas
Reno
700
3
Kansas
Republic
655
3
Kansas
Rice
534
3
Kansas
Riley
828
3
Kansas
Rooks
358
2
Kansas
Rush
378
2
Kansas
Russell
344
2
Kansas
Saline
598
3
Kansas
Scott
444
2
Kansas
Sedgwick
958
3
Kansas
Seward
518
3
Kansas
Shawnee
1,012
4
Kansas
Sheridan
477
2
Kansas
Sherman
498
2
Kansas
Smith
530
3
Kansas
Stafford
611
3
Kansas
Stanton
458
2
Kansas
Stevens
542
3
Kansas
Sumner
546
3
Kansas
Thomas
486
2
Kansas
Trego
370
2
Kansas
Wabaunsee
581
3
Kansas
Wallace
355
2
Kansas
Washington
643
3
Kansas
Wichita
402
2
Kansas
Wilson
616
3
Kansas
Woodson
471
2
Kansas
Wyandotte
3,132
7
Kentucky
Adair
1,427
4
Kentucky
Allen
1,431
4
Kentucky
Anderson
1,926
5
Kentucky
Ballard
1,356
4
( printed page 65089)
Kentucky
Barren
1,287
4
Kentucky
Bath
1,098
4
Kentucky
Bell
1,061
4
Kentucky
Boone
2,906
6
Kentucky
Bourbon
2,131
6
Kentucky
Boyd
1,157
4
Kentucky
Boyle
1,709
5
Kentucky
Bracken
1,227
4
Kentucky
Breathitt
738
3
Kentucky
Breckinridge
1,206
4
Kentucky
Bullitt
2,194
6
Kentucky
Butler
1,230
4
Kentucky
Caldwell
925
3
Kentucky
Calloway
1,490
4
Kentucky
Campbell
3,069
7
Kentucky
Carlisle
1,128
4
Kentucky
Carroll
1,657
5
Kentucky
Carter
1,197
4
Kentucky
Casey
934
3
Kentucky
Christian
1,357
4
Kentucky
Clark
1,746
5
Kentucky
Clay
767
3
Kentucky
Clinton
1,223
4
Kentucky
Crittenden
834
3
Kentucky
Cumberland
830
3
Kentucky
Daviess
1,633
5
Kentucky
Edmonson
941
3
Kentucky
Elliott
725
3
Kentucky
Estill
890
3
Kentucky
Fayette
3,671
7
Kentucky
Fleming
1,018
4
Kentucky
Floyd
1,229
4
Kentucky
Franklin
1,880
5
Kentucky
Fulton
1,160
4
Kentucky
Gallatin
1,724
5
Kentucky
Garrard
1,482
4
Kentucky
Grant
2,036
6
Kentucky
Graves
1,327
4
Kentucky
Grayson
1,102
4
Kentucky
Green
1,218
4
Kentucky
Greenup
963
3
Kentucky
Hancock
1,066
4
Kentucky
Hardin
1,516
5
Kentucky
Harlan
1,799
5
Kentucky
Harrison
1,494
4
Kentucky
Hart
1,110
4
Kentucky
Henderson
1,546
5
Kentucky
Henry
1,918
5
Kentucky
Hickman
1,198
4
Kentucky
Hopkins
1,041
4
Kentucky
Jackson
955
3
Kentucky
Jefferson
3,934
7
Kentucky
Jessamine
2,959
6
Kentucky
Johnson
1,218
4
Kentucky
Kenton
3,020
7
Kentucky
Knott
1,279
4
Kentucky
Knox
1,236
4
Kentucky
Larue
1,549
5
Kentucky
Laurel
1,844
5
Kentucky
Lawrence
728
3
Kentucky
Lee
911
3
Kentucky
Leslie
629
3
Kentucky
Letcher
830
3
Kentucky
Lewis
715
3
Kentucky
Lincoln
1,396
4
Kentucky
Livingston
819
3
Kentucky
Logan
1,274
4
Kentucky
Lyon
950
3
Kentucky
Madison
1,813
5
Kentucky
Magoffin
896
3
Kentucky
Marion
1,417
4
( printed page 65090)
Kentucky
Marshall
1,406
4
Kentucky
Martin
488
2
Kentucky
Mason
1,511
5
Kentucky
McCracken
1,402
4
Kentucky
McCreary
1,797
5
Kentucky
McLean
1,357
4
Kentucky
Meade
1,654
5
Kentucky
Menifee
1,554
5
Kentucky
Mercer
2,282
6
Kentucky
Metcalfe
1,275
4
Kentucky
Monroe
1,050
4
Kentucky
Montgomery
1,530
5
Kentucky
Morgan
775
3
Kentucky
Muhlenberg
1,009
4
Kentucky
Nelson
1,723
5
Kentucky
Nicholas
1,008
4
Kentucky
Ohio
1,373
4
Kentucky
Oldham
3,650
7
Kentucky
Owen
1,331
4
Kentucky
Owsley
1,055
4
Kentucky
Pendleton
1,183
4
Kentucky
Perry
910
3
Kentucky
Pike
891
3
Kentucky
Powell
1,450
4
Kentucky
Pulaski
1,497
4
Kentucky
Robertson
858
3
Kentucky
Rockcastle
1,390
4
Kentucky
Rowan
1,064
4
Kentucky
Russell
1,562
5
Kentucky
Scott
2,517
6
Kentucky
Shelby
2,577
6
Kentucky
Simpson
1,617
5
Kentucky
Spencer
2,032
6
Kentucky
Taylor
1,351
4
Kentucky
Todd
1,387
4
Kentucky
Trigg
1,181
4
Kentucky
Trimble
1,208
4
Kentucky
Union
1,384
4
Kentucky
Warren
1,643
5
Kentucky
Washington
1,421
4
Kentucky
Wayne
1,773
5
Kentucky
Webster
1,128
4
Kentucky
Whitley
1,224
4
Kentucky
Wolfe
889
3
Kentucky
Woodford
3,004
7
Louisiana
Acadia
1,418
4
Louisiana
Allen
983
3
Louisiana
Ascension
2,223
6
Louisiana
Assumption
1,278
4
Louisiana
Avoyelles
1,040
4
Louisiana
Beauregard
1,071
4
Louisiana
Bienville
1,223
4
Louisiana
Bossier
1,334
4
Louisiana
Caddo
1,142
4
Louisiana
Calcasieu
1,140
4
Louisiana
Caldwell
1,080
4
Louisiana
Cameron
1,150
4
Louisiana
Catahoula
931
3
Louisiana
Claiborne
1,269
4
Louisiana
Concordia
902
3
Louisiana
De Soto
1,022
4
Louisiana
East Baton Rouge
2,459
6
Louisiana
East Carroll
955
3
Louisiana
East Feliciana
1,542
5
Louisiana
Evangeline
1,009
4
Louisiana
Franklin
953
3
Louisiana
Grant
1,066
4
Louisiana
Iberia
1,506
5
Louisiana
Iberville
1,482
4
Louisiana
Jackson
2,102
6
Louisiana
Jefferson
1,763
5
( printed page 65091)
Louisiana
Jefferson Davis
871
3
Louisiana
La Salle
1,350
4
Louisiana
Lafayette
2,529
6
Louisiana
Lafourche
1,176
4
Louisiana
Lincoln
1,562
5
Louisiana
Livingston
2,333
6
Louisiana
Madison
884
3
Louisiana
Morehouse
938
3
Louisiana
Natchitoches
1,090
4
Louisiana
Orleans
35,002
11
Louisiana
Ouachita
1,394
4
Louisiana
Plaquemines
2,311
6
Louisiana
Pointe Coupee
1,138
4
Louisiana
Rapides
1,363
4
Louisiana
Red River
716
3
Louisiana
Richland
836
3
Louisiana
Sabine
1,515
5
Louisiana
St. Bernard
3,397
7
Louisiana
St. Charles
3,322
7
Louisiana
St. Helena
1,586
5
Louisiana
St. James
1,040
4
Louisiana
St. John the Baptist
2,728
6
Louisiana
St. Landry
1,107
4
Louisiana
St. Martin
1,333
4
Louisiana
St. Mary
1,182
4
Louisiana
St. Tammany
3,126
7
Louisiana
Tangipahoa
2,224
6
Louisiana
Tensas
844
3
Louisiana
Terrebonne
1,458
4
Louisiana
Union
1,579
5
Louisiana
Vermilion
1,306
4
Louisiana
Vernon
1,450
4
Louisiana
Washington
1,761
5
Louisiana
Webster
2,310
6
Louisiana
West Baton Rouge
1,572
5
Louisiana
West Carroll
1,425
4
Louisiana
West Feliciana
1,454
4
Louisiana
Winn
1,267
4
Maine
Androscoggin
1,937
5
Maine
Aroostook
718
3
Maine
Cumberland
3,234
7
Maine
Franklin
1,167
4
Maine
Hancock
1,568
5
Maine
Kennebec
1,539
5
Maine
Knox
2,266
6
Maine
Lincoln
2,195
6
Maine
Oxford
1,918
5
Maine
Penobscot
1,013
4
Maine
Piscataquis
812
3
Maine
Sagadahoc
2,298
6
Maine
Somerset
1,044
4
Maine
Waldo
1,334
4
Maine
Washington
685
3
Maine
York
3,009
7
Maryland
Allegany
1,958
5
Maryland
Anne Arundel
5,980
8
Maryland
Baltimore
5,459
8
Maryland
Calvert
3,184
7
Maryland
Caroline
2,361
6
Maryland
Carroll
4,503
7
Maryland
Cecil
4,639
7
Maryland
Charles
2,674
6
Maryland
Dorchester
2,163
6
Maryland
Frederick
4,260
7
Maryland
Garrett
1,743
5
Maryland
Harford
3,922
7
Maryland
Howard
4,857
7
Maryland
Kent
2,704
6
Maryland
Montgomery
4,783
7
Maryland
Prince George's
5,225
8
Maryland
Queen Anne's
2,515
6
( printed page 65092)
Maryland
Somerset
2,013
6
Maryland
St. Mary's
2,265
6
Maryland
Talbot
3,362
7
Maryland
Washington
3,043
7
Maryland
Wicomico
2,730
6
Maryland
Worcester
1,915
5
Massachusetts
Barnstable
17,137
9
Massachusetts
Berkshire
4,511
7
Massachusetts
Bristol
10,200
9
Massachusetts
Dukes
9,074
8
Massachusetts
Essex
11,648
9
Massachusetts
Franklin
3,191
7
Massachusetts
Hampden
5,123
8
Massachusetts
Hampshire
5,281
8
Massachusetts
Middlesex
16,780
9
Massachusetts
Nantucket
40,659
11
Massachusetts
Norfolk
12,768
9
Massachusetts
Plymouth
10,108
9
Massachusetts
Suffolk
44,817
11
Massachusetts
Worcester
5,902
8
Michigan
Alcona
1,726
5
Michigan
Alger
1,245
4
Michigan
Allegan
2,527
6
Michigan
Alpena
1,551
5
Michigan
Antrim
2,071
6
Michigan
Arenac
1,626
5
Michigan
Baraga
993
3
Michigan
Barry
2,046
6
Michigan
Bay
2,058
6
Michigan
Benzie
2,460
6
Michigan
Berrien
3,118
7
Michigan
Branch
1,962
5
Michigan
Calhoun
1,851
5
Michigan
Cass
1,824
5
Michigan
Charlevoix
2,542
6
Michigan
Cheboygan
1,663
5
Michigan
Chippewa
1,043
4
Michigan
Clare
1,641
5
Michigan
Clinton
1,897
5
Michigan
Crawford
2,030
6
Michigan
Delta
1,156
4
Michigan
Dickinson
1,126
4
Michigan
Eaton
2,270
6
Michigan
Emmet
2,386
6
Michigan
Genesee
3,082
7
Michigan
Gladwin
1,742
5
Michigan
Gogebic
1,457
4
Michigan
Grand Traverse
3,311
7
Michigan
Gratiot
1,616
5
Michigan
Hillsdale
1,920
5
Michigan
Houghton
1,061
4
Michigan
Huron
1,598
5
Michigan
Ingham
2,303
6
Michigan
Ionia
2,229
6
Michigan
Iosco
1,824
5
Michigan
Iron
1,195
4
Michigan
Isabella
1,603
5
Michigan
Jackson
2,322
6
Michigan
Kalamazoo
2,828
6
Michigan
Kalkaska
1,740
5
Michigan
Kent
3,218
7
Michigan
Keweenaw
1,774
5
Michigan
Lake
1,770
5
Michigan
Lapeer
3,094
7
Michigan
Leelanau
3,747
7
Michigan
Lenawee
2,013
6
Michigan
Livingston
3,826
7
Michigan
Luce
1,094
4
Michigan
Mackinac
1,238
4
Michigan
Macomb
4,886
7
Michigan
Manistee
1,778
5
( printed page 65093)
Michigan
Marquette
1,306
4
Michigan
Mason
1,586
5
Michigan
Mecosta
1,762
5
Michigan
Menominee
1,058
4
Michigan
Midland
2,086
6
Michigan
Missaukee
1,759
5
Michigan
Monroe
2,522
6
Michigan
Montcalm
1,764
5
Michigan
Montmorency
1,550
5
Michigan
Muskegon
2,406
6
Michigan
Newaygo
2,151
6
Michigan
Oakland
5,942
8
Michigan
Oceana
2,161
6
Michigan
Ogemaw
1,727
5
Michigan
Ontonagon
910
3
Michigan
Osceola
1,640
5
Michigan
Oscoda
1,776
5
Michigan
Otsego
1,935
5
Michigan
Ottawa
3,482
7
Michigan
Presque Isle
1,598
5
Michigan
Roscommon
2,549
6
Michigan
Saginaw
1,654
5
Michigan
Sanilac
1,678
5
Michigan
Schoolcraft
1,310
4
Michigan
Shiawassee
1,730
5
Michigan
St. Clair
3,176
7
Michigan
St. Joseph
1,851
5
Michigan
Tuscola
1,838
5
Michigan
Van Buren
2,245
6
Michigan
Washtenaw
3,791
7
Michigan
Wayne
5,463
8
Michigan
Wexford
2,223
6
Minnesota
Aitkin
703
3
Minnesota
Anoka
4,820
7
Minnesota
Becker
761
3
Minnesota
Beltrami
587
3
Minnesota
Benton
1,619
5
Minnesota
Big Stone
833
3
Minnesota
Blue Earth
1,734
5
Minnesota
Brown
1,574
5
Minnesota
Carlton
829
3
Minnesota
Carver
2,365
6
Minnesota
Cass
766
3
Minnesota
Chippewa
1,202
4
Minnesota
Chisago
2,318
6
Minnesota
Clay
856
3
Minnesota
Clearwater
501
3
Minnesota
Cook
1,411
4
Minnesota
Cottonwood
1,424
4
Minnesota
Crow Wing
884
3
Minnesota
Dakota
2,762
6
Minnesota
Dodge
1,873
5
Minnesota
Douglas
1,018
4
Minnesota
Faribault
1,683
5
Minnesota
Fillmore
1,403
4
Minnesota
Freeborn
1,758
5
Minnesota
Goodhue
1,917
5
Minnesota
Grant
1,028
4
Minnesota
Hennepin
4,446
7
Minnesota
Houston
1,044
4
Minnesota
Hubbard
694
3
Minnesota
Isanti
1,835
5
Minnesota
Itasca
798
3
Minnesota
Jackson
1,486
4
Minnesota
Kanabec
1,030
4
Minnesota
Kandiyohi
1,282
4
Minnesota
Kittson
450
2
Minnesota
Koochiching
562
3
Minnesota
Lac qui Parle
978
3
Minnesota
Lake
1,386
4
Minnesota
Lake of the Woods
472
2
( printed page 65094)
Minnesota
Le Sueur
1,796
5
Minnesota
Lincoln
931
3
Minnesota
Lyon
1,161
4
Minnesota
Mahnomen
537
3
Minnesota
Marshall
489
2
Minnesota
Martin
1,638
5
Minnesota
McLeod
1,676
5
Minnesota
Meeker
1,434
4
Minnesota
Mille Lacs
1,385
4
Minnesota
Morrison
1,070
4
Minnesota
Mower
1,567
5
Minnesota
Murray
1,236
4
Minnesota
Nicollet
1,810
5
Minnesota
Nobles
1,343
4
Minnesota
Norman
668
3
Minnesota
Olmsted
1,771
5
Minnesota
Otter Tail
838
3
Minnesota
Pennington
419
2
Minnesota
Pine
1,015
4
Minnesota
Pipestone
1,126
4
Minnesota
Polk
662
3
Minnesota
Pope
986
3
Minnesota
Ramsey
15,209
9
Minnesota
Red Lake
504
3
Minnesota
Redwood
1,378
4
Minnesota
Renville
1,511
5
Minnesota
Rice
2,186
6
Minnesota
Rock
1,116
4
Minnesota
Roseau
422
2
Minnesota
Scott
2,797
6
Minnesota
Sherburne
2,253
6
Minnesota
Sibley
1,787
5
Minnesota
St. Louis
1,102
4
Minnesota
Stearns
1,263
4
Minnesota
Steele
1,701
5
Minnesota
Stevens
1,178
4
Minnesota
Swift
1,000
3
Minnesota
Todd
931
3
Minnesota
Traverse
905
3
Minnesota
Wabasha
1,500
4
Minnesota
Wadena
812
3
Minnesota
Waseca
1,876
5
Minnesota
Washington
4,160
7
Minnesota
Watonwan
1,486
4
Minnesota
Wilkin
854
3
Minnesota
Winona
1,591
5
Minnesota
Wright
2,218
6
Minnesota
Yellow Medicine
1,029
4
Mississippi
Adams
803
3
Mississippi
Alcorn
1,084
4
Mississippi
Amite
1,258
4
Mississippi
Attala
1,028
4
Mississippi
Benton
776
3
Mississippi
Bolivar
878
3
Mississippi
Calhoun
762
3
Mississippi
Carroll
793
3
Mississippi
Chickasaw
738
3
Mississippi
Choctaw
939
3
Mississippi
Claiborne
962
3
Mississippi
Clarke
1,368
4
Mississippi
Clay
904
3
Mississippi
Coahoma
926
3
Mississippi
Copiah
1,317
4
Mississippi
Covington
1,258
4
Mississippi
DeSoto
1,569
5
Mississippi
Forrest
2,167
6
Mississippi
Franklin
1,315
4
Mississippi
George
2,418
6
Mississippi
Greene
1,303
4
Mississippi
Grenada
972
3
Mississippi
Hancock
1,901
5
( printed page 65095)
Mississippi
Harrison
3,082
7
Mississippi
Hinds
1,078
4
Mississippi
Holmes
984
3
Mississippi
Humphreys
902
3
Mississippi
Issaquena
935
3
Mississippi
Itawamba
899
3
Mississippi
Jackson
3,077
7
Mississippi
Jasper
1,108
4
Mississippi
Jefferson
1,174
4
Mississippi
Jefferson Davis
1,060
4
Mississippi
Jones
1,778
5
Mississippi
Kemper
907
3
Mississippi
Lafayette
1,115
4
Mississippi
Lamar
1,590
5
Mississippi
Lauderdale
1,114
4
Mississippi
Lawrence
1,249
4
Mississippi
Leake
1,191
4
Mississippi
Lee
1,070
4
Mississippi
Leflore
888
3
Mississippi
Lincoln
1,804
5
Mississippi
Lowndes
901
3
Mississippi
Madison
1,298
4
Mississippi
Marion
1,085
4
Mississippi
Marshall
1,078
4
Mississippi
Monroe
938
3
Mississippi
Montgomery
727
3
Mississippi
Neshoba
1,706
5
Mississippi
Newton
2,458
6
Mississippi
Noxubee
851
3
Mississippi
Oktibbeha
1,370
4
Mississippi
Panola
885
3
Mississippi
Pearl River
2,229
6
Mississippi
Perry
1,714
5
Mississippi
Pike
1,542
5
Mississippi
Pontotoc
941
3
Mississippi
Prentiss
739
3
Mississippi
Quitman
787
3
Mississippi
Rankin
1,188
4
Mississippi
Scott
1,289
4
Mississippi
Sharkey
851
3
Mississippi
Simpson
1,635
5
Mississippi
Smith
1,568
5
Mississippi
Stone
1,461
4
Mississippi
Sunflower
850
3
Mississippi
Tallahatchie
724
3
Mississippi
Tate
1,359
4
Mississippi
Tippah
990
3
Mississippi
Tishomingo
1,049
4
Mississippi
Tunica
800
3
Mississippi
Union
1,239
4
Mississippi
Walthall
2,319
6
Mississippi
Warren
876
3
Mississippi
Washington
1,008
4
Mississippi
Wayne
1,256
4
Mississippi
Webster
654
3
Mississippi
Wilkinson
1,103
4
Mississippi
Winston
1,336
4
Mississippi
Yalobusha
966
3
Mississippi
Yazoo
882
3
Missouri
Adair
810
3
Missouri
Andrew
1,470
4
Missouri
Atchison
1,314
4
Missouri
Audrain
1,281
4
Missouri
Barry
1,342
4
Missouri
Barton
800
3
Missouri
Bates
959
3
Missouri
Benton
892
3
Missouri
Bollinger
1,034
4
Missouri
Boone
2,035
6
Missouri
Buchanan
1,432
4
Missouri
Butler
1,199
4
( printed page 65096)
Missouri
Caldwell
1,095
4
Missouri
Callaway
1,424
4
Missouri
Camden
1,003
4
Missouri
Cape Girardeau
1,513
5
Missouri
Carroll
1,036
4
Missouri
Carter
838
3
Missouri
Cass
1,475
4
Missouri
Cedar
917
3
Missouri
Chariton
1,066
4
Missouri
Christian
1,910
5
Missouri
Clark
932
3
Missouri
Clay
2,714
6
Missouri
Clinton
1,233
4
Missouri
Cole
1,579
5
Missouri
Cooper
1,066
4
Missouri
Crawford
998
3
Missouri
Dade
1,022
4
Missouri
Dallas
1,117
4
Missouri
Daviess
941
3
Missouri
DeKalb
911
3
Missouri
Dent
793
3
Missouri
Douglas
857
3
Missouri
Dunklin
1,549
5
Missouri
Franklin
1,945
5
Missouri
Gasconade
1,269
4
Missouri
Gentry
925
3
Missouri
Greene
2,639
6
Missouri
Grundy
819
3
Missouri
Harrison
761
3
Missouri
Henry
967
3
Missouri
Hickory
866
3
Missouri
Holt
1,193
4
Missouri
Howard
1,067
4
Missouri
Howell
1,098
4
Missouri
Iron
1,066
4
Missouri
Jackson
2,940
6
Missouri
Jasper
1,195
4
Missouri
Jefferson
2,108
6
Missouri
Johnson
1,354
4
Missouri
Knox
1,113
4
Missouri
Laclede
1,102
4
Missouri
Lafayette
1,465
4
Missouri
Lawrence
1,422
4
Missouri
Lewis
885
3
Missouri
Lincoln
1,738
5
Missouri
Linn
804
3
Missouri
Livingston
1,028
4
Missouri
Macon
858
3
Missouri
Madison
778
3
Missouri
Maries
826
3
Missouri
Marion
981
3
Missouri
McDonald
1,623
5
Missouri
Mercer
4,286
7
Missouri
Miller
1,183
4
Missouri
Mississippi
1,484
4
Missouri
Moniteau
1,104
4
Missouri
Monroe
946
3
Missouri
Montgomery
1,311
4
Missouri
Morgan
1,242
4
Missouri
New Madrid
1,470
4
Missouri
Newton
1,408
4
Missouri
Nodaway
956
3
Missouri
Oregon
803
3
Missouri
Osage
1,120
4
Missouri
Ozark
1,093
4
Missouri
Pemiscot
1,418
4
Missouri
Perry
1,190
4
Missouri
Pettis
1,110
4
Missouri
Phelps
1,215
4
Missouri
Pike
1,294
4
Missouri
Platte
1,845
5
( printed page 65097)
Missouri
Polk
1,127
4
Missouri
Pulaski
1,048
4
Missouri
Putnam
693
3
Missouri
Ralls
1,150
4
Missouri
Randolph
939
3
Missouri
Ray
1,192
4
Missouri
Reynolds
838
3
Missouri
Ripley
813
3
Missouri
Saline
1,094
4
Missouri
Schuyler
649
3
Missouri
Scotland
898
3
Missouri
Scott
1,396
4
Missouri
Shannon
842
3
Missouri
Shelby
950
3
Missouri
St Louis
2,902
6
Missouri
St. Charles
3,193
7
Missouri
St. Clair
814
3
Missouri
St. Francois
1,626
5
Missouri
Ste. Genevieve
1,157
4
Missouri
Stoddard
1,638
5
Missouri
Stone
1,542
5
Missouri
Sullivan
651
3
Missouri
Taney
1,382
4
Missouri
Texas
822
3
Missouri
Vernon
884
3
Missouri
Warren
1,850
5
Missouri
Washington
1,182
4
Missouri
Wayne
827
3
Missouri
Webster
1,378
4
Missouri
Worth
733
3
Missouri
Wright
1,007
4
Montana
Beaverhead
438
2
Montana
Big Horn
197
1
Montana
Blaine
196
1
Montana
Broadwater
371
2
Montana
Carbon
613
3
Montana
Carter
158
1
Montana
Cascade
340
2
Montana
Chouteau
336
2
Montana
Custer
155
1
Montana
Daniels
234
1
Montana
Dawson
175
1
Montana
Deer Lodge
502
3
Montana
Fallon
210
1
Montana
Fergus
297
2
Montana
Flathead
1,875
5
Montana
Gallatin
873
3
Montana
Garfield
132
1
Montana
Glacier
269
2
Montana
Golden Valley
194
1
Montana
Granite
560
3
Montana
Hill
255
2
Montana
Jefferson
482
2
Montana
Judith Basin
421
2
Montana
Lake
925
3
Montana
Lewis and Clark
452
2
Montana
Liberty
268
2
Montana
Lincoln
2,295
6
Montana
Madison
518
3
Montana
McCone
181
1
Montana
Meagher
347
2
Montana
Mineral
1,550
5
Montana
Missoula
1,150
4
Montana
Musselshell
194
1
Montana
Park
570
3
Montana
Petroleum
222
1
Montana
Phillips
175
1
Montana
Pondera
362
2
Montana
Powder River
174
1
Montana
Powell
496
2
Montana
Prairie
169
1
( printed page 65098)
Montana
Ravalli
2,141
6
Montana
Richland
232
1
Montana
Roosevelt
239
1
Montana
Rosebud
144
1
Montana
Sanders
877
3
Montana
Sheridan
268
2
Montana
Silver Bow
782
3
Montana
Stillwater
384
2
Montana
Sweet Grass
445
2
Montana
Teton
290
2
Montana
Toole
280
2
Montana
Treasure
191
1
Montana
Valley
206
1
Montana
Wheatland
228
1
Montana
Wibaux
193
1
Montana
Yellowstone
404
2
Nebraska
Adams
1,246
4
Nebraska
Antelope
869
3
Nebraska
Arthur
156
1
Nebraska
Banner
245
1
Nebraska
Blaine
193
1
Nebraska
Boone
922
3
Nebraska
Box Butte
382
2
Nebraska
Boyd
349
2
Nebraska
Brown
274
2
Nebraska
Buffalo
1,050
4
Nebraska
Burt
1,360
4
Nebraska
Butler
1,522
5
Nebraska
Cass
1,660
5
Nebraska
Cedar
960
3
Nebraska
Chase
534
3
Nebraska
Cherry
180
1
Nebraska
Cheyenne
299
2
Nebraska
Clay
1,202
4
Nebraska
Colfax
1,303
4
Nebraska
Cuming
1,257
4
Nebraska
Custer
428
2
Nebraska
Dakota
1,078
4
Nebraska
Dawes
290
2
Nebraska
Dawson
811
3
Nebraska
Deuel
344
2
Nebraska
Dixon
997
3
Nebraska
Dodge
1,564
5
Nebraska
Douglas
3,120
7
Nebraska
Dundy
382
2
Nebraska
Fillmore
1,348
4
Nebraska
Franklin
614
3
Nebraska
Frontier
423
2
Nebraska
Furnas
483
2
Nebraska
Gage
874
3
Nebraska
Garden
204
1
Nebraska
Garfield
281
2
Nebraska
Gosper
669
3
Nebraska
Grant
170
1
Nebraska
Greeley
593
3
Nebraska
Hall
1,329
4
Nebraska
Hamilton
1,473
4
Nebraska
Harlan
571
3
Nebraska
Hayes
332
2
Nebraska
Hitchcock
390
2
Nebraska
Holt
414
2
Nebraska
Hooker
162
1
Nebraska
Howard
799
3
Nebraska
Jefferson
945
3
Nebraska
Johnson
774
3
Nebraska
Kearney
1,158
4
Nebraska
Keith
407
2
Nebraska
Keya Paha
276
2
Nebraska
Kimball
247
1
Nebraska
Knox
581
3
Nebraska
Lancaster
1,570
5
( printed page 65099)
Nebraska
Lincoln
407
2
Nebraska
Logan
248
1
Nebraska
Loup
223
1
Nebraska
Madison
1,066
4
Nebraska
McPherson
174
1
Nebraska
Merrick
1,071
4
Nebraska
Morrill
262
2
Nebraska
Nance
734
3
Nebraska
Nemaha
1,017
4
Nebraska
Nuckolls
720
3
Nebraska
Otoe
1,198
4
Nebraska
Pawnee
676
3
Nebraska
Perkins
513
3
Nebraska
Phelps
1,183
4
Nebraska
Pierce
997
3
Nebraska
Platte
1,360
4
Nebraska
Polk
1,481
4
Nebraska
Red Willow
455
2
Nebraska
Richardson
778
3
Nebraska
Rock
255
2
Nebraska
Saline
1,054
4
Nebraska
Sarpy
2,854
6
Nebraska
Saunders
1,618
5
Nebraska
Scotts Bluff
518
3
Nebraska
Seward
1,429
4
Nebraska
Sheridan
202
1
Nebraska
Sherman
497
2
Nebraska
Sioux
222
1
Nebraska
Stanton
1,054
4
Nebraska
Thayer
1,066
4
Nebraska
Thomas
164
1
Nebraska
Thurston
1,068
4
Nebraska
Valley
539
3
Nebraska
Washington
1,802
5
Nebraska
Wayne
1,166
4
Nebraska
Webster
680
3
Nebraska
Wheeler
420
2
Nebraska
York
1,607
5
Nevada
Carson City
2,588
6
Nevada
Churchill
1,250
4
Nevada
Clark
2,854
6
Nevada
Douglas
672
3
Nevada
Elko
131
1
Nevada
Esmeralda
834
3
Nevada
Eureka
184
1
Nevada
Humboldt
304
2
Nevada
Lander
198
1
Nevada
Lincoln
846
3
Nevada
Lyon
1,124
4
Nevada
Mineral
154
1
Nevada
Nye
835
3
Nevada
Pershing
544
3
Nevada
Storey
25,714
10
Nevada
Washoe
476
2
Nevada
White Pine
435
2
New Hampshire
Belknap
2,755
6
New Hampshire
Carroll
2,266
6
New Hampshire
Cheshire
2,541
6
New Hampshire
Coos
957
3
New Hampshire
Grafton
1,718
5
New Hampshire
Hillsborough
4,495
7
New Hampshire
Merrimack
2,146
6
New Hampshire
Rockingham
5,459
8
New Hampshire
Strafford
2,328
6
New Hampshire
Sullivan
2,047
6
New Jersey
Atlantic
4,637
7
New Jersey
Bergen
38,527
11
New Jersey
Burlington
5,422
8
New Jersey
Camden
9,157
8
New Jersey
Cape May
5,639
8
New Jersey
Cumberland
3,771
7
( printed page 65100)
New Jersey
Essex
36,694
11
New Jersey
Gloucester
7,588
8
New Jersey
Hudson *
7,396
8
New Jersey
Hunterdon
9,595
8
New Jersey
Mercer
15,084
9
New Jersey
Middlesex
11,731
9
New Jersey
Monmouth
13,750
9
New Jersey
Morris
21,135
10
New Jersey
Ocean
11,618
9
New Jersey
Passaic
25,729
10
New Jersey
Salem
3,658
7
New Jersey
Somerset
11,552
9
New Jersey
Sussex
5,709
8
New Jersey
Union
74,526
12
New Jersey
Warren
5,942
8
New Mexico
Bernalillo
382
2
New Mexico
Catron
109
1
New Mexico
Chaves
170
1
New Mexico
Cibola
122
1
New Mexico
Colfax
179
1
New Mexico
Curry
421
2
New Mexico
De Baca
103
1
New Mexico
Dona Ana
1,252
4
New Mexico
Eddy
204
1
New Mexico
Grant
149
1
New Mexico
Guadalupe
83
1
New Mexico
Harding *
187
1
New Mexico
Hidalgo
111
1
New Mexico
Lea
125
1
New Mexico
Lincoln
147
1
New Mexico
Los Alamos *
187
1
New Mexico
Luna
182
1
New Mexico
McKinley
60
1
New Mexico
Mora
247
1
New Mexico
Otero
193
1
New Mexico
Quay
144
1
New Mexico
Rio Arriba
262
2
New Mexico
Roosevelt
212
1
New Mexico
San Juan
259
2
New Mexico
San Miguel
200
1
New Mexico
Sandoval
157
1
New Mexico
Santa Fe
388
2
New Mexico
Sierra
140
1
New Mexico
Socorro
166
1
New Mexico
Taos
470
2
New Mexico
Torrance
154
1
New Mexico
Union
160
1
New Mexico
Valencia
534
3
New York
Albany
2,548
6
New York
Allegany
845
3
New York
Bronx *
1,366
4
New York
Broome
2,362
6
New York
Cattaraugus
1,034
4
New York
Cayuga
1,218
4
New York
Chautauqua
1,121
4
New York
Chemung
1,104
4
New York
Chenango
886
3
New York
Clinton
865
3
New York
Columbia
2,532
6
New York
Cortland
859
3
New York
Delaware
1,366
4
New York
Dutchess
5,033
8
New York
Erie
1,478
4
New York
Essex
1,148
4
New York
Franklin
777
3
New York
Fulton
1,298
4
New York
Genesee
1,116
4
New York
Greene
1,704
5
New York
Hamilton *
1,366
4
New York
Herkimer
937
3
New York
Jefferson
698
3
( printed page 65101)
New York
Kings *
1,366
4
New York
Lewis
656
3
New York
Livingston
1,169
4
New York
Madison
1,014
4
New York
Monroe
1,575
5
New York
Montgomery
1,194
4
New York
Nassau
24,317
10
New York
New York
6,000
8
New York
Niagara
1,353
4
New York
Oneida
945
3
New York
Onondaga
1,187
4
New York
Ontario
1,343
4
New York
Orange
3,471
7
New York
Orleans
993
3
New York
Oswego
1,820
5
New York
Otsego
1,346
4
New York
Putnam
7,612
8
New York
Queens
1,366
4
New York
Rensselaer
2,076
6
New York
Richmond
79,163
12
New York
Rockland
20,123
10
New York
Saratoga
2,254
6
New York
Schenectady
1,706
5
New York
Schoharie
1,374
4
New York
Schuyler
1,244
4
New York
Seneca
1,204
4
New York
St. Lawrence
597
3
New York
Steuben
882
3
New York
Suffolk
14,506
9
New York
Sullivan
2,238
6
New York
Tioga
1,108
4
New York
Tompkins
1,349
4
New York
Ulster
2,831
6
New York
Warren
2,509
6
New York
Washington
1,085
4
New York
Wayne
1,990
5
New York
Westchester
12,075
9
New York
Wyoming
1,073
4
New York
Yates
1,490
4
North Carolina
Alamance
3,094
7
North Carolina
Alexander
3,703
7
North Carolina
Alleghany
2,761
6
North Carolina
Anson
2,219
6
North Carolina
Ashe
3,330
7
North Carolina
Avery
3,490
7
North Carolina
Beaufort
1,538
5
North Carolina
Bertie
1,611
5
North Carolina
Bladen
2,363
6
North Carolina
Brunswick
2,546
6
North Carolina
Buncombe
3,589
7
North Carolina
Burke
3,224
7
North Carolina
Cabarrus
3,922
7
North Carolina
Caldwell
3,879
7
North Carolina
Camden
1,507
5
North Carolina
Carteret
1,680
5
North Carolina
Caswell
2,075
6
North Carolina
Catawba
2,882
6
North Carolina
Chatham
2,710
6
North Carolina
Cherokee
3,951
7
North Carolina
Chowan
1,906
5
North Carolina
Clay
4,134
7
North Carolina
Cleveland
2,442
6
North Carolina
Columbus
1,768
5
North Carolina
Craven
1,922
5
North Carolina
Cumberland
2,024
6
North Carolina
Currituck
2,408
6
North Carolina
Dare
1,014
4
North Carolina
Davidson
3,185
7
North Carolina
Davie
3,317
7
North Carolina
Duplin
2,367
6
North Carolina
Durham
4,333
7
( printed page 65102)
North Carolina
Edgecombe
1,659
5
North Carolina
Forsyth
3,647
7
North Carolina
Franklin
2,314
6
North Carolina
Gaston
3,374
7
North Carolina
Gates
1,471
4
North Carolina
Graham
2,985
6
North Carolina
Granville
2,161
6
North Carolina
Greene
2,396
6
North Carolina
Guilford
4,057
7
North Carolina
Halifax
1,448
4
North Carolina
Harnett
2,837
6
North Carolina
Haywood
3,717
7
North Carolina
Henderson
4,194
7
North Carolina
Hertford
1,547
5
North Carolina
Hoke
2,152
6
North Carolina
Hyde
1,455
4
North Carolina
Iredell
3,653
7
North Carolina
Jackson
4,878
7
North Carolina
Johnston
2,866
6
North Carolina
Jones
1,847
5
North Carolina
Lee
2,574
6
North Carolina
Lenoir
2,661
6
North Carolina
Lincoln
3,176
7
North Carolina
Macon
4,831
7
North Carolina
Madison
3,154
7
North Carolina
Martin
1,702
5
North Carolina
McDowell
2,684
6
North Carolina
Mecklenburg
7,693
8
North Carolina
Mitchell
3,465
7
North Carolina
Montgomery
2,670
6
North Carolina
Moore
2,422
6
North Carolina
Nash
2,002
6
North Carolina
New Hanover
7,981
8
North Carolina
Northampton
1,609
5
North Carolina
Onslow
2,359
6
North Carolina
Orange
3,899
7
North Carolina
Pamlico
1,565
5
North Carolina
Pasquotank
1,552
5
North Carolina
Pender
2,494
6
North Carolina
Perquimans
1,828
5
North Carolina
Person
1,970
5
North Carolina
Pitt
1,911
5
North Carolina
Polk
3,746
7
North Carolina
Randolph
3,051
7
North Carolina
Richmond
1,986
5
North Carolina
Robeson
1,595
5
North Carolina
Rockingham
2,132
6
North Carolina
Rowan
2,876
6
North Carolina
Rutherford
2,428
6
North Carolina
Sampson
2,467
6
North Carolina
Scotland
1,775
5
North Carolina
Stanly
2,920
6
North Carolina
Stokes
2,325
6
North Carolina
Surry
2,917
6
North Carolina
Swain
3,569
7
North Carolina
Transylvania
5,134
8
North Carolina
Tyrrell
1,447
4
North Carolina
Union
2,950
6
North Carolina
Vance
1,714
5
North Carolina
Wake
5,110
8
North Carolina
Warren
1,717
5
North Carolina
Washington
1,563
5
North Carolina
Watauga
3,221
7
North Carolina
Wayne
2,530
6
North Carolina
Wilkes
2,398
6
North Carolina
Wilson
1,977
5
North Carolina
Yadkin
2,606
6
North Carolina
Yancey
3,702
7
North Dakota
Adams
200
1
North Dakota
Barnes
358
2
North Dakota
Benson
284
2
( printed page 65103)
North Dakota
Billings
200
1
North Dakota
Bottineau
327
2
North Dakota
Bowman
199
1
North Dakota
Burke
236
1
North Dakota
Burleigh
271
2
North Dakota
Cass
701
3
North Dakota
Cavalier
434
2
North Dakota
Dickey
402
2
North Dakota
Divide
228
1
North Dakota
Dunn
202
1
North Dakota
Eddy
252
2
North Dakota
Emmons
224
1
North Dakota
Foster
319
2
North Dakota
Golden Valley
197
1
North Dakota
Grand Forks
634
3
North Dakota
Grant
247
1
North Dakota
Griggs
283
2
North Dakota
Hettinger
269
2
North Dakota
Kidder
225
1
North Dakota
LaMoure
446
2
North Dakota
Logan
196
1
North Dakota
McHenry
263
2
North Dakota
McIntosh
230
1
North Dakota
McKenzie
243
1
North Dakota
McLean
342
2
North Dakota
Mercer
214
1
North Dakota
Morton
242
1
North Dakota
Mountrail
245
1
North Dakota
Nelson
276
2
North Dakota
Oliver
194
1
North Dakota
Pembina
612
3
North Dakota
Pierce
277
2
North Dakota
Ramsey
294
2
North Dakota
Ransom
416
2
North Dakota
Renville
429
2
North Dakota
Richland
756
3
North Dakota
Rolette
263
2
North Dakota
Sargent
434
2
North Dakota
Sheridan
225
1
North Dakota
Sioux
161
1
North Dakota
Slope
195
1
North Dakota
Stark
259
2
North Dakota
Steele
462
2
North Dakota
Stutsman
326
2
North Dakota
Towner
287
2
North Dakota
Traill
674
3
North Dakota
Walsh
575
3
North Dakota
Ward
335
2
North Dakota
Wells
300
2
North Dakota
Williams
258
2
Ohio
Adams
1,512
5
Ohio
Allen
2,425
6
Ohio
Ashland
2,312
6
Ohio
Ashtabula
1,919
5
Ohio
Athens
1,424
4
Ohio
Auglaize
2,346
6
Ohio
Belmont
1,315
4
Ohio
Brown
1,894
5
Ohio
Butler
3,289
7
Ohio
Carroll
1,673
5
Ohio
Champaign
2,274
6
Ohio
Clark
2,831
6
Ohio
Clermont
2,889
6
Ohio
Clinton
2,320
6
Ohio
Columbiana
2,317
6
Ohio
Coshocton
1,822
5
Ohio
Crawford
1,950
5
Ohio
Cuyahoga
17,394
9
Ohio
Darke
2,536
6
Ohio
Defiance
1,655
5
Ohio
Delaware
3,034
7
( printed page 65104)
Ohio
Erie
2,494
6
Ohio
Fairfield
2,659
6
Ohio
Fayette
1,938
5
Ohio
Franklin
3,747
7
Ohio
Fulton
2,123
6
Ohio
Gallia
1,439
4
Ohio
Geauga
4,966
7
Ohio
Greene
2,466
6
Ohio
Guernsey
1,532
5
Ohio
Hamilton
4,110
7
Ohio
Hancock
1,939
5
Ohio
Hardin
1,755
5
Ohio
Harrison
926
3
Ohio
Henry
2,018
6
Ohio
Highland
1,962
5
Ohio
Hocking
2,013
6
Ohio
Holmes
2,787
6
Ohio
Huron
2,217
6
Ohio
Jackson
1,094
4
Ohio
Jefferson
1,493
4
Ohio
Knox
2,302
6
Ohio
Lake
6,431
8
Ohio
Lawrence
1,428
4
Ohio
Licking
2,814
6
Ohio
Logan
1,718
5
Ohio
Lorain
2,531
6
Ohio
Lucas
2,692
6
Ohio
Madison
2,479
6
Ohio
Mahoning
2,488
6
Ohio
Marion
1,783
5
Ohio
Medina
3,881
7
Ohio
Meigs
1,385
4
Ohio
Mercer
2,606
6
Ohio
Miami
2,620
6
Ohio
Monroe
1,126
4
Ohio
Montgomery
3,101
7
Ohio
Morgan
1,174
4
Ohio
Morrow
1,971
5
Ohio
Muskingum
1,539
5
Ohio
Noble
1,289
4
Ohio
Ottawa
1,742
5
Ohio
Paulding
1,672
5
Ohio
Perry
1,809
5
Ohio
Pickaway
2,386
6
Ohio
Pike
1,322
4
Ohio
Portage
3,396
7
Ohio
Preble
2,008
6
Ohio
Putnam
1,909
5
Ohio
Richland
2,187
6
Ohio
Ross
1,652
5
Ohio
Sandusky
1,840
5
Ohio
Scioto
1,295
4
Ohio
Seneca
1,877
5
Ohio
Shelby
2,194
6
Ohio
Stark
3,231
7
Ohio
Summit
4,578
7
Ohio
Trumbull
2,414
6
Ohio
Tuscarawas
2,285
6
Ohio
Union
2,050
6
Ohio
Van Wert
2,079
6
Ohio
Vinton
1,651
5
Ohio
Warren
3,881
7
Ohio
Washington
1,576
5
Ohio
Wayne
3,568
7
Ohio
Williams
1,799
5
Ohio
Wood
2,211
6
Ohio
Wyandot
2,227
6
Oklahoma
Adair
943
3
Oklahoma
Alfalfa
565
3
Oklahoma
Atoka
502
3
Oklahoma
Beaver
292
2
( printed page 65105)
Oklahoma
Beckham
460
2
Oklahoma
Blaine
490
2
Oklahoma
Bryan
694
3
Oklahoma
Caddo
495
2
Oklahoma
Canadian
800
3
Oklahoma
Carter
610
3
Oklahoma
Cherokee
925
3
Oklahoma
Choctaw
486
2
Oklahoma
Cimarron
241
1
Oklahoma
Cleveland
1,490
4
Oklahoma
Coal
507
3
Oklahoma
Comanche
614
3
Oklahoma
Cotton
418
2
Oklahoma
Craig
616
3
Oklahoma
Creek
725
3
Oklahoma
Custer
463
2
Oklahoma
Delaware
1,206
4
Oklahoma
Dewey
417
2
Oklahoma
Ellis
262
2
Oklahoma
Garfield
547
3
Oklahoma
Garvin
658
3
Oklahoma
Grady
631
3
Oklahoma
Grant
466
2
Oklahoma
Greer
317
2
Oklahoma
Harmon
292
2
Oklahoma
Harper
264
2
Oklahoma
Haskell
704
3
Oklahoma
Hughes
485
2
Oklahoma
Jackson
418
2
Oklahoma
Jefferson
401
2
Oklahoma
Johnston
601
3
Oklahoma
Kay
590
3
Oklahoma
Kingfisher
603
3
Oklahoma
Kiowa
402
2
Oklahoma
Latimer
512
3
Oklahoma
Le Flore
976
3
Oklahoma
Lincoln
698
3
Oklahoma
Logan
780
3
Oklahoma
Love
635
3
Oklahoma
Major
446
2
Oklahoma
Marshall
539
3
Oklahoma
Mayes
994
3
Oklahoma
McClain
919
3
Oklahoma
McCurtain
763
3
Oklahoma
McIntosh
618
3
Oklahoma
Murray
554
3
Oklahoma
Muskogee
724
3
Oklahoma
Noble
574
3
Oklahoma
Nowata
609
3
Oklahoma
Okfuskee
617
3
Oklahoma
Oklahoma
1,542
5
Oklahoma
Okmulgee
725
3
Oklahoma
Osage
434
2
Oklahoma
Ottawa
1,014
4
Oklahoma
Pawnee
476
2
Oklahoma
Payne
804
3
Oklahoma
Pittsburg
605
3
Oklahoma
Pontotoc
646
3
Oklahoma
Pottawatomie
793
3
Oklahoma
Pushmataha
444
2
Oklahoma
Roger Mills
312
2
Oklahoma
Rogers
1,124
4
Oklahoma
Seminole
594
3
Oklahoma
Sequoyah
1,029
4
Oklahoma
Stephens
541
3
Oklahoma
Texas
415
2
Oklahoma
Tillman
438
2
Oklahoma
Tulsa
1,698
5
Oklahoma
Wagoner
1,075
4
Oklahoma
Washington
824
3
Oklahoma
Washita
472
2
( printed page 65106)
Oklahoma
Woods
389
2
Oklahoma
Woodward
364
2
Oregon
Baker
437
2
Oregon
Benton
3,083
7
Oregon
Clackamas
7,680
8
Oregon
Clatsop
2,221
6
Oregon
Columbia
3,050
7
Oregon
Coos
2,691
6
Oregon
Crook
425
2
Oregon
Curry
1,559
5
Oregon
Deschutes
4,138
7
Oregon
Douglas
1,648
5
Oregon
Gilliam
244
1
Oregon
Grant
245
1
Oregon
Harney
231
1
Oregon
Hood River
7,491
8
Oregon
Jackson
2,259
6
Oregon
Jefferson
449
2
Oregon
Josephine
3,322
7
Oregon
Klamath
810
3
Oregon
Lake
390
2
Oregon
Lane
3,658
7
Oregon
Lincoln
2,086
6
Oregon
Linn
2,279
6
Oregon
Malheur
430
2
Oregon
Marion
4,086
7
Oregon
Morrow
292
2
Oregon
Multnomah
8,701
8
Oregon
Polk
3,958
7
Oregon
Sherman
294
2
Oregon
Tillamook
4,207
7
Oregon
Umatilla
612
3
Oregon
Union
835
3
Oregon
Wallowa
491
2
Oregon
Wasco
315
2
Oregon
Washington
5,835
8
Oregon
Wheeler
219
1
Oregon
Yamhill
5,508
8
Pennsylvania
Adams
3,025
7
Pennsylvania
Allegheny
3,810
7
Pennsylvania
Armstrong
1,866
5
Pennsylvania
Beaver
2,381
6
Pennsylvania
Bedford
1,584
5
Pennsylvania
Berks
4,422
7
Pennsylvania
Blair
2,501
6
Pennsylvania
Bradford
1,432
4
Pennsylvania
Bucks
7,534
8
Pennsylvania
Butler
3,160
7
Pennsylvania
Cambria
2,150
6
Pennsylvania
Cameron
1,502
5
Pennsylvania
Carbon
3,549
7
Pennsylvania
Centre
2,720
6
Pennsylvania
Chester
8,286
8
Pennsylvania
Clarion
1,470
4
Pennsylvania
Clearfield
1,320
4
Pennsylvania
Clinton
2,243
6
Pennsylvania
Columbia
2,510
6
Pennsylvania
Crawford
1,390
4
Pennsylvania
Cumberland
3,061
7
Pennsylvania
Dauphin
4,233
7
Pennsylvania
Delaware
18,282
9
Pennsylvania
Elk
2,483
6
Pennsylvania
Erie
1,856
5
Pennsylvania
Fayette
1,475
4
Pennsylvania
Forest
1,606
5
Pennsylvania
Franklin
3,103
7
Pennsylvania
Fulton
1,854
5
Pennsylvania
Greene
947
3
Pennsylvania
Huntingdon
1,949
5
Pennsylvania
Indiana
1,503
5
Pennsylvania
Jefferson
1,485
4
( printed page 65107)
Pennsylvania
Juniata
2,447
6
Pennsylvania
Lackawanna
2,564
6
Pennsylvania
Lancaster
6,364
8
Pennsylvania
Lawrence
1,953
5
Pennsylvania
Lebanon
4,279
7
Pennsylvania
Lehigh
3,603
7
Pennsylvania
Luzerne
2,833
6
Pennsylvania
Lycoming
1,854
5
Pennsylvania
McKean
943
3
Pennsylvania
Mercer
1,656
5
Pennsylvania
Mifflin
2,551
6
Pennsylvania
Monroe
4,153
7
Pennsylvania
Montgomery
10,198
9
Pennsylvania
Montour
2,397
6
Pennsylvania
Northampton
3,890
7
Pennsylvania
Northumberland
2,479
6
Pennsylvania
Perry
2,562
6
Pennsylvania
Philadelphia
20,872
10
Pennsylvania
Pike
2,302
6
Pennsylvania
Potter
1,342
4
Pennsylvania
Schuylkill
2,706
6
Pennsylvania
Snyder
2,846
6
Pennsylvania
Somerset
1,516
5
Pennsylvania
Sullivan
1,502
5
Pennsylvania
Susquehanna
1,730
5
Pennsylvania
Tioga
1,862
5
Pennsylvania
Union
3,325
7
Pennsylvania
Venango
1,191
4
Pennsylvania
Warren
1,030
4
Pennsylvania
Washington
1,676
5
Pennsylvania
Wayne
1,689
5
Pennsylvania
Westmoreland
2,251
6
Pennsylvania
Wyoming
1,821
5
Pennsylvania
York
3,844
7
Puerto Rico
All Areas
4,693
7
Rhode Island
Bristol
17,945
9
Rhode Island
Kent
5,242
8
Rhode Island
Newport
10,690
9
Rhode Island
Providence
7,186
8
Rhode Island
Washington
6,194
8
South Carolina
Abbeville
1,623
5
South Carolina
Aiken
1,775
5
South Carolina
Allendale
1,002
4
South Carolina
Anderson
2,651
6
South Carolina
Bamberg
1,051
4
South Carolina
Barnwell
1,045
4
South Carolina
Beaufort
1,978
5
South Carolina
Berkeley
2,196
6
South Carolina
Calhoun
1,182
4
South Carolina
Charleston
3,974
7
South Carolina
Cherokee
1,624
5
South Carolina
Chester
1,598
5
South Carolina
Chesterfield
1,126
4
South Carolina
Clarendon
1,132
4
South Carolina
Colleton
1,400
4
South Carolina
Darlington
797
3
South Carolina
Dillon
1,113
4
South Carolina
Dorchester
1,588
5
South Carolina
Edgefield
1,626
5
South Carolina
Fairfield
1,194
4
South Carolina
Florence
1,256
4
South Carolina
Georgetown
1,698
5
South Carolina
Greenville
2,722
6
South Carolina
Greenwood
1,486
4
South Carolina
Hampton
1,198
4
South Carolina
Horry
1,737
5
South Carolina
Jasper
1,163
4
South Carolina
Kershaw
1,693
5
South Carolina
Lancaster
1,763
5
South Carolina
Laurens
1,789
5
South Carolina
Lee
1,105
4
( printed page 65108)
South Carolina
Lexington
2,224
6
South Carolina
Marion
1,202
4
South Carolina
Marlboro
963
3
South Carolina
McCormick
2,101
6
South Carolina
Newberry
1,642
5
South Carolina
Oconee
3,834
7
South Carolina
Orangeburg
1,097
4
South Carolina
Pickens
3,722
7
South Carolina
Richland
2,637
6
South Carolina
Saluda
1,613
5
South Carolina
Spartanburg
3,223
7
South Carolina
Sumter
1,566
5
South Carolina
Union
1,398
4
South Carolina
Williamsburg
1,324
4
South Carolina
York
3,254
7
South Dakota
Aurora
474
2
South Dakota
Beadle
430
2
South Dakota
Bennett
193
1
South Dakota
Bon Homme
630
3
South Dakota
Brookings
697
3
South Dakota
Brown
590
3
South Dakota
Brule
394
2
South Dakota
Buffalo
218
1
South Dakota
Butte
210
1
South Dakota
Campbell
251
2
South Dakota
Charles Mix
477
2
South Dakota
Clark
506
3
South Dakota
Clay
1,021
4
South Dakota
Codington
590
3
South Dakota
Corson
138
1
South Dakota
Custer
310
2
South Dakota
Davison
567
3
South Dakota
Day
481
2
South Dakota
Deuel
566
3
South Dakota
Dewey
170
1
South Dakota
Douglas
525
3
South Dakota
Edmunds
372
2
South Dakota
Fall River
203
1
South Dakota
Faulk
313
2
South Dakota
Grant
582
3
South Dakota
Gregory
317
2
South Dakota
Haakon
174
1
South Dakota
Hamlin
634
3
South Dakota
Hand
278
2
South Dakota
Hanson
616
3
South Dakota
Harding
119
1
South Dakota
Hughes
353
2
South Dakota
Hutchinson
640
3
South Dakota
Hyde
242
1
South Dakota
Jackson
160
1
South Dakota
Jerauld
321
2
South Dakota
Jones
214
1
South Dakota
Kingsbury
594
3
South Dakota
Lake
786
3
South Dakota
Lawrence
579
3
South Dakota
Lincoln
1,338
4
South Dakota
Lyman
275
2
South Dakota
Marshall
482
2
South Dakota
McCook
688
3
South Dakota
McPherson
277
2
South Dakota
Meade
214
1
South Dakota
Mellette
166
1
South Dakota
Miner
556
3
South Dakota
Minnehaha
1,169
4
South Dakota
Moody
964
3
South Dakota
Pennington
281
2
South Dakota
Perkins
151
1
South Dakota
Potter
354
2
South Dakota
Roberts
560
3
South Dakota
Sanborn
390
2
South Dakota
Shannon
134
1
( printed page 65109)
South Dakota
Spink
451
2
South Dakota
Stanley
166
1
South Dakota
Sully
386
2
South Dakota
Todd
166
1
South Dakota
Tripp
270
2
South Dakota
Turner
1,033
4
South Dakota
Union
1,538
5
South Dakota
Walworth
272
2
South Dakota
Yankton
839
3
South Dakota
Ziebach
138
1
Tennessee
Anderson
3,226
7
Tennessee
Bedford
1,995
5
Tennessee
Benton
1,264
4
Tennessee
Bledsoe
1,739
5
Tennessee
Blount
4,243
7
Tennessee
Bradley
3,043
7
Tennessee
Campbell
1,576
5
Tennessee
Cannon
2,214
6
Tennessee
Carroll
1,340
4
Tennessee
Carter
2,426
6
Tennessee
Cheatham
2,487
6
Tennessee
Chester
1,315
4
Tennessee
Claiborne
1,472
4
Tennessee
Clay
1,212
4
Tennessee
Cocke
2,247
6
Tennessee
Coffee
2,065
6
Tennessee
Crockett
1,638
5
Tennessee
Cumberland
2,056
6
Tennessee
Davidson
5,247
8
Tennessee
Decatur
1,061
4
Tennessee
DeKalb
2,035
6
Tennessee
Dickson
2,090
6
Tennessee
Dyer
1,517
5
Tennessee
Fayette
1,625
5
Tennessee
Fentress
1,802
5
Tennessee
Franklin
2,145
6
Tennessee
Gibson
1,275
4
Tennessee
Giles
1,674
5
Tennessee
Grainger
1,651
5
Tennessee
Greene
2,353
6
Tennessee
Grundy
1,709
5
Tennessee
Hamblen
3,082
7
Tennessee
Hamilton
2,459
6
Tennessee
Hancock
1,563
5
Tennessee
Hardeman
989
3
Tennessee
Hardin
1,181
4
Tennessee
Hawkins
2,173
6
Tennessee
Haywood
1,297
4
Tennessee
Henderson
1,115
4
Tennessee
Henry
1,229
4
Tennessee
Hickman
1,215
4
Tennessee
Houston
1,166
4
Tennessee
Humphreys
1,279
4
Tennessee
Jackson
1,385
4
Tennessee
Jefferson
3,082
7
Tennessee
Johnson
2,995
6
Tennessee
Knox
4,136
7
Tennessee
Lake
1,207
4
Tennessee
Lauderdale
1,136
4
Tennessee
Lawrence
1,446
4
Tennessee
Lewis
1,525
5
Tennessee
Lincoln
1,619
5
Tennessee
Loudon
3,150
7
Tennessee
Macon
2,118
6
Tennessee
Madison
2,024
6
Tennessee
Marion
1,607
5
Tennessee
Marshall
1,804
5
Tennessee
Maury
2,063
6
Tennessee
McMinn
2,251
6
Tennessee
McNairy
849
3
Tennessee
Meigs
2,250
6
( printed page 65110)
Tennessee
Monroe
2,341
6
Tennessee
Montgomery
1,930
5
Tennessee
Moore
1,673
5
Tennessee
Morgan
1,858
5
Tennessee
Obion
1,333
4
Tennessee
Overton
1,984
5
Tennessee
Perry
1,187
4
Tennessee
Pickett
1,891
5
Tennessee
Polk
3,309
7
Tennessee
Putnam
2,383
6
Tennessee
Rhea
2,164
6
Tennessee
Roane
2,854
6
Tennessee
Robertson
2,038
6
Tennessee
Rutherford
2,367
6
Tennessee
Scott
1,619
5
Tennessee
Sequatchie
1,810
5
Tennessee
Sevier
3,016
7
Tennessee
Shelby
3,057
7
Tennessee
Smith
1,668
5
Tennessee
Stewart
1,655
5
Tennessee
Sullivan
2,788
6
Tennessee
Sumner
2,637
6
Tennessee
Tipton
1,558
5
Tennessee
Trousdale
2,103
6
Tennessee
Unicoi
5,030
8
Tennessee
Union
2,150
6
Tennessee
Van Buren
1,586
5
Tennessee
Warren
1,958
5
Tennessee
Washington
3,245
7
Tennessee
Wayne
1,030
4
Tennessee
Weakley
1,219
4
Tennessee
White
2,006
6
Tennessee
Williamson
4,133
7
Tennessee
Wilson
2,646
6
Texas
Anderson
830
3
Texas
Andrews
131
1
Texas
Angelina
1,856
5
Texas
Aransas
806
3
Texas
Archer
423
2
Texas
Armstrong
299
2
Texas
Atascosa
760
3
Texas
Austin
1,741
5
Texas
Bailey
352
2
Texas
Bandera
1,390
4
Texas
Bastrop
1,487
4
Texas
Baylor
414
2
Texas
Bee
661
3
Texas
Bell
1,034
4
Texas
Bexar
1,600
5
Texas
Blanco
1,953
5
Texas
Borden
278
2
Texas
Bosque
1,182
4
Texas
Bowie
1,301
4
Texas
Brazoria
1,213
4
Texas
Brazos
1,370
4
Texas
Brewster
92
1
Texas
Briscoe
219
1
Texas
Brooks
461
2
Texas
Brown
718
3
Texas
Burleson
1,122
4
Texas
Burnet
1,452
4
Texas
Caldwell
1,341
4
Texas
Calhoun
694
3
Texas
Callahan
474
2
Texas
Cameron
1,239
4
Texas
Camp
1,512
5
Texas
Carson
355
2
Texas
Cass
1,003
4
Texas
Castro
532
3
Texas
Chambers
725
3
Texas
Cherokee
1,086
4
( printed page 65111)
Texas
Childress
258
2
Texas
Clay
509
3
Texas
Cochran
295
2
Texas
Coke
418
2
Texas
Coleman
490
2
Texas
Collin
2,027
6
Texas
Collingsworth
365
2
Texas
Colorado
1,210
4
Texas
Comal
1,682
5
Texas
Comanche
782
3
Texas
Concho
411
2
Texas
Cooke
1,130
4
Texas
Coryell
850
3
Texas
Cottle
187
1
Texas
Crane
90
1
Texas
Crockett
162
1
Texas
Crosby
373
2
Texas
Culberson
66
1
Texas
Dallam
481
2
Texas
Dallas
2,375
6
Texas
Dawson
425
2
Texas
Deaf Smith
352
2
Texas
Delta
754
3
Texas
Denton
2,318
6
Texas
DeWitt
959
3
Texas
Dickens
229
1
Texas
Dimmit
394
2
Texas
Donley
288
2
Texas
Duval
580
3
Texas
Eastland
583
3
Texas
Ector
113
1
Texas
Edwards
334
2
Texas
El Paso
1,750
5
Texas
Ellis
1,270
4
Texas
Erath
1,066
4
Texas
Falls
694
3
Texas
Fannin
920
3
Texas
Fayette
1,503
5
Texas
Fisher
342
2
Texas
Floyd
387
2
Texas
Foard
274
2
Texas
Fort Bend
1,541
5
Texas
Franklin
982
3
Texas
Freestone
720
3
Texas
Frio
626
3
Texas
Gaines
482
2
Texas
Galveston
1,261
4
Texas
Garza
213
1
Texas
Gillespie
1,595
5
Texas
Glasscock
282
2
Texas
Goliad
726
3
Texas
Gonzales
939
3
Texas
Gray
342
2
Texas
Grayson
1,537
5
Texas
Gregg
1,163
4
Texas
Grimes
1,438
4
Texas
Guadalupe
1,617
5
Texas
Hale
473
2
Texas
Hall
231
1
Texas
Hamilton
720
3
Texas
Hansford
295
2
Texas
Hardeman
279
2
Texas
Hardin
1,008
4
Texas
Harris
2,098
6
Texas
Harrison
959
3
Texas
Hartley
301
2
Texas
Haskell
338
2
Texas
Hays
2,302
6
Texas
Hemphill
213
1
Texas
Henderson
1,309
4
Texas
Hidalgo
1,612
5
( printed page 65112)
Texas
Hill
958
3
Texas
Hockley
390
2
Texas
Hood
1,857
5
Texas
Hopkins
1,124
4
Texas
Houston
864
3
Texas
Howard
355
2
Texas
Hudspeth
121
1
Texas
Hunt
1,268
4
Texas
Hutchinson
202
1
Texas
Irion
187
1
Texas
Jack
570
3
Texas
Jackson
871
3
Texas
Jasper
1,229
4
Texas
Jeff Davis
105
1
Texas
Jefferson
688
3
Texas
Jim Hogg
358
2
Texas
Jim Wells
500
2
Texas
Johnson
1,748
5
Texas
Jones
416
2
Texas
Karnes
654
3
Texas
Kaufman
1,245
4
Texas
Kendall
1,734
5
Texas
Kenedy
282
2
Texas
Kent
166
1
Texas
Kerr
907
3
Texas
Kimble
521
3
Texas
King
170
1
Texas
Kinney
318
2
Texas
Kleberg
478
2
Texas
Knox
238
1
Texas
La Salle
474
2
Texas
Lamar
704
3
Texas
Lamb
418
2
Texas
Lampasas
972
3
Texas
Lavaca
1,024
4
Texas
Lee
1,156
4
Texas
Leon
854
3
Texas
Liberty
1,205
4
Texas
Limestone
594
3
Texas
Lipscomb
294
2
Texas
Live Oak
568
3
Texas
Llano
1,141
4
Texas
Loving
64
1
Texas
Lubbock
649
3
Texas
Lynn
377
2
Texas
Madison
910
3
Texas
Marion
781
3
Texas
Martin
347
2
Texas
Mason
777
3
Texas
Matagorda
811
3
Texas
Maverick
234
1
Texas
McCulloch
579
3
Texas
McLennan
998
3
Texas
McMullen
566
3
Texas
Medina
902
3
Texas
Menard
395
2
Texas
Midland
307
2
Texas
Milam
949
3
Texas
Mills
778
3
Texas
Mitchell
273
2
Texas
Montague
1,008
4
Texas
Montgomery
2,247
6
Texas
Moore
459
2
Texas
Morris
666
3
Texas
Motley
214
1
Texas
Nacogdoches
1,094
4
Texas
Navarro
694
3
Texas
Newton
766
3
Texas
Nolan
380
2
Texas
Nueces
757
3
Texas
Ochiltree
346
2
( printed page 65113)
Texas
Oldham
170
1
Texas
Orange
1,363
4
Texas
Palo Pinto
640
3
Texas
Panola
806
3
Texas
Parker
1,830
5
Texas
Parmer
479
2
Texas
Pecos
111
1
Texas
Polk
1,087
4
Texas
Potter
297
2
Texas
Presidio
259
2
Texas
Rains
1,252
4
Texas
Randall
444
2
Texas
Reagan
163
1
Texas
Real
492
2
Texas
Red River
703
3
Texas
Reeves
111
1
Texas
Refugio
344
2
Texas
Roberts
174
1
Texas
Robertson
851
3
Texas
Rockwall
2,503
6
Texas
Runnels
478
2
Texas
Rusk
1,030
4
Texas
Sabine
1,525
5
Texas
San Augustine
1,061
4
Texas
San Jacinto
1,694
5
Texas
San Patricio
710
3
Texas
San Saba
614
3
Texas
Schleicher
271
2
Texas
Scurry
304
2
Texas
Shackelford
350
2
Texas
Shelby
1,484
4
Texas
Sherman
448
2
Texas
Smith
1,253
4
Texas
Somervell
1,385
4
Texas
Starr
530
3
Texas
Stephens
384
2
Texas
Sterling
160
1
Texas
Stonewall
234
1
Texas
Sutton
290
2
Texas
Swisher
368
2
Texas
Tarrant
2,409
6
Texas
Taylor
529
3
Texas
Terrell
86
1
Texas
Terry
488
2
Texas
Throckmorton
291
2
Texas
Titus
1,269
4
Texas
Tom Green
502
3
Texas
Travis
1,441
4
Texas
Trinity
998
3
Texas
Tyler
1,561
5
Texas
Upshur
1,245
4
Texas
Upton
110
1
Texas
Uvalde
516
3
Texas
Val Verde
169
1
Texas
Van Zandt
1,292
4
Texas
Victoria
718
3
Texas
Walker
1,962
5
Texas
Waller
2,244
6
Texas
Ward
110
1
Texas
Washington
1,967
5
Texas
Webb
357
2
Texas
Wharton
931
3
Texas
Wheeler
312
2
Texas
Wichita
522
3
Texas
Wilbarger
274
2
Texas
Willacy
853
3
Texas
Williamson
1,876
5
Texas
Wilson
1,052
4
Texas
Winkler
82
1
Texas
Wise
1,508
5
Texas
Wood
1,198
4
( printed page 65114)
Texas
Yoakum
463
2
Texas
Young
455
2
Texas
Zapata
532
3
Texas
Zavala
522
3
Utah
Beaver
1,595
5
Utah
Box Elder
422
2
Utah
Cache
1,502
5
Utah
Carbon
351
2
Utah
Daggett
560
3
Utah
Davis
3,042
7
Utah
Duchesne
295
2
Utah
Emery
689
3
Utah
Garfield
1,073
4
Utah
Grand
846
3
Utah
Iron
646
3
Utah
Juab
455
2
Utah
Kane
465
2
Utah
Millard
651
3
Utah
Morgan
848
3
Utah
Piute
1,065
4
Utah
Rich
252
2
Utah
Salt Lake
3,794
7
Utah
San Juan
217
1
Utah
Sanpete
976
3
Utah
Sevier
1,064
4
Utah
Summit
1,000
3
Utah
Tooele
382
2
Utah
Uintah
186
1
Utah
Utah
2,228
6
Utah
Wasatch
2,349
6
Utah
Washington
1,327
4
Utah
Wayne
1,342
4
Utah
Weber
4,618
7
Vermont
Addison
1,436
4
Vermont
Bennington
1,374
4
Vermont
Caledonia
1,610
5
Vermont
Chittenden
1,973
5
Vermont
Essex
1,134
4
Vermont
Franklin
1,217
4
Vermont
Grand Isle
2,546
6
Vermont
Lamoille
1,636
5
Vermont
Orange
1,470
4
Vermont
Orleans
1,229
4
Vermont
Rutland
2,106
6
Vermont
Washington
1,907
5
Vermont
Windham
1,954
5
Vermont
Windsor
2,835
6
Virginia
Accomack
1,570
5
Virginia
Albemarle
3,557
7
Virginia
Alleghany
1,758
5
Virginia
Amelia
1,796
5
Virginia
Amherst
1,922
5
Virginia
Appomattox
1,226
4
Virginia
Arlington
2,140
6
Virginia
Augusta
2,367
6
Virginia
Bath
1,692
5
Virginia
Bedford
2,336
6
Virginia
Bland
1,162
4
Virginia
Botetourt
2,186
6
Virginia
Brunswick
1,097
4
Virginia
Buchanan
2,140
6
Virginia
Buckingham
1,524
5
Virginia
Campbell
1,499
4
Virginia
Caroline
1,829
5
Virginia
Carroll
2,070
6
Virginia
Charles City
2,151
6
Virginia
Charlotte
1,058
4
Virginia
Chesapeake City
2,800
6
Virginia
Chesterfield
4,206
7
Virginia
Clarke
3,825
7
Virginia
Craig
1,522
5
( printed page 65115)
Virginia
Culpeper
3,330
7
Virginia
Cumberland
1,774
5
Virginia
Dickenson
1,245
4
Virginia
Dinwiddie
1,308
4
Virginia
Essex
1,529
5
Virginia
Fairfax
6,689
8
Virginia
Fauquier
4,800
7
Virginia
Floyd
1,690
5
Virginia
Fluvanna
1,859
5
Virginia
Franklin
1,746
5
Virginia
Frederick
2,941
6
Virginia
Giles
1,670
5
Virginia
Gloucester
2,637
6
Virginia
Goochland
2,401
6
Virginia
Grayson
2,094
6
Virginia
Greene
3,100
7
Virginia
Greensville
1,119
4
Virginia
Halifax
1,270
4
Virginia
Hanover
3,050
7
Virginia
Henrico
3,217
7
Virginia
Henry
1,266
4
Virginia
Highland
1,838
5
Virginia
Isle of Wight
1,510
5
Virginia
James City
4,134
7
Virginia
King and Queen
1,586
5
Virginia
King George
2,294
6
Virginia
King William
1,614
5
Virginia
Lancaster
1,994
5
Virginia
Lee
1,381
4
Virginia
Loudoun
8,646
8
Virginia
Louisa
1,898
5
Virginia
Lunenburg
1,066
4
Virginia
Madison
2,478
6
Virginia
Mathews
2,153
6
Virginia
Mecklenburg
1,266
4
Virginia
Middlesex
2,181
6
Virginia
Montgomery
2,505
6
Virginia
Nelson
1,682
5
Virginia
New Kent
2,262
6
Virginia
Northampton
1,915
5
Virginia
Northumberland
1,538
5
Virginia
Nottoway
1,688
5
Virginia
Orange
2,510
6
Virginia
Page
3,132
7
Virginia
Patrick
1,316
4
Virginia
Pittsylvania
1,266
4
Virginia
Powhatan
2,422
6
Virginia
Prince Edward
1,374
4
Virginia
Prince George
1,571
5
Virginia
Prince William
5,283
8
Virginia
Pulaski
1,795
5
Virginia
Rappahannock
2,952
6
Virginia
Richmond
1,390
4
Virginia
Roanoke
2,669
6
Virginia
Rockbridge
2,299
6
Virginia
Rockingham
3,234
7
Virginia
Russell
1,282
4
Virginia
Scott
1,250
4
Virginia
Shenandoah
2,624
6
Virginia
Smyth
1,252
4
Virginia
Southampton
1,575
5
Virginia
Spotsylvania
3,430
7
Virginia
Stafford
3,904
7
Virginia
Suffolk
1,871
5
Virginia
Surry
1,524
5
Virginia
Sussex
1,243
4
Virginia
Tazewell
1,249
4
Virginia
Virginia Beach City
2,916
6
Virginia
Warren
3,062
7
Virginia
Washington
1,942
5
Virginia
Westmoreland
1,613
5
( printed page 65116)
Virginia
Wise
1,893
5
Virginia
Wythe
1,726
5
Virginia
York
39,100
11
Washington
Adams
596
3
Washington
Asotin
408
2
Washington
Benton
1,361
4
Washington
Chelan
5,250
8
Washington
Clallam
8,840
8
Washington
Clark
8,009
8
Washington
Columbia
566
3
Washington
Cowlitz
4,094
7
Washington
Douglas
644
3
Washington
Ferry
314
2
Washington
Franklin
1,158
4
Washington
Garfield
423
2
Washington
Grant
1,538
5
Washington
Grays Harbor
1,854
5
Washington
Island
7,574
8
Washington
Jefferson
4,353
7
Washington
King
17,070
9
Washington
Kitsap
10,295
9
Washington
Kittitas
2,162
6
Washington
Klickitat
726
3
Washington
Lewis
2,418
6
Washington
Lincoln
485
2
Washington
Mason
3,966
7
Washington
Okanogan
674
3
Washington
Pacific
1,661
5
Washington
Pend Oreille
1,467
4
Washington
Pierce
7,724
8
Washington
San Juan
5,046
8
Washington
Skagit
4,090
7
Washington
Skamania
3,653
7
Washington
Snohomish
7,723
8
Washington
Spokane
1,691
5
Washington
Stevens
936
3
Washington
Thurston
6,766
8
Washington
Wahkiakum
2,152
6
Washington
Walla Walla
1,064
4
Washington
Whatcom
4,767
7
Washington
Whitman
687
3
Washington
Yakima
1,017
4
West Virginia
Barbour
818
3
West Virginia
Berkeley
2,578
6
West Virginia
Boone
866
3
West Virginia
Braxton
677
3
West Virginia
Brooke
965
3
West Virginia
Cabell
1,056
4
West Virginia
Calhoun
582
3
West Virginia
Clay
883
3
West Virginia
Doddridge
664
3
West Virginia
Fayette
1,054
4
West Virginia
Gilmer
634
3
West Virginia
Grant
1,310
4
West Virginia
Greenbrier
1,192
4
West Virginia
Hampshire
1,299
4
West Virginia
Hancock
1,898
5
West Virginia
Hardy
1,379
4
West Virginia
Harrison
998
3
West Virginia
Jackson
1,011
4
West Virginia
Jefferson
2,370
6
West Virginia
Kanawha
1,129
4
West Virginia
Lewis
855
3
West Virginia
Lincoln
878
3
West Virginia
Logan
1,533
5
West Virginia
Marion
1,170
4
West Virginia
Marshall
760
3
West Virginia
Mason
1,021
4
West Virginia
McDowell
721
3
West Virginia
Mercer
1,131
4
West Virginia
Mineral
1,042
4
( printed page 65117)
West Virginia
Mingo
662
3
West Virginia
Monongalia
1,101
4
West Virginia
Monroe
1,086
4
West Virginia
Morgan
1,859
5
West Virginia
Nicholas
1,157
4
West Virginia
Ohio
978
3
West Virginia
Pendleton
934
3
West Virginia
Pleasants
846
3
West Virginia
Pocahontas
895
3
West Virginia
Preston
1,132
4
West Virginia
Putnam
1,411
4
West Virginia
Raleigh
1,097
4
West Virginia
Randolph
826
3
West Virginia
Ritchie
725
3
West Virginia
Roane
677
3
West Virginia
Summers
950
3
West Virginia
Taylor
1,094
4
West Virginia
Tucker
791
3
West Virginia
Tyler
744
3
West Virginia
Upshur
838
3
West Virginia
Wayne
838
3
West Virginia
Webster
879
3
West Virginia
Wetzel
646
3
West Virginia
Wirt
931
3
West Virginia
Wood
1,008
4
West Virginia
Wyoming
955
3
Wisconsin
Adams
1,704
5
Wisconsin
Ashland
903
3
Wisconsin
Barron
1,303
4
Wisconsin
Bayfield
849
3
Wisconsin
Brown
2,354
6
Wisconsin
Buffalo
1,201
4
Wisconsin
Burnett
1,478
4
Wisconsin
Calumet
2,199
6
Wisconsin
Chippewa
1,222
4
Wisconsin
Clark
1,194
4
Wisconsin
Columbia
2,020
6
Wisconsin
Crawford
1,390
4
Wisconsin
Dane
2,611
6
Wisconsin
Dodge
1,968
5
Wisconsin
Door
1,706
5
Wisconsin
Douglas
1,001
3
Wisconsin
Dunn
1,470
4
Wisconsin
Eau Claire
1,426
4
Wisconsin
Florence
1,012
4
Wisconsin
Fond du Lac
1,881
5
Wisconsin
Forest
1,136
4
Wisconsin
Grant
1,540
5
Wisconsin
Green
1,817
5
Wisconsin
Green Lake
1,585
5
Wisconsin
Iowa
1,794
5
Wisconsin
Iron
870
3
Wisconsin
Jackson
1,282
4
Wisconsin
Jefferson
2,470
6
Wisconsin
Juneau
1,496
4
Wisconsin
Kenosha
3,610
7
Wisconsin
Kewaunee
2,018
6
Wisconsin
La Crosse
1,550
5
Wisconsin
Lafayette
1,690
5
Wisconsin
Langlade
1,374
4
Wisconsin
Lincoln
1,253
4
Wisconsin
Manitowoc
2,246
6
Wisconsin
Marathon
1,477
4
Wisconsin
Marinette
1,364
4
Wisconsin
Marquette
1,711
5
Wisconsin
Menominee
572
3
Wisconsin
Milwaukee
5,134
8
Wisconsin
Monroe
1,528
5
Wisconsin
Oconto
1,609
5
Wisconsin
Oneida
1,654
5
Wisconsin
Outagamie
2,533
6
( printed page 65118)
Wisconsin
Ozaukee
3,234
7
Wisconsin
Pepin
1,478
4
Wisconsin
Pierce
1,856
5
Wisconsin
Polk
1,720
5
Wisconsin
Portage
2,408
6
Wisconsin
Price
1,134
4
Wisconsin
Racine
3,420
7
Wisconsin
Richland
1,746
5
Wisconsin
Rock
2,762
6
Wisconsin
Rusk
1,534
5
Wisconsin
Sauk
2,170
6
Wisconsin
Sawyer
1,589
5
Wisconsin
Shawano
2,010
6
Wisconsin
Sheboygan
2,362
6
Wisconsin
St. Croix
2,583
6
Wisconsin
Taylor
1,072
4
Wisconsin
Trempealeau
1,435
4
Wisconsin
Vernon
1,414
4
Wisconsin
Vilas
2,525
6
Wisconsin
Walworth
3,127
7
Wisconsin
Washburn
1,393
4
Wisconsin
Washington
3,241
7
Wisconsin
Waukesha
3,788
7
Wisconsin
Waupaca
1,721
5
Wisconsin
Waushara
2,071
6
Wisconsin
Winnebago
2,015
6
Wisconsin
Wood
1,460
4
Wyoming
Albany
182
1
Wyoming
Big Horn
574
3
Wyoming
Campbell
142
1
Wyoming
Carbon
171
1
Wyoming
Converse
123
1
Wyoming
Crook
288
2
Wyoming
Fremont
249
1
Wyoming
Goshen
330
2
Wyoming
Hot Springs
130
1
Wyoming
Johnson
216
1
Wyoming
Laramie
244
1
Wyoming
Lincoln
725
3
Wyoming
Natrona
150
1
Wyoming
Niobrara
210
1
Wyoming
Park
541
3
Wyoming
Platte
268
2
Wyoming
Sheridan
365
2
Wyoming
Sublette
586
3
Wyoming
Sweetwater
78
1
Wyoming
Teton
2,446
6
Wyoming
Uinta
298
2
Wyoming
Washakie
311
2
Wyoming
Weston
174
1
* State-average Land and Building value used where no county-specific value is available.