80_FR_16499 80 FR 16440 - Traylor/Skanska/Jay Dee Joint Venture: Grant of a Permanent Variance

80 FR 16440 - Traylor/Skanska/Jay Dee Joint Venture: Grant of a Permanent Variance

DEPARTMENT OF LABOR
Occupational Safety and Health Administration

Federal Register Volume 80, Issue 59 (March 27, 2015)

Page Range16440-16449
FR Document2015-06975

In this notice, OSHA grants a permanent variance to Traylor/ Skanska/Jay Dee Joint Venture from the provisions of OSHA standards that regulate work in compressed air environments at 29 CFR 1926.803.

Federal Register, Volume 80 Issue 59 (Friday, March 27, 2015)
[Federal Register Volume 80, Number 59 (Friday, March 27, 2015)]
[Notices]
[Pages 16440-16449]
From the Federal Register Online  [www.thefederalregister.org]
[FR Doc No: 2015-06975]


=======================================================================
-----------------------------------------------------------------------

DEPARTMENT OF LABOR

Occupational Safety and Health Administration

[Docket No. OSHA-2012-0035]


Traylor/Skanska/Jay Dee Joint Venture: Grant of a Permanent 
Variance

AGENCY: Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), Labor.

ACTION: Notice.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: In this notice, OSHA grants a permanent variance to Traylor/
Skanska/Jay Dee Joint Venture from the provisions of OSHA standards 
that regulate work in compressed air environments at 29 CFR 1926.803.

DATES: The permanent variance specified by this notice becomes 
effective on March 27, 2015 and shall remain in effect until January 
31, 2016.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Information regarding this notice is 
available from the following sources:
    Press inquiries: Contact Mr. Frank Meilinger, Director, OSHA Office 
of Communications, U.S. Department of Labor, 200 Constitution Avenue 
NW., Room N-3647, Washington, DC 20210; telephone: (202) 693-1999; 
email: [email protected].
    General and technical information: Contact Mr. Kevin Robinson, 
Acting Director, Office of Technical Programs and Coordination 
Activities, Directorate of Technical Support and Emergency Management, 
Occupational Safety and Health Administration, U.S. Department of 
Labor, 200 Constitution Avenue NW., Room N-3655, Washington, DC 20210; 
phone: (202) 693-2110 or email: [email protected].

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: 
    Copies of this Federal Register notice. Electronic copies of this 
Federal Register notice are available at http://www.regulations.gov. 
This Federal Register notice, as well as news releases and other 
relevant information, also are available at OSHA's Web page at http://www.osha.gov.

I. Notice of Application

    On April 26, 2012, Traylor Bros., Inc., 835 N. Congress Ave., 
Evansville, IN 47715, and Traylor/Skanska/Jay Dee Joint Venture, Blue 
Plains Tunnel, 5000 Overlook Avenue SW., Washington, DC 20032, 
submitted under Section 6(d) of the Occupational Safety and Health Act 
of 1970 (``OSH Act''; 29 U.S.C. 655) and 29 CFR 1905.11 (``Variances 
and other relief under section 6(d)'') an application for a permanent 
variance from several provisions of the OSHA standard that regulates 
work in compressed air at 29 CFR 1926.803. OSHA is addressing this 
request as two separate applications: (1) Traylor Bros., Inc. 
(``Traylor'') request for a permanent variance for future tunneling 
projects; and (2) Traylor/Skanska/Jay Dee Joint Venture, Blue Plains 
Tunnel (``Traylor JV'' or ``the applicant''). This notice only 
addresses the Traylor JV application for an interim order and permanent 
variance for the Blue Plains Tunnel project.\1\ This notice does not 
address the Traylor application for a permanent variance for future 
projects. That request will be addressed separately.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \1\ See Section III discussion of condition A Scope.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Traylor JV also requested an interim order pending OSHA's decision 
on the application for a variance (Ex. OSHA-2012-0035-0008). 
Specifically, this notice addresses the application submitted by 
Traylor JV for the Blue Plains Tunnel project in which the applicant 
seeks a permanent variance and interim order from the provisions of the 
standard that: (1) Prohibit compressed-air worker exposure to pressures 
exceeding 50 pounds per square inch (p.s.i.) except in an emergency (29 
CFR 1926.803(e)(5)); \2\ (2) require the use of the decompression 
values specified in decompression tables in Appendix A of the 
compressed-air standard for construction (29 CFR 1926.803(f)(1)); and 
(3) require the use of automated operational controls and a special 
decompression chamber (29 CFR 1926.803(g)(1)(iii) and .803(g)(1)(xvii), 
respectively).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \2\ The decompression tables in Appendix A of subpart S express 
the maximum working pressures as pounds per square inch gauge 
(p.s.i.g.), with a maximum working pressure of 50 p.s.i.g. 
Therefore, throughout this notice, OSHA expresses the 50 p.s.i. 
value specified by Sec.  1926.803(e)(5) as 50 p.s.i.g., consistent 
with the terminology in Appendix A, Table 1 of subpart S.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    The applicant is a contractor that works on complex tunnel projects 
using recently developed equipment and procedures for soft-ground 
tunneling. The applicant's workers engage in the construction of 
tunnels using advanced shielded mechanical excavation

[[Page 16441]]

techniques in conjunction with an earth pressure balanced tunnel boring 
machine (EPBTBM).
    According to its application, Traylor is currently the managing 
partner of Traylor/Skanska/Jay Dee Joint Venture (``Traylor JV''), the 
general contractor for the DC Water and Sewer Authority's project to 
construct the Blue Plains Tunnel. Traylor JV asserts that generally, it 
bores tunnels (i.e., Blue Plains Tunnel) below the water table through 
soft soils consisting of clay, silt, and sand. Traylor JV employs 
specially trained personnel for the construction of the tunnel, and 
states that this construction will use shielded mechanical-excavation 
techniques. Traylor JV asserts that its workers perform hyperbaric 
interventions at pressures greater than 50 p.s.i.g. in the excavation 
chamber of the EPBTBM; these interventions consist of conducting 
inspections and maintenance work on the cutter-head structure and 
cutting tools of the EPBTBM.
    Traylor JV asserts that innovations in tunnel excavation, 
specifically with EPBTBMs, have, in most cases, eliminated the need to 
pressurize the entire tunnel. This technology negates the requirement 
that all members of a tunnel-excavation crew work in compressed air 
while excavating the tunnel. These advances in technology modified 
substantially the methods used by the construction industry to excavate 
subaqueous tunnels compared to the caisson work regulated by the 
current OSHA compressed-air standard for construction at 29 CFR 
1926.803. Such advances reduce the number of workers exposed, and the 
total duration of exposure, to hyperbaric pressure during tunnel 
construction.
    Using shielded mechanical-excavation techniques, in conjunction 
with precast concrete tunnel liners and backfill grout, EPBTBMs provide 
methods to achieve the face pressures required to maintain a stabilized 
tunnel face through various geologies, and isolate that pressure to the 
forward section (the working chamber) of the EPBTBM. Interventions in 
the working chamber (the pressurized portion of the EPBTBM) take place 
only after halting tunnel excavation and preparing the machine and crew 
for an intervention. Interventions occur to inspect or maintain the 
mechanical-excavation components located in the working chamber. 
Maintenance conducted in the working chamber includes changing 
replaceable cutting tools and disposable wear bars, and, in rare cases, 
repairing structural damage to the cutter head.
    In addition to innovations in tunnel-excavation methods, Traylor JV 
asserts that innovations in hyperbaric medicine and technology improve 
the safety of decompression from hyperbaric exposures. According to 
Traylor JV, the use of decompression protocols incorporating oxygen is 
at least as effective for tunnel workers as compliance with the 
decompression tables specified by the existing OSHA standard (29 CFR 
part 1926, subpart S, Appendix A decompression tables). These 
hyperbaric exposures are possible due to advances in technology, a 
better understanding of hyperbaric medicine, and the development of a 
project-specific Hyperbaric Operations Manual (HOM) that requires 
specialized medical support and hyperbaric supervision to provide 
assistance to a team of specially trained man-lock attendants and 
hyperbaric or compressed-air workers.
    OSHA initiated a technical review of the Traylor JV's variance 
application and developed a set of follow-up questions that it sent to 
Traylor JV on September 17, 2012 (Ex. OSHA-2012-0035-0003). On October 
26, 2012, Traylor JV submitted its response and a request for an 
interim order for the Blue Plains Tunnel Project (Ex. OSHA-2012-0035-
0008). In its response to OSHA's follow-up questions, Traylor JV 
indicated that the maximum pressure to which it is likely to expose 
workers during interventions for the Blue Plains Tunnel project is 52 
p.s.i.g. and does not involve the use of trimix breathing gas (composed 
of a mixture of oxygen, nitrogen, and helium in varying concentrations 
used for breathing by compressed air workers for compression and 
decompression when working at pressures exceeding 73 p.s.i.g.). 
Therefore, to work effectively on this project, Traylor JV must perform 
hyperbaric interventions in compressed air at pressures higher than the 
maximum pressure specified by the existing OSHA standard, 29 CFR 
1926.803(e)(5), which states: ``No employee shall be subjected to 
pressure exceeding 50 p.s.i.g. except in emergency'' (see footnote 2).
    OSHA considered Traylor JV's application for a permanent variance 
and interim order for the Blue Plains Tunnel project. OSHA determined 
that Traylor JV proposed an alternative that will provide a workplace 
as safe and healthful as that provided by the standard. On July 11, 
2013, OSHA granted Traylor JV a project-specific interim order for the 
completion of the Blue Plains Tunnel (Ex. OSHA-2012-0035-0011) in order 
to permit the applicant to begin work while OSHA continued to consider 
its application for a permanent variance. Further, on December 11, 
2014, OSHA published a Federal Register notice announcing Traylor JV's 
application for a permanent variance and interim order, grant of an 
interim order, and request for comments (79 FR 73631) for the Blue 
Plains Tunnel project.

II. The Variance Application

A. Background

    As indicated earlier in this notice, Traylor JV asserts that the 
advances in tunnel excavation technology described in Section I of this 
notice modified significantly the equipment and methods used by 
contractors to construct subaqueous tunnels, thereby making several 
provisions of OSHA's compressed-air standard for construction at 29 CFR 
1926.803 inappropriate for this type of work. These advances reduce 
both the number of workers exposed, and the total duration of exposure, 
to the hyperbaric conditions associated with tunnel construction.
    Using shielded mechanical-excavation techniques, in conjunction 
with pre-cast concrete tunnel liners and backfill grout, EPBTBMs 
provide methods to achieve the face pressures required to maintain a 
stabilized tunnel face, through various geologies, while isolating that 
pressure to the forward section (working or excavation chamber) of the 
EPBTBM.
    Interventions involving the working chamber (the pressurized 
chamber at the head of the EPBTBM) take place only after the applicant 
halts tunnel excavation and prepares the machine and crew for an 
intervention. Interventions occur to inspect or maintain the 
mechanical-excavation components located in the forward portion of the 
working chamber. Maintenance conducted in the forward portion of the 
working chamber includes changing replaceable cutting tools, disposable 
wear bars, and, in rare cases, repairs to the cutter head due to 
structural damage.
    In addition to innovations in tunnel-excavation methods, research 
conducted after OSHA published its compressed-air standard for 
construction in 1971, resulted in advances in hyperbaric medicine. In 
this regard, the applicant asserts that the use of decompression 
protocols incorporating oxygen is more efficient, effective, and safer 
for tunnel workers than compliance with the existing OSHA standard (29 
CFR part 1926, subpart S, Appendix A decompression tables). According 
to the applicant, contractors routinely and safely expose employees 
performing

[[Page 16442]]

interventions in the working chamber of EPBTBMs to hyperbaric pressures 
up to 75 p.s.i.g., which is 50% higher than maximum pressure specified 
by the existing OSHA standard (see 29 CFR 1926.803(e)(5)).
    The applicant contends that the alternative safety measures 
included in its application provide its workers with a place of 
employment that is at least as safe and healthful as they would obtain 
under the existing provisions of OSHA's compressed-air standard for 
construction. The applicant certifies that it provided employee 
representatives of affected workers with a copy of the variance 
application.\3\ The applicant also certifies that it notified its 
workers of the variance application by posting, at prominent locations 
where it normally posts workplace notices, a summary of the application 
and information specifying where the workers can examine a copy of the 
application. In addition, the applicant informed its workers and their 
representatives of their rights to petition the Assistant Secretary of 
Labor for Occupational Safety and Health for a hearing on the variance 
application.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \3\ See the definition of ``Affected employee or worker'' in 
section VI. D.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

B. Variance From Paragraph (e)(5) of 29 CFR 1926.803, Prohibition of 
Exposure to Pressure Greater Than 50 p.s.i.g. (See Footnote 1)

    The applicant states that it may perform hyperbaric interventions 
at pressures greater than 50 p.s.i.g. in the working chamber of the 
EPBTBM; this pressure exceeds the pressure limit of 50 p.s.i.g. 
specified for nonemergency purposes by 29 CFR 1926.803(e)(5). The 
EPBTBM has twin man locks, with each man lock having two compartments. 
This configuration allows workers to access the man locks for 
compression and decompression, and medical personnel to access the man 
locks if required in an emergency.
    EPBTBMs are capable of maintaining pressure at the tunnel face, and 
stabilizing existing geological conditions, through the controlled use 
of propel cylinders, a mechanically driven cutter head, bulkheads 
within the shield, ground-treatment foam, and a screw conveyor that 
moves excavated material from the working chamber. As noted earlier, 
the forward-most portion of the EPBTBM is the working chamber, and this 
chamber is the only pressurized segment of the EPBTBM. Within the 
shield, the working chamber consists of two sections: The staging 
chamber and the forward working chamber. The staging chamber is the 
section of the working chamber between the man-lock door and the entry 
door to the forward working chamber. The forward working chamber is 
immediately behind the cutter head and tunnel face.
    The applicant will pressurize the working chamber to the level 
required to maintain a stable tunnel face. Pressure in the staging 
chamber ranges from atmospheric (no increased pressure) to a maximum 
pressure equal to the pressure in the working chamber. The applicant 
asserts that most of the hyperbaric interventions will be around 14.7 
p.s.i.g. However, the applicant maintains that they may have to perform 
interventions at pressures up to 52 p.s.i.g.
    During interventions, workers enter the working chamber through one 
of the twin man locks that open into the staging chamber. To reach the 
forward part of the working chamber, workers pass through a door in a 
bulkhead that separates the staging chamber from the forward working 
chamber. The maximum crew size allowed in the forward working chamber 
is three. At certain hyperbaric pressures (i.e., when decompression 
times are greater than work times), the twin man locks allow for crew 
rotation. During crew rotation, one crew can be compressing or 
decompressing while the second crew is working. Therefore, the working 
crew always has an unoccupied man lock at its disposal.
    The applicant developed a project-specific HOM for the Blue Plains 
Tunnel (Ex. OSHA-2012-0035-0007) that describes in detail the 
hyperbaric procedures and required medical examinations used during the 
tunnel-construction project. The HOM discusses standard operating 
procedures and emergency and contingency procedures. The procedures 
include using experienced and knowledgeable man-lock attendants who 
have the training and experience necessary to recognize and treat 
decompression illnesses and injuries. The attendants are under the 
direct supervision of the hyperbaric supervisor and attending 
physician. In addition, procedures include medical screening and review 
of prospective compressed-air workers (CAWs). The purpose of this 
screening procedure is to vet prospective CAWs with medical conditions 
(e.g., deep vein thrombosis, poor vascular circulation, and muscle 
cramping) that could be aggravated by sitting in a cramped space (e.g., 
a man lock) for extended periods or by exposure to elevated pressures 
and compressed gas mixtures. A transportable recompression chamber 
(shuttle) is available to extract workers from the hyperbaric working 
chamber for emergency evacuation and medical treatment; the shuttle 
attaches to the topside medical lock, which is a large recompression 
chamber. The applicant believes that the procedures included in the HOM 
provide safe work conditions when interventions are necessary, 
including interventions above 50 p.s.i.g.

C. Variance From Paragraph (f)(1) of 29 CFR 1926.803, Requirement To 
Use OSHA Decompression Tables

    OSHA's compressed-air standard for construction requires 
decompression in accordance with the decompression tables in Appendix A 
of 29 CFR part 1926, subpart S (see 29 CFR 1926.803(f)(1)). As an 
alternative to the OSHA decompression tables, the applicant proposes to 
use newer decompression schedules that supplement breathing air used 
during decompression with pure oxygen. The applicant asserts that these 
decompression protocols are safer for tunnel workers than the 
decompression protocols specified in Appendix A of 29 CFR part 1926, 
subpart S.
    Accordingly, the applicant proposes to use the 1992 French 
Decompression Tables to decompress CAWs after they exit the hyperbaric 
conditions in the working chamber. Depending on the maximum working 
pressure and exposure times, the 1992 French Decompression Tables 
provide for air decompression with or without oxygen. Traylor JV 
asserts that oxygen decompression has many benefits, including (1) 
keeping the partial pressure of nitrogen in the lungs as low as 
possible; (2) keeping external pressure as low as possible to reduce 
the formation of bubbles in the blood; (3) removing nitrogen from the 
lungs and arterial blood and increasing the rate of elimination of 
nitrogen; (4) improving the quality of breathing during decompression 
stops so that workers are less tired and to prevent bone necrosis; (5) 
reducing decompression time by about 33 percent as compared to air 
decompression; and (6) reducing inflammation. As described in Section V 
of this notice, OSHA's review of the use of oxygen in several major 
tunneling projects completed in the past indicates that it contributed 
significantly to the reduction of decompression illness (DCI) and other 
associated adverse effects observed and reported among CAWs.
    In addition, the HOM requires a physician certified in hyperbaric 
medicine to manage the medical condition of CAWs during hyperbaric 
exposures and decompression. A trained and experienced man-lock 
attendant also will be present during

[[Page 16443]]

hyperbaric exposures and decompression. This man-lock attendant will 
operate the hyperbaric system to ensure compliance with the specified 
decompression table. A hyperbaric supervisor (competent person), 
trained in hyperbaric operations, procedures, and safety, directly 
oversees all hyperbaric interventions, and ensures that staff follow 
the procedures delineated in the HOM or by the attending physician.
    The applicant asserts that at higher hyperbaric pressures, 
decompression times exceed 75 minutes. The HOM establishes protocols 
and procedures that provide the basis for alternate means of protection 
for CAWs under these conditions. Accordingly, based on these protocols 
and procedures, the applicant requests to use the 1992 French 
Decompression Tables for hyperbaric interventions up to 52 p.s.i.g. for 
completion of the Blue Plains Tunnel project. The applicant is 
committed to follow the decompression procedures described in the Blue 
Plains Tunnel project-specific HOM during these interventions.

D. Variance From Paragraph (g)(1)(iii) of 29 CFR 1926.803, 
Automatically Regulated Continuous Decompression

    According to the applicant, breathing air under hyperbaric 
conditions increases the amount of nitrogen gas dissolved in a CAW's 
tissues. The greater the hyperbaric pressure under these conditions, 
and the more time spent under the increased pressure, the greater the 
amount of nitrogen gas dissolved in the tissues. When the pressure 
decreases during decompression, tissues release the dissolved nitrogen 
gas into the blood system, which then carries the nitrogen gas to the 
lungs for elimination through exhalation. Releasing hyperbaric pressure 
too rapidly during decompression can increase the size of the bubbles 
formed by nitrogen gas in the blood system, resulting in DCI, commonly 
referred to as ``the bends.'' This description of the etiology of DCI 
is consistent with current scientific theory and research on the issue 
(see footnote 13 in this notice discussing a 1985 NIOSH report on DCI).
    The 1992 French Decompression Tables proposed for use by the 
applicant provide for stops during worker decompression (i.e., staged 
decompression) to control the release of nitrogen gas from tissues into 
the blood system. Studies show that staged decompression, in 
combination with other features of the 1992 French Decompression Tables 
such as the use of oxygen, result in a lower incidence of DCI than the 
OSHA decompression requirements of 29 CFR 1926.803, which specify the 
use of automatically regulated continuous decompression (see footnotes 
9 through 14 in this notice for references to these studies).\4\ In 
addition, the applicant asserts that staged decompression is at least 
as effective as an automatic controller in regulating the decompression 
process because:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \4\ In the study cited in footnote 11, starting at page 338, Dr. 
Eric Kindwall notes that the use of automatically regulated 
continuous decompression in the Washington State safety standards 
for compressed-air work (from which OSHA derived its decompression 
tables) was at the insistence of contractors and the union, and 
against the advice of the expert who calculated the decompression 
table and recommended using staged decompression. Dr. Kindwall then 
states, ``Continuous decompression is inefficient and wasteful. For 
example, if the last stage from 4 psig . . . to the surface took 1 
h, at least half the time is spent at pressures less than 2 psig . . 
., which provides less and less meaningful bubble suppression . . 
.'' In addition, the report referenced in footnote 5 under the 
section titled, ``Background on the Need for Interim Decompression 
Tables'' addresses the continuous-decompression protocol in the OSHA 
compressed-air standard for construction, noting that ``[a]side from 
the tables for saturation diving to deep depths, no other widely 
used or officially approved diving decompression tables use straight 
line, continuous decompressions at varying rates. Stage 
decompression is usually the rule, since it is simpler to control.''
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    1. A hyperbaric supervisor (a competent person experienced and 
trained in hyperbaric operations, procedures, and safety) directly 
supervises all hyperbaric interventions and ensures that the man-lock 
attendant, who is a competent person in the manual control of 
hyperbaric systems, follows the schedule specified in the decompression 
tables, including stops; and
    2. The use of the 1992 French Decompression Tables for staged 
decompression offers an equal or better level of management and control 
over the decompression process than an automatic controller and results 
in lower occurrences of DCI.
    Accordingly, the applicant is applying for a permanent variance 
from the OSHA standard at 29 CFR 1926.803(g)(1)(iii), which requires 
automatic controls to regulate decompression. As noted above, the 
applicant is committed to conduct the staged decompression according to 
the 1992 French Decompression Tables under the direct control of the 
trained man-lock attendant and under the oversight of the hyperbaric 
supervisor.

E. Variance From Paragraph (g)(1)(xvii) of 29 CFR 1926.803, Requirement 
of Special Decompression Chamber

    The OSHA compressed-air standard for construction requires 
employers to use a special decompression chamber when total 
decompression time exceeds 75 minutes (see 29 CFR 
1926.803(g)(1)(xvii)). Another provision of OSHA's compressed-air 
standard calls for locating the special decompression chamber adjacent 
to the man lock on the atmospheric pressure side of the tunnel bulkhead 
(see 29 CFR 1926.803(g)(2)(vii)). However, since only the working 
chamber of the EPBTBM is under pressure, and only a few workers out of 
the entire crew are exposed to hyperbaric pressure, the man locks 
(which, as noted earlier, connect directly to the working chamber) are 
of sufficient size to accommodate the exposed workers. In addition, 
available space in the EPBTBM does not allow for an additional special 
decompression lock. Again, the applicant uses the man locks, each of 
which adequately accommodates a three-member crew, for this purpose 
when decompression lasts up to 75 minutes. When decompression exceeds 
75 minutes, crews can open the door connecting the two compartments in 
each man lock during decompression stops or exit the man lock and move 
into the staging chamber where additional space is available. This 
alternative enables CAWs to move about and flex their joints to prevent 
neuromuscular problems during decompression.

F. Previous Tunnel Construction Variance

    OSHA notes that on May 23, 2014, it granted a sub-aqueous tunnel 
construction permanent variance to Tully/OHL USA Joint Venture (79 FR 
29809) from the same provisions of the standard that regulates work in 
compressed air (at 29 CFR 1926.803(e)(5), (f)(1), (g)(1)(iii), and 
(g)(1)(xvii)) that are the subject of the present application. 
Generally, the alternate conditions in this notice are based on and 
very similar to the alternate conditions of the previous permanent 
variance.

G. Multi-State Variance

    As stated earlier in this notice, Traylor JV applied for an interim 
order for its Blue Plains Tunnel project only. On July 11, 2013, OSHA 
granted an interim order to cover only the Blue Plains Tunnel project, 
which is located entirely in the District of Columbia and thus under 
Federal OSHA's exclusive jurisdiction. Further, on December 11, 2014, 
OSHA published a Federal Register notice announcing Traylor JV's 
application for a permanent variance and interim order, grant of an 
interim order, and request for comments (79 FR 73631).

[[Page 16444]]

    Additionally, twenty-seven state safety and health plans have been 
approved by OSHA under section 18 of the (OSH) Act.\5\ As part of the 
permanent variance process, the Directorate of Cooperative and State 
Programs will notify the State Plans of Traylor JV's variance 
application and grant of the Blue Plains permanent variance. In 
considering Traylor JV's application for a permanent variance and 
interim order, OSHA noted that four states have previously granted sub-
aqueous tunnel construction variances and imposed different or 
additional requirements and conditions (California, Nevada, Oregon, and 
Washington). California also promulgated a new standard \6\ for similar 
sub-aqueous tunnel construction work.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \5\ Five State Plans (Connecticut, Illinois, New Jersey, New 
York, and the Virgin Islands) limit their occupational safety and 
health authority to state and local employers only. State Plans that 
exercise their occupational safety and health authority over both 
public- and private-sector employers are: Alaska, Arizona, 
California, Hawaii, Indiana, Iowa, Kentucky, Maryland, Michigan, 
Minnesota, Nevada, New Mexico, North Carolina, Oregon, Puerto Rico, 
South Carolina, Tennessee, Utah, Vermont, Virginia, Washington, and 
Wyoming.
    \6\ See California Code of Regulations, Title 8, Subchapter 7, 
Group 26, Article 154, available at http://www.dir.ca.gov/title8/sb7g26a154.html.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

III. Description of the Conditions Specified for the Permanent Variance

    This section describes the alternative means of compliance with 29 
CFR 1926.803(e)(5), (f)(1), (g)(1)(iii), and (g)(1)(xvii) and provides 
additional detail regarding the conditions that form the basis of 
Traylor JV's permanent variance.

Condition A: Scope

    The scope of the permanent variance limits coverage to the work 
situations specified under this condition. Clearly defining the scope 
of the permanent variance provides Traylor JV, Traylor JV's employees, 
other stakeholders, the public, and OSHA with necessary information 
regarding the work situations in which the permanent variance applies.
    According to 29 CFR 1905.11, an employer or class or group of 
employers \7\ may request a permanent variance for a specific workplace 
or workplaces. If granted, the variance applies to the specific 
employer(s) that submitted the application. In this instance, the 
permanent variance applies to the applicant, Traylor/Skanska/Jay Dee 
Joint Venture at the Blue Plains Tunnel project and does not apply to 
any other employers.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \7\ A class or group of employers (such as members of a trade 
alliance or association) may apply jointly for a variance provided 
an authorized representative for each employer signs the application 
and the application identifies each employer's affected facilities.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Condition B: Application

    This condition specifies the circumstances under which the 
permanent variance is in effect, notably only for hyperbaric work 
performed during interventions. The condition places clear limits on 
the circumstances under which the applicant can expose its employees to 
hyperbaric pressure.

Condition C: List of Abbreviations

    Condition C defines a number of abbreviations used in the permanent 
variance. OSHA believes that defining these abbreviations serves to 
clarify and standardize their usage, thereby enhancing the applicant's 
and its employees' understanding of the conditions specified by the 
permanent variance.

Condition D: Definitions

    The condition defines a series of terms, mostly technical terms, 
used in the permanent variance to standardize and clarify their 
meaning. Defining these terms serves to enhance the applicant's and its 
employees' understanding of the conditions specified by the permanent 
variance.

Condition E: Safety and Health Practices

    This condition requires the applicant to develop and submit to OSHA 
an HOM specific to the Blue Plains project at least six months before 
using the EPBTBM for tunneling operations. Additionally, the condition 
includes a series of related hazard prevention and control requirements 
and methods (e.g., decompression tables, job hazard analyses (JHA), 
operations and inspections checklists, incident investigation, 
recording and notification to OSHA of recordable hyperbaric injuries 
and illnesses, etc.) designed to ensure the continued effective 
functioning of the hyperbaric equipment and operating system.
    Review of the HOM enables OSHA to: (1) Determine that the safety 
and health instructions and measures it specifies are appropriate and 
do adequately protect the safety and health of the CAWs; and (2) 
request the applicant to revise or modify the HOM if it finds that the 
hyperbaric safety and health procedures are not suitable for the 
specific project and do not adequately protect the safety and health of 
the CAWs. Once approved, the project-specific HOM becomes part of the 
variance, thus enabling OSHA to enforce its safety and health 
procedures and measures.\8\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \8\ Grant of the July 11, 2013, project-specific interim order 
constituted OSHA's approval of Traylor JV's Blue Plains Tunnel 
project-specific HOM.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Condition F: Communication

    Condition F requires the applicant to develop and implement an 
effective system of information sharing and communication. Effective 
information sharing and communication ensures that affected workers 
receive updated information regarding any safety-related hazards and 
incidents, and corrective actions taken, prior to the start of each 
shift. The condition also requires the applicant to ensure that 
reliable means of emergency communications are available and maintained 
for affected workers and support personnel during hyperbaric 
operations. Availability of such reliable means of communications 
enables affected workers and support personnel to respond quickly and 
effectively to hazardous conditions or emergencies that may develop 
during EPBTBM operations.

Condition G: Worker Qualification and Training

    This condition requires the applicant to develop and implement an 
effective qualification and training program for affected workers. The 
condition specifies the factors that an affected worker must know to 
perform safely during hyperbaric operations, including how to enter, 
work in, and exit from hyperbaric conditions under both normal and 
emergency conditions. Having well-trained and qualified workers 
performing hyperbaric intervention work ensures that they recognize, 
and respond appropriately to, hyperbaric safety and health hazards. 
These qualification and training requirements enable affected workers 
to cope effectively with emergencies, as well as the discomfort and 
physiological effects of hyperbaric exposure, thereby preventing worker 
injury, illness, and fatalities.
    Paragraph (2)(e) of this condition also requires the applicant to 
provide affected workers with information they can use to contact the 
appropriate healthcare professionals if they believe they are 
developing hyperbaric-related health effects. This requirement provides 
for early intervention and treatment of DCI and other health effects 
resulting from hyperbaric exposure, thereby reducing the potential 
severity of these effects.

[[Page 16445]]

Condition H: Inspections, Tests, and Accident Prevention

    Condition H requires the applicant to develop, implement, and 
operate a program of frequent and regular inspections of the EPBTBM's 
hyperbaric equipment and support systems, and associated work areas. 
This condition helps to ensure the safe operation and physical 
integrity of the equipment and work areas necessary to conduct 
hyperbaric operations. The condition also enhances worker safety by 
reducing the risk of hyperbaric-related emergencies.
    Paragraph (3) of this condition requires the applicant to document 
tests, inspections, corrective actions, and repairs involving the 
EPBTBM, and maintain these documents at the job site for the duration 
of the job. This requirement provides the applicant with information 
needed to schedule tests and inspections to ensure the continued safe 
operation of the equipment and systems, and to determine that the 
actions taken to correct defects in hyperbaric equipment and systems 
were appropriate, prior to returning them to service.

Condition I: Compression and Decompression

    This condition requires the applicant to consult with its 
designated medical advisor regarding special compression or 
decompression procedures appropriate for any un-acclimated CAW. This 
provision ensures that the applicant consults with the medical advisor, 
and involves the medical advisor in the evaluation, development, and 
implementation of compression or decompression protocols appropriate 
for any CAW requiring acclimation to the hyperbaric conditions 
encountered during EPBTBM operations. Accordingly, CAWs requiring 
acclimation have an opportunity to acclimate prior to exposure to these 
hyperbaric conditions. OSHA believes this condition will prevent or 
reduce adverse reactions among CAWs to the effects of compression or 
decompression associated with the intervention work they perform in the 
EPBTBM.

Condition J: Recordkeeping

    Condition J requires the applicant to maintain records of specific 
factors associated with each hyperbaric intervention. The information 
gathered and recorded under this provision, in concert with the 
information provided under condition K (using the OSHA 301 Incident 
Report form to investigate and record hyperbaric recordable injuries as 
defined by 29 CFR 1904.4, 1904.7, 1904.8 through 1904.12), enables the 
applicant and OSHA to determine the effectiveness of the permanent 
variance in preventing DCI and other hyperbaric-related effects.\9\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \9\ See 29 CFR part 1904 Recording and Reporting Occupational 
Injuries and Illnesses (http://www.osha.gov/pls/oshaweb/owadisp.show_document?p_table=STANDARDS&p_id=9631); recordkeeping 
forms and instructions (http://www.osha.gov/recordkeeping/RKform300pkg-fillable-enabled.pdf); OSHA Recordkeeping Handbook 
(http://www.osha.gov/recordkeeping/handbook/index.html); and updates 
to OSHA's recordkeeping rule and Web page ((79 FR 56130); http://www.osha.gov/recordkeeping2014/index.html)).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Condition K: Notifications

    Under this condition, the applicant is required, within specified 
periods to: (1) Notify OSHA of any recordable injuries, illnesses, in-
patient hospitalizations, amputations, loss of an eye, or fatalities 
that occur as a result of hyperbaric exposures during EPBTBM 
operations; (2) provide OSHA with a copy of the incident investigation 
report (using OSHA 301 form) of these events; (3) include on the 301 
form information on the hyperbaric conditions associated with the 
recordable injury or illness, the root-cause determination, and 
preventive and corrective actions identified and implemented; (4) 
provide its certification that it informed affected workers of the 
incident and the results of the incident investigation; (5) notify the 
Office of Technical Programs and Coordination Activities (OTPCA) and 
the Baltimore/Washington DC Area Office within 15 working days should 
the applicant need to revise its HOM to accommodate changes in its 
compressed-air operations that affect its ability to comply with the 
conditions of the permanent variance; and (6) provide OTPCA and the 
Baltimore/Washington DC Area Office, at the end of the project, with a 
report evaluating the effectiveness of the decompression tables.
    These notification requirements enable the applicant, its 
employees, and OSHA to determine the effectiveness of the permanent 
variance in providing the requisite level of safety to the applicant's 
workers and, based on this determination, whether to revise or revoke 
the conditions of the permanent variance. Timely notification permits 
OSHA to take whatever action may be necessary and appropriate to 
prevent further injuries and illnesses. Providing notification to 
employees informs them of the precautions taken by the applicant to 
prevent similar incidents in the future.
    This condition also requires the applicant to notify OSHA if it 
ceases to do business, has a new address or location for its main 
office, or transfers the operations covered by the permanent variance 
to a successor company. In addition, the condition specifies that OSHA 
must approve the transfer of the permanent variance to a successor 
company. These requirements allow OSHA to communicate effectively with 
the applicant regarding the status of the permanent variance, and 
expedite the Agency's administration and enforcement of the permanent 
variance. Stipulating that an applicant must have OSHA's approval to 
transfer a variance to a successor company provides assurance that the 
successor company has knowledge of, and will comply with, the 
conditions specified by the permanent variance, thereby ensuring the 
safety of workers involved in performing the operations covered by the 
permanent variance.

IV. Comments on the Proposed Variance Application

    OSHA received no comments on the proposed variance, including no 
comments from State Plans.

V. Decision

    After reviewing Traylor JV's proposed variance as described above, 
and having received no comment, OSHA determines that:
    A. Traylor JV developed, and proposed to implement, effective 
alternative measures to the prohibition of using compressed air under 
hyperbaric conditions exceeding 50 p.s.i.g. The alternative measures 
include use of engineering and administrative controls of the hazards 
associated with work performed in compressed-air conditions exceeding 
50 p.s.i.g. while engaged in the construction of a subaqueous tunnel 
using advanced shielded mechanical-excavation techniques in conjunction 
with an EPBTBM. Prior to conducting interventions in the EPBTBM's 
pressurized working chamber, the applicant halts tunnel excavation and 
prepares the machine and crew to conduct the interventions. 
Interventions involve inspection, maintenance, or repair of the 
mechanical-excavation components located in the working chamber.
    B. Traylor JV developed, and proposed to implement, safe hyperbaric 
work procedures, emergency and contingency procedures, and medical 
examinations for the Blue Plains Tunneling project's CAWs. The 
applicant compiled these standard operating procedures into a project-
specific HOM (Ex. OSHA-2012-0035-0007). The HOM discusses the

[[Page 16446]]

procedures and personnel qualifications for performing work safely 
during the compression and decompression phases of interventions. The 
HOM also specifies the decompression tables the applicant proposes to 
use. Depending on the maximum working pressure and exposure times 
during the interventions, the tables provide for decompression using 
air, pure oxygen, or a combination of air and oxygen. The decompression 
tables also include delays or stops for various time intervals at 
different pressure levels during the transition to atmospheric pressure 
(i.e., staged decompression). In all cases, a physician certified in 
hyperbaric medicine will manage the medical condition of CAWs during 
decompression. In addition, a trained and experienced man-lock 
attendant, experienced in recognizing decompression sickness or 
illnesses and injuries, will be present. Of key importance, a 
hyperbaric supervisor (competent person), trained in hyperbaric 
operations, procedures, and safety, will directly supervise all 
hyperbaric operations to ensure compliance with the procedures 
delineated in the project-specific HOM or by the attending physician.
    C. Traylor JV developed, and proposed to implement, a training 
program to instruct affected workers in the hazards associated with 
conducting hyperbaric operations.
    D. Traylor JV developed, and proposed to implement, an effective 
alternative to the use of automatic controllers that continuously 
decrease pressure to achieve decompression in accordance with the 
tables specified by the standard. The alternative includes using the 
1992 French Decompression Tables for guiding staged decompression to 
achieve lower occurrences of DCI, using a trained and competent 
attendant for implementing appropriate hyperbaric entry and exit 
procedures, and providing a competent hyperbaric supervisor and 
attending physician certified in hyperbaric medicine, to oversee all 
hyperbaric operations.
    E. Traylor JV developed, and proposed to implement, an effective 
alternative to the use of the special decompression chamber required by 
the standard. EPBTBM technology permits the tunnel's work areas to be 
at atmospheric pressure, with only the face of the EPBTBM (i.e., the 
working chamber) at elevated pressure during interventions. The 
applicant limits interventions conducted in the working chamber to 
performing required inspection, maintenance, and repair of the cutting 
tools on the face of the EPBTBM. The EPBTBM's man lock and working 
chamber provide sufficient space for the maximum crew of three CAWs to 
stand up and move around, and safely accommodate decompression times up 
to 360 minutes. Therefore, OSHA preliminarily determined that the 
EPBTBM's man lock and working chamber function as effectively as the 
special decompression chamber required by the standard.
    OSHA conducted a review of the scientific literature regarding 
decompression to determine whether the alternative decompression method 
(i.e., the 1992 French Decompression Tables) Traylor JV proposed 
provide a workplace as safe and healthful as that provided by the 
standard. Based on this review, OSHA determined that tunneling 
operations performed with these tables \10\ resulted in a lower 
occurrence of DCI than the decompression tables specified by the 
standard.11 12 13
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \10\ In 1992, the French Ministry of Labour replaced the 1974 
French Decompression Tables with the 1992 French Decompression 
Tables, which differ from OSHA's decompression tables in Appendix A 
by using: (1) Staged decompression as opposed to continuous (linear) 
decompression; (2) decompression tables based on air or both air and 
pure oxygen; and (3) emergency tables when unexpected exposure times 
occur (up to 30 minutes above the maximum allowed working time).
    \11\ Kindwall, EP (1997). Compressed air tunneling and caisson 
work decompression procedures: Development, problems, and solutions. 
Undersea and Hyperbaric Medicine, 24(4), pp. 337-345. This article 
reported 60 treated cases of DCI among 4,168 exposures between 19 
and 31 p.s.i.g. over a 51-week contract period, for a DCI incidence 
of 1.44% for the decompression tables specified by the OSHA 
standard.
    \12\ Sealey, JL (1969). Safe exit from the hyperbaric 
environment: Medical experience with pressurized tunnel operations. 
Journal of Occupational Medicine, 11(5), pp. 273-275. This article 
reported 210 treated cases of DCI among 38,600 hyperbaric exposures 
between 13 and 34 p.s.i.g. over a 32-month period, for an incidence 
of 0.54% for the decompression tables specified by the Washington 
State safety standards for compressed-air work, which are similar to 
the tables in the OSHA standard. Moreover, the article reported 51 
treated cases of DCI for 3,000 exposures between 30 and 34 p.s.i.g., 
for an incidence of 1.7% for the Washington State tables.
    \13\ In 1985, the National Institute for Occupational Safety and 
Health (NIOSH) published a report entitled ``Criteria for Interim 
Decompression Tables for Caisson and Tunnel Workers''; this report 
reviewed studies of DCI and other hyperbaric-related injuries 
resulting from use of OSHA's tables. This report is available on 
NIOSH's Web site: http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/topics/decompression/default.html.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    The review conducted by OSHA found several research studies 
supporting the determination that the 1992 French Decompression Tables 
resulted in a lower rate of DCI than the decompression tables specified 
by the standard. For example, H. L. Anderson studied the occurrence of 
DCI at maximum hyperbaric pressures ranging from 4 p.s.i.g. to 43 
p.s.i.g. during construction of the Great Belt Tunnel in Denmark (1992-
1996); \14\ this project used the 1992 French Decompression Tables to 
decompress the workers during part of the construction. Anderson 
observed 6 DCI cases out of 7,220 decompression events, and reported 
that switching to the 1992 French Decompression tables reduced the DCI 
incidence to 0.08%. The DCI incidence in the study by H. L. Andersen is 
substantially less than the DCI incidence reported for the 
decompression tables specified in Appendix A. OSHA found no studies in 
which the DCI incidence reported for the 1992 French Decompression 
Tables were higher than the DCI incidence reported for the OSHA 
decompression tables.\15\ Therefore, OSHA concludes that use of the 
1992 French Decompression Tables protects workers at least as 
effectively as the OSHA decompression tables.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \14\ Anderson HL (2002). Decompression sickness during 
construction of the Great Belt tunnel, Denmark. Undersea and 
Hyperbaric Medicine, 29(3), pp. 172-188.
    \15\ Le P[eacute]chon JC, Barre P, Baud JP, Ollivier F 
(September 1996). Compressed air work--French Tables 1992--
operational results. JCLP Hyperbarie Paris, Centre Medical 
Subaquatique Interentreprise, Marseille: Communication a l'EUBS, pp. 
1-5 (see Ex. OSHA-2012-0035-0008).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Based on a review of available evidence, the experience of State 
Plans that either granted variances (Nevada, Oregon and Washington) 
\16\ or promulgated a new standard (California) \17\ for hyperbaric 
exposures occurring during similar subaqueous tunnel-construction work, 
and the information provided in the applicant's variance application, 
OSHA is granting the permanent variance.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \16\ These state variances are available in the docket: Exs. 
OSHA-2012-0035-0006 (Nevada), OSHA-2012-0035-0005 (Oregon), and 
OSHA-2012-0035-0004 (Washington).
    \17\ See California Code of Regulations, Title 8, Subchapter 7, 
Group 26, Article 154, available at http://www.dir.ca.gov/title8/sb7g26a154.html.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Under section 6(d) of the Occupational Safety and Health Act of 
1970 (29 U.S.C. 655), the Agency finds that when the employer complies 
with the conditions of the following order, the working conditions of 
the employer's workers are at least as safe and healthful as if the 
employer complied with the working conditions specified by paragraphs 
(e)(5), (f)(1), (g)(1)(iii), and (g)(1)(xvii) of 29 CFR 1926.803. 
Therefore, Traylor JV will: (1) Comply with the conditions listed in 
section VI of this notice for the period between the grant of the 
interim order and completion of the Blue Plains Tunnel project, but no 
later than January 31, 2016; (2) comply fully with

[[Page 16447]]

all other applicable provisions of 29 CFR part 1926; and (3) provide a 
copy of this Federal Register notice to all employees affected by the 
conditions, including the affected employees of other employers, using 
the same means it used to inform these employees of its application for 
a permanent variance. Additionally, this final order will remain in 
effect until OSHA modifies or revokes it in accordance with 29 CFR 
1905.13.

VI. Order

    As of the effective date of this final order, OSHA is revoking the 
interim order granted to the employer on July 11, 2013, and affirmed on 
December 11, 2014 (79 FR 73631). OSHA issues this final order 
authorizing Traylor/Skanska/Jay Dee Joint Venture (``Traylor JV'') to 
comply with following conditions instead of complying with the 
requirements of paragraphs 29 CFR 1926.803(e)(5), (f)(1), (g)(1)(iii), 
and (g)(1)(xvii). This final order applies to all employees of Traylor 
JV exposed to hyperbaric conditions at the Blue Plains Tunnel project. 
These conditions are:

A. Scope

    The permanent variance applies only to work:
    1. That occurs in conjunction with construction of the Blue Plains 
Tunnel project, a tunnel constructed using advanced shielded 
mechanical-excavation techniques and involving operation of an EPBTBM;
    2. Performed under compressed-air and hyperbaric conditions up to 
52 p.s.i.g;
    3. In the EPBTBM's forward section (the working chamber) and 
associated hyperbaric chambers used to pressurize and decompress 
employees entering and exiting the working chamber;
    4. Except for the requirements specified by 29 CFR 1926.803(e)(5), 
(f)(1), (g)(1)(iii), and (g)(1)(xvii), Traylor JV must comply fully 
with all other applicable provisions of 29 CFR part 1926; and
    5. This order remains in effect until one of the following 
conditions occurs: (1) Completion of the Blue Plains Tunnel project, 
but no later than January 31, 2016; or (2) OSHA modifies or revokes 
this final order in accordance with 29 CFR 1905.13.

B. Application

    The permanent variance applies only when Traylor JV stops the 
tunnel-boring work, pressurizes the working chamber, and the CAWs 
either enter the working chamber to perform interventions (i.e., 
inspect, maintain, or repair the mechanical-excavation components), or 
exit the working chamber after performing interventions.

C. List of Abbreviations

    Abbreviations used throughout this permanent variance include the 
following:

1. CAW--Compressed-air worker
2. CFR--Code of Federal Regulations
3. DCI--Decompression Illness
4. EPBTBM--Earth Pressure Balanced Tunnel Boring Machine
5. HOM--Hyperbaric Operations and Safety Manual
6. JHA--Job hazard analysis
7. OSHA--Occupational Safety and Health Administration
8. OTPCA--Office of Technical Programs and Coordination Activities

D. Definitions

    The following definitions apply to this permanent variance. These 
definitions supplement the definitions in Traylor JV's project-specific 
HOM.
    1. Affected employee or worker--an employee or worker who is 
affected by the conditions of this permanent variance, or any one of 
his or her authorized representatives. The term ``employee'' has the 
meaning defined and used under the Occupational Safety and Health Act 
of 1970 (29 U.S.C. 651 et seq.)
    2. Atmospheric pressure--the pressure of air at sea-level, 
generally 14.7 p.s.i.a., 1 atmosphere absolute, or 0 p.s.i.g.
    3. Compressed-air worker--an individual who is specially trained 
and medically qualified to perform work in a pressurized environment 
while breathing air at pressures up to 52 p.s.i.g.
    4. Competent person--an individual who is capable of identifying 
existing and predictable hazards in the surroundings or working 
conditions that are unsanitary, hazardous, or dangerous to employees, 
and who has authorization to take prompt corrective measures to 
eliminate them.\18\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \18\ Adapted from 29 CFR 1926.32(f).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    5. Decompression illness (also called decompression sickness or the 
bends)--an illness caused by gas bubbles appearing in body compartments 
due to a reduction in ambient pressure. Examples of symptoms of 
decompression illness include (but are not limited to): Joint pain 
(also known as the ``bends'' for agonizing pain or the ``niggles'' for 
slight pain); areas of bone destruction (termed dysbaric 
osteonecrosis); skin disorders (such as cutis marmorata, which causes a 
pink marbling of the skin); spinal cord and brain disorders (such as 
stroke, paralysis, paresthesia, and bladder dysfunction); 
cardiopulmonary disorders, such as shortness of breath; and arterial 
gas embolism (gas bubbles in the arteries that block blood flow).\19\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \19\ See Appendix 10 of ``A Guide to the Work in Compressed Air 
Regulations 1996,'' published by the United Kingdom Health and 
Safety Executive available from NIOSH at http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docket/archive/pdfs/NIOSH-254/compReg1996.pdf.

    Note: Health effects associated with hyperbaric intervention but 
not considered symptoms of DCI can include: Barotrauma (direct 
damage to air-containing cavities in the body such as ears, sinuses 
and lungs); nitrogen narcosis (reversible alteration in 
consciousness that may occur in hyperbaric environments and is 
caused by the anesthetic effect of certain gases at high pressure); 
and oxygen toxicity (a central nervous system condition resulting 
from the harmful effects of breathing molecular oxygen 
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
(O2) at elevated partial pressures).

    6. Earth Pressure Balanced Tunnel Boring Machine--the machinery 
used to excavate the tunnel.
    7. Hot work--any activity performed in a hazardous location that 
may introduce an ignition source into a potentially flammable 
atmosphere.\20\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \20\ Also see 29 CFR 1910.146(b).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    8. Hyperbaric--at a higher pressure than atmospheric pressure.
    9. Hyperbaric intervention--a term that describes the process of 
stopping the EPBTBM and preparing and executing work under hyperbaric 
pressure in the working chamber for the purpose of inspecting, 
replacing, or repairing cutting tools and/or the cutter head structure.
    10. Hyperbaric Operations Manual--a detailed, project-specific 
health and safety plan developed and implemented by Traylor JV for 
working in compressed air during the Blue Plains' tunnel project.
    11. Job hazard analysis--an evaluation of tasks or operations to 
identify potential hazards and to determine the necessary controls.
    12. Man lock--an enclosed space capable of pressurization, and used 
for compressing or decompressing any employee or material when either 
is passing into or out of a working chamber.
    13. Pressure--a force acting on a unit area. Usually expressed as 
pounds per square inch (p.s.i.).
    14. p.s.i.--pounds per square inch, a common unit of measurement of 
pressure; a pressure given in p.s.i. corresponds to absolute pressure.
    15. p.s.i.a.--pounds per square inch absolute, or absolute 
pressure, is the sum of the atmospheric pressure and gauge pressure. At 
sea-level, atmospheric pressure is approximately 14.7 p.s.i. Adding 
14.7 to a pressure

[[Page 16448]]

expressed in units of p.s.i.g. will yield the absolute pressure, 
expressed as p.s.i.a.
    16. p.s.i.g.--pounds per square inch gauge, a common unit of 
pressure; pressure expressed as p.s.i.g. corresponds to pressure 
relative to atmospheric pressure. At sea-level, atmospheric pressure is 
approximately 14.7 p.s.i. Subtracting 14.7 from a pressure expressed in 
units of p.s.i.a. yields the gauge pressure, expressed as p.s.i.g.
    17. Qualified person--an individual who, by possession of a 
recognized degree, certificate, or professional standing, or who, by 
extensive knowledge, training, and experience, successfully 
demonstrates an ability to solve or resolve problems relating to the 
subject matter, the work, or the project.\21\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \21\ Adapted from 29 CFR 1926.32(m).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    18. Working chamber--an enclosed space in the EPBTBM in which CAWs 
perform interventions, and which is accessible only through a man lock.

E. Safety and Health Practices

    1. Traylor JV must develop and implement an HOM specific to the 
Blue Plains project, and submit the HOM to OSHA at least six months 
before using the EPBTBM. Traylor JV must receive a written 
acknowledgement from OSHA regarding the acceptability of the HOM.\22\ 
The HOM shall provide the governing safety and health requirements 
regarding hyperbaric exposures during the tunnel-construction project.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \22\ See footnote 8.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    2. Traylor JV must implement the safety and health instructions 
included in the manufacturer's operations manuals for the EPBTBM, and 
the safety and health instructions provided by the manufacturer for the 
operation of decompression equipment.
    3. Traylor JV must use air as the only breathing gas in the working 
chamber.
    4. Traylor JV must use the 1992 French Decompression Tables for 
air, air-oxygen, and oxygen decompression specified in the HOM, 
specifically the extracted portions of the 1992 French Decompression 
tables titled ``French Regulation Air Standard Tables.''
    5. Traylor JV must equip man-locks used by its employees with an 
oxygen-delivery system as specified by the HOM. Traylor JV must not 
store oxygen or other compressed gases used in conjunction with 
hyperbaric work in the tunnel.
    6. Workers performing hot work under hyperbaric conditions must use 
flame-retardant personal protective equipment and clothing.
    7. In hyperbaric work areas, Traylor JV must maintain an adequate 
fire-suppression system approved for hyperbaric work areas.
    8. Traylor JV must develop and implement one or more JHAs for work 
in the hyperbaric work areas, and review, periodically and as necessary 
(e.g., after making changes to a planned intervention that affects its 
operation), the contents of the JHAs with affected employees. The JHAs 
must include all the job functions that the risk assessment \23\ 
indicates are essential to prevent injury or illness.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \23\ See ANSI/AIHA Z10-2012, American National Standard for 
Occupational Health and Safety Management Systems, for reference.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    9. Traylor JV must develop a set of checklists to guide compressed-
air work and ensure that employees follow the procedures required by 
this permanent variance (including all procedures required by the HOM, 
which this variance incorporates by reference). The checklists must 
include all steps and equipment functions that the risk assessment 
indicates are essential to prevent injury or illness during compressed-
air work.
    10. Traylor JV must ensure that the safety and health provisions of 
the HOM adequately protect the workers of all contractors and 
subcontractors involved in hyperbaric operations.\24\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \24\ See ANSI/ASSE A10.33-2011, American National Standard for 
Construction and Demolition Operations--Safety and Health Program 
Requirements for Multi-Employer Projects, for reference.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

F. Communication

    1. Prior to beginning a shift, Traylor JV must implement a system 
that informs workers exposed to hyperbaric conditions of any hazardous 
occurrences or conditions that might affect their safety, including 
hyperbaric incidents, gas releases, equipment failures, earth or rock 
slides, cave-ins, flooding, fires, or explosions.
    2. Traylor JV must provide a power-assisted means of communication 
among affected workers and support personnel in hyperbaric conditions 
where unassisted voice communication is inadequate.
    (a) Traylor JV must use an independent power supply for powered 
communication systems, and these systems must operate such that use or 
disruption of any one phone or signal location will not disrupt the 
operation of the system from any other location.
    (b) Traylor JV must test communication systems at the start of each 
shift and as necessary thereafter to ensure proper operation.

G. Worker Qualifications and Training

    Traylor JV must:
    1. Ensure that each affected worker receives effective training on 
how to safely enter, work in, exit from, and undertake emergency 
evacuation or rescue from, hyperbaric conditions, and document this 
training.
    2. Provide effective instruction, before beginning hyperbaric 
operations, to each worker who performs work, or controls the exposure 
of others, in hyperbaric conditions, and document this instruction. The 
instruction must include topics such as:
    (a) The physics and physiology of hyperbaric work;
    (b) Recognition of pressure-related injuries;
    (c) Information on the causes and recognition of the signs and 
symptoms associated with decompression illness, and other hyperbaric 
intervention-related health effects (e.g., barotrauma, nitrogen 
narcosis, and oxygen toxicity).
    (d) How to avoid discomfort during compression and decompression; 
and
    (e) Information the workers can use to contact the appropriate 
healthcare professionals should the workers have concerns that they may 
be experiencing adverse health effects from hyperbaric exposure.
    3. Repeat the instruction specified in paragraph (2) of this 
condition periodically and as necessary (e.g., after making changes to 
its hyperbaric operations).
    4. When conducting training for its hyperbaric workers make this 
training available to OSHA personnel and notify the OTPCA at OSHA's 
national office and OSHA's Baltimore/Washington DC Area Office before 
the training takes place.

H. Inspections, Tests, and Accident Prevention

    1. Traylor JV must initiate and maintain a program of frequent and 
regular inspections of the EPBTBM's hyperbaric equipment and support 
systems (such as temperature control, illumination, ventilation, and 
fire-prevention and fire-suppression systems), and hyperbaric work 
areas, as required under 29 CFR 1926.20(b)(2) by:
    (a) Developing a set of checklists to be used by a competent person 
in conducting weekly inspections of hyperbaric equipment and work 
areas; and
    (b) Ensuring that a competent person conducts daily visual checks 
and weekly inspections of the EPBTBM.
    2. If the competent person determines that the equipment 
constitutes a safety hazard, Traylor JV must remove the

[[Page 16449]]

equipment from service until it corrects the hazardous condition and 
has the correction approved by a qualified person.
    3. Traylor JV must maintain records of all tests and inspections of 
the EPBTBM, as well as associated corrective actions and repairs, at 
the job site for the duration of the job.

I. Compression and Decompression

    Traylor JV must consult with its attending physician concerning the 
need for special compression or decompression exposures appropriate for 
CAWs not acclimated to hyperbaric exposure.

J. Recordkeeping

    Traylor JV must maintain a record of any recordable injury, 
illness, or fatality (as defined by 29 CFR part 1904 Recording and 
Reporting Occupational Injuries and Illnesses), resulting from exposure 
of an employee to hyperbaric conditions by completing the OSHA 301 
Incident Report form and OSHA 300 Log of Work Related Injuries and 
Illnesses.

    Note:  Examples of important information to include on the OSHA 
301 Incident Report form (along with the corresponding question on 
the form) are: The task performed (Question (Q) 14); an estimate of 
the CAW's workload (Q 14); the composition of the gas mixture (e.g., 
air or oxygen (Q 14)); the maximum working pressure (Q 14); 
temperature in the work and decompression environments (Q 14); 
unusual occurrences, if any, during the task or decompression (Q 
14); time of symptom onset (Q 15); duration between decompression 
and onset of symptoms (Q 15); type and duration of symptoms (Q 16); 
a medical summary of the illness or injury (Q 16); duration of the 
hyperbaric intervention (Q 17); possible contributing factors (Q 
17); the number of prior interventions completed by the injured or 
ill CAW (Q 17); the number of prior interventions completed by the 
injured or ill CAW at this working pressure (Q 17); contact 
information for the treating healthcare provider (Q 17); and date 
and time of last hyperbaric exposure for this CAW.

    In addition to completing the OSHA 301 Incident Report form and 
OSHA 300 Log of Work Related Injuries and Illnesses, Traylor JV must 
maintain records of:
    1. The date, times (e.g., began compression, time spent 
compressing, time performing intervention, time spent decompressing), 
and pressure for each hyperbaric intervention.
    2. The name of each individual worker exposed to hyperbaric 
pressure and the decompression protocols and results for each worker.
    3. The total number of interventions and the amount of hyperbaric 
work time at each pressure.
    4. The results of the post-intervention physical assessment of each 
CAW for signs and symptoms of decompression illness, barotrauma, 
nitrogen narcosis, oxygen toxicity or other health effects associated 
with work in compressed air for each hyperbaric intervention.

K. Notifications

    1. To assist OSHA in administering the conditions specified herein, 
Traylor JV must:
    (a) Notify the OTPCA and the Baltimore/Washington DC Area Office of 
any recordable injuries, illnesses, in-patient hospitalizations, 
amputations, loss of an eye, or fatality (by submitting the completed 
OSHA 301 Incident Report form \25\) resulting from exposure of an 
employee to hyperbaric conditions including those that do not require 
recompression treatment (e.g., nitrogen narcosis, oxygen toxicity, 
barotrauma), but still meet the recordable injury or illness criteria 
of 29 CFR part 1904. The notification must be made within 8 hours of 
the incident or 8 hours after becoming aware of a recordable injury, 
illness, in-patient hospitalizations, amputations, loss of an eye, or 
fatality, and submit a copy of the incident investigation (OSHA form 
301) within 24 hours of the incident or 24 hours after becoming aware 
of a recordable case. In addition to the information required by the 
OSHA form 301, the incident-investigation report must include a root-
cause determination, and the preventive and corrective actions 
identified and implemented.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \25\ See footnote 9.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    (b) Provide certification within 15 working days of the incident 
that Traylor JV informed affected workers of the incident and the 
results of the incident investigation (including the root-cause 
determination and preventive and corrective actions identified and 
implemented).
    (c) Notify the OTPCA and the Baltimore/Washington DC Area Office 
within 15 working days and in writing, of any change in the compressed-
air operations that affects Traylor JV's ability to comply with the 
conditions specified herein.
    (d) Upon completion of the Blue Plains Tunnel project, evaluate the 
effectiveness of the decompression tables used throughout the project, 
and provide a written report of this evaluation to the OTPCA and the 
Baltimore/Washington DC Area Office.

    Note:  The evaluation report must contain summaries of: (1) The 
number, dates, durations, and pressures of the hyperbaric 
interventions completed; (2) decompression protocols implemented 
(including composition of gas mixtures (air and/or oxygen), and the 
results achieved; (3) the total number of interventions and the 
number of hyperbaric incidents (decompression illnesses and/or 
health effects associated with hyperbaric interventions as recorded 
on OSHA 301 and 300 forms, and relevant medical diagnoses and 
treating physicians' opinions); and (4) root causes of any 
hyperbaric incidents, and preventive and corrective actions 
identified and implemented.

    (e) To assist OSHA in administering the conditions specified 
herein, inform the OTPCA and the Baltimore/Washington DC Area Office as 
soon as possible after it has knowledge that it will:
    (i) Cease to do business;
    (ii) Change the location and address of the main office for 
managing the tunneling operations specified herein; or
    (iii) Transfer the operations specified herein to a successor 
company.
    (f) Notify all affected employees of this permanent variance by the 
same means required to inform them of its application for a variance.
    2. OSHA must approve the transfer of the permanent variance to a 
successor company.

Authority and Signature

    David Michaels, Ph.D., MPH, Assistant Secretary of Labor for 
Occupational Safety and Health, 200 Constitution Avenue NW., 
Washington, DC 20210, authorized the preparation of this notice. 
Accordingly, the Agency is issuing this notice pursuant to Section 
29 U.S.C. 655(6)(d), Secretary of Labor's Order No. 1-2012 (77 FR 
3912, Jan. 25, 2012), and 29 CFR 1905.11.

David Michaels,
Assistant Secretary of Labor for Occupational Safety and Health.
[FR Doc. 2015-06975 Filed 3-26-15; 8:45 am]
 BILLING CODE 4510-26-P



                                                  16440                             Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 59 / Friday, March 27, 2015 / Notices

                                                  DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE                                     with the FDA including validation                     I. Notice of Application
                                                                                                            batches, standards and stability studies.                On April 26, 2012, Traylor Bros., Inc.,
                                                  Drug Enforcement Administration                             No other activity for this drug code is             835 N. Congress Ave., Evansville, IN
                                                  [Docket No. DEA–392]                                      authorized for this registration.                     47715, and Traylor/Skanska/Jay Dee
                                                                                                              Dated: March 20, 2015.                              Joint Venture, Blue Plains Tunnel, 5000
                                                  Bulk Manufacturer of Controlled                           Joseph T. Rannazzisi,                                 Overlook Avenue SW., Washington, DC
                                                  Substances Application: Apertus                                                                                 20032, submitted under Section 6(d) of
                                                                                                            Deputy Assistant Administrator.
                                                  Pharmaceuticals                                                                                                 the Occupational Safety and Health Act
                                                                                                            [FR Doc. 2015–06966 Filed 3–26–15; 8:45 am]
                                                                                                                                                                  of 1970 (‘‘OSH Act’’; 29 U.S.C. 655) and
                                                  ACTION:    Notice of application.                         BILLING CODE 4410–09–P
                                                                                                                                                                  29 CFR 1905.11 (‘‘Variances and other
                                                  DATES:  Registered bulk manufacturers of                                                                        relief under section 6(d)’’) an
                                                  the affected basic classes, and                                                                                 application for a permanent variance
                                                  applicants therefore, may file written                                                                          from several provisions of the OSHA
                                                                                                            DEPARTMENT OF LABOR
                                                                                                                                                                  standard that regulates work in
                                                  comments on or objections to the
                                                                                                            Occupational Safety and Health                        compressed air at 29 CFR 1926.803.
                                                  issuance of the proposed registration in
                                                                                                            Administration                                        OSHA is addressing this request as two
                                                  accordance with 21 CFR 1301.33(a) on
                                                                                                                                                                  separate applications: (1) Traylor Bros.,
                                                  or before May 26, 2015.
                                                                                                                                                                  Inc. (‘‘Traylor’’) request for a permanent
                                                  ADDRESSES: Written comments should                        [Docket No. OSHA–2012–0035]
                                                                                                                                                                  variance for future tunneling projects;
                                                  be sent to: Drug Enforcement                                                                                    and (2) Traylor/Skanska/Jay Dee Joint
                                                  Administration, Attention: DEA Federal                    Traylor/Skanska/Jay Dee Joint
                                                                                                            Venture: Grant of a Permanent                         Venture, Blue Plains Tunnel (‘‘Traylor
                                                  Register Representative/ODW, 8701                                                                               JV’’ or ‘‘the applicant’’). This notice only
                                                  Morrissette Drive, Springfield, Virginia                  Variance
                                                                                                                                                                  addresses the Traylor JV application for
                                                  22152. Request for hearings should be                     AGENCY: Occupational Safety and Health                an interim order and permanent
                                                  sent to: Drug Enforcement                                 Administration (OSHA), Labor.                         variance for the Blue Plains Tunnel
                                                  Administration, Attention: Hearing                                                                              project.1 This notice does not address
                                                  Clerk/LJ, 8701 Morrissette Drive,                         ACTION: Notice.
                                                                                                                                                                  the Traylor application for a permanent
                                                  Springfield, Virginia 22152.                                                                                    variance for future projects. That request
                                                                                                            SUMMARY:   In this notice, OSHA grants a
                                                  SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: The                            permanent variance to Traylor/Skanska/                will be addressed separately.
                                                  Attorney General has delegated his                        Jay Dee Joint Venture from the                           Traylor JV also requested an interim
                                                  authority under the Controlled                            provisions of OSHA standards that                     order pending OSHA’s decision on the
                                                  Substances Act to the Administrator of                    regulate work in compressed air                       application for a variance (Ex. OSHA–
                                                  the Drug Enforcement Administration                       environments at 29 CFR 1926.803.                      2012–0035–0008). Specifically, this
                                                  (DEA), 28 CFR 0.100(b). Authority to                                                                            notice addresses the application
                                                                                                            DATES: The permanent variance
                                                  exercise all necessary functions with                                                                           submitted by Traylor JV for the Blue
                                                  respect to the promulgation and                           specified by this notice becomes                      Plains Tunnel project in which the
                                                  implementation of 21 CFR part 1301,                       effective on March 27, 2015 and shall                 applicant seeks a permanent variance
                                                  incident to the registration of                           remain in effect until January 31, 2016.              and interim order from the provisions of
                                                  manufacturers, distributors, dispensers,                  FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:                      the standard that: (1) Prohibit
                                                  importers, and exporters of controlled                    Information regarding this notice is                  compressed-air worker exposure to
                                                  substances (other than final orders in                    available from the following sources:                 pressures exceeding 50 pounds per
                                                  connection with suspension, denial, or                       Press inquiries: Contact Mr. Frank                 square inch (p.s.i.) except in an
                                                  revocation of registration) has been                      Meilinger, Director, OSHA Office of                   emergency (29 CFR 1926.803(e)(5)); 2 (2)
                                                  redelegated to the Deputy Assistant                       Communications, U.S. Department of                    require the use of the decompression
                                                  Administrator of the DEA Office of                        Labor, 200 Constitution Avenue NW.,                   values specified in decompression
                                                  Diversion Control (‘‘Deputy Assistant                     Room N–3647, Washington, DC 20210;                    tables in Appendix A of the
                                                  Administrator’’) pursuant to section 7 of                 telephone: (202) 693–1999; email:                     compressed-air standard for
                                                  28 CFR part 0, appendix to subpart R.                     Meilinger.francis2@dol.gov.                           construction (29 CFR 1926.803(f)(1));
                                                     In accordance with 21 CFR                                 General and technical information:                 and (3) require the use of automated
                                                  1301.33(a), this is notice that on March                  Contact Mr. Kevin Robinson, Acting                    operational controls and a special
                                                  20, 2014, Apertus Pharmaceuticals, 331                    Director, Office of Technical Programs                decompression chamber (29 CFR
                                                  Consort Drive, St. Louis, Missouri                        and Coordination Activities, Directorate              1926.803(g)(1)(iii) and .803(g)(1)(xvii),
                                                  63011, applied to be registered as a bulk                 of Technical Support and Emergency                    respectively).
                                                  manufacturer of the following basic                       Management, Occupational Safety and                      The applicant is a contractor that
                                                  classes of controlled substances:                         Health Administration, U.S. Department                works on complex tunnel projects using
                                                                                                            of Labor, 200 Constitution Avenue NW.,                recently developed equipment and
                                                          Controlled substance                 Schedule     Room N–3655, Washington, DC 20210;                    procedures for soft-ground tunneling.
                                                                                                            phone: (202) 693–2110 or email:                       The applicant’s workers engage in the
                                                  Marihuana (7360) .........................   I                                                                  construction of tunnels using advanced
                                                  Tetrahydrocannabinols (7370) .....           I
                                                                                                            robinson.kevin@dol.gov.
                                                                                                            SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
                                                                                                                                                                  shielded mechanical excavation
mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with NOTICES




                                                    The company plans to divide the                           Copies of this Federal Register                       1 See Section III discussion of condition A Scope.
                                                  synthesized cannabidiol, with a portion                   notice. Electronic copies of this Federal               2 The decompression tables in Appendix A of
                                                  going for sale as an API in nabiximol.                    Register notice are available at http://              subpart S express the maximum working pressures
                                                  The raw material will be used to                          www.regulations.gov. This Federal                     as pounds per square inch gauge (p.s.i.g.), with a
                                                  synthesize dronabinol. Therefore, they                    Register notice, as well as news releases             maximum working pressure of 50 p.s.i.g. Therefore,
                                                                                                                                                                  throughout this notice, OSHA expresses the 50 p.s.i.
                                                  anticipate consuming and purchasing                       and other relevant information, also are              value specified by § 1926.803(e)(5) as 50 p.s.i.g.,
                                                  small quantities of CS for generating                     available at OSHA’s Web page at                       consistent with the terminology in Appendix A,
                                                  data to support the Drug Master File                      http://www.osha.gov.                                  Table 1 of subpart S.



                                             VerDate Sep<11>2014    20:59 Mar 26, 2015    Jkt 235001   PO 00000   Frm 00082   Fmt 4703   Sfmt 4703   E:\FR\FM\27MRN1.SGM    27MRN1


                                                                                  Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 59 / Friday, March 27, 2015 / Notices                                           16441

                                                  techniques in conjunction with an earth                    In addition to innovations in tunnel-              a permanent variance. Further, on
                                                  pressure balanced tunnel boring                         excavation methods, Traylor JV asserts                December 11, 2014, OSHA published a
                                                  machine (EPBTBM).                                       that innovations in hyperbaric medicine               Federal Register notice announcing
                                                     According to its application, Traylor                and technology improve the safety of                  Traylor JV’s application for a permanent
                                                  is currently the managing partner of                    decompression from hyperbaric                         variance and interim order, grant of an
                                                  Traylor/Skanska/Jay Dee Joint Venture                   exposures. According to Traylor JV, the               interim order, and request for comments
                                                  (‘‘Traylor JV’’), the general contractor for            use of decompression protocols                        (79 FR 73631) for the Blue Plains
                                                  the DC Water and Sewer Authority’s                      incorporating oxygen is at least as                   Tunnel project.
                                                  project to construct the Blue Plains                    effective for tunnel workers as
                                                                                                          compliance with the decompression                     II. The Variance Application
                                                  Tunnel. Traylor JV asserts that
                                                  generally, it bores tunnels (i.e., Blue                 tables specified by the existing OSHA                 A. Background
                                                  Plains Tunnel) below the water table                    standard (29 CFR part 1926, subpart S,
                                                                                                                                                                   As indicated earlier in this notice,
                                                  through soft soils consisting of clay, silt,            Appendix A decompression tables).
                                                                                                                                                                Traylor JV asserts that the advances in
                                                  and sand. Traylor JV employs specially                  These hyperbaric exposures are possible
                                                                                                                                                                tunnel excavation technology described
                                                  trained personnel for the construction of               due to advances in technology, a better
                                                                                                                                                                in Section I of this notice modified
                                                  the tunnel, and states that this                        understanding of hyperbaric medicine,
                                                                                                                                                                significantly the equipment and
                                                  construction will use shielded                          and the development of a project-
                                                                                                                                                                methods used by contractors to
                                                  mechanical-excavation techniques.                       specific Hyperbaric Operations Manual
                                                                                                                                                                construct subaqueous tunnels, thereby
                                                  Traylor JV asserts that its workers                     (HOM) that requires specialized medical
                                                                                                                                                                making several provisions of OSHA’s
                                                  perform hyperbaric interventions at                     support and hyperbaric supervision to
                                                                                                                                                                compressed-air standard for
                                                  pressures greater than 50 p.s.i.g. in the               provide assistance to a team of specially
                                                                                                          trained man-lock attendants and                       construction at 29 CFR 1926.803
                                                  excavation chamber of the EPBTBM;                                                                             inappropriate for this type of work.
                                                  these interventions consist of                          hyperbaric or compressed-air workers.
                                                                                                             OSHA initiated a technical review of               These advances reduce both the number
                                                  conducting inspections and                                                                                    of workers exposed, and the total
                                                  maintenance work on the cutter-head                     the Traylor JV’s variance application
                                                                                                          and developed a set of follow-up                      duration of exposure, to the hyperbaric
                                                  structure and cutting tools of the                                                                            conditions associated with tunnel
                                                  EPBTBM.                                                 questions that it sent to Traylor JV on
                                                                                                          September 17, 2012 (Ex. OSHA–2012–                    construction.
                                                     Traylor JV asserts that innovations in                                                                        Using shielded mechanical-
                                                                                                          0035–0003). On October 26, 2012,
                                                  tunnel excavation, specifically with                                                                          excavation techniques, in conjunction
                                                                                                          Traylor JV submitted its response and a
                                                  EPBTBMs, have, in most cases,                                                                                 with pre-cast concrete tunnel liners and
                                                                                                          request for an interim order for the Blue
                                                  eliminated the need to pressurize the                                                                         backfill grout, EPBTBMs provide
                                                                                                          Plains Tunnel Project (Ex. OSHA–2012–
                                                  entire tunnel. This technology negates                                                                        methods to achieve the face pressures
                                                                                                          0035–0008). In its response to OSHA’s
                                                  the requirement that all members of a                                                                         required to maintain a stabilized tunnel
                                                                                                          follow-up questions, Traylor JV
                                                  tunnel-excavation crew work in                          indicated that the maximum pressure to                face, through various geologies, while
                                                  compressed air while excavating the                     which it is likely to expose workers                  isolating that pressure to the forward
                                                  tunnel. These advances in technology                    during interventions for the Blue Plains              section (working or excavation chamber)
                                                  modified substantially the methods                      Tunnel project is 52 p.s.i.g. and does not            of the EPBTBM.
                                                  used by the construction industry to                    involve the use of trimix breathing gas                  Interventions involving the working
                                                  excavate subaqueous tunnels compared                    (composed of a mixture of oxygen,                     chamber (the pressurized chamber at the
                                                  to the caisson work regulated by the                    nitrogen, and helium in varying                       head of the EPBTBM) take place only
                                                  current OSHA compressed-air standard                    concentrations used for breathing by                  after the applicant halts tunnel
                                                  for construction at 29 CFR 1926.803.                    compressed air workers for compression                excavation and prepares the machine
                                                  Such advances reduce the number of                      and decompression when working at                     and crew for an intervention.
                                                  workers exposed, and the total duration                 pressures exceeding 73 p.s.i.g.).                     Interventions occur to inspect or
                                                  of exposure, to hyperbaric pressure                     Therefore, to work effectively on this                maintain the mechanical-excavation
                                                  during tunnel construction.                             project, Traylor JV must perform                      components located in the forward
                                                     Using shielded mechanical-                           hyperbaric interventions in compressed                portion of the working chamber.
                                                  excavation techniques, in conjunction                   air at pressures higher than the                      Maintenance conducted in the forward
                                                  with precast concrete tunnel liners and                 maximum pressure specified by the                     portion of the working chamber
                                                  backfill grout, EPBTBMs provide                         existing OSHA standard, 29 CFR                        includes changing replaceable cutting
                                                  methods to achieve the face pressures                   1926.803(e)(5), which states: ‘‘No                    tools, disposable wear bars, and, in rare
                                                  required to maintain a stabilized tunnel                employee shall be subjected to pressure               cases, repairs to the cutter head due to
                                                  face through various geologies, and                     exceeding 50 p.s.i.g. except in                       structural damage.
                                                  isolate that pressure to the forward                    emergency’’ (see footnote 2).                            In addition to innovations in tunnel-
                                                  section (the working chamber) of the                       OSHA considered Traylor JV’s                       excavation methods, research conducted
                                                  EPBTBM. Interventions in the working                    application for a permanent variance                  after OSHA published its compressed-
                                                  chamber (the pressurized portion of the                 and interim order for the Blue Plains                 air standard for construction in 1971,
                                                  EPBTBM) take place only after halting                   Tunnel project. OSHA determined that                  resulted in advances in hyperbaric
                                                  tunnel excavation and preparing the                     Traylor JV proposed an alternative that               medicine. In this regard, the applicant
                                                  machine and crew for an intervention.                   will provide a workplace as safe and                  asserts that the use of decompression
mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with NOTICES




                                                  Interventions occur to inspect or                       healthful as that provided by the                     protocols incorporating oxygen is more
                                                  maintain the mechanical-excavation                      standard. On July 11, 2013, OSHA                      efficient, effective, and safer for tunnel
                                                  components located in the working                       granted Traylor JV a project-specific                 workers than compliance with the
                                                  chamber. Maintenance conducted in the                   interim order for the completion of the               existing OSHA standard (29 CFR part
                                                  working chamber includes changing                       Blue Plains Tunnel (Ex. OSHA–2012–                    1926, subpart S, Appendix A
                                                  replaceable cutting tools and disposable                0035–0011) in order to permit the                     decompression tables). According to the
                                                  wear bars, and, in rare cases, repairing                applicant to begin work while OSHA                    applicant, contractors routinely and
                                                  structural damage to the cutter head.                   continued to consider its application for             safely expose employees performing


                                             VerDate Sep<11>2014   20:59 Mar 26, 2015   Jkt 235001   PO 00000   Frm 00083   Fmt 4703   Sfmt 4703   E:\FR\FM\27MRN1.SGM   27MRN1


                                                  16442                           Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 59 / Friday, March 27, 2015 / Notices

                                                  interventions in the working chamber of                 working chamber between the man-lock                  for emergency evacuation and medical
                                                  EPBTBMs to hyperbaric pressures up to                   door and the entry door to the forward                treatment; the shuttle attaches to the
                                                  75 p.s.i.g., which is 50% higher than                   working chamber. The forward working                  topside medical lock, which is a large
                                                  maximum pressure specified by the                       chamber is immediately behind the                     recompression chamber. The applicant
                                                  existing OSHA standard (see 29 CFR                      cutter head and tunnel face.                          believes that the procedures included in
                                                  1926.803(e)(5)).                                           The applicant will pressurize the                  the HOM provide safe work conditions
                                                     The applicant contends that the                      working chamber to the level required                 when interventions are necessary,
                                                  alternative safety measures included in                 to maintain a stable tunnel face.                     including interventions above 50 p.s.i.g.
                                                  its application provide its workers with                Pressure in the staging chamber ranges
                                                  a place of employment that is at least as               from atmospheric (no increased                        C. Variance From Paragraph (f)(1) of 29
                                                  safe and healthful as they would obtain                 pressure) to a maximum pressure equal                 CFR 1926.803, Requirement To Use
                                                  under the existing provisions of OSHA’s                 to the pressure in the working chamber.               OSHA Decompression Tables
                                                  compressed-air standard for                             The applicant asserts that most of the                   OSHA’s compressed-air standard for
                                                  construction. The applicant certifies                   hyperbaric interventions will be around               construction requires decompression in
                                                  that it provided employee                               14.7 p.s.i.g. However, the applicant                  accordance with the decompression
                                                  representatives of affected workers with                maintains that they may have to perform               tables in Appendix A of 29 CFR part
                                                  a copy of the variance application.3 The                interventions at pressures up to 52                   1926, subpart S (see 29 CFR
                                                  applicant also certifies that it notified its           p.s.i.g.                                              1926.803(f)(1)). As an alternative to the
                                                  workers of the variance application by                     During interventions, workers enter                OSHA decompression tables, the
                                                  posting, at prominent locations where it                the working chamber through one of the                applicant proposes to use newer
                                                  normally posts workplace notices, a                     twin man locks that open into the                     decompression schedules that
                                                  summary of the application and                          staging chamber. To reach the forward                 supplement breathing air used during
                                                  information specifying where the                        part of the working chamber, workers                  decompression with pure oxygen. The
                                                  workers can examine a copy of the                       pass through a door in a bulkhead that                applicant asserts that these
                                                  application. In addition, the applicant                 separates the staging chamber from the                decompression protocols are safer for
                                                  informed its workers and their                          forward working chamber. The                          tunnel workers than the decompression
                                                  representatives of their rights to petition             maximum crew size allowed in the                      protocols specified in Appendix A of 29
                                                  the Assistant Secretary of Labor for                    forward working chamber is three. At                  CFR part 1926, subpart S.
                                                  Occupational Safety and Health for a                    certain hyperbaric pressures (i.e., when                 Accordingly, the applicant proposes
                                                  hearing on the variance application.                    decompression times are greater than                  to use the 1992 French Decompression
                                                                                                          work times), the twin man locks allow                 Tables to decompress CAWs after they
                                                  B. Variance From Paragraph (e)(5) of 29                 for crew rotation. During crew rotation,              exit the hyperbaric conditions in the
                                                  CFR 1926.803, Prohibition of Exposure                   one crew can be compressing or                        working chamber. Depending on the
                                                  to Pressure Greater Than 50 p.s.i.g. (See               decompressing while the second crew is                maximum working pressure and
                                                  Footnote 1)                                             working. Therefore, the working crew                  exposure times, the 1992 French
                                                     The applicant states that it may                     always has an unoccupied man lock at                  Decompression Tables provide for air
                                                  perform hyperbaric interventions at                     its disposal.                                         decompression with or without oxygen.
                                                  pressures greater than 50 p.s.i.g. in the                  The applicant developed a project-                 Traylor JV asserts that oxygen
                                                  working chamber of the EPBTBM; this                     specific HOM for the Blue Plains                      decompression has many benefits,
                                                  pressure exceeds the pressure limit of                  Tunnel (Ex. OSHA–2012–0035–0007)                      including (1) keeping the partial
                                                  50 p.s.i.g. specified for nonemergency                  that describes in detail the hyperbaric               pressure of nitrogen in the lungs as low
                                                  purposes by 29 CFR 1926.803(e)(5). The                  procedures and required medical                       as possible; (2) keeping external
                                                  EPBTBM has twin man locks, with each                    examinations used during the tunnel-                  pressure as low as possible to reduce the
                                                  man lock having two compartments.                       construction project. The HOM                         formation of bubbles in the blood; (3)
                                                  This configuration allows workers to                    discusses standard operating procedures               removing nitrogen from the lungs and
                                                  access the man locks for compression                    and emergency and contingency                         arterial blood and increasing the rate of
                                                  and decompression, and medical                          procedures. The procedures include                    elimination of nitrogen; (4) improving
                                                  personnel to access the man locks if                    using experienced and knowledgeable                   the quality of breathing during
                                                  required in an emergency.                               man-lock attendants who have the                      decompression stops so that workers are
                                                     EPBTBMs are capable of maintaining                   training and experience necessary to                  less tired and to prevent bone necrosis;
                                                  pressure at the tunnel face, and                        recognize and treat decompression                     (5) reducing decompression time by
                                                  stabilizing existing geological                         illnesses and injuries. The attendants                about 33 percent as compared to air
                                                  conditions, through the controlled use                  are under the direct supervision of the               decompression; and (6) reducing
                                                  of propel cylinders, a mechanically                     hyperbaric supervisor and attending                   inflammation. As described in Section V
                                                  driven cutter head, bulkheads within                    physician. In addition, procedures                    of this notice, OSHA’s review of the use
                                                  the shield, ground-treatment foam, and                  include medical screening and review of               of oxygen in several major tunneling
                                                  a screw conveyor that moves excavated                   prospective compressed-air workers                    projects completed in the past indicates
                                                  material from the working chamber. As                   (CAWs). The purpose of this screening                 that it contributed significantly to the
                                                  noted earlier, the forward-most portion                 procedure is to vet prospective CAWs                  reduction of decompression illness
                                                  of the EPBTBM is the working chamber,                   with medical conditions (e.g., deep vein              (DCI) and other associated adverse
                                                  and this chamber is the only pressurized                thrombosis, poor vascular circulation,                effects observed and reported among
mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with NOTICES




                                                  segment of the EPBTBM. Within the                       and muscle cramping) that could be                    CAWs.
                                                  shield, the working chamber consists of                 aggravated by sitting in a cramped space                 In addition, the HOM requires a
                                                  two sections: The staging chamber and                   (e.g., a man lock) for extended periods               physician certified in hyperbaric
                                                  the forward working chamber. The                        or by exposure to elevated pressures and              medicine to manage the medical
                                                  staging chamber is the section of the                   compressed gas mixtures. A                            condition of CAWs during hyperbaric
                                                                                                          transportable recompression chamber                   exposures and decompression. A
                                                   3 See the definition of ‘‘Affected employee or         (shuttle) is available to extract workers             trained and experienced man-lock
                                                  worker’’ in section VI. D.                              from the hyperbaric working chamber                   attendant also will be present during


                                             VerDate Sep<11>2014   20:59 Mar 26, 2015   Jkt 235001   PO 00000   Frm 00084   Fmt 4703   Sfmt 4703   E:\FR\FM\27MRN1.SGM   27MRN1


                                                                                  Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 59 / Friday, March 27, 2015 / Notices                                                 16443

                                                  hyperbaric exposures and                                DCI than the OSHA decompression                            use a special decompression chamber
                                                  decompression. This man-lock                            requirements of 29 CFR 1926.803,                           when total decompression time exceeds
                                                  attendant will operate the hyperbaric                   which specify the use of automatically                     75 minutes (see 29 CFR
                                                  system to ensure compliance with the                    regulated continuous decompression                         1926.803(g)(1)(xvii)). Another provision
                                                  specified decompression table. A                        (see footnotes 9 through 14 in this                        of OSHA’s compressed-air standard
                                                  hyperbaric supervisor (competent                        notice for references to these studies).4                  calls for locating the special
                                                  person), trained in hyperbaric                          In addition, the applicant asserts that                    decompression chamber adjacent to the
                                                  operations, procedures, and safety,                     staged decompression is at least as                        man lock on the atmospheric pressure
                                                  directly oversees all hyperbaric                        effective as an automatic controller in                    side of the tunnel bulkhead (see 29 CFR
                                                  interventions, and ensures that staff                   regulating the decompression process                       1926.803(g)(2)(vii)). However, since
                                                  follow the procedures delineated in the                 because:                                                   only the working chamber of the
                                                  HOM or by the attending physician.                         1. A hyperbaric supervisor (a                           EPBTBM is under pressure, and only a
                                                     The applicant asserts that at higher                 competent person experienced and                           few workers out of the entire crew are
                                                  hyperbaric pressures, decompression                     trained in hyperbaric operations,                          exposed to hyperbaric pressure, the man
                                                  times exceed 75 minutes. The HOM                        procedures, and safety) directly                           locks (which, as noted earlier, connect
                                                  establishes protocols and procedures                    supervises all hyperbaric interventions                    directly to the working chamber) are of
                                                  that provide the basis for alternate                    and ensures that the man-lock                              sufficient size to accommodate the
                                                  means of protection for CAWs under                      attendant, who is a competent person in                    exposed workers. In addition, available
                                                  these conditions. Accordingly, based on                 the manual control of hyperbaric                           space in the EPBTBM does not allow for
                                                  these protocols and procedures, the                     systems, follows the schedule specified                    an additional special decompression
                                                  applicant requests to use the 1992                      in the decompression tables, including                     lock. Again, the applicant uses the man
                                                  French Decompression Tables for                         stops; and                                                 locks, each of which adequately
                                                  hyperbaric interventions up to 52 p.s.i.g.                 2. The use of the 1992 French                           accommodates a three-member crew, for
                                                  for completion of the Blue Plains                       Decompression Tables for staged                            this purpose when decompression lasts
                                                  Tunnel project. The applicant is                        decompression offers an equal or better                    up to 75 minutes. When decompression
                                                  committed to follow the decompression                   level of management and control over                       exceeds 75 minutes, crews can open the
                                                  procedures described in the Blue Plains                 the decompression process than an                          door connecting the two compartments
                                                  Tunnel project-specific HOM during                      automatic controller and results in                        in each man lock during decompression
                                                  these interventions.                                    lower occurrences of DCI.                                  stops or exit the man lock and move
                                                                                                             Accordingly, the applicant is applying                  into the staging chamber where
                                                  D. Variance From Paragraph (g)(1)(iii) of               for a permanent variance from the
                                                  29 CFR 1926.803, Automatically                                                                                     additional space is available. This
                                                                                                          OSHA standard at 29 CFR                                    alternative enables CAWs to move about
                                                  Regulated Continuous Decompression                      1926.803(g)(1)(iii), which requires                        and flex their joints to prevent
                                                     According to the applicant, breathing                automatic controls to regulate                             neuromuscular problems during
                                                  air under hyperbaric conditions                         decompression. As noted above, the                         decompression.
                                                  increases the amount of nitrogen gas                    applicant is committed to conduct the
                                                  dissolved in a CAW’s tissues. The                       staged decompression according to the                      F. Previous Tunnel Construction
                                                  greater the hyperbaric pressure under                   1992 French Decompression Tables                           Variance
                                                  these conditions, and the more time                     under the direct control of the trained                       OSHA notes that on May 23, 2014, it
                                                  spent under the increased pressure, the                 man-lock attendant and under the                           granted a sub-aqueous tunnel
                                                  greater the amount of nitrogen gas                      oversight of the hyperbaric supervisor.                    construction permanent variance to
                                                  dissolved in the tissues. When the                                                                                 Tully/OHL USA Joint Venture (79 FR
                                                  pressure decreases during                               E. Variance From Paragraph (g)(1)(xvii)
                                                                                                                                                                     29809) from the same provisions of the
                                                  decompression, tissues release the                      of 29 CFR 1926.803, Requirement of
                                                                                                                                                                     standard that regulates work in
                                                  dissolved nitrogen gas into the blood                   Special Decompression Chamber
                                                                                                                                                                     compressed air (at 29 CFR
                                                  system, which then carries the nitrogen                   The OSHA compressed-air standard                         1926.803(e)(5), (f)(1), (g)(1)(iii), and
                                                  gas to the lungs for elimination through                for construction requires employers to                     (g)(1)(xvii)) that are the subject of the
                                                  exhalation. Releasing hyperbaric                                                                                   present application. Generally, the
                                                  pressure too rapidly during                                4 In the study cited in footnote 11, starting at page
                                                                                                                                                                     alternate conditions in this notice are
                                                  decompression can increase the size of                  338, Dr. Eric Kindwall notes that the use of
                                                                                                          automatically regulated continuous decompression
                                                                                                                                                                     based on and very similar to the
                                                  the bubbles formed by nitrogen gas in                   in the Washington State safety standards for               alternate conditions of the previous
                                                  the blood system, resulting in DCI,                     compressed-air work (from which OSHA derived its           permanent variance.
                                                  commonly referred to as ‘‘the bends.’’                  decompression tables) was at the insistence of
                                                  This description of the etiology of DCI                 contractors and the union, and against the advice          G. Multi-State Variance
                                                                                                          of the expert who calculated the decompression
                                                  is consistent with current scientific                   table and recommended using staged
                                                                                                                                                                       As stated earlier in this notice,
                                                  theory and research on the issue (see                   decompression. Dr. Kindwall then states,                   Traylor JV applied for an interim order
                                                  footnote 13 in this notice discussing a                 ‘‘Continuous decompression is inefficient and              for its Blue Plains Tunnel project only.
                                                  1985 NIOSH report on DCI).                              wasteful. For example, if the last stage from 4 psig       On July 11, 2013, OSHA granted an
                                                                                                          . . . to the surface took 1 h, at least half the time
                                                     The 1992 French Decompression                        is spent at pressures less than 2 psig . . ., which
                                                                                                                                                                     interim order to cover only the Blue
                                                  Tables proposed for use by the applicant                provides less and less meaningful bubble                   Plains Tunnel project, which is located
                                                  provide for stops during worker                         suppression . . .’’ In addition, the report referenced     entirely in the District of Columbia and
                                                                                                          in footnote 5 under the section titled, ‘‘Background
mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with NOTICES




                                                  decompression (i.e., staged                                                                                        thus under Federal OSHA’s exclusive
                                                                                                          on the Need for Interim Decompression Tables’’
                                                  decompression) to control the release of                addresses the continuous-decompression protocol
                                                                                                                                                                     jurisdiction. Further, on December 11,
                                                  nitrogen gas from tissues into the blood                in the OSHA compressed-air standard for                    2014, OSHA published a Federal
                                                  system. Studies show that staged                        construction, noting that ‘‘[a]side from the tables for    Register notice announcing Traylor JV’s
                                                  decompression, in combination with                      saturation diving to deep depths, no other widely          application for a permanent variance
                                                                                                          used or officially approved diving decompression
                                                  other features of the 1992 French                       tables use straight line, continuous decompressions
                                                                                                                                                                     and interim order, grant of an interim
                                                  Decompression Tables such as the use                    at varying rates. Stage decompression is usually the       order, and request for comments (79 FR
                                                  of oxygen, result in a lower incidence of               rule, since it is simpler to control.’’                    73631).


                                             VerDate Sep<11>2014   20:59 Mar 26, 2015   Jkt 235001   PO 00000   Frm 00085   Fmt 4703   Sfmt 4703    E:\FR\FM\27MRN1.SGM     27MRN1


                                                  16444                           Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 59 / Friday, March 27, 2015 / Notices

                                                    Additionally, twenty-seven state                      Blue Plains Tunnel project and does not               enforce its safety and health procedures
                                                  safety and health plans have been                       apply to any other employers.                         and measures.8
                                                  approved by OSHA under section 18 of
                                                                                                          Condition B: Application                              Condition F: Communication
                                                  the (OSH) Act.5 As part of the
                                                  permanent variance process, the                            This condition specifies the                          Condition F requires the applicant to
                                                  Directorate of Cooperative and State                    circumstances under which the                         develop and implement an effective
                                                  Programs will notify the State Plans of                 permanent variance is in effect, notably              system of information sharing and
                                                  Traylor JV’s variance application and                   only for hyperbaric work performed                    communication. Effective information
                                                  grant of the Blue Plains permanent                      during interventions. The condition                   sharing and communication ensures
                                                  variance. In considering Traylor JV’s                   places clear limits on the circumstances              that affected workers receive updated
                                                  application for a permanent variance                    under which the applicant can expose                  information regarding any safety-related
                                                  and interim order, OSHA noted that                      its employees to hyperbaric pressure.
                                                  four states have previously granted sub-                                                                      hazards and incidents, and corrective
                                                  aqueous tunnel construction variances                   Condition C: List of Abbreviations                    actions taken, prior to the start of each
                                                  and imposed different or additional                                                                           shift. The condition also requires the
                                                                                                            Condition C defines a number of                     applicant to ensure that reliable means
                                                  requirements and conditions (California,
                                                                                                          abbreviations used in the permanent                   of emergency communications are
                                                  Nevada, Oregon, and Washington).
                                                                                                          variance. OSHA believes that defining                 available and maintained for affected
                                                  California also promulgated a new
                                                                                                          these abbreviations serves to clarify and             workers and support personnel during
                                                  standard 6 for similar sub-aqueous
                                                  tunnel construction work.                               standardize their usage, thereby                      hyperbaric operations. Availability of
                                                                                                          enhancing the applicant’s and its                     such reliable means of communications
                                                  III. Description of the Conditions                      employees’ understanding of the                       enables affected workers and support
                                                  Specified for the Permanent Variance                    conditions specified by the permanent                 personnel to respond quickly and
                                                     This section describes the alternative               variance.                                             effectively to hazardous conditions or
                                                  means of compliance with 29 CFR                         Condition D: Definitions                              emergencies that may develop during
                                                  1926.803(e)(5), (f)(1), (g)(1)(iii), and                                                                      EPBTBM operations.
                                                  (g)(1)(xvii) and provides additional                      The condition defines a series of
                                                  detail regarding the conditions that form               terms, mostly technical terms, used in                Condition G: Worker Qualification and
                                                  the basis of Traylor JV’s permanent                     the permanent variance to standardize                 Training
                                                  variance.                                               and clarify their meaning. Defining
                                                                                                                                                                   This condition requires the applicant
                                                                                                          these terms serves to enhance the
                                                  Condition A: Scope                                                                                            to develop and implement an effective
                                                                                                          applicant’s and its employees’
                                                     The scope of the permanent variance                                                                        qualification and training program for
                                                                                                          understanding of the conditions
                                                  limits coverage to the work situations                                                                        affected workers. The condition
                                                                                                          specified by the permanent variance.
                                                  specified under this condition. Clearly                                                                       specifies the factors that an affected
                                                  defining the scope of the permanent                     Condition E: Safety and Health                        worker must know to perform safely
                                                  variance provides Traylor JV, Traylor                   Practices                                             during hyperbaric operations, including
                                                  JV’s employees, other stakeholders, the                                                                       how to enter, work in, and exit from
                                                                                                             This condition requires the applicant              hyperbaric conditions under both
                                                  public, and OSHA with necessary                         to develop and submit to OSHA an
                                                  information regarding the work                                                                                normal and emergency conditions.
                                                                                                          HOM specific to the Blue Plains project               Having well-trained and qualified
                                                  situations in which the permanent
                                                                                                          at least six months before using the                  workers performing hyperbaric
                                                  variance applies.
                                                     According to 29 CFR 1905.11, an                      EPBTBM for tunneling operations.
                                                                                                                                                                intervention work ensures that they
                                                  employer or class or group of                           Additionally, the condition includes a
                                                                                                                                                                recognize, and respond appropriately to,
                                                  employers 7 may request a permanent                     series of related hazard prevention and
                                                                                                                                                                hyperbaric safety and health hazards.
                                                  variance for a specific workplace or                    control requirements and methods (e.g.,
                                                                                                                                                                These qualification and training
                                                  workplaces. If granted, the variance                    decompression tables, job hazard
                                                                                                                                                                requirements enable affected workers to
                                                  applies to the specific employer(s) that                analyses (JHA), operations and
                                                                                                                                                                cope effectively with emergencies, as
                                                  submitted the application. In this                      inspections checklists, incident
                                                                                                                                                                well as the discomfort and physiological
                                                  instance, the permanent variance                        investigation, recording and notification
                                                                                                                                                                effects of hyperbaric exposure, thereby
                                                  applies to the applicant, Traylor/                      to OSHA of recordable hyperbaric
                                                                                                                                                                preventing worker injury, illness, and
                                                  Skanska/Jay Dee Joint Venture at the                    injuries and illnesses, etc.) designed to
                                                                                                                                                                fatalities.
                                                                                                          ensure the continued effective
                                                    5 Five State Plans (Connecticut, Illinois, New        functioning of the hyperbaric equipment                  Paragraph (2)(e) of this condition also
                                                  Jersey, New York, and the Virgin Islands) limit their   and operating system.                                 requires the applicant to provide
                                                  occupational safety and health authority to state
                                                                                                             Review of the HOM enables OSHA to:                 affected workers with information they
                                                  and local employers only. State Plans that exercise                                                           can use to contact the appropriate
                                                  their occupational safety and health authority over     (1) Determine that the safety and health
                                                  both public- and private-sector employers are:          instructions and measures it specifies                healthcare professionals if they believe
                                                  Alaska, Arizona, California, Hawaii, Indiana, Iowa,     are appropriate and do adequately                     they are developing hyperbaric-related
                                                  Kentucky, Maryland, Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada,
                                                                                                          protect the safety and health of the                  health effects. This requirement
                                                  New Mexico, North Carolina, Oregon, Puerto Rico,                                                              provides for early intervention and
                                                  South Carolina, Tennessee, Utah, Vermont,               CAWs; and (2) request the applicant to
                                                  Virginia, Washington, and Wyoming.                      revise or modify the HOM if it finds that             treatment of DCI and other health effects
mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with NOTICES




                                                    6 See California Code of Regulations, Title 8,
                                                                                                          the hyperbaric safety and health                      resulting from hyperbaric exposure,
                                                  Subchapter 7, Group 26, Article 154, available at
                                                                                                          procedures are not suitable for the                   thereby reducing the potential severity
                                                  http://www.dir.ca.gov/title8/sb7g26a154.html.                                                                 of these effects.
                                                    7 A class or group of employers (such as members      specific project and do not adequately
                                                  of a trade alliance or association) may apply jointly   protect the safety and health of the
                                                  for a variance provided an authorized                                                                           8 Grant of the July 11, 2013, project-specific
                                                                                                          CAWs. Once approved, the project-
                                                  representative for each employer signs the                                                                    interim order constituted OSHA’s approval of
                                                  application and the application identifies each
                                                                                                          specific HOM becomes part of the                      Traylor JV’s Blue Plains Tunnel project-specific
                                                  employer’s affected facilities.                         variance, thus enabling OSHA to                       HOM.



                                             VerDate Sep<11>2014   20:59 Mar 26, 2015   Jkt 235001   PO 00000   Frm 00086   Fmt 4703   Sfmt 4703   E:\FR\FM\27MRN1.SGM   27MRN1


                                                                                  Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 59 / Friday, March 27, 2015 / Notices                                           16445

                                                  Condition H: Inspections, Tests, and                    1904.8 through 1904.12), enables the                  do business, has a new address or
                                                  Accident Prevention                                     applicant and OSHA to determine the                   location for its main office, or transfers
                                                    Condition H requires the applicant to                 effectiveness of the permanent variance               the operations covered by the
                                                  develop, implement, and operate a                       in preventing DCI and other hyperbaric-               permanent variance to a successor
                                                  program of frequent and regular                         related effects.9                                     company. In addition, the condition
                                                                                                                                                                specifies that OSHA must approve the
                                                  inspections of the EPBTBM’s hyperbaric                  Condition K: Notifications
                                                                                                                                                                transfer of the permanent variance to a
                                                  equipment and support systems, and                         Under this condition, the applicant is             successor company. These requirements
                                                  associated work areas. This condition                   required, within specified periods to: (1)            allow OSHA to communicate effectively
                                                  helps to ensure the safe operation and                  Notify OSHA of any recordable injuries,               with the applicant regarding the status
                                                  physical integrity of the equipment and                 illnesses, in-patient hospitalizations,               of the permanent variance, and expedite
                                                  work areas necessary to conduct                         amputations, loss of an eye, or fatalities            the Agency’s administration and
                                                  hyperbaric operations. The condition                    that occur as a result of hyperbaric                  enforcement of the permanent variance.
                                                  also enhances worker safety by reducing                 exposures during EPBTBM operations;                   Stipulating that an applicant must have
                                                  the risk of hyperbaric-related                          (2) provide OSHA with a copy of the                   OSHA’s approval to transfer a variance
                                                  emergencies.                                            incident investigation report (using                  to a successor company provides
                                                    Paragraph (3) of this condition                       OSHA 301 form) of these events; (3)                   assurance that the successor company
                                                  requires the applicant to document                      include on the 301 form information on                has knowledge of, and will comply
                                                  tests, inspections, corrective actions,                 the hyperbaric conditions associated                  with, the conditions specified by the
                                                  and repairs involving the EPBTBM, and                   with the recordable injury or illness, the            permanent variance, thereby ensuring
                                                  maintain these documents at the job site                root-cause determination, and                         the safety of workers involved in
                                                  for the duration of the job. This                       preventive and corrective actions                     performing the operations covered by
                                                  requirement provides the applicant with                 identified and implemented; (4) provide               the permanent variance.
                                                  information needed to schedule tests                    its certification that it informed affected
                                                  and inspections to ensure the continued                 workers of the incident and the results               IV. Comments on the Proposed
                                                  safe operation of the equipment and                     of the incident investigation; (5) notify             Variance Application
                                                  systems, and to determine that the                      the Office of Technical Programs and                    OSHA received no comments on the
                                                  actions taken to correct defects in                     Coordination Activities (OTPCA) and                   proposed variance, including no
                                                  hyperbaric equipment and systems were                   the Baltimore/Washington DC Area                      comments from State Plans.
                                                  appropriate, prior to returning them to                 Office within 15 working days should
                                                  service.                                                                                                      V. Decision
                                                                                                          the applicant need to revise its HOM to
                                                                                                          accommodate changes in its                               After reviewing Traylor JV’s proposed
                                                  Condition I: Compression and
                                                                                                          compressed-air operations that affect its             variance as described above, and having
                                                  Decompression
                                                                                                          ability to comply with the conditions of              received no comment, OSHA
                                                     This condition requires the applicant                the permanent variance; and (6) provide               determines that:
                                                  to consult with its designated medical                  OTPCA and the Baltimore/Washington                       A. Traylor JV developed, and
                                                  advisor regarding special compression                   DC Area Office, at the end of the project,            proposed to implement, effective
                                                  or decompression procedures                             with a report evaluating the                          alternative measures to the prohibition
                                                  appropriate for any un-acclimated CAW.                  effectiveness of the decompression                    of using compressed air under
                                                  This provision ensures that the                         tables.                                               hyperbaric conditions exceeding 50
                                                  applicant consults with the medical                        These notification requirements                    p.s.i.g. The alternative measures include
                                                  advisor, and involves the medical                       enable the applicant, its employees, and              use of engineering and administrative
                                                  advisor in the evaluation, development,                 OSHA to determine the effectiveness of                controls of the hazards associated with
                                                  and implementation of compression or                    the permanent variance in providing the               work performed in compressed-air
                                                  decompression protocols appropriate for                 requisite level of safety to the                      conditions exceeding 50 p.s.i.g. while
                                                  any CAW requiring acclimation to the                    applicant’s workers and, based on this                engaged in the construction of a
                                                  hyperbaric conditions encountered                       determination, whether to revise or                   subaqueous tunnel using advanced
                                                  during EPBTBM operations.                               revoke the conditions of the permanent                shielded mechanical-excavation
                                                  Accordingly, CAWs requiring                             variance. Timely notification permits                 techniques in conjunction with an
                                                  acclimation have an opportunity to                      OSHA to take whatever action may be                   EPBTBM. Prior to conducting
                                                  acclimate prior to exposure to these                    necessary and appropriate to prevent                  interventions in the EPBTBM’s
                                                  hyperbaric conditions. OSHA believes                    further injuries and illnesses. Providing             pressurized working chamber, the
                                                  this condition will prevent or reduce                   notification to employees informs them                applicant halts tunnel excavation and
                                                  adverse reactions among CAWs to the                     of the precautions taken by the                       prepares the machine and crew to
                                                  effects of compression or decompression                 applicant to prevent similar incidents in             conduct the interventions. Interventions
                                                  associated with the intervention work                   the future.                                           involve inspection, maintenance, or
                                                  they perform in the EPBTBM.                                This condition also requires the                   repair of the mechanical-excavation
                                                                                                          applicant to notify OSHA if it ceases to              components located in the working
                                                  Condition J: Recordkeeping
                                                                                                                                                                chamber.
                                                    Condition J requires the applicant to                    9 See 29 CFR part 1904 Recording and Reporting        B. Traylor JV developed, and
                                                  maintain records of specific factors                    Occupational Injuries and Illnesses (http://          proposed to implement, safe hyperbaric
                                                                                                          www.osha.gov/pls/oshaweb/owadisp.show_
mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with NOTICES




                                                  associated with each hyperbaric                                                                               work procedures, emergency and
                                                                                                          document?p_table=STANDARDS&p_id=9631);
                                                  intervention. The information gathered                  recordkeeping forms and instructions (http://
                                                                                                                                                                contingency procedures, and medical
                                                  and recorded under this provision, in                   www.osha.gov/recordkeeping/RKform300pkg-              examinations for the Blue Plains
                                                  concert with the information provided                   fillable-enabled.pdf); OSHA Recordkeeping             Tunneling project’s CAWs. The
                                                  under condition K (using the OSHA 301                   Handbook (http://www.osha.gov/recordkeeping/          applicant compiled these standard
                                                                                                          handbook/index.html); and updates to OSHA’s
                                                  Incident Report form to investigate and                 recordkeeping rule and Web page ((79 FR 56130);
                                                                                                                                                                operating procedures into a project-
                                                  record hyperbaric recordable injuries as                http://www.osha.gov/recordkeeping2014/                specific HOM (Ex. OSHA–2012–0035–
                                                  defined by 29 CFR 1904.4, 1904.7,                       index.html)).                                         0007). The HOM discusses the


                                             VerDate Sep<11>2014   20:59 Mar 26, 2015   Jkt 235001   PO 00000   Frm 00087   Fmt 4703   Sfmt 4703   E:\FR\FM\27MRN1.SGM   27MRN1


                                                  16446                           Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 59 / Friday, March 27, 2015 / Notices

                                                  procedures and personnel qualifications                 EPBTBM. The EPBTBM’s man lock and                       from 4 p.s.i.g. to 43 p.s.i.g. during
                                                  for performing work safely during the                   working chamber provide sufficient                      construction of the Great Belt Tunnel in
                                                  compression and decompression phases                    space for the maximum crew of three                     Denmark (1992–1996); 14 this project
                                                  of interventions. The HOM also                          CAWs to stand up and move around,                       used the 1992 French Decompression
                                                  specifies the decompression tables the                  and safely accommodate decompression                    Tables to decompress the workers
                                                  applicant proposes to use. Depending                    times up to 360 minutes. Therefore,                     during part of the construction.
                                                  on the maximum working pressure and                     OSHA preliminarily determined that the                  Anderson observed 6 DCI cases out of
                                                  exposure times during the interventions,                EPBTBM’s man lock and working                           7,220 decompression events, and
                                                  the tables provide for decompression                    chamber function as effectively as the                  reported that switching to the 1992
                                                  using air, pure oxygen, or a combination                special decompression chamber                           French Decompression tables reduced
                                                  of air and oxygen. The decompression                    required by the standard.                               the DCI incidence to 0.08%. The DCI
                                                  tables also include delays or stops for                    OSHA conducted a review of the                       incidence in the study by H. L.
                                                  various time intervals at different                     scientific literature regarding                         Andersen is substantially less than the
                                                  pressure levels during the transition to                decompression to determine whether                      DCI incidence reported for the
                                                  atmospheric pressure (i.e., staged                      the alternative decompression method                    decompression tables specified in
                                                  decompression). In all cases, a                         (i.e., the 1992 French Decompression                    Appendix A. OSHA found no studies in
                                                  physician certified in hyperbaric                       Tables) Traylor JV proposed provide a                   which the DCI incidence reported for
                                                  medicine will manage the medical                        workplace as safe and healthful as that                 the 1992 French Decompression Tables
                                                  condition of CAWs during                                provided by the standard. Based on this                 were higher than the DCI incidence
                                                  decompression. In addition, a trained                   review, OSHA determined that                            reported for the OSHA decompression
                                                  and experienced man-lock attendant,                     tunneling operations performed with                     tables.15 Therefore, OSHA concludes
                                                  experienced in recognizing                              these tables 10 resulted in a lower                     that use of the 1992 French
                                                  decompression sickness or illnesses and                 occurrence of DCI than the                              Decompression Tables protects workers
                                                  injuries, will be present. Of key                       decompression tables specified by the                   at least as effectively as the OSHA
                                                  importance, a hyperbaric supervisor                     standard.11 12 13                                       decompression tables.
                                                  (competent person), trained in                             The review conducted by OSHA                            Based on a review of available
                                                  hyperbaric operations, procedures, and                  found several research studies                          evidence, the experience of State Plans
                                                  safety, will directly supervise all                     supporting the determination that the                   that either granted variances (Nevada,
                                                  hyperbaric operations to ensure                         1992 French Decompression Tables                        Oregon and Washington) 16 or
                                                  compliance with the procedures                          resulted in a lower rate of DCI than the                promulgated a new standard
                                                  delineated in the project-specific HOM                  decompression tables specified by the                   (California) 17 for hyperbaric exposures
                                                  or by the attending physician.                          standard. For example, H. L. Anderson                   occurring during similar subaqueous
                                                     C. Traylor JV developed, and                         studied the occurrence of DCI at                        tunnel-construction work, and the
                                                  proposed to implement, a training                       maximum hyperbaric pressures ranging                    information provided in the applicant’s
                                                  program to instruct affected workers in                                                                         variance application, OSHA is granting
                                                  the hazards associated with conducting                    10 In 1992, the French Ministry of Labour
                                                                                                                                                                  the permanent variance.
                                                  hyperbaric operations.                                  replaced the 1974 French Decompression Tables              Under section 6(d) of the
                                                                                                          with the 1992 French Decompression Tables, which
                                                     D. Traylor JV developed, and                         differ from OSHA’s decompression tables in
                                                                                                                                                                  Occupational Safety and Health Act of
                                                  proposed to implement, an effective                     Appendix A by using: (1) Staged decompression as        1970 (29 U.S.C. 655), the Agency finds
                                                  alternative to the use of automatic                     opposed to continuous (linear) decompression; (2)       that when the employer complies with
                                                  controllers that continuously decrease                  decompression tables based on air or both air and       the conditions of the following order,
                                                                                                          pure oxygen; and (3) emergency tables when
                                                  pressure to achieve decompression in                    unexpected exposure times occur (up to 30 minutes       the working conditions of the
                                                  accordance with the tables specified by                 above the maximum allowed working time).                employer’s workers are at least as safe
                                                  the standard. The alternative includes                    11 Kindwall, EP (1997). Compressed air tunneling      and healthful as if the employer
                                                  using the 1992 French Decompression                     and caisson work decompression procedures:              complied with the working conditions
                                                                                                          Development, problems, and solutions. Undersea
                                                  Tables for guiding staged                               and Hyperbaric Medicine, 24(4), pp. 337–345. This
                                                                                                                                                                  specified by paragraphs (e)(5), (f)(1),
                                                  decompression to achieve lower                          article reported 60 treated cases of DCI among 4,168    (g)(1)(iii), and (g)(1)(xvii) of 29 CFR
                                                  occurrences of DCI, using a trained and                 exposures between 19 and 31 p.s.i.g. over a 51-week     1926.803. Therefore, Traylor JV will: (1)
                                                  competent attendant for implementing                    contract period, for a DCI incidence of 1.44% for       Comply with the conditions listed in
                                                                                                          the decompression tables specified by the OSHA
                                                  appropriate hyperbaric entry and exit                   standard.
                                                                                                                                                                  section VI of this notice for the period
                                                  procedures, and providing a competent                     12 Sealey, JL (1969). Safe exit from the hyperbaric   between the grant of the interim order
                                                  hyperbaric supervisor and attending                     environment: Medical experience with pressurized        and completion of the Blue Plains
                                                  physician certified in hyperbaric                       tunnel operations. Journal of Occupational              Tunnel project, but no later than
                                                  medicine, to oversee all hyperbaric                     Medicine, 11(5), pp. 273–275. This article reported     January 31, 2016; (2) comply fully with
                                                                                                          210 treated cases of DCI among 38,600 hyperbaric
                                                  operations.                                             exposures between 13 and 34 p.s.i.g. over a 32-
                                                     E. Traylor JV developed, and                         month period, for an incidence of 0.54% for the           14 Anderson HL (2002). Decompression sickness

                                                  proposed to implement, an effective                     decompression tables specified by the Washington        during construction of the Great Belt tunnel,
                                                                                                          State safety standards for compressed-air work,         Denmark. Undersea and Hyperbaric Medicine,
                                                  alternative to the use of the special                                                                           29(3), pp. 172–188.
                                                                                                          which are similar to the tables in the OSHA
                                                  decompression chamber required by the                   standard. Moreover, the article reported 51 treated       15 Le Péchon JC, Barre P, Baud JP, Ollivier F
                                                  standard. EPBTBM technology permits                     cases of DCI for 3,000 exposures between 30 and 34      (September 1996). Compressed air work—French
                                                  the tunnel’s work areas to be at                        p.s.i.g., for an incidence of 1.7% for the Washington   Tables 1992—operational results. JCLP Hyperbarie
                                                                                                          State tables.                                           Paris, Centre Medical Subaquatique Interentreprise,
mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with NOTICES




                                                  atmospheric pressure, with only the face
                                                                                                            13 In 1985, the National Institute for Occupational   Marseille: Communication a l’EUBS, pp. 1–5 (see
                                                  of the EPBTBM (i.e., the working                        Safety and Health (NIOSH) published a report            Ex. OSHA–2012–0035–0008).
                                                  chamber) at elevated pressure during                    entitled ‘‘Criteria for Interim Decompression Tables      16 These state variances are available in the

                                                  interventions. The applicant limits                     for Caisson and Tunnel Workers’’; this report           docket: Exs. OSHA–2012–0035–0006 (Nevada),
                                                  interventions conducted in the working                  reviewed studies of DCI and other hyperbaric-           OSHA–2012–0035–0005 (Oregon), and OSHA–
                                                                                                          related injuries resulting from use of OSHA’s tables.   2012–0035–0004 (Washington).
                                                  chamber to performing required                          This report is available on NIOSH’s Web site: http://     17 See California Code of Regulations, Title 8,
                                                  inspection, maintenance, and repair of                  www.cdc.gov/niosh/topics/decompression/                 Subchapter 7, Group 26, Article 154, available at
                                                  the cutting tools on the face of the                    default.html.                                           http://www.dir.ca.gov/title8/sb7g26a154.html.



                                             VerDate Sep<11>2014   20:59 Mar 26, 2015   Jkt 235001   PO 00000   Frm 00088   Fmt 4703   Sfmt 4703   E:\FR\FM\27MRN1.SGM    27MRN1


                                                                                  Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 59 / Friday, March 27, 2015 / Notices                                                 16447

                                                  all other applicable provisions of 29                   exit the working chamber after                        dysfunction); cardiopulmonary
                                                  CFR part 1926; and (3) provide a copy                   performing interventions.                             disorders, such as shortness of breath;
                                                  of this Federal Register notice to all                                                                        and arterial gas embolism (gas bubbles
                                                                                                          C. List of Abbreviations
                                                  employees affected by the conditions,                                                                         in the arteries that block blood flow).19
                                                  including the affected employees of                       Abbreviations used throughout this
                                                                                                                                                                   Note: Health effects associated with
                                                  other employers, using the same means                   permanent variance include the                        hyperbaric intervention but not considered
                                                  it used to inform these employees of its                following:                                            symptoms of DCI can include: Barotrauma
                                                  application for a permanent variance.                   1. CAW—Compressed-air worker                          (direct damage to air-containing cavities in
                                                  Additionally, this final order will                     2. CFR—Code of Federal Regulations                    the body such as ears, sinuses and lungs);
                                                  remain in effect until OSHA modifies or                 3. DCI—Decompression Illness                          nitrogen narcosis (reversible alteration in
                                                  revokes it in accordance with 29 CFR                    4. EPBTBM—Earth Pressure Balanced Tunnel              consciousness that may occur in hyperbaric
                                                                                                               Boring Machine                                   environments and is caused by the anesthetic
                                                  1905.13.                                                5. HOM—Hyperbaric Operations and Safety               effect of certain gases at high pressure); and
                                                  VI. Order                                                    Manual                                           oxygen toxicity (a central nervous system
                                                                                                          6. JHA—Job hazard analysis                            condition resulting from the harmful effects
                                                     As of the effective date of this final               7. OSHA—Occupational Safety and Health                of breathing molecular oxygen (O2) at
                                                  order, OSHA is revoking the interim                          Administration                                   elevated partial pressures).
                                                  order granted to the employer on July                   8. OTPCA—Office of Technical Programs and
                                                  11, 2013, and affirmed on December 11,                       Coordination Activities                            6. Earth Pressure Balanced Tunnel
                                                  2014 (79 FR 73631). OSHA issues this                                                                          Boring Machine—the machinery used to
                                                                                                          D. Definitions                                        excavate the tunnel.
                                                  final order authorizing Traylor/Skanska/
                                                  Jay Dee Joint Venture (‘‘Traylor JV’’) to                  The following definitions apply to                   7. Hot work—any activity performed
                                                  comply with following conditions                        this permanent variance. These                        in a hazardous location that may
                                                  instead of complying with the                           definitions supplement the definitions                introduce an ignition source into a
                                                  requirements of paragraphs 29 CFR                       in Traylor JV’s project-specific HOM.                 potentially flammable atmosphere.20
                                                  1926.803(e)(5), (f)(1), (g)(1)(iii), and                   1. Affected employee or worker—an                    8. Hyperbaric—at a higher pressure
                                                  (g)(1)(xvii). This final order applies to               employee or worker who is affected by                 than atmospheric pressure.
                                                                                                          the conditions of this permanent                        9. Hyperbaric intervention—a term
                                                  all employees of Traylor JV exposed to
                                                                                                          variance, or any one of his or her                    that describes the process of stopping
                                                  hyperbaric conditions at the Blue Plains
                                                                                                          authorized representatives. The term                  the EPBTBM and preparing and
                                                  Tunnel project. These conditions are:
                                                                                                          ‘‘employee’’ has the meaning defined                  executing work under hyperbaric
                                                  A. Scope                                                and used under the Occupational Safety                pressure in the working chamber for the
                                                     The permanent variance applies only                  and Health Act of 1970 (29 U.S.C. 651                 purpose of inspecting, replacing, or
                                                  to work:                                                et seq.)                                              repairing cutting tools and/or the cutter
                                                     1. That occurs in conjunction with                      2. Atmospheric pressure—the                        head structure.
                                                  construction of the Blue Plains Tunnel                  pressure of air at sea-level, generally                 10. Hyperbaric Operations Manual—a
                                                  project, a tunnel constructed using                     14.7 p.s.i.a., 1 atmosphere absolute, or 0            detailed, project-specific health and
                                                  advanced shielded mechanical-                           p.s.i.g.                                              safety plan developed and implemented
                                                  excavation techniques and involving                        3. Compressed-air worker—an                        by Traylor JV for working in compressed
                                                  operation of an EPBTBM;                                 individual who is specially trained and               air during the Blue Plains’ tunnel
                                                     2. Performed under compressed-air                    medically qualified to perform work in                project.
                                                  and hyperbaric conditions up to 52                      a pressurized environment while                         11. Job hazard analysis—an
                                                  p.s.i.g;                                                breathing air at pressures up to 52                   evaluation of tasks or operations to
                                                     3. In the EPBTBM’s forward section                   p.s.i.g.                                              identify potential hazards and to
                                                  (the working chamber) and associated                       4. Competent person—an individual                  determine the necessary controls.
                                                  hyperbaric chambers used to pressurize                  who is capable of identifying existing                  12. Man lock—an enclosed space
                                                  and decompress employees entering and                   and predictable hazards in the                        capable of pressurization, and used for
                                                  exiting the working chamber;                            surroundings or working conditions that               compressing or decompressing any
                                                     4. Except for the requirements                       are unsanitary, hazardous, or dangerous               employee or material when either is
                                                  specified by 29 CFR 1926.803(e)(5),                     to employees, and who has                             passing into or out of a working
                                                  (f)(1), (g)(1)(iii), and (g)(1)(xvii), Traylor          authorization to take prompt corrective               chamber.
                                                  JV must comply fully with all other                     measures to eliminate them.18                           13. Pressure—a force acting on a unit
                                                  applicable provisions of 29 CFR part                       5. Decompression illness (also called              area. Usually expressed as pounds per
                                                  1926; and                                               decompression sickness or the bends)—                 square inch (p.s.i.).
                                                     5. This order remains in effect until                an illness caused by gas bubbles                        14. p.s.i.—pounds per square inch, a
                                                  one of the following conditions occurs:                 appearing in body compartments due to                 common unit of measurement of
                                                  (1) Completion of the Blue Plains                       a reduction in ambient pressure.                      pressure; a pressure given in p.s.i.
                                                  Tunnel project, but no later than                       Examples of symptoms of                               corresponds to absolute pressure.
                                                  January 31, 2016; or (2) OSHA modifies                  decompression illness include (but are                  15. p.s.i.a.—pounds per square inch
                                                  or revokes this final order in accordance               not limited to): Joint pain (also known               absolute, or absolute pressure, is the
                                                  with 29 CFR 1905.13.                                    as the ‘‘bends’’ for agonizing pain or the            sum of the atmospheric pressure and
                                                                                                          ‘‘niggles’’ for slight pain); areas of bone           gauge pressure. At sea-level,
                                                  B. Application
mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with NOTICES




                                                                                                          destruction (termed dysbaric                          atmospheric pressure is approximately
                                                    The permanent variance applies only                   osteonecrosis); skin disorders (such as               14.7 p.s.i. Adding 14.7 to a pressure
                                                  when Traylor JV stops the tunnel-boring                 cutis marmorata, which causes a pink
                                                  work, pressurizes the working chamber,                  marbling of the skin); spinal cord and                  19 See Appendix 10 of ‘‘A Guide to the Work in

                                                  and the CAWs either enter the working                                                                         Compressed Air Regulations 1996,’’ published by
                                                                                                          brain disorders (such as stroke,                      the United Kingdom Health and Safety Executive
                                                  chamber to perform interventions (i.e.,                 paralysis, paresthesia, and bladder                   available from NIOSH at http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/
                                                  inspect, maintain, or repair the                                                                              docket/archive/pdfs/NIOSH-254/compReg1996.pdf.
                                                  mechanical-excavation components), or                     18 Adapted   from 29 CFR 1926.32(f).                  20 Also see 29 CFR 1910.146(b).




                                             VerDate Sep<11>2014   20:59 Mar 26, 2015   Jkt 235001   PO 00000   Frm 00089   Fmt 4703   Sfmt 4703   E:\FR\FM\27MRN1.SGM   27MRN1


                                                  16448                             Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 59 / Friday, March 27, 2015 / Notices

                                                  expressed in units of p.s.i.g. will yield                 flame-retardant personal protective                   G. Worker Qualifications and Training
                                                  the absolute pressure, expressed as                       equipment and clothing.                                 Traylor JV must:
                                                  p.s.i.a.                                                     7. In hyperbaric work areas, Traylor
                                                                                                                                                                    1. Ensure that each affected worker
                                                    16. p.s.i.g.—pounds per square inch                     JV must maintain an adequate fire-
                                                                                                                                                                  receives effective training on how to
                                                  gauge, a common unit of pressure;                         suppression system approved for
                                                                                                                                                                  safely enter, work in, exit from, and
                                                  pressure expressed as p.s.i.g.                            hyperbaric work areas.
                                                                                                               8. Traylor JV must develop and                     undertake emergency evacuation or
                                                  corresponds to pressure relative to                                                                             rescue from, hyperbaric conditions, and
                                                  atmospheric pressure. At sea-level,                       implement one or more JHAs for work
                                                                                                            in the hyperbaric work areas, and                     document this training.
                                                  atmospheric pressure is approximately                                                                             2. Provide effective instruction, before
                                                  14.7 p.s.i. Subtracting 14.7 from a                       review, periodically and as necessary
                                                                                                            (e.g., after making changes to a planned              beginning hyperbaric operations, to
                                                  pressure expressed in units of p.s.i.a.                                                                         each worker who performs work, or
                                                  yields the gauge pressure, expressed as                   intervention that affects its operation),
                                                                                                            the contents of the JHAs with affected                controls the exposure of others, in
                                                  p.s.i.g.                                                                                                        hyperbaric conditions, and document
                                                    17. Qualified person—an individual                      employees. The JHAs must include all
                                                                                                            the job functions that the risk                       this instruction. The instruction must
                                                  who, by possession of a recognized                                                                              include topics such as:
                                                  degree, certificate, or professional                      assessment 23 indicates are essential to
                                                                                                            prevent injury or illness.                              (a) The physics and physiology of
                                                  standing, or who, by extensive                                                                                  hyperbaric work;
                                                                                                               9. Traylor JV must develop a set of
                                                  knowledge, training, and experience,                                                                              (b) Recognition of pressure-related
                                                                                                            checklists to guide compressed-air work
                                                  successfully demonstrates an ability to                                                                         injuries;
                                                                                                            and ensure that employees follow the
                                                  solve or resolve problems relating to the                                                                         (c) Information on the causes and
                                                                                                            procedures required by this permanent
                                                  subject matter, the work, or the                                                                                recognition of the signs and symptoms
                                                                                                            variance (including all procedures
                                                  project.21                                                                                                      associated with decompression illness,
                                                                                                            required by the HOM, which this
                                                    18. Working chamber—an enclosed                         variance incorporates by reference). The              and other hyperbaric intervention-
                                                  space in the EPBTBM in which CAWs                         checklists must include all steps and                 related health effects (e.g., barotrauma,
                                                  perform interventions, and which is                       equipment functions that the risk                     nitrogen narcosis, and oxygen toxicity).
                                                  accessible only through a man lock.                       assessment indicates are essential to                   (d) How to avoid discomfort during
                                                  E. Safety and Health Practices                            prevent injury or illness during                      compression and decompression; and
                                                                                                            compressed-air work.                                    (e) Information the workers can use to
                                                    1. Traylor JV must develop and                             10. Traylor JV must ensure that the                contact the appropriate healthcare
                                                  implement an HOM specific to the Blue                     safety and health provisions of the HOM               professionals should the workers have
                                                  Plains project, and submit the HOM to                     adequately protect the workers of all                 concerns that they may be experiencing
                                                  OSHA at least six months before using                     contractors and subcontractors involved               adverse health effects from hyperbaric
                                                  the EPBTBM. Traylor JV must receive a                     in hyperbaric operations.24                           exposure.
                                                  written acknowledgement from OSHA                                                                                 3. Repeat the instruction specified in
                                                  regarding the acceptability of the                        F. Communication                                      paragraph (2) of this condition
                                                  HOM.22 The HOM shall provide the                             1. Prior to beginning a shift, Traylor             periodically and as necessary (e.g., after
                                                  governing safety and health                               JV must implement a system that                       making changes to its hyperbaric
                                                  requirements regarding hyperbaric                         informs workers exposed to hyperbaric                 operations).
                                                  exposures during the tunnel-                              conditions of any hazardous                             4. When conducting training for its
                                                  construction project.                                     occurrences or conditions that might                  hyperbaric workers make this training
                                                    2. Traylor JV must implement the                        affect their safety, including hyperbaric             available to OSHA personnel and notify
                                                  safety and health instructions included                   incidents, gas releases, equipment                    the OTPCA at OSHA’s national office
                                                  in the manufacturer’s operations                          failures, earth or rock slides, cave-ins,             and OSHA’s Baltimore/Washington DC
                                                  manuals for the EPBTBM, and the safety                    flooding, fires, or explosions.                       Area Office before the training takes
                                                  and health instructions provided by the                      2. Traylor JV must provide a power-                place.
                                                  manufacturer for the operation of                         assisted means of communication
                                                  decompression equipment.                                  among affected workers and support                    H. Inspections, Tests, and Accident
                                                    3. Traylor JV must use air as the only                  personnel in hyperbaric conditions                    Prevention
                                                  breathing gas in the working chamber.                     where unassisted voice communication                     1. Traylor JV must initiate and
                                                    4. Traylor JV must use the 1992                         is inadequate.                                        maintain a program of frequent and
                                                  French Decompression Tables for air,                         (a) Traylor JV must use an                         regular inspections of the EPBTBM’s
                                                  air-oxygen, and oxygen decompression                      independent power supply for powered                  hyperbaric equipment and support
                                                  specified in the HOM, specifically the                    communication systems, and these                      systems (such as temperature control,
                                                  extracted portions of the 1992 French                     systems must operate such that use or                 illumination, ventilation, and fire-
                                                  Decompression tables titled ‘‘French                      disruption of any one phone or signal                 prevention and fire-suppression
                                                  Regulation Air Standard Tables.’’                         location will not disrupt the operation               systems), and hyperbaric work areas, as
                                                    5. Traylor JV must equip man-locks                      of the system from any other location.                required under 29 CFR 1926.20(b)(2) by:
                                                  used by its employees with an oxygen-                        (b) Traylor JV must test                              (a) Developing a set of checklists to be
                                                  delivery system as specified by the                       communication systems at the start of                 used by a competent person in
                                                  HOM. Traylor JV must not store oxygen                     each shift and as necessary thereafter to
                                                                                                                                                                  conducting weekly inspections of
                                                                                                            ensure proper operation.
mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with NOTICES




                                                  or other compressed gases used in                                                                               hyperbaric equipment and work areas;
                                                  conjunction with hyperbaric work in the                     23 See ANSI/AIHA Z10–2012, American National
                                                                                                                                                                  and
                                                  tunnel.                                                   Standard for Occupational Health and Safety              (b) Ensuring that a competent person
                                                    6. Workers performing hot work                          Management Systems, for reference.                    conducts daily visual checks and
                                                  under hyperbaric conditions must use                        24 See ANSI/ASSE A10.33–2011, American
                                                                                                                                                                  weekly inspections of the EPBTBM.
                                                                                                            National Standard for Construction and Demolition        2. If the competent person determines
                                                                                                            Operations—Safety and Health Program
                                                    21 Adapted    from 29 CFR 1926.32(m).                   Requirements for Multi-Employer Projects, for         that the equipment constitutes a safety
                                                    22 See   footnote 8.                                    reference.                                            hazard, Traylor JV must remove the


                                             VerDate Sep<11>2014     20:59 Mar 26, 2015   Jkt 235001   PO 00000   Frm 00090   Fmt 4703   Sfmt 4703   E:\FR\FM\27MRN1.SGM   27MRN1


                                                                                  Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 59 / Friday, March 27, 2015 / Notices                                                  16449

                                                  equipment from service until it corrects                   4. The results of the post-intervention             composition of gas mixtures (air and/or
                                                  the hazardous condition and has the                     physical assessment of each CAW for                    oxygen), and the results achieved; (3) the
                                                  correction approved by a qualified                      signs and symptoms of decompression                    total number of interventions and the number
                                                                                                          illness, barotrauma, nitrogen narcosis,                of hyperbaric incidents (decompression
                                                  person.
                                                                                                                                                                 illnesses and/or health effects associated
                                                     3. Traylor JV must maintain records of               oxygen toxicity or other health effects                with hyperbaric interventions as recorded on
                                                  all tests and inspections of the EPBTBM,                associated with work in compressed air                 OSHA 301 and 300 forms, and relevant
                                                  as well as associated corrective actions                for each hyperbaric intervention.                      medical diagnoses and treating physicians’
                                                  and repairs, at the job site for the                                                                           opinions); and (4) root causes of any
                                                                                                          K. Notifications
                                                  duration of the job.                                                                                           hyperbaric incidents, and preventive and
                                                                                                             1. To assist OSHA in administering                  corrective actions identified and
                                                  I. Compression and Decompression                        the conditions specified herein, Traylor               implemented.
                                                     Traylor JV must consult with its                     JV must:                                                  (e) To assist OSHA in administering
                                                  attending physician concerning the                         (a) Notify the OTPCA and the                        the conditions specified herein, inform
                                                  need for special compression or                         Baltimore/Washington DC Area Office                    the OTPCA and the Baltimore/
                                                  decompression exposures appropriate                     of any recordable injuries, illnesses, in-             Washington DC Area Office as soon as
                                                  for CAWs not acclimated to hyperbaric                   patient hospitalizations, amputations,                 possible after it has knowledge that it
                                                  exposure.                                               loss of an eye, or fatality (by submitting             will:
                                                                                                          the completed OSHA 301 Incident                           (i) Cease to do business;
                                                  J. Recordkeeping
                                                                                                          Report form 25) resulting from exposure                   (ii) Change the location and address of
                                                     Traylor JV must maintain a record of                 of an employee to hyperbaric conditions                the main office for managing the
                                                  any recordable injury, illness, or fatality             including those that do not require                    tunneling operations specified herein;
                                                  (as defined by 29 CFR part 1904                         recompression treatment (e.g., nitrogen                or
                                                  Recording and Reporting Occupational                    narcosis, oxygen toxicity, barotrauma),                   (iii) Transfer the operations specified
                                                  Injuries and Illnesses), resulting from                 but still meet the recordable injury or                herein to a successor company.
                                                  exposure of an employee to hyperbaric                   illness criteria of 29 CFR part 1904. The                 (f) Notify all affected employees of
                                                  conditions by completing the OSHA 301                   notification must be made within 8                     this permanent variance by the same
                                                  Incident Report form and OSHA 300                       hours of the incident or 8 hours after                 means required to inform them of its
                                                  Log of Work Related Injuries and                        becoming aware of a recordable injury,                 application for a variance.
                                                  Illnesses.                                              illness, in-patient hospitalizations,                     2. OSHA must approve the transfer of
                                                     Note: Examples of important information              amputations, loss of an eye, or fatality,              the permanent variance to a successor
                                                  to include on the OSHA 301 Incident Report              and submit a copy of the incident                      company.
                                                  form (along with the corresponding question             investigation (OSHA form 301) within
                                                  on the form) are: The task performed                                                                           Authority and Signature
                                                                                                          24 hours of the incident or 24 hours
                                                  (Question (Q) 14); an estimate of the CAW’s             after becoming aware of a recordable                     David Michaels, Ph.D., MPH, Assistant
                                                  workload (Q 14); the composition of the gas                                                                    Secretary of Labor for Occupational Safety
                                                  mixture (e.g., air or oxygen (Q 14)); the
                                                                                                          case. In addition to the information
                                                                                                          required by the OSHA form 301, the                     and Health, 200 Constitution Avenue NW.,
                                                  maximum working pressure (Q 14);                                                                               Washington, DC 20210, authorized the
                                                  temperature in the work and decompression               incident-investigation report must                     preparation of this notice. Accordingly, the
                                                  environments (Q 14); unusual occurrences, if            include a root-cause determination, and                Agency is issuing this notice pursuant to
                                                  any, during the task or decompression (Q 14);           the preventive and corrective actions                  Section 29 U.S.C. 655(6)(d), Secretary of
                                                  time of symptom onset (Q 15); duration                  identified and implemented.                            Labor’s Order No. 1–2012 (77 FR 3912, Jan.
                                                  between decompression and onset of                         (b) Provide certification within 15                 25, 2012), and 29 CFR 1905.11.
                                                  symptoms (Q 15); type and duration of                   working days of the incident that
                                                  symptoms (Q 16); a medical summary of the                                                                      David Michaels,
                                                                                                          Traylor JV informed affected workers of
                                                  illness or injury (Q 16); duration of the                                                                      Assistant Secretary of Labor for Occupational
                                                  hyperbaric intervention (Q 17); possible                the incident and the results of the
                                                                                                                                                                 Safety and Health.
                                                  contributing factors (Q 17); the number of              incident investigation (including the
                                                                                                          root-cause determination and preventive                [FR Doc. 2015–06975 Filed 3–26–15; 8:45 am]
                                                  prior interventions completed by the injured
                                                  or ill CAW (Q 17); the number of prior                  and corrective actions identified and                  BILLING CODE 4510–26–P
                                                  interventions completed by the injured or ill           implemented).
                                                  CAW at this working pressure (Q 17); contact               (c) Notify the OTPCA and the
                                                  information for the treating healthcare                 Baltimore/Washington DC Area Office                    DEPARTMENT OF LABOR
                                                  provider (Q 17); and date and time of last              within 15 working days and in writing,
                                                  hyperbaric exposure for this CAW.                                                                              Office of the Secretary
                                                                                                          of any change in the compressed-air
                                                     In addition to completing the OSHA                   operations that affects Traylor JV’s                   Agency Information Collection
                                                  301 Incident Report form and OSHA                       ability to comply with the conditions                  Activities; Submission for OMB
                                                  300 Log of Work Related Injuries and                    specified herein.                                      Review; Comment Request; Inorganic
                                                  Illnesses, Traylor JV must maintain                        (d) Upon completion of the Blue                     Arsenic Standard
                                                  records of:                                             Plains Tunnel project, evaluate the
                                                     1. The date, times (e.g., began                      effectiveness of the decompression                     ACTION:   Notice.
                                                  compression, time spent compressing,                    tables used throughout the project, and
                                                  time performing intervention, time                      provide a written report of this                       SUMMARY:   The Department of Labor
                                                  spent decompressing), and pressure for                  evaluation to the OTPCA and the                        (DOL) is submitting the Occupational
mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with NOTICES




                                                  each hyperbaric intervention.                           Baltimore/Washington DC Area Office.                   Safety and Health Administration
                                                     2. The name of each individual                                                                              (OSHA) sponsored information
                                                                                                            Note: The evaluation report must contain
                                                  worker exposed to hyperbaric pressure                   summaries of: (1) The number, dates,
                                                                                                                                                                 collection request (ICR) titled,
                                                  and the decompression protocols and                     durations, and pressures of the hyperbaric             ‘‘Inorganic Arsenic Standard,’’ to the
                                                  results for each worker.                                interventions completed; (2) decompression             Office of Management and Budget
                                                     3. The total number of interventions                 protocols implemented (including                       (OMB) for review and approval for
                                                  and the amount of hyperbaric work time                                                                         continued use, without change, in
                                                  at each pressure.                                         25 See   footnote 9.                                 accordance with the Paperwork


                                             VerDate Sep<11>2014   20:59 Mar 26, 2015   Jkt 235001   PO 00000   Frm 00091    Fmt 4703   Sfmt 4703   E:\FR\FM\27MRN1.SGM   27MRN1



Document Created: 2015-12-18 11:36:29
Document Modified: 2015-12-18 11:36:29
CategoryRegulatory Information
CollectionFederal Register
sudoc ClassAE 2.7:
GS 4.107:
AE 2.106:
PublisherOffice of the Federal Register, National Archives and Records Administration
SectionNotices
ActionNotice.
DatesThe permanent variance specified by this notice becomes effective on March 27, 2015 and shall remain in effect until January 31, 2016.
ContactInformation regarding this notice is available from the following sources:
FR Citation80 FR 16440 

2024 Federal Register | Disclaimer | Privacy Policy
USC | CFR | eCFR