81_FR_3425 81 FR 3412 - Proposed Agency Information Collection Activities; Comment Request

81 FR 3412 - Proposed Agency Information Collection Activities; Comment Request

FEDERAL RESERVE SYSTEM

Federal Register Volume 81, Issue 13 (January 21, 2016)

Page Range3412-3420
FR Document2016-01043

On June 15, 1984, the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) delegated to the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (Board) its approval authority under the Paperwork Reduction Act (PRA), to approve of and assign OMB numbers to collection of information requests and requirements conducted or sponsored by the Board. Board- approved collections of information are incorporated into the official OMB inventory of currently approved collections of information. Copies of the PRA Submission, supporting statements and approved collection of information instruments are placed into OMB's public docket files. The Federal Reserve may not conduct or sponsor, and the respondent is not required to respond to, an information collection that has been extended, revised, or implemented on or after October 1, 1995, unless it displays a currently valid OMB number.

Federal Register, Volume 81 Issue 13 (Thursday, January 21, 2016)
[Federal Register Volume 81, Number 13 (Thursday, January 21, 2016)]
[Notices]
[Pages 3412-3420]
From the Federal Register Online  [www.thefederalregister.org]
[FR Doc No: 2016-01043]


=======================================================================
-----------------------------------------------------------------------

FEDERAL RESERVE SYSTEM


Proposed Agency Information Collection Activities; Comment 
Request

AGENCY: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System.
SUMMARY: On June 15, 1984, the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) 
delegated to the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System 
(Board) its approval authority under the Paperwork Reduction Act (PRA), 
to approve of and assign OMB numbers to collection of information 
requests and requirements conducted or sponsored by the Board. Board-
approved collections of information are incorporated into the official 
OMB inventory of currently approved collections of information. Copies 
of the PRA Submission, supporting statements and approved collection of 
information instruments are placed into OMB's public docket files. The 
Federal Reserve may not conduct or sponsor, and the respondent is not 
required to respond to, an information collection that has been 
extended, revised, or implemented on or after October 1, 1995, unless 
it displays a currently valid OMB number.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Federal Reserve Board Clearance 
Officer--Nuha Elmaghrabi--Office of the Chief Data Officer, Board of 
Governors of the Federal Reserve System, Washington, DC 20551 (202) 
452-3829. Telecommunications Device for the Deaf (TDD) users may 
contact (202) 263-4869, Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve 
System, Washington, DC 20551.
    OMB Desk Officer--Shagufta Ahmed--Office of Information and 
Regulatory Affairs, Office of Management and Budget, New Executive 
Office Building, Room 10235, 725 17th Street NW., Washington, DC 20503.
    Final approval under OMB delegated authority of the extension for 
three years, with revision, of the following information collection:
    Report title: Capital Assessments and Stress Testing information 
collection.
    Agency form number: FR Y-14A/Q/M.
    OMB control number: 7100-0341.
    Effective Dates: December 31, 2015, June 30, 2016 and September 30, 
2016.
    Frequency: Annually, semi-annually, quarterly, and monthly.
    Respondents: Any top-tier bank holding company (BHC) (other than a 
foreign banking organization), that has $50 billion or more in total 
consolidated assets, as determined based on: (i) The average of the 
BHC's total consolidated assets in the four most recent quarters as 
reported quarterly on the BHC's Consolidated Financial Statements for 
Bank Holding Companies (FR Y-9C) (OMB No. 7100-0128); or (ii) the 
average of the BHC's total consolidated assets in the most recent 
consecutive quarters as reported quarterly on the BHC's FR Y-9Cs, if 
the BHC has not filed an FR Y-9C for each of the most recent four 
quarters. Reporting is required as of the first day of the quarter 
immediately following the quarter in which it meets this asset 
threshold, unless otherwise directed by the Federal Reserve.
    Estimated annual reporting hours: FR Y-14A: Summary, 65,142 hours; 
Macro scenario, 2,046 hours; Operational Risk, 396 hours; Regulatory 
capital transitions, 759 hours; Regulatory capital instruments, 660 
hours; Retail repurchase, 1,320 hours; and Business plan changes, 330 
hours. FR Y-14Q: Securities, 1,716 hours; Retail, 2,112 hours; Pre-
provision net revenue (PPNR), 93,852 hours; Wholesale, 20,064 hours; 
Trading, 69,336 hours; Regulatory capital transitions, 3,036 hours; 
Regulatory capital instruments, 6,864 hours; Operational risk, 6,600 
hours; Mortgage Servicing Rights (MSR) Valuation, 1,152 hours; 
Supplemental, 528 hours; and Retail Fair Value Option/Held for Sale 
(Retail FVO/HFS), 1,408 hours; Counterparty, 18,288 hours; and 
Balances, 2,112 hours; FR Y-14M: 1st lien mortgage, 173,040 hours; Home 
equity, 166,860 hours; and Credit card, 110,160 hours. FR Y-14 On-going 
automation revisions, 15,840 hours. FR Y-14 Attestation implementation, 
43,200 hours; and On-going audit and review, 23,040 hours.
    Estimated average hours per response: FR Y-14A: Summary, 987 hours; 
Macro scenario, 31 hours; Operational Risk, 12 hours; Regulatory 
capital transitions, 23 hours; Regulatory capital instruments, 20 
hours; Retail Repurchase, 20 hours; and Business Plan Changes, 10 
hours. FR Y-14Q: Securities, 13 hours; Retail, 16 hours; PPNR, 711 
hours; Wholesale, 152 hours; Trading, 1,926 hours; Regulatory capital 
transitions, 23 hours; Regulatory capital instruments, 52 hours; 
Operational risk, 50 hours; MSR Valuation, 24 hours; Supplemental, 4 
hours; and Retail FVO/HFS, 16 hours; Counterparty, 508 hours; and 
Balances, 16 hours; FR Y-14M: 1st lien mortgage, 515 hours; Home 
equity, 515 hours; and Credit card, 510 hours. FR Y-14 On-Going 
automation revisions, 480 hours. FR Y-14 Attestation Implementation, 
4,800 hours; and On-going audit and review, 2,560 hours.
    Number of respondents: 33.
    General description of report: The FR Y-14 series of reports are 
authorized by section 165 of the Dodd-Frank Act, which requires the 
Federal Reserve to ensure that certain BHCs and nonbank financial 
companies supervised by the Federal Reserve are subject to enhanced 
risk-based and leverage standards in order to mitigate risks to the 
financial stability of the United States (12 U.S.C. 5365). 
Additionally, section 5 of the Bank Holding Company Act authorizes the 
Federal Reserve to issue regulations and conduct information 
collections with regard to the supervision of BHCs (12 U.S.C. 1844).
    As these data are collected as part of the supervisory process, 
they are subject to confidential treatment under exemption 8 of the 
Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) (5 U.S.C. 552(b)(8)). In addition, 
commercial and financial information contained in these information 
collections may be exempt from disclosure under exemption 4 of FOIA (5 
U.S.C. 552(b)(4)), if disclosure would likely have the effect of (1) 
impairing the government's ability to obtain the necessary information 
in the future, or (2) causing substantial harm to the competitive 
position of the respondent. Such exemptions would be made on a case-by-
case basis.
    Though the Federal Reserve intends to share the information 
collected under the FR Y-14 with the Department of Treasury's Office of 
Financial Research, such sharing shall not be deemed a waiver of any 
privilege applicable to such information, including but not limited to 
any confidential status (12 U.S.C. 1821(t); 12 U.S.C. 1828(x)).
    Abstract: The data collected through the FR Y-14A/Q/M schedules 
provide the Federal Reserve with the additional information and 
perspective needed to help ensure that large BHCs have strong, 
firm[hyphen]wide risk measurement and management processes supporting 
their internal assessments of capital adequacy and that their capital 
resources are

[[Page 3413]]

sufficient given their business focus, activities, and resulting risk 
exposures. The annual Comprehensive Capital Analysis and Review (CCAR) 
exercise is also complemented by other Federal Reserve supervisory 
efforts aimed at enhancing the continued viability of large BHCs, 
including continuous monitoring of BHCs' planning and management of 
liquidity and funding resources and regular assessments of credit, 
market and operational risks, and associated risk management practices. 
Information gathered in this data collection is also used in the 
supervision and regulation of these financial institutions. In order to 
fully evaluate the data submissions, the Federal Reserve may conduct 
follow up discussions with or request responses to follow up questions 
from respondents, as needed.
    The Capital Assessments and Stress Testing information collection 
consists of the FR Y-14A, Q, and M reports. The semi-annual FR Y-14A 
collects information on the stress tests conducted by BHCs, including 
quantitative projections of balance sheet, income, losses, and capital 
across a range of macroeconomic scenarios, and qualitative information 
on methodologies used to develop internal projections of capital across 
scenarios.\1\ The quarterly FR Y-14Q and the monthly FR Y-14M are used 
to support supervisory stress test models and for continuous monitoring 
efforts. The quarterly FR Y-14Q collects granular data on BHCs' various 
asset classes, including loans, securities and trading assets, and PPNR 
for the reporting period. The monthly FR Y-14M comprises three retail 
loan- and portfolio-level collections, and one detailed address 
matching collection to supplement two of the portfolio and loan-level 
collections.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \1\ BHCs that must re-submit their capital plan generally also 
must provide a revised FR Y-14A in connection with their 
resubmission.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Current Actions: On September 16, 2015, the Federal Reserve 
published a notice in the Federal Register (80 FR 55621) requesting 
public comment for 60 days on the extension, with revision, of the FR 
Y-14A/Q/M. The Federal Reserve proposed to revise several schedules of 
the FR Y 14A/Q/M reports effective December 31, 2015, March 31, 2015 
and June 30, 2016, and to implement an attestation requirement for 
LISSC firms as-of June 30, 2016. The comment period for this notice 
expired on November 16, 2015.
    The Board received two comment letters addressing the proposed 
changes: One from the Financial Services Roundtable, and one from The 
Clearing House, the Institute of International Bankers, the American 
Bankers Association, and the Securities Industry and Financial Markets 
Association. Comments focused on the scope and timing of the proposed 
attestation requirement, and the timing of proposed modifications to 
existing items or schedules, in particular the FR Y-14Q Wholesale 
schedules (Schedule H.1 and H.2). Commenters requested clarification of 
the instructions for proposed or existing items, or were technical in 
nature. Responses to these comments are addressed in the attached draft 
FR Y-14A/Q/M reporting forms and instructions.
    The Federal Reserve also received several comments not directly 
related to the proposed revisions to the FR Y-14 information collection 
regarding (1) challenges with the frequency and timing of changes, (2) 
the Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) process, (3) technical 
instructions and data submission processes, (4) edit checks and (5) 
estimate of reporting burden. Although not specifically addressed 
herein, these comment letters, well as feedback provided in meetings 
with both individual respondents and industry groups, have assisted the 
Federal Reserve's effort to continually improve its internal processes 
and practices. The following section includes a detailed discussion of 
aspects of the proposed FR Y-14 collection for which the Federal 
Reserve received substantive comments and an evaluation of, and 
responses to the comments received.

Detailed Discussion of Public Comments

A. General Comments

    In general, commenters expressed concern with the timing of the 
proposed changes. Specifically commenters stated there was not 
sufficient time to undertake the changes necessary to implement the 
proposed revisions and develop appropriate processes and procedures 
surrounding the attestation requirement. One commenter recommended that 
the Federal Reserve provide a minimum of sixth months between the 
finalization of reporting and technical requirements and the effective 
date of proposed changes to the FR Y-14A/Q/M reports in order for 
respondents to adhere to standard software development life cycles.
    In response to these comments, the final FR Y-14 regulatory report 
(final FR Y-14) delays the effective date for nearly all proposed 
changes to reports with a June 30, 2016, as-of date, as detailed in the 
schedule-specific sections below. This extension provides respondents 
with approximately six months to make needed system changes. In 
addition, the final FR Y-14 delays by two quarters, until September 30, 
2016, the effective date of certain changes to the wholesale schedules 
(Schedules H.1 and H.2), as indicated in the schedule-specific section 
below.
    Certain changes in the final FR Y-14 would take effect beginning 
with the regulatory reports that have a December 31, 2015, as-of date. 
These changes include the shift in the FR Y-14A as-of date, from 
September 30 to December 31, in accordance with modifications to the 
capital plan and stress test rules; formalization of the FR Y-14Q 
Business Plan Changes schedule as a regulatory report (rather than as a 
case-by-case supervisory collection of information); elimination of the 
FR Y-14Q Securities B.2 sub-schedule, and removal of certain items 
related to tier 1 common capital.\2\ These changes align the FR Y-14 
reports with changes in the final capital rule that the Board recently 
approved, better align regulatory reporting requirements with other 
existing requirements, reduce burden, or formalize information 
collections that are already reported as part of the supervisory 
process. In light of the limited comment on, and limited impact of, 
these proposed changes, they will be implemented, as proposed, with a 
December 31, 2015, as-of date.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \2\ See 79 Federal Register 64026 (October 27, 2014); 80 Federal 
Register 75419 (December 2, 2015).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    In response to the Federal Reserve's solicitation for feedback 
regarding burden associated with the FR Y-14A/Q/M, one commenter 
suggested that the estimates of reporting burden are substantially 
lower than a good-faith estimate provided by a sample of reporting 
firms. The commenter outlined the type of effort and resources, and 
associated burden required to file the FR Y-14A/Q/M reports and offered 
to engage in further discussion with the Federal Reserve regarding 
burden estimates. Burden estimates are based on a schedule by schedule 
calculation while the estimates provided by the commenter are 
aggregated. This difference makes it difficult to modify the proposed 
burden estimates without more detailed information from the commenter. 
For these reasons, the burden estimates remain the same as proposed.
    Commenters also suggested several improvements to the current FAQ 
process, including providing status on a real time basis, establishing 
a searchable

[[Page 3414]]

repository, distributing more frequently, and setting a standard 
schedule for responding to questions. The Federal Reserve is 
continually working to improve the FAQ process. As part of these 
ongoing efforts the Federal Reserve recently implemented a new FAQ 
system to enhance the Federal Reserve's ability to track and respond to 
questions. The new system will allow for more insight into the status 
of FAQs and help ensure more consistent timing on responses. In 
addition, similar to the effort undertaken in 2013,\3\ the Federal 
Reserve incorporated all relevant historical FAQs into the final 
instructions associated with this proposal. The Federal Reserve will 
continue to incorporate relevant comments and questions related to the 
FR Y-14 into the instructions on a regular basis.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \3\ See 78 Federal Register 59934.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    In the proposal, the Federal Reserve notified respondents of the 
intent to share FR Y-14 data sets with the Office of Financial Research 
(OFR). One commenter recommended that the OFR publish aggregate 
summaries of the data so reporting companies, and the public, can gain 
insights into industry trends and developments.

B. Attestation

    Commenters generally expressed concerns about specific elements of 
the proposed attestation requirement for the FR Y-14 submission and, in 
particular, the timing necessary to meet the proposed requirements.
    Both commenters argued that the proposed effective date of June 30, 
2016, would not provide sufficient time to implement several of the 
proposed attestation requirements. However, one commenter agreed that 
it would be practical and appropriate for respondents to provide an 
attestation as to conformance with the FR Y-14 instructions by June 30, 
2016, subject to the specific recommendations in the commenter's 
letter. Both commenters indicated that additional time was needed to 
adapt to The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations (COSO)-based 
framework, including materially supplementing and/or modifying existing 
systems and processes, and establishing policies, documentation, and 
certification frameworks. One commenter pointed out that, although some 
respondents may be able to leverage parts of their existing control 
infrastructure required under the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 (Sarbanes-
Oxley), the scope and level of data granularity on the FR Y-14 forms is 
substantially larger than what is required under Sarbanes-Oxley and 
therefore beyond the capability of most firms. Finally, one commenter 
noted that the implementation of the various attestation requirements 
would require a significant investment in firm personnel, management, 
and compliance and information technology resources, and additional 
time for implementation would allow for more deliberate expansion and 
upgrade of existing processes and systems to support the attestation.
    In light of the above, both commenters suggested alternative 
implementation timelines. One commenter noted that a major consulting 
firm estimated it would take a company 15 months to implement the 
controls necessary to assess risk information. The other commenter 
suggested a phased-in implementation approach, which would provide 
respondents additional time to make the more substantial alterations to 
existing systems and processes necessary to support certain components 
of the proposed attestation. The phased in approach would involve: (i) 
An attestation solely regarding compliance with the FR Y-14 
instructions effective as of June 30, 2016, which is the same timeframe 
as in the proposal; (ii) an incremental requirement for respondents to 
demonstrate as part of the supervisory process, by April 2017, that a 
framework has been put in place to identify, test, and independently 
validate key control activities to support these attestations; and 
(iii) an attestation regarding the effectiveness of internal controls 
and to the material correctness of data as of April 2018.
    In addition, one commenter indicated that the proposal appeared to 
require attestation to internal controls with each annual, quarterly 
and monthly FR Y-14 report submission, but that doing so would not be 
feasible at that frequency. The commenter suggested that the 
effectiveness of internal controls be limited to annual submissions on 
the FR Y-14A.
    The Federal Reserve recognized in the initial Federal Register 
notice the time needed for LISCC firms to ``enhance certain systems and 
processes'' and ``modify internal control frameworks and data 
governance committees.'' In response to comments and in order to allow 
additional time for respondents to put internal controls processes and 
frameworks in place and complete testing of these processes and 
frameworks, the initial attestation requirement in the final Y-14 will 
be delayed until reports with a December 31, 2016, as-of date. In 
addition, in connection with the initial attestation and to allow time 
for respondents to develop and test their internal control systems, the 
initial attestation will relate solely to the effectiveness of internal 
controls over submissions as of December 31, 2016, rather than with 
respect to submissions throughout the year. Effective for the monthly, 
quarterly, and semi-annual FR Y-14 reports submitted as of January 31, 
2017, and thereafter, respondents will attest to conformance with the 
FR Y-14 instructions and to the material correctness of data to the 
best of the respondent's knowledge, and agree to report material 
weaknesses and any material errors in the data as they are identified 
starting January 1, 2017. Effective December 31, 2017, and for all 
future reporting periods, a respondent's attestation as to the 
effectiveness of internal controls will be with regard to FR Y-14 
submissions filed throughout the year.
    To clarify the timing of these staggered attestation requirements, 
the final Y-14 includes three separate attestation cover pages. First, 
as indicated, with respect to the monthly, quarterly, and annual FR Y-
14 reports with a December 31, 2016, as-of date, respondents will 
attest to internal controls around the reports submitted as of that 
date. Second, effective for the monthly, quarterly, and semi-annual FR 
Y-14 reports submitted beginning January 31, 2017, and thereafter, 
respondents will attest on a separate cover page to the respondent's 
conformance with the FR Y-14 instructions and to the material 
correctness of data to the best of the respondent's knowledge, and 
agree to report material weaknesses and any material errors in the data 
as they are identified starting January 1, 2017. Third and finally, 
effective for reports with a December 31, 2017, as-of date and for all 
future FR Y-14 submissions as of December 31 of a calendar year, the 
initial December 31, 2016, cover page will be replaced by a new cover 
page that will be submitted annually and will include an attestation to 
the effectiveness of internal controls around the annual FR Y-14A 
submission and around the FR Y-14Q/M reports that are submitted 
throughout the year.
    Commenters suggested various modifications to the attestation 
requirement and associated attestation language. One commenter noted 
that the proposal indicates that the Federal Reserve would not expect 
to penalize a firm for incorrect reporting where there has been a good 
faith effort to reasonably interpret the instructions or seek input on 
a question or interpretation from the Federal Reserve

[[Page 3415]]

and requested that similar qualifying language be added to the 
attestation form. The final FR Y-14 includes these revisions to the 
attestation form.
    Under the proposal, the firm's CFO would have been required to 
attest to the internal controls over the reporting of actual data as-of 
the reporting period. A commenter noted that internal controls over 
financial reporting and risk management data are the joint 
responsibility of senior management and that the CFO is not 
individually responsible for internal controls over the reporting of FR 
Y-14 data. The commenter suggested that the attestation form be 
modified to indicate that the CFO attests that senior management is 
responsible for the internal controls over the reporting of the FR Y-14 
data. In response, the final FR Y-14 incorporates this modification to 
the attestation form.
    Both commenters addressed the definition of materiality in the 
attestation language. One commenter expressed concern with the absence 
of a definition of ``materiality'' which inherently requires each 
respondent to make an individual determination on materiality. The 
other commenter requested that the Federal Reserve confirm that 
respondents would be expected to develop materiality policies based on 
their own capital plan submission. The Federal Reserve does not 
generally define materiality within the FR Y-14 reports.
    Furthermore, outlining materiality for specific respondents would 
not be feasible. As stated in the Federal Register for the proposal, a 
BHC would be required to have a policy for determining materiality in 
the context of quantitative and qualitative considerations for their 
firm. Accordingly, the final FR Y-14 includes the proposed definition 
of materiality without change.
    One commenter requested that the Federal Reserve make attestation 
requirements applicable to the intermediate holding company (IHC) 
subsidiaries of LISCC foreign banking organizations (FBOs) no earlier 
than April 2018. On February 18, 2014, the Board adopted a final rule 
implementing enhanced prudential standards for FBOs,\4\ which, among 
other things, requires an FBO with U.S. non-branch assets of greater 
than $50 billion to establish a U.S. IHC by July 1, 2016, to which it 
must transfer its entire ownership interest in all U.S. BHCs, U.S. 
insured depository institutions, and U.S. subsidiaries.\5\ The 
commenter expressed concern that the timing of the implementation of 
the attestation requirement would be particularly challenging for FBOs 
currently restructuring to complete the formation of their IHC. 
Currently, the Board has not proposed reporting requirements for IHCs, 
which, as noted in the preamble to the final rule implementing enhanced 
prudential standards for FBOs, would be addressed at a later date.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \4\ 79 Federal Register 17239 (March 27, 2014).
    \5\ See 12 CFR 252.153.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    At such time as the Board proposes reporting requirements for IHCs, 
the Federal Reserve expects to invite comment through a notice and 
comment process, and would evaluate the particular circumstances and 
challenges surrounding IHC formation vis-[agrave]-vis the full spectrum 
of Board regulatory reporting requirements. The Federal Reserve does, 
however, reiterate that the attestation requirement applies to LISCC 
firms.

C. Schedule Specific Comments

FR Y-14A
Schedules A.1.c.1 (General RWA) and A.1.d. (Capital)
    Related to the proposed modifications to the collection in 
accordance with revisions to the capital plan and stress test rules, 
specifically elimination of the use of the tier 1 common ratio, one 
commenter noted that as of the end of the comment period, the changes 
to the capital plan and stress test rules had not yet been finalized 
and asked that the Federal Reserve reflect any changes in the final 
release of the FR Y-14 forms. On November 25, 2015, the Board approved 
the final rule to modify the capital plan and stress test rules. 
Accordingly, and in response to the comment, the final FR Y-14 removes 
items relating to the reporting of ``tier 1 common capital'' as 
proposed from the following schedules in order to align with the final 
rule: FR Y-14A General RWA (Schedule A.1.c.1), Standardized RWA 
(Schedule A.1.c.2), Capital (Schedule A.1.d), Regulatory Capital 
Transitions (Schedule D.4), Regulatory Capital Instruments (RCI, 
Schedule C), and the FR Y-14Q Regulatory Capital Transitions (Schedule 
D.4) and Regulatory Capital Instruments (Schedule C).\6\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \6\ Effective January 1, 2016, tier 1 common capital has been 
removed from the Board's capital plan rule (12 CFR 225.8). See 80 
Federal Register 75419 (December 2, 2015).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Both commenters supported the removal of items related to tier 1 
capital consistent with the rule, however recommended removing the 
items from the technical instructions in order to limit the number of 
edit checks respondents are required to respond to, rather than keeping 
these items in the technical instructions as proposed. The Federal 
Reserve recognizes the burden of responding to edits, as well as the 
technical effort by both the Federal Reserve and respondents to 
incorporate report changes. The Federal Reserve will keep the tier 1 
common capital-related items in the FR Y-14A Summary schedule (Schedule 
A) technical instructions in order to mitigate the operational risk of 
making changes as proposed; however, to address the commenters concerns 
and reduce the burden on respondents, edit checks on these items will 
be eliminated and responses will not be requested.
Schedules A.1.c.2 (Standardized RWA) and D.4 (RCT)
    Under the proposal, the Standardized RWA (FR Y-14A, Schedule 
A.1.c.2) and Regulatory Capital Transitions (FR Y-14A, Schedule D.4 and 
FR Y-14Q, Schedule D.4) schedules would have been revised by replacing 
the existing market-risk weight asset portion with the relevant items 
from the FFIEC 102 and aligning the remaining items with the FR Y-9C 
Schedule HC-R Part II. Both commenters noted that the aforementioned 
changes were effective for the Standardized RWA schedule (FR Y-14A, 
Schedule A.1.c.d) as-of December 31, 2015 and for the Regulatory 
Capital Instruments schedules (FR Y-14A Schedule D.4, FR Y-14Q Schedule 
D.4) as-of June 30, 2016. They recommended that the effective dates be 
consistent and delayed until June 30, 2016. In response, the changes 
for all three schedules (FR Y-14A, A.1.c.2 (Standardized RWA), D.4 
(RCT) and 14Q D.4 (RCT) will be implemented as modified below, 
effective June 30, 2016.
    One commenter expressed concern that these modifications would 
require an unnecessary level of forecasting granularity around Market 
Risk RWA and recommended that this level of detail not be included in 
the final version. The other commenter stated they had no objection to 
the changes as proposed. In response to the comment received, the 
Federal Reserve further reviewed the items proposed to be added to 
these schedule in alignment with the FFIEC 102. In light of these 
comments, the final FR Y-14 removes the requirement to report 
projections for certain more granular proposed items from the FR Y14A 
Standardized RWA (Schedule A.1.c.2) and Regulatory Capital Transitions 
(Schedule D.4) schedules, while retaining general alignment with the 
structure of the FFIEC 102 report and reporting of the actual 
information. These changes will

[[Page 3416]]

be implemented as modified effective June 30, 2016.
Schedule A.2.b (Retail Repurchase)
    Commenters expressed concern with the proposal to break out the 
Retail Repurchase schedule from the Summary (Schedule A) and moving the 
submission date in line with the quarterly schedules given the schedule 
contains projected data as well as actual data. The commenters were 
also concerned that the proposed effective date of June 30, 2016 would 
not allow respondents enough time to implement the necessary controls 
and processes required to submit the new semi-annual schedule and 
recommended delaying implementation an additional six months to be 
effective December 31, 2016. The Federal Reserve agrees that the 
projected data should remain part of the Summary (Schedule A) and 
confirms that the new FR Y-14A semi-annual schedule breaks out only the 
actual data from the existing Retail Repurchase schedule (Schedule 
A.2.b). Given the information to be collected on both schedules is 
already reported on the FR Y-14A, the restructuring changes only the 
submission date for actual not projected data, and that the submission 
date is more than six months out, the final FR Y-14 proceeds with this 
change as indicated above, effective June 30, 2016 as proposed.
Schedule A.2.c (ASC 310-30)
    The Federal Reserve proposed eliminating this schedule effective 
as-of June 30, 2016. One commenter recommended that the Federal Reserve 
eliminate this schedule as-of December 31, 2015. The other commenter 
noted that although they have previously requested a six month window 
between the finalization of changes and effective date, it is less 
burdensome to remove a minor reporting item and therefore supported the 
change as proposed. In an effort to allow as much time as possible 
between finalization and the effective date for both the removal and 
addition of items and in support of limiting the changes effective for 
the December 31, 2015 as-of date, the final FR Y-14 implements this 
change as proposed.
Schedule A.7.c (PPNR)
    In an effort to reduce burden, the Federal Reserve proposed 
aligning this schedule with the ``normal environment'' requirement. 
There were no questions or concerns on the proposed change, however one 
commenter requested that the Federal Reserve periodically review 
whether the items to be submitted are still necessary and propose 
removing those that are not. The Federal Reserve continues to review 
the FR Y-14 and propose to remove items as they are no longer 
necessary, as evidenced in this proposal with the removal of two 
schedules and other items. Upon further review, the final FR Y-14 
eliminates three additional variables from the PPNR Metrics schedule 
(Schedule A.7.c): Merchant Banking/Private Equity--Assets Under 
Management (Line 27), Sales and Trading--Total Proprietary Trading 
Revenue (Line 29), and Investment Services--Corporate Trust Deals 
Administered (Line 43). In addition, a materiality threshold will be 
added to the investment banking metrics of the PPNR Metrics schedule to 
further limit the amount of detail required for many firms. The 
instructions will be updated to indicate that only firms who report 
greater than $100 million in item 15, Investment Banking, of Schedule 
A.7.a (PPNR Projections) should report the investment banking metrics 
(Lines 11 to 26) in Section A of Schedule A.7.c (PPNR Metrics). The 
Federal Reserve will continue to review the FR Y-14 reports for 
unnecessary items for potential elimination in future proposals. In 
addition, in response to the general request for additional time to 
implement changes, the effective date of all modifications to this 
schedule will be delayed until June 30, 2016.
Schedule F (Business Plan Changes)
    One commenter supported the formalization of the Business Plan 
Changes (BPC) schedule (Schedule F), but was concerned that the BPC 
schedule instructions as proposed did not appear consistent with the FR 
Y-14A summary and did not incorporate previous FAQ guidance. The 
commenter also requested that clarification on the definition of 
``material''. The final FR Y-14 BPC instructions have been updated to 
identify a limited number of items on the BPC schedule which, for 
technical reasons, require different instructions. In addition, the 
final FR Y-14 instructions have been updated to include certain 
clarifications from the FAQ process. Finally, the requirement to report 
the BPC schedule is based on whether the BHC includes material business 
plan changes in their capital plan, as defined in the CCAR 
instructions. In response, the final FR Y-14 includes updates to the 
BPC instructions to refer BHCs to the CCAR instructions for a given 
year for requirements of materiality.
FR Y-14Q
    The majority of comments received regarding the FR Y-14Q requested 
clarification of item definitions and will be addressed in the final 
instructions. Several substantive comments, particularly on the 
Wholesale Corporate Loan (Schedule H.1) and Commercial Real Estate 
(Schedule H.2) schedules, are summarized below.
Schedule A.1-A.10 (Retail)
    Commenters requested additional information on the proposed change 
to the loan population on the Retail schedule. They noted that the 
initial notice in the Federal Register stated that the change would 
limit the population of the schedule to ``accrual loans'', while the 
draft instructions indicate a BHC should ``include loans and leases 
held for investment at amortized cost.'' The language in the Federal 
Register Notice should have stated that the change was to ``restrict 
the loan population of this schedule to loans held at amortized cost in 
order to accurately reflect the intention of the schedule and be 
responsive to industry comments.'' This is in alignment with the 
language in the draft instructions. In response to the general request 
to provide additional time to implement changes, the effective date of 
this change will be delayed until the report as-of June 30, 2016.
Schedule A.8-A.9 (Retail)
    One commenter expressed concern with the effective date of the 
proposal to exclude non-purpose loans for purchasing and carrying 
securities from this schedule as it requires changes to complex, 
product-specific loan tagging rules, including for loans already tagged 
for months in the quarter. The commenter requested that the Federal 
Reserve make this change effective as-of June 30, 2016. The effective 
date of this change, as well as the complementary changes to the FR Y-
14Q Wholesale (Schedule H.1) and Balances (Schedule M) schedules until 
the report as-of June 30, 2016.
Schedule C.3 (Regulatory Capital Instruments (RCI)--Issuances During 
the Quarter)
    Both commenters requested clarification on the intended effective 
date of this change and the nature of the one-time submissions. The 
additions and modifications will be implemented as proposed, however in 
response to the general request to provide additional time to implement 
changes, the effective date of the changes proposed for December 31, 
2015 will be delayed until the report as-of June 30, 2016. As a result, 
all proposed changes to the RCI schedule will be effective June 30, 
2016, at which time there will be one separate

[[Page 3417]]

one-time submission of all subordinated debt instruments for the 
effective date. Additionally, any new respondents are required to 
report the one-time submission.
Schedule D.4 (RCT)
    As with the corresponding changes to the FR Y-14A Standardized RWA 
(Schedule A.1.c.2) and RCT (D.4) schedules, commenters noted the 
inconsistent effective dates and recommended that the proposed changes 
to the FR Y-14Q RCT (Schedule D.4) also be effective June 30, 2016. The 
Federal Reserve agrees with this suggestion and the proposed changes 
will be made effective as-of June 30, 2016.
    As noted in regards to the FR Y-14A, one commenter expressed 
concern that the proposed modifications would require an unnecessary 
level of forecasting granularity around Market Risk RWA. Since the FR 
Y-14Q RCT Schedule (Schedule D.4) does not require any projected data, 
the changes to the FR Y-14Q RCT schedule will be implemented as 
proposed effective June 30, 2016.
Schedule G (PPNR)
    One commenter noted that the Federal Reserve should not eliminate 
the deposit funding threshold for submission of the Net Interest Income 
(NII) worksheet and require all respondents to submit such schedules. 
Specifically, the commenter stated that requiring firms to submit the 
NII templates would impose undue burden and offered an alternative of 
only completing the banking book assets and liabilities rather than 
both trading book and banking book. The Federal Reserve notes that the 
schedule separates out specific instructions related to trading and 
banking book expectations and the trading line items are already 
required to be completed for other regulatory reporting purposes (FR Y-
9C). Furthermore, the underlying NII reporting systems are already 
required as part of separate supervisory expectations related to 
interest rate risk identification. Finally, collecting this information 
will enhance the comparability of assets and liabilities across BHCs 
and promote greater consistency in supervisory evaluations. Therefore, 
the changes do not appear to impose unnecessary burden and the final FR 
Y-14 implements the revisions as proposed.
    One commenter stated that the Federal Register Notice did not 
indicate an effective date for the change in the NII worksheet deposit 
funding threshold. The other commenter added that this change will 
require sufficient time for newly covered firms to build reporting 
systems. The effective date was erroneously omitted from the proposal, 
and changes were intended to be proposed to be effective March 31, 
2016. In response to these and the general comments on timing, the 
effective date of this change will be delayed until June 30, 2016.
Schedule H.1 (Corporate Loan) and H.2 (Commercial Real Estate)
    Both commenters expressed concerns with the effective date of the 
changes to the Corporate Loan and CRE schedules, especially regarding 
the disposed loan and syndicated pipeline reporting. In particular 
commenters explained that respondents may need to update systems to 
capture and report the information required as proposed. They also 
noted that the non-purpose loans were proposed to be included on the 
Corporate Loan schedule (H.1) as-of December 31, 2015, but that the new 
purpose codes associated with those loans were proposed to be effective 
March 31, 2016 and asked that the changes be implemented concurrently. 
In response to the aforementioned comments and in consideration of the 
additional time needed to implement changes, the changes related to 
disposed loans and the syndicated pipeline will be effective September 
30, 2016, and all other changes to the Corporate Loan and Commercial 
Real Estate schedules effective as-of June 30, 2016.
    Commenters requested clarification on the definition and purpose of 
disposed loans as it relates the expansion of the loan population and 
the proposed Disposition Flag field. Specifically, they questioned 
whether facility information should be reported as-of the disposition 
date and if that means capturing balances and data prior to the actual 
payoff or charge-off of the facility. The Federal Reserve confirms that 
the data should be reported as-of the date of disposition, not prior to 
the payoff or charge-off of the facility.
    In addition, one commenter recommended adding Disposition Flag 
values for when loans fall under the $1M reporting threshold, or shift 
from one loan schedule to another. In response, the final FR Y-14 adds 
two options to the Disposition Flag field. In addition, to accommodate 
the new item for facilities shifting from one schedule to another, the 
final FR Y-14 adds an additional field to capture to which schedule the 
facility shifted.
    The Federal Reserve proposed expanding the options of the 
Participation Flag item to include the Shared National Credit (SNC) 
program. One commenter stated that some respondents are classified as 
expanded reporters and, therefore, subject to a broader data collection 
referred to as ``Large Corporate Syndicated Credit'' (LCSC) and 
therefore recommended that all references to SNCs in the proposal be 
clarified to include all LCSC eligible credits as well for respondents 
that are classified as expanded reporters. The Federal Reserve confirms 
that intent of the new proposed options in the Participation Loan Flag 
are, in conjunction with the SNC Internal Credit Facility ID, to 
distinguish whether or not the credit facility is included in the SNC 
report. Accordingly, the final FR Y-14 implements the change as 
proposed, effective June 30, 2016.
    Both commenters indicated that two items for the Credit Rating 
Agency Equivalent Rating field (Field 96, 97 of Schedule H.1 and Field 
59, 60 of Schedule H.2) were included in the draft instructions but not 
proposed as changes and therefore had no specified effective date. 
Commenters had several questions regarding the reporting of these 
items. The Federal Reserve confirms that these items were erroneously 
included in the draft instructions, were not proposed to be added, and 
therefore will not be implemented. These items have been removed from 
the final FR Y-14 instructions.

Schedule H.1 (Corporate Loan)

    Both commenters asked for guidance regarding the intended 
difference between two of the five categories to be added to the Credit 
Facility Purpose item, namely (1) non-purpose margin lending 
collateralized by securities and (2) other non-purpose lending 
collateralized by securities. One commenter stated that per the 
definition, a ``non-purpose loan'' cannot be a margin loan. After 
considering the definition and types of loans to be reported in both 
proposed categories mentioned in the comment, the final FR Y-14 adds 
only one consolidated category for ``Non-purpose loans collateralized 
by securities'' rather than the two categories proposed.
    The Federal Reserve proposed expanding the loan population to 
include non-purpose loans that are not graded in conjunction with 
complementary changes to FR Y-14Q Schedules A.8, A.9, and M to reflect 
the intention of the schedule and be response to industry comments. One 
commenter recommend that the definition of non-purpose loans be revised 
to ``loans collateralized by securities and that the proceeds of such

[[Page 3418]]

loans are not contractually restricted to be used only to purchase or 
carry securities.'' The same commenter expressed that it was unclear 
whether non-graded loans for purchasing and carrying securities are to 
be reported at the facility level, and if so that this information is 
generally not readily available for reporting.
    The corporate loan population was amended to include non-purpose 
loans collateralized by securities made for any purpose other than 
purchasing or carrying securities which are reportable in the relevant 
FR Y-9C categories outlined in the instructions. Loans reported in FR 
Y-9C, Schedule HC-C, line item 9.b.(1) (Loans for purchasing or 
carrying securities) should not be reported at the facility level in 
the Corporate schedule. Accordingly, the final FR Y-14 includes the 
definition as proposed.
    One commenter stated that scored non-purpose loans are currently 
reported on FR Y-14M report and requested confirmation that scored non-
purpose loans are not included within ``non-purpose loans that are not 
graded.'' The corporate loan population will be expanded as proposed to 
include both scored and graded non-purpose loans which are reportable 
in the relevant FR Y-9C line items indicated in the Corporate Loan 
Schedule (Schedule H.1) instructions. This change is intended to help 
ensure that non-purpose commercial loans and loans for purchasing or 
carrying securities are treated consistently across institutions and 
the Federal Reserve confirms that any non-purpose loans reportable in 
other FR Y-9C line items not specified in the Corporate Loan schedule 
instructions should continue to be reported on other FR Y-14 schedules 
per the instructions of those schedules. As previously indicated, the 
final FR Y-14 delays the effective date of this proposed change until 
June 30, 2016.
    One commenter asked for further details surrounding the reporting 
of the new Credit Facility Purpose (Field 22) code ``bridge 
financing'', including whether this code value only includes real 
estate financing loans and how it relates to the ``mini-perm'' loan 
purpose code recently added to the CRE schedule (Schedule H.2). The 
Federal Reserve clarifies that bridge financing is not limited to only 
real estate financing loans. Bridge financing is interim financing, 
typically taken out for a period of 2 weeks to 3 years pending the 
arrangement of larger or longer-term financing. The ``Bridge 
Financing'' purpose code on the Corporate schedule (Schedule H.1) is 
not meant to be related to the mini-perm loan purpose code on the CRE 
schedule (Schedule H.2).
    Both commenters requested clarification as to what was to be 
reported in the two new credit facility types proposed for Field 20 
(Credit Facility Type), ``Fronting Loan'' and ``Swingline''. In 
response to comments, the final FR Y-14 modifies Field 20 (Credit 
Facility Type) to include one additional option called ``Fronting 
Exposure'', as opposed to the two additional options proposed. The 
Fronting Exposure option should be selected for credit facilities 
reported in the schedule that represent a BHC's exposure to fund 
certain obligations (e.g., swinglines or letters of credit) on behalf 
of other participant lenders. In addition, the instructions are revised 
to indicate that for credit facilities which include a fronting 
exposure, BHCs should report their pro-rata share of the stated 
commitment amount as one facility to the borrower and the fronting 
obligations as separate credit facilities to each of the lending group 
participants.
    In regards to the proposed changes to the Credit Facility Type 
field, one commenter also requested guidance on reporting facilities 
that have both a Swingline and LC Issuance limit. In response to 
comments, the final FR Y-14 instructions have been revised to indicate 
that for credit facilities which include a fronting exposure, BHCs 
should report their pro-rata share of the stated commitment amount as 
one facility to the borrower and the fronting obligations as separate 
credit facilities to each of the lending group participants. Fronting 
exposures are those that represent a BHC's exposure to fund certain 
obligations (e.g., swinglines or letters of credit) on behalf of other 
participant lenders. For such exposures, the BHC should report the new 
Fronting Exposure option in the Credit Facility Type field. To address 
this, the general instructions will have been updated to include the 
following example: For example, consider a facility with $400 million 
committed balance where the BHC is the agent bank and the BHC's pro-
rata share of the commitment is 10% or $40 million. Assume further that 
the credit facility contains a $50 million sublimit that the BHC, as 
agent, has an obligation to advance on behalf of lending group 
participants which may include swinglines, letters of credit and other 
fronting obligations. In this example, the agent BHC would report one 
credit facility to the borrower with a commitment of $40 million and 
would report separate facilities to each of the lending group 
participants with pro-rata commitments totaling $45 million (or 90%).
    Both commenters asked for clarification regarding the removal of 
the requirement to only report legally binding commitments. 
Specifically, one commenter asked for clarification regarding the 
definition of ``legally binding'' and asked whether all uncommitted 
and/or unadvised lines on the FR Y-14Q report should be included or if 
the change was to allow for the inclusion of exposures in the 
syndicated loan pipeline. The other commenter asked if by removing the 
legally binding restriction to the loan population, the Board intended 
to report all facilities in the syndicated loan pipeline or just those 
facilities considered commitments to commit based on a reporting 
company's legal definition. The Federal Reserve confirms that the loan 
population has been amended to capture commitments as defined in the FR 
Y-9C, Schedule HC-L. In addition, the FR Y-14Q Corporate Loan schedule 
(Schedule H.1) has been amended to capture facilities in the syndicated 
loan pipeline including single-signed exposures, regardless of whether 
the BHC considers those facilities to be commitments. As per the FR Y-
14Q, Corporate Loan schedule instructions, BHCs should not report 
informal ``advised lines.''
    Also in regards to the removal of the requirement to report only 
legally binding commitments, one commenter noted that the language in 
the proposed instructions for the Corporate Loan Schedule (H.1) was not 
consistent with that of the Commercial Real Estate (CRE) Schedule (H.2) 
and asked if the intention was to eliminate the legally binding 
restriction from both schedules. The Federal Reserve agrees that there 
should be consistency between the wholesale schedules, and the CRE 
schedule (H.2) of the final FR Y-14 has been revised to also remove the 
legally binding language in alignment with the Corporate schedule 
(H.1).
    Both commenters stated that it was unclear what type of lending is 
intended to be captured in the syndicated loan population and what is 
meant by ``closed and settled''. In response, the Federal Reserve 
confirms that the loan population should include syndicated loan 
commitments in the various stages of the syndication process, including 
single-signed exposures where the BHC has signed a commitment letter 
and has extended the terms to the borrower, even if the borrower has 
not countersigned. In response to the comment, the final FR Y-14 
clarifies the Syndicated Loan Flag field by including the following: 
``Closed and settled refers

[[Page 3419]]

to the final phase where loan documents are fully executed and fully 
binding with post-closing selldown to all participants complete. Loans 
which have closed but are still pending execution of final 
documentation by all syndicate participants should remain in phase 3 
`Closed but not settled'.''
    One commenter asked for clarification as to whether only those 
syndicated loans for which the respondents serves as lead bank should 
be reported. The Federal Reserve confirms that any BHC which has signed 
a commitment letter and extended terms to the borrower should report 
the syndicated loans.
    Finally, one commenter stated that information about these 
syndicated pipeline commitments is generally not captured in a 
reporting company's loan accounting systems, but is maintained 
``offline'' and appears in analytical documents and other artifacts. 
Thus, reporting companies would face a significant, on-going manual 
burden to somehow systematically collect the required detail on 
syndicated pipeline commitments to support the requested reporting, 
particularly at the level of detail required. Additionally, absent 
proposed changes for how to populate correctly the Origination Date, 
Maturity Date, and Committed Exposure Global for pipeline loans, the 
Board has provided no guidance on which Corporate Loan (Schedule H.l) 
fields would be required at time of submission. The other commenter 
requested a delay in implementation of the disposed loans and 
syndicated pipeline items of two quarters to at least September 30, 
2016. In consideration of this feedback, the implementation of changes 
related to disposed loans and syndicated pipeline in the final FR Y-14 
will be delayed until September 30, 2016.
Schedule L (Counterparty)
    One commenter asked if it is acceptable for BHCs to use Global 
Industry Classification Standards (GICS) codes on this schedule as 
allowed in Schedule H.1 (Corporate Loan), field 8, in place of the 
North American Industry Classification System (NAICS) codes indicated 
in the new column instructions. The Federal Reserve notes that the 
instructions for Schedule H.1, field 8, also indicate that the NAICS 
code should be provided and only offer alternatives in the case the 
NAICS code is not available. In addition, prior submissions have shown 
that it is rare for firms to provide GICS instead of NAICS codes. To 
capture the greater level of granularity they make available, 
particularly for financial institutions, the final FR Y-14 retains the 
requirement that NAICS codes be used and the instructions remain as 
proposed.
    In addition, one commenter pointed out that the current 
instructions do not reflect changes effective in the second quarter of 
2015 that revised the level at which the BHC must report data on 
schedules L.1 and L.4. The Federal Reserve confirms that there has been 
no change to this requirement and that the final instructions for these 
schedules will reflect the requirement as outlined in the current 
instructions.
    All proposed modifications to the Counterparty Schedule (Schedule 
L) were proposed to be effective December 31, 2015. Given the general 
request to provide additional time to implement changes, the effective 
date of all Counterparty schedule changes to the final FR Y-14 will be 
delayed until June 30, 2016
FR Y-14M
Schedule A (First Lien) and Schedule B (Home Equity)
    Generally, commenters supported the addition of the ``Serviced by 
Others'' flag on the First Lien (Schedule A) and Home Equity (Schedule 
B) schedules. Both commenters noted, however, that the title of the 
field, ``SBO Flag'', implied that the ``Y'' code should be defined as 
serviced by others and the ``N'' code as serviced by the BHC rather 
than the definitions specified in the instructions. The Federal Reserve 
agrees that it would be more logical for the flag codes in the 
instructions to be defined as suggested by the commenter rather than as 
proposed, and the final FR Y-14 instructions have been adjusted to 
reflect this change. Given the general request to provide additional 
time to implement changes, final FR Y-14 delays the effective date of 
this change until June 30, 2016.
Schedule B (Home Equity)
    The Federal Reserve proposed adding a new modification type, 
proposed code 13 ``HELOC Line Renewal'' in Field 77 (Modification Type) 
on this schedule. Field 77 instructs that the modification type should 
be reported for any loan that is currently operating under modified 
terms and should identify the specific terms that were altered through 
loss mitigation efforts. Both commenters questioned if all HELOC line 
renewals should be reported on this line or only those completed 
through loss mitigation efforts.
    The Federal Reserve appreciates this feedback and agrees there is a 
distinction between these two cases not captured in this item as 
proposed. The Federal Reserve believes that renewal of a creditworthy 
borrower is equivalent to prepayment of the existing line and 
origination of a new line. For a borrower who does not meet current 
credit standards, the line renewal is equivalent to a type of loan 
modification: the contractual terms of the line will be changed because 
the borrower has been identified as one who is likely to default if the 
bank takes no action. Therefore, those borrowers should be treated as 
though they did not prepay, but instead, entered the amortization 
period of the HELOC with modified terms. To capture the distinction 
between these two cases and in response to the comment, the final FR Y-
14 has been modified to add an additional code to the Modification Type 
field, Code 13 to represent the ``HELOC Line Renewal (Regular)'', and 
code 14 to represent ``HELOC Line Renewal (loss mitigation strategy)''. 
The instructions for the final FR Y-14 also will be updated to reflect 
the additional item codes and their definitions. Given the general 
request to provide additional time to implement changes, this change 
will be effective in the final FR Y-14 beginning June 30, 2016
    In the initial Federal Register Notice, the Federal Reserve 
specifically requested information on the collection of data related to 
the performance of a first lien that is related to a junior lien 
reported on the FR Y-14M Home Equity Schedule (Schedule B), including 
what standards could make the item easier to report. In response to 
this request, one commenter recommended that the Performance of the 
First Lien on the First Lien Schedule (Schedule A) and Performance of 
Junior Liens on the Home Equity Schedule (Schedule B) fields be removed 
from the aforementioned FR Y-14M collections and that the Current 
Credit Bureau Score, which is already being reported, be used as a 
proxy to monitor any deterioration for evaluating performance and 
probability of default. The Federal Reserve recognizes the cost and 
burden expressed by the industry in supplying these items and 
appreciates the feedback provided in response to the request. The 
Federal Reserve agrees with the proposed suggestion to use current 
scores as a reasonably proxy, and accordingly, the above-mentioned 
fields in the final FR Y-14 have been removed from the applicable 
schedules. To ensure the information necessary is available given this 
change, the instructions for the final FR Y-14 also require that the 
fields `Current Credit Bureau Score Date' and `Current Credit Bureau 
Score' be updated at least one month within the quarter, and refreshed

[[Page 3420]]

at least one month within every subsequent quarter. These changes will 
be effective beginning June 30, 2016.

Technical Clarifications

    Commenters asked for a number of technical clarifications regarding 
specific data items on the FR Y-14 forms. These questions will be 
addressed in the finalized version of the amended FR Y-14A/Q/M 
instructions.

    Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, January 14, 
2016.

Robert deV. Frierson,
Secretary of the Board.
[FR Doc. 2016-01043 Filed 1-20-16; 8:45 am]
 BILLING CODE P



                                                    3412                         Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 13 / Thursday, January 21, 2016 / Notices

                                                      Parties: Kawasaki Kisen Kaisha, Ltd.;                    Final approval under OMB delegated                  and Business Plan Changes, 10 hours.
                                                    and Liberty Global Logistics LLC.                       authority of the extension for three                   FR Y–14Q: Securities, 13 hours; Retail,
                                                      Filing Party: John P. Meade, Esq.;                    years, with revision, of the following                 16 hours; PPNR, 711 hours; Wholesale,
                                                    General Counsel; K- Line America, Inc.;                 information collection:                                152 hours; Trading, 1,926 hours;
                                                    6199 Bethlehem Road, Preston, MD                           Report title: Capital Assessments and               Regulatory capital transitions, 23 hours;
                                                    21655.                                                  Stress Testing information collection.                 Regulatory capital instruments, 52
                                                      Synopsis: The agreement would                            Agency form number: FR Y–14A/Q/                     hours; Operational risk, 50 hours; MSR
                                                    authorize the parties to discuss non-rate               M.                                                     Valuation, 24 hours; Supplemental, 4
                                                    operational matters worldwide.                             OMB control number: 7100–0341.                      hours; and Retail FVO/HFS, 16 hours;
                                                                                                               Effective Dates: December 31, 2015,                 Counterparty, 508 hours; and Balances,
                                                      By Order of the Federal Maritime                      June 30, 2016 and September 30, 2016.
                                                    Commission.                                                                                                    16 hours; FR Y–14M: 1st lien mortgage,
                                                                                                               Frequency: Annually, semi-annually,                 515 hours; Home equity, 515 hours; and
                                                      Dated: January 15, 2016.
                                                                                                            quarterly, and monthly.                                Credit card, 510 hours. FR Y–14 On-
                                                    Rachel E. Dickon,                                          Respondents: Any top-tier bank
                                                    Assistant Secretary.
                                                                                                                                                                   Going automation revisions, 480 hours.
                                                                                                            holding company (BHC) (other than a                    FR Y–14 Attestation Implementation,
                                                    [FR Doc. 2016–01160 Filed 1–20–16; 8:45 am]             foreign banking organization), that has                4,800 hours; and On-going audit and
                                                    BILLING CODE P                                          $50 billion or more in total consolidated              review, 2,560 hours.
                                                                                                            assets, as determined based on: (i) The                   Number of respondents: 33.
                                                                                                            average of the BHC’s total consolidated                   General description of report: The FR
                                                    FEDERAL RESERVE SYSTEM                                  assets in the four most recent quarters                Y–14 series of reports are authorized by
                                                                                                            as reported quarterly on the BHC’s                     section 165 of the Dodd-Frank Act,
                                                    Proposed Agency Information                             Consolidated Financial Statements for                  which requires the Federal Reserve to
                                                    Collection Activities; Comment                          Bank Holding Companies (FR Y–9C)                       ensure that certain BHCs and nonbank
                                                    Request                                                 (OMB No. 7100–0128); or (ii) the                       financial companies supervised by the
                                                                                                            average of the BHC’s total consolidated                Federal Reserve are subject to enhanced
                                                    AGENCY:   Board of Governors of the                     assets in the most recent consecutive
                                                    Federal Reserve System.                                                                                        risk-based and leverage standards in
                                                                                                            quarters as reported quarterly on the                  order to mitigate risks to the financial
                                                    SUMMARY: On June 15, 1984, the Office                   BHC’s FR Y–9Cs, if the BHC has not
                                                    of Management and Budget (OMB)                                                                                 stability of the United States (12 U.S.C.
                                                                                                            filed an FR Y–9C for each of the most                  5365). Additionally, section 5 of the
                                                    delegated to the Board of Governors of                  recent four quarters. Reporting is
                                                    the Federal Reserve System (Board) its                                                                         Bank Holding Company Act authorizes
                                                                                                            required as of the first day of the quarter            the Federal Reserve to issue regulations
                                                    approval authority under the Paperwork                  immediately following the quarter in                   and conduct information collections
                                                    Reduction Act (PRA), to approve of and                  which it meets this asset threshold,                   with regard to the supervision of BHCs
                                                    assign OMB numbers to collection of                     unless otherwise directed by the Federal               (12 U.S.C. 1844).
                                                    information requests and requirements                   Reserve.                                                  As these data are collected as part of
                                                    conducted or sponsored by the Board.                       Estimated annual reporting hours: FR                the supervisory process, they are subject
                                                    Board-approved collections of                           Y–14A: Summary, 65,142 hours; Macro                    to confidential treatment under
                                                    information are incorporated into the                   scenario, 2,046 hours; Operational Risk,               exemption 8 of the Freedom of
                                                    official OMB inventory of currently                     396 hours; Regulatory capital                          Information Act (FOIA) (5 U.S.C.
                                                    approved collections of information.                    transitions, 759 hours; Regulatory                     552(b)(8)). In addition, commercial and
                                                    Copies of the PRA Submission,                           capital instruments, 660 hours; Retail                 financial information contained in these
                                                    supporting statements and approved                      repurchase, 1,320 hours; and Business                  information collections may be exempt
                                                    collection of information instruments                   plan changes, 330 hours. FR Y–14Q:                     from disclosure under exemption 4 of
                                                    are placed into OMB’s public docket                     Securities, 1,716 hours; Retail, 2,112                 FOIA (5 U.S.C. 552(b)(4)), if disclosure
                                                    files. The Federal Reserve may not                      hours; Pre-provision net revenue                       would likely have the effect of (1)
                                                    conduct or sponsor, and the respondent                  (PPNR), 93,852 hours; Wholesale,                       impairing the government’s ability to
                                                    is not required to respond to, an                       20,064 hours; Trading, 69,336 hours;                   obtain the necessary information in the
                                                    information collection that has been                    Regulatory capital transitions, 3,036                  future, or (2) causing substantial harm to
                                                    extended, revised, or implemented on or                 hours; Regulatory capital instruments,                 the competitive position of the
                                                    after October 1, 1995, unless it displays               6,864 hours; Operational risk, 6,600                   respondent. Such exemptions would be
                                                    a currently valid OMB number.                           hours; Mortgage Servicing Rights (MSR)                 made on a case-by-case basis.
                                                    FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:                        Valuation, 1,152 hours; Supplemental,                     Though the Federal Reserve intends
                                                    Federal Reserve Board Clearance                         528 hours; and Retail Fair Value                       to share the information collected under
                                                    Officer—Nuha Elmaghrabi—Office of                       Option/Held for Sale (Retail FVO/HFS),                 the FR Y–14 with the Department of
                                                    the Chief Data Officer, Board of                        1,408 hours; Counterparty, 18,288                      Treasury’s Office of Financial Research,
                                                    Governors of the Federal Reserve                        hours; and Balances, 2,112 hours; FR Y–                such sharing shall not be deemed a
                                                    System, Washington, DC 20551 (202)                      14M: 1st lien mortgage, 173,040 hours;                 waiver of any privilege applicable to
                                                    452–3829. Telecommunications Device                     Home equity, 166,860 hours; and Credit                 such information, including but not
                                                    for the Deaf (TDD) users may contact                    card, 110,160 hours. FR Y–14 On-going                  limited to any confidential status (12
                                                    (202) 263–4869, Board of Governors of                   automation revisions, 15,840 hours. FR                 U.S.C. 1821(t); 12 U.S.C. 1828(x)).
                                                    the Federal Reserve System,                             Y–14 Attestation implementation,                          Abstract: The data collected through
asabaliauskas on DSK9F6TC42PROD with NOTICES




                                                    Washington, DC 20551.                                   43,200 hours; and On-going audit and                   the FR Y–14A/Q/M schedules provide
                                                       OMB Desk Officer—Shagufta                            review, 23,040 hours.                                  the Federal Reserve with the additional
                                                    Ahmed—Office of Information and                            Estimated average hours per response:               information and perspective needed to
                                                    Regulatory Affairs, Office of                           FR Y–14A: Summary, 987 hours; Macro                    help ensure that large BHCs have strong,
                                                    Management and Budget, New                              scenario, 31 hours; Operational Risk, 12               firm-wide risk measurement and
                                                    Executive Office Building, Room 10235,                  hours; Regulatory capital transitions, 23              management processes supporting their
                                                    725 17th Street NW., Washington, DC                     hours; Regulatory capital instruments,                 internal assessments of capital adequacy
                                                    20503.                                                  20 hours; Retail Repurchase, 20 hours;                 and that their capital resources are


                                               VerDate Sep<11>2014   18:26 Jan 20, 2016   Jkt 238001   PO 00000   Frm 00036   Fmt 4703   Sfmt 4703   E:\FR\FM\21JAN1.SGM   21JAN1


                                                                                 Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 13 / Thursday, January 21, 2016 / Notices                                                     3413

                                                    sufficient given their business focus,                  Roundtable, and one from The Clearing                  detailed in the schedule-specific
                                                    activities, and resulting risk exposures.               House, the Institute of International                  sections below. This extension provides
                                                    The annual Comprehensive Capital                        Bankers, the American Bankers                          respondents with approximately six
                                                    Analysis and Review (CCAR) exercise is                  Association, and the Securities Industry               months to make needed system changes.
                                                    also complemented by other Federal                      and Financial Markets Association.                     In addition, the final FR Y–14 delays by
                                                    Reserve supervisory efforts aimed at                    Comments focused on the scope and                      two quarters, until September 30, 2016,
                                                    enhancing the continued viability of                    timing of the proposed attestation                     the effective date of certain changes to
                                                    large BHCs, including continuous                        requirement, and the timing of proposed                the wholesale schedules (Schedules H.1
                                                    monitoring of BHCs’ planning and                        modifications to existing items or                     and H.2), as indicated in the schedule-
                                                    management of liquidity and funding                     schedules, in particular the FR Y–14Q                  specific section below.
                                                    resources and regular assessments of                    Wholesale schedules (Schedule H.1 and                     Certain changes in the final FR Y–14
                                                    credit, market and operational risks, and               H.2). Commenters requested                             would take effect beginning with the
                                                    associated risk management practices.                   clarification of the instructions for                  regulatory reports that have a December
                                                    Information gathered in this data                       proposed or existing items, or were                    31, 2015, as-of date. These changes
                                                    collection is also used in the                          technical in nature. Responses to these                include the shift in the FR Y–14A as-of
                                                    supervision and regulation of these                     comments are addressed in the attached                 date, from September 30 to December
                                                    financial institutions. In order to fully               draft FR Y–14A/Q/M reporting forms                     31, in accordance with modifications to
                                                    evaluate the data submissions, the                      and instructions.                                      the capital plan and stress test rules;
                                                    Federal Reserve may conduct follow up                     The Federal Reserve also received                    formalization of the FR Y–14Q Business
                                                    discussions with or request responses to                several comments not directly related to               Plan Changes schedule as a regulatory
                                                    follow up questions from respondents,                   the proposed revisions to the FR Y–14                  report (rather than as a case-by-case
                                                    as needed.                                              information collection regarding (1)                   supervisory collection of information);
                                                       The Capital Assessments and Stress                   challenges with the frequency and                      elimination of the FR Y–14Q Securities
                                                    Testing information collection consists                 timing of changes, (2) the Frequently                  B.2 sub-schedule, and removal of
                                                    of the FR Y–14A, Q, and M reports. The                  Asked Questions (FAQ) process, (3)                     certain items related to tier 1 common
                                                    semi-annual FR Y–14A collects                           technical instructions and data                        capital.2 These changes align the FR
                                                    information on the stress tests                         submission processes, (4) edit checks                  Y–14 reports with changes in the final
                                                    conducted by BHCs, including                            and (5) estimate of reporting burden.                  capital rule that the Board recently
                                                    quantitative projections of balance                     Although not specifically addressed                    approved, better align regulatory
                                                    sheet, income, losses, and capital across               herein, these comment letters, well as                 reporting requirements with other
                                                    a range of macroeconomic scenarios,                     feedback provided in meetings with                     existing requirements, reduce burden, or
                                                    and qualitative information on                          both individual respondents and                        formalize information collections that
                                                    methodologies used to develop internal                  industry groups, have assisted the                     are already reported as part of the
                                                    projections of capital across scenarios.1               Federal Reserve’s effort to continually                supervisory process. In light of the
                                                    The quarterly FR Y–14Q and the                          improve its internal processes and                     limited comment on, and limited impact
                                                    monthly FR Y–14M are used to support                    practices. The following section                       of, these proposed changes, they will be
                                                    supervisory stress test models and for                  includes a detailed discussion of aspects              implemented, as proposed, with a
                                                    continuous monitoring efforts. The                      of the proposed FR Y–14 collection for                 December 31, 2015, as-of date.
                                                    quarterly FR Y–14Q collects granular                    which the Federal Reserve received                       In response to the Federal Reserve’s
                                                    data on BHCs’ various asset classes,                    substantive comments and an                            solicitation for feedback regarding
                                                    including loans, securities and trading                 evaluation of, and responses to the                    burden associated with the FR
                                                    assets, and PPNR for the reporting                      comments received.                                     Y–14A/Q/M, one commenter suggested
                                                    period. The monthly FR Y–14M                                                                                   that the estimates of reporting burden
                                                    comprises three retail loan- and                        Detailed Discussion of Public                          are substantially lower than a good-faith
                                                    portfolio-level collections, and one                    Comments                                               estimate provided by a sample of
                                                    detailed address matching collection to                 A. General Comments                                    reporting firms. The commenter
                                                    supplement two of the portfolio and                                                                            outlined the type of effort and resources,
                                                                                                               In general, commenters expressed
                                                    loan-level collections.                                                                                        and associated burden required to file
                                                                                                            concern with the timing of the proposed
                                                       Current Actions: On September 16,                                                                           the FR Y–14A/Q/M reports and offered
                                                                                                            changes. Specifically commenters stated
                                                    2015, the Federal Reserve published a                                                                          to engage in further discussion with the
                                                                                                            there was not sufficient time to
                                                    notice in the Federal Register (80 FR                                                                          Federal Reserve regarding burden
                                                                                                            undertake the changes necessary to
                                                    55621) requesting public comment for                                                                           estimates. Burden estimates are based
                                                                                                            implement the proposed revisions and
                                                    60 days on the extension, with revision,                                                                       on a schedule by schedule calculation
                                                                                                            develop appropriate processes and
                                                    of the FR Y–14A/Q/M. The Federal                                                                               while the estimates provided by the
                                                                                                            procedures surrounding the attestation
                                                    Reserve proposed to revise several                                                                             commenter are aggregated. This
                                                                                                            requirement. One commenter
                                                    schedules of the FR Y 14A/Q/M reports                                                                          difference makes it difficult to modify
                                                                                                            recommended that the Federal Reserve
                                                    effective December 31, 2015, March 31,                                                                         the proposed burden estimates without
                                                                                                            provide a minimum of sixth months
                                                    2015 and June 30, 2016, and to                                                                                 more detailed information from the
                                                                                                            between the finalization of reporting
                                                    implement an attestation requirement                                                                           commenter. For these reasons, the
                                                                                                            and technical requirements and the
                                                    for LISSC firms as-of June 30, 2016. The                                                                       burden estimates remain the same as
                                                                                                            effective date of proposed changes to the
asabaliauskas on DSK9F6TC42PROD with NOTICES




                                                    comment period for this notice expired                                                                         proposed.
                                                                                                            FR Y–14A/Q/M reports in order for                        Commenters also suggested several
                                                    on November 16, 2015.
                                                       The Board received two comment                       respondents to adhere to standard                      improvements to the current FAQ
                                                    letters addressing the proposed changes:                software development life cycles.                      process, including providing status on a
                                                                                                               In response to these comments, the
                                                    One from the Financial Services                                                                                real time basis, establishing a searchable
                                                                                                            final FR Y–14 regulatory report (final FR
                                                      1 BHCs that must re-submit their capital plan         Y–14) delays the effective date for                      2 See 79 Federal Register 64026 (October 27,

                                                    generally also must provide a revised FR Y–14A in       nearly all proposed changes to reports                 2014); 80 Federal Register 75419 (December 2,
                                                    connection with their resubmission.                     with a June 30, 2016, as-of date, as                   2015).



                                               VerDate Sep<11>2014   18:26 Jan 20, 2016   Jkt 238001   PO 00000   Frm 00037   Fmt 4703   Sfmt 4703   E:\FR\FM\21JAN1.SGM   21JAN1


                                                    3414                           Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 13 / Thursday, January 21, 2016 / Notices

                                                    repository, distributing more frequently,                 required under Sarbanes-Oxley and                      and to allow time for respondents to
                                                    and setting a standard schedule for                       therefore beyond the capability of most                develop and test their internal control
                                                    responding to questions. The Federal                      firms. Finally, one commenter noted                    systems, the initial attestation will relate
                                                    Reserve is continually working to                         that the implementation of the various                 solely to the effectiveness of internal
                                                    improve the FAQ process. As part of                       attestation requirements would require a               controls over submissions as of
                                                    these ongoing efforts the Federal                         significant investment in firm                         December 31, 2016, rather than with
                                                    Reserve recently implemented a new                        personnel, management, and                             respect to submissions throughout the
                                                    FAQ system to enhance the Federal                         compliance and information technology                  year. Effective for the monthly,
                                                    Reserve’s ability to track and respond to                 resources, and additional time for                     quarterly, and semi-annual FR Y–14
                                                    questions. The new system will allow                      implementation would allow for more                    reports submitted as of January 31,
                                                    for more insight into the status of FAQs                  deliberate expansion and upgrade of                    2017, and thereafter, respondents will
                                                    and help ensure more consistent timing                    existing processes and systems to                      attest to conformance with the FR Y–14
                                                    on responses. In addition, similar to the                 support the attestation.                               instructions and to the material
                                                    effort undertaken in 2013,3 the Federal                      In light of the above, both commenters              correctness of data to the best of the
                                                    Reserve incorporated all relevant                         suggested alternative implementation                   respondent’s knowledge, and agree to
                                                    historical FAQs into the final                            timelines. One commenter noted that a                  report material weaknesses and any
                                                    instructions associated with this                         major consulting firm estimated it                     material errors in the data as they are
                                                    proposal. The Federal Reserve will                        would take a company 15 months to                      identified starting January 1, 2017.
                                                    continue to incorporate relevant                          implement the controls necessary to                    Effective December 31, 2017, and for all
                                                    comments and questions related to the                     assess risk information. The other                     future reporting periods, a respondent’s
                                                    FR Y–14 into the instructions on a                        commenter suggested a phased-in                        attestation as to the effectiveness of
                                                    regular basis.                                            implementation approach, which would                   internal controls will be with regard to
                                                       In the proposal, the Federal Reserve                   provide respondents additional time to                 FR Y–14 submissions filed throughout
                                                    notified respondents of the intent to                     make the more substantial alterations to               the year.
                                                    share FR Y–14 data sets with the Office                   existing systems and processes                            To clarify the timing of these
                                                    of Financial Research (OFR). One                          necessary to support certain                           staggered attestation requirements, the
                                                    commenter recommended that the OFR                        components of the proposed attestation.                final Y–14 includes three separate
                                                    publish aggregate summaries of the data                   The phased in approach would involve:                  attestation cover pages. First, as
                                                    so reporting companies, and the public,                   (i) An attestation solely regarding                    indicated, with respect to the monthly,
                                                    can gain insights into industry trends                    compliance with the FR Y–14                            quarterly, and annual FR Y–14 reports
                                                    and developments.                                         instructions effective as of June 30,                  with a December 31, 2016, as-of date,
                                                                                                              2016, which is the same timeframe as in                respondents will attest to internal
                                                    B. Attestation
                                                                                                              the proposal; (ii) an incremental                      controls around the reports submitted as
                                                       Commenters generally expressed                         requirement for respondents to                         of that date. Second, effective for the
                                                    concerns about specific elements of the                   demonstrate as part of the supervisory                 monthly, quarterly, and semi-annual FR
                                                    proposed attestation requirement for the                  process, by April 2017, that a framework               Y–14 reports submitted beginning
                                                    FR Y–14 submission and, in particular,                    has been put in place to identify, test,               January 31, 2017, and thereafter,
                                                    the timing necessary to meet the                          and independently validate key control                 respondents will attest on a separate
                                                    proposed requirements.                                    activities to support these attestations;              cover page to the respondent’s
                                                       Both commenters argued that the                        and (iii) an attestation regarding the                 conformance with the FR Y–14
                                                    proposed effective date of June 30, 2016,                 effectiveness of internal controls and to              instructions and to the material
                                                    would not provide sufficient time to                      the material correctness of data as of                 correctness of data to the best of the
                                                    implement several of the proposed                         April 2018.                                            respondent’s knowledge, and agree to
                                                    attestation requirements. However, one                       In addition, one commenter indicated                report material weaknesses and any
                                                    commenter agreed that it would be                         that the proposal appeared to require                  material errors in the data as they are
                                                    practical and appropriate for                             attestation to internal controls with each             identified starting January 1, 2017.
                                                    respondents to provide an attestation as                  annual, quarterly and monthly FR Y–14                  Third and finally, effective for reports
                                                    to conformance with the FR Y–14                           report submission, but that doing so                   with a December 31, 2017, as-of date
                                                    instructions by June 30, 2016, subject to                 would not be feasible at that frequency.               and for all future FR Y–14 submissions
                                                    the specific recommendations in the                       The commenter suggested that the                       as of December 31 of a calendar year,
                                                    commenter’s letter. Both commenters                       effectiveness of internal controls be                  the initial December 31, 2016, cover
                                                    indicated that additional time was                        limited to annual submissions on the FR                page will be replaced by a new cover
                                                    needed to adapt to The Committee of                       Y–14A.                                                 page that will be submitted annually
                                                    Sponsoring Organizations (COSO)-based                        The Federal Reserve recognized in the               and will include an attestation to the
                                                    framework, including materially                           initial Federal Register notice the time               effectiveness of internal controls around
                                                    supplementing and/or modifying                            needed for LISCC firms to ‘‘enhance                    the annual FR Y–14A submission and
                                                    existing systems and processes, and                       certain systems and processes’’ and                    around the FR Y–14Q/M reports that are
                                                    establishing policies, documentation,                     ‘‘modify internal control frameworks                   submitted throughout the year.
                                                    and certification frameworks. One                         and data governance committees.’’ In                      Commenters suggested various
                                                    commenter pointed out that, although                      response to comments and in order to                   modifications to the attestation
                                                    some respondents may be able to                           allow additional time for respondents to               requirement and associated attestation
asabaliauskas on DSK9F6TC42PROD with NOTICES




                                                    leverage parts of their existing control                  put internal controls processes and                    language. One commenter noted that the
                                                    infrastructure required under the                         frameworks in place and complete                       proposal indicates that the Federal
                                                    Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 (Sarbanes-                     testing of these processes and                         Reserve would not expect to penalize a
                                                    Oxley), the scope and level of data                       frameworks, the initial attestation                    firm for incorrect reporting where there
                                                    granularity on the FR Y–14 forms is                       requirement in the final Y–14 will be                  has been a good faith effort to
                                                    substantially larger than what is                         delayed until reports with a December                  reasonably interpret the instructions or
                                                                                                              31, 2016, as-of date. In addition, in                  seek input on a question or
                                                      3 See   78 Federal Register 59934.                      connection with the initial attestation                interpretation from the Federal Reserve


                                               VerDate Sep<11>2014     18:26 Jan 20, 2016   Jkt 238001   PO 00000   Frm 00038   Fmt 4703   Sfmt 4703   E:\FR\FM\21JAN1.SGM   21JAN1


                                                                                   Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 13 / Thursday, January 21, 2016 / Notices                                            3415

                                                    and requested that similar qualifying                     expressed concern that the timing of the               rather than keeping these items in the
                                                    language be added to the attestation                      implementation of the attestation                      technical instructions as proposed. The
                                                    form. The final FR Y–14 includes these                    requirement would be particularly                      Federal Reserve recognizes the burden
                                                    revisions to the attestation form.                        challenging for FBOs currently                         of responding to edits, as well as the
                                                       Under the proposal, the firm’s CFO                     restructuring to complete the formation                technical effort by both the Federal
                                                    would have been required to attest to                     of their IHC. Currently, the Board has                 Reserve and respondents to incorporate
                                                    the internal controls over the reporting                  not proposed reporting requirements for                report changes. The Federal Reserve
                                                    of actual data as-of the reporting period.                IHCs, which, as noted in the preamble                  will keep the tier 1 common capital-
                                                    A commenter noted that internal                           to the final rule implementing enhanced                related items in the FR Y–14A Summary
                                                    controls over financial reporting and                     prudential standards for FBOs, would                   schedule (Schedule A) technical
                                                    risk management data are the joint                        be addressed at a later date.                          instructions in order to mitigate the
                                                    responsibility of senior management                          At such time as the Board proposes                  operational risk of making changes as
                                                    and that the CFO is not individually                      reporting requirements for IHCs, the                   proposed; however, to address the
                                                    responsible for internal controls over                    Federal Reserve expects to invite                      commenters concerns and reduce the
                                                    the reporting of FR Y–14 data. The                        comment through a notice and comment                   burden on respondents, edit checks on
                                                    commenter suggested that the                              process, and would evaluate the                        these items will be eliminated and
                                                    attestation form be modified to indicate                  particular circumstances and challenges                responses will not be requested.
                                                    that the CFO attests that senior                          surrounding IHC formation vis-à-vis the
                                                    management is responsible for the                         full spectrum of Board regulatory                      Schedules A.1.c.2 (Standardized RWA)
                                                    internal controls over the reporting of                   reporting requirements. The Federal                    and D.4 (RCT)
                                                    the FR Y–14 data. In response, the final                  Reserve does, however, reiterate that the                 Under the proposal, the Standardized
                                                    FR Y–14 incorporates this modification                    attestation requirement applies to LISCC               RWA (FR Y–14A, Schedule A.1.c.2) and
                                                    to the attestation form.                                  firms.                                                 Regulatory Capital Transitions (FR
                                                       Both commenters addressed the                                                                                 Y–14A, Schedule D.4 and FR Y–14Q,
                                                    definition of materiality in the                          C. Schedule Specific Comments                          Schedule D.4) schedules would have
                                                    attestation language. One commenter                       FR Y–14A                                               been revised by replacing the existing
                                                    expressed concern with the absence of                                                                            market-risk weight asset portion with
                                                                                                              Schedules A.1.c.1 (General RWA) and
                                                    a definition of ‘‘materiality’’ which                                                                            the relevant items from the FFIEC 102
                                                                                                              A.1.d. (Capital)
                                                    inherently requires each respondent to                                                                           and aligning the remaining items with
                                                    make an individual determination on                          Related to the proposed modifications               the FR Y–9C Schedule HC–R Part II.
                                                    materiality. The other commenter                          to the collection in accordance with                   Both commenters noted that the
                                                    requested that the Federal Reserve                        revisions to the capital plan and stress               aforementioned changes were effective
                                                    confirm that respondents would be                         test rules, specifically elimination of the            for the Standardized RWA schedule (FR
                                                    expected to develop materiality policies                  use of the tier 1 common ratio, one                    Y–14A, Schedule A.1.c.d) as-of
                                                    based on their own capital plan                           commenter noted that as of the end of                  December 31, 2015 and for the
                                                    submission. The Federal Reserve does                      the comment period, the changes to the                 Regulatory Capital Instruments
                                                    not generally define materiality within                   capital plan and stress test rules had not             schedules (FR Y–14A Schedule D.4, FR
                                                    the FR Y–14 reports.                                      yet been finalized and asked that the                  Y–14Q Schedule D.4) as-of June 30,
                                                       Furthermore, outlining materiality for                 Federal Reserve reflect any changes in                 2016. They recommended that the
                                                    specific respondents would not be                         the final release of the FR Y–14 forms.                effective dates be consistent and
                                                    feasible. As stated in the Federal                        On November 25, 2015, the Board                        delayed until June 30, 2016. In
                                                    Register for the proposal, a BHC would                    approved the final rule to modify the                  response, the changes for all three
                                                    be required to have a policy for                          capital plan and stress test rules.                    schedules (FR Y–14A, A.1.c.2
                                                    determining materiality in the context of                 Accordingly, and in response to the                    (Standardized RWA), D.4 (RCT) and
                                                    quantitative and qualitative                              comment, the final FR Y–14 removes                     14Q D.4 (RCT) will be implemented as
                                                    considerations for their firm.                            items relating to the reporting of ‘‘tier 1            modified below, effective June 30, 2016.
                                                    Accordingly, the final FR Y–14 includes                   common capital’’ as proposed from the                     One commenter expressed concern
                                                    the proposed definition of materiality                    following schedules in order to align                  that these modifications would require
                                                    without change.                                           with the final rule: FR Y–14A General                  an unnecessary level of forecasting
                                                       One commenter requested that the                       RWA (Schedule A.1.c.1), Standardized                   granularity around Market Risk RWA
                                                    Federal Reserve make attestation                          RWA (Schedule A.1.c.2), Capital                        and recommended that this level of
                                                    requirements applicable to the                            (Schedule A.1.d), Regulatory Capital                   detail not be included in the final
                                                    intermediate holding company (IHC)                        Transitions (Schedule D.4), Regulatory                 version. The other commenter stated
                                                    subsidiaries of LISCC foreign banking                     Capital Instruments (RCI, Schedule C),                 they had no objection to the changes as
                                                    organizations (FBOs) no earlier than                      and the FR Y–14Q Regulatory Capital                    proposed. In response to the comment
                                                    April 2018. On February 18, 2014, the                     Transitions (Schedule D.4) and                         received, the Federal Reserve further
                                                    Board adopted a final rule                                Regulatory Capital Instruments                         reviewed the items proposed to be
                                                    implementing enhanced prudential                          (Schedule C).6                                         added to these schedule in alignment
                                                    standards for FBOs,4 which, among                            Both commenters supported the                       with the FFIEC 102. In light of these
                                                    other things, requires an FBO with U.S.                   removal of items related to tier 1 capital             comments, the final FR Y–14 removes
                                                    non-branch assets of greater than $50                     consistent with the rule, however                      the requirement to report projections for
asabaliauskas on DSK9F6TC42PROD with NOTICES




                                                    billion to establish a U.S. IHC by July 1,                recommended removing the items from                    certain more granular proposed items
                                                    2016, to which it must transfer its entire                the technical instructions in order to                 from the FR Y14A Standardized RWA
                                                    ownership interest in all U.S. BHCs,                      limit the number of edit checks                        (Schedule A.1.c.2) and Regulatory
                                                    U.S. insured depository institutions,                     respondents are required to respond to,                Capital Transitions (Schedule D.4)
                                                    and U.S. subsidiaries.5 The commenter                                                                            schedules, while retaining general
                                                                                                                6 Effective January 1, 2016, tier 1 common capital

                                                                                                              has been removed from the Board’s capital plan rule
                                                                                                                                                                     alignment with the structure of the
                                                      4 79   Federal Register 17239 (March 27, 2014).         (12 CFR 225.8). See 80 Federal Register 75419          FFIEC 102 report and reporting of the
                                                      5 See   12 CFR 252.153.                                 (December 2, 2015).                                    actual information. These changes will


                                               VerDate Sep<11>2014     18:26 Jan 20, 2016   Jkt 238001   PO 00000   Frm 00039   Fmt 4703   Sfmt 4703   E:\FR\FM\21JAN1.SGM   21JAN1


                                                    3416                         Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 13 / Thursday, January 21, 2016 / Notices

                                                    be implemented as modified effective                    not. The Federal Reserve continues to                  clarification of item definitions and will
                                                    June 30, 2016.                                          review the FR Y–14 and propose to                      be addressed in the final instructions.
                                                                                                            remove items as they are no longer                     Several substantive comments,
                                                    Schedule A.2.b (Retail Repurchase)
                                                                                                            necessary, as evidenced in this proposal               particularly on the Wholesale Corporate
                                                       Commenters expressed concern with                    with the removal of two schedules and                  Loan (Schedule H.1) and Commercial
                                                    the proposal to break out the Retail                    other items. Upon further review, the                  Real Estate (Schedule H.2) schedules,
                                                    Repurchase schedule from the Summary                    final FR Y–14 eliminates three                         are summarized below.
                                                    (Schedule A) and moving the                             additional variables from the PPNR
                                                    submission date in line with the                                                                               Schedule A.1–A.10 (Retail)
                                                                                                            Metrics schedule (Schedule A.7.c):
                                                    quarterly schedules given the schedule                  Merchant Banking/Private Equity—                         Commenters requested additional
                                                    contains projected data as well as actual               Assets Under Management (Line 27),                     information on the proposed change to
                                                    data. The commenters were also                          Sales and Trading—Total Proprietary                    the loan population on the Retail
                                                    concerned that the proposed effective                   Trading Revenue (Line 29), and                         schedule. They noted that the initial
                                                    date of June 30, 2016 would not allow                   Investment Services—Corporate Trust                    notice in the Federal Register stated
                                                    respondents enough time to implement                    Deals Administered (Line 43). In                       that the change would limit the
                                                    the necessary controls and processes                    addition, a materiality threshold will be              population of the schedule to ‘‘accrual
                                                    required to submit the new semi-annual                  added to the investment banking                        loans’’, while the draft instructions
                                                    schedule and recommended delaying                       metrics of the PPNR Metrics schedule to                indicate a BHC should ‘‘include loans
                                                    implementation an additional six                        further limit the amount of detail                     and leases held for investment at
                                                    months to be effective December 31,                     required for many firms. The                           amortized cost.’’ The language in the
                                                    2016. The Federal Reserve agrees that                   instructions will be updated to indicate               Federal Register Notice should have
                                                    the projected data should remain part of                that only firms who report greater than                stated that the change was to ‘‘restrict
                                                    the Summary (Schedule A) and                            $100 million in item 15, Investment                    the loan population of this schedule to
                                                    confirms that the new FR Y–14A semi-                    Banking, of Schedule A.7.a (PPNR                       loans held at amortized cost in order to
                                                    annual schedule breaks out only the                     Projections) should report the                         accurately reflect the intention of the
                                                    actual data from the existing Retail                    investment banking metrics (Lines 11 to                schedule and be responsive to industry
                                                    Repurchase schedule (Schedule A.2.b).                   26) in Section A of Schedule A.7.c                     comments.’’ This is in alignment with
                                                    Given the information to be collected on                (PPNR Metrics). The Federal Reserve                    the language in the draft instructions. In
                                                    both schedules is already reported on                   will continue to review the FR Y–14                    response to the general request to
                                                    the FR Y–14A, the restructuring changes                 reports for unnecessary items for                      provide additional time to implement
                                                    only the submission date for actual not                 potential elimination in future                        changes, the effective date of this
                                                    projected data, and that the submission                 proposals. In addition, in response to                 change will be delayed until the report
                                                    date is more than six months out, the                   the general request for additional time                as-of June 30, 2016.
                                                    final FR Y–14 proceeds with this change                 to implement changes, the effective date               Schedule A.8–A.9 (Retail)
                                                    as indicated above, effective June 30,                  of all modifications to this schedule will
                                                    2016 as proposed.                                       be delayed until June 30, 2016.                          One commenter expressed concern
                                                                                                                                                                   with the effective date of the proposal
                                                    Schedule A.2.c (ASC 310–30)                             Schedule F (Business Plan Changes)                     to exclude non-purpose loans for
                                                       The Federal Reserve proposed                            One commenter supported the                         purchasing and carrying securities from
                                                    eliminating this schedule effective as-of               formalization of the Business Plan                     this schedule as it requires changes to
                                                    June 30, 2016. One commenter                            Changes (BPC) schedule (Schedule F),                   complex, product-specific loan tagging
                                                    recommended that the Federal Reserve                    but was concerned that the BPC                         rules, including for loans already tagged
                                                    eliminate this schedule as-of December                  schedule instructions as proposed did                  for months in the quarter. The
                                                    31, 2015. The other commenter noted                     not appear consistent with the FR Y–                   commenter requested that the Federal
                                                    that although they have previously                      14A summary and did not incorporate                    Reserve make this change effective as-of
                                                    requested a six month window between                    previous FAQ guidance. The commenter                   June 30, 2016. The effective date of this
                                                    the finalization of changes and effective               also requested that clarification on the               change, as well as the complementary
                                                    date, it is less burdensome to remove a                 definition of ‘‘material’’. The final FR               changes to the FR Y–14Q Wholesale
                                                    minor reporting item and therefore                      Y–14 BPC instructions have been                        (Schedule H.1) and Balances (Schedule
                                                    supported the change as proposed. In an                 updated to identify a limited number of                M) schedules until the report as-of June
                                                    effort to allow as much time as possible                items on the BPC schedule which, for                   30, 2016.
                                                    between finalization and the effective                  technical reasons, require different
                                                                                                                                                                   Schedule C.3 (Regulatory Capital
                                                    date for both the removal and addition                  instructions. In addition, the final FR Y–
                                                                                                                                                                   Instruments (RCI)—Issuances During the
                                                    of items and in support of limiting the                 14 instructions have been updated to
                                                                                                                                                                   Quarter)
                                                    changes effective for the December 31,                  include certain clarifications from the
                                                    2015 as-of date, the final FR Y–14                      FAQ process. Finally, the requirement                     Both commenters requested
                                                    implements this change as proposed.                     to report the BPC schedule is based on                 clarification on the intended effective
                                                                                                            whether the BHC includes material                      date of this change and the nature of the
                                                    Schedule A.7.c (PPNR)                                                                                          one-time submissions. The additions
                                                                                                            business plan changes in their capital
                                                       In an effort to reduce burden, the                   plan, as defined in the CCAR                           and modifications will be implemented
                                                    Federal Reserve proposed aligning this                  instructions. In response, the final FR                as proposed, however in response to the
asabaliauskas on DSK9F6TC42PROD with NOTICES




                                                    schedule with the ‘‘normal                              Y–14 includes updates to the BPC                       general request to provide additional
                                                    environment’’ requirement. There were                   instructions to refer BHCs to the CCAR                 time to implement changes, the effective
                                                    no questions or concerns on the                         instructions for a given year for                      date of the changes proposed for
                                                    proposed change, however one                            requirements of materiality.                           December 31, 2015 will be delayed until
                                                    commenter requested that the Federal                                                                           the report as-of June 30, 2016. As a
                                                    Reserve periodically review whether the                 FR Y–14Q                                               result, all proposed changes to the RCI
                                                    items to be submitted are still necessary                 The majority of comments received                    schedule will be effective June 30, 2016,
                                                    and propose removing those that are                     regarding the FR Y–14Q requested                       at which time there will be one separate


                                               VerDate Sep<11>2014   18:26 Jan 20, 2016   Jkt 238001   PO 00000   Frm 00040   Fmt 4703   Sfmt 4703   E:\FR\FM\21JAN1.SGM   21JAN1


                                                                                 Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 13 / Thursday, January 21, 2016 / Notices                                             3417

                                                    one-time submission of all subordinated                 that this change will require sufficient               One commenter stated that some
                                                    debt instruments for the effective date.                time for newly covered firms to build                  respondents are classified as expanded
                                                    Additionally, any new respondents are                   reporting systems. The effective date                  reporters and, therefore, subject to a
                                                    required to report the one-time                         was erroneously omitted from the                       broader data collection referred to as
                                                    submission.                                             proposal, and changes were intended to                 ‘‘Large Corporate Syndicated Credit’’
                                                                                                            be proposed to be effective March 31,                  (LCSC) and therefore recommended that
                                                    Schedule D.4 (RCT)
                                                                                                            2016. In response to these and the                     all references to SNCs in the proposal be
                                                      As with the corresponding changes to                  general comments on timing, the                        clarified to include all LCSC eligible
                                                    the FR Y–14A Standardized RWA                           effective date of this change will be                  credits as well for respondents that are
                                                    (Schedule A.1.c.2) and RCT (D.4)                        delayed until June 30, 2016.                           classified as expanded reporters. The
                                                    schedules, commenters noted the                                                                                Federal Reserve confirms that intent of
                                                    inconsistent effective dates and                        Schedule H.1 (Corporate Loan) and H.2
                                                                                                                                                                   the new proposed options in the
                                                    recommended that the proposed                           (Commercial Real Estate)
                                                                                                                                                                   Participation Loan Flag are, in
                                                    changes to the FR Y–14Q RCT                                Both commenters expressed concerns                  conjunction with the SNC Internal
                                                    (Schedule D.4) also be effective June 30,               with the effective date of the changes to              Credit Facility ID, to distinguish
                                                    2016. The Federal Reserve agrees with                   the Corporate Loan and CRE schedules,                  whether or not the credit facility is
                                                    this suggestion and the proposed                        especially regarding the disposed loan                 included in the SNC report.
                                                    changes will be made effective as-of                    and syndicated pipeline reporting. In                  Accordingly, the final FR Y–14
                                                    June 30, 2016.                                          particular commenters explained that                   implements the change as proposed,
                                                      As noted in regards to the FR Y–14A,                  respondents may need to update                         effective June 30, 2016.
                                                    one commenter expressed concern that                    systems to capture and report the                         Both commenters indicated that two
                                                    the proposed modifications would                        information required as proposed. They                 items for the Credit Rating Agency
                                                    require an unnecessary level of                         also noted that the non-purpose loans                  Equivalent Rating field (Field 96, 97 of
                                                    forecasting granularity around Market                   were proposed to be included on the                    Schedule H.1 and Field 59, 60 of
                                                    Risk RWA. Since the FR Y–14Q RCT                        Corporate Loan schedule (H.1) as-of                    Schedule H.2) were included in the
                                                    Schedule (Schedule D.4) does not                        December 31, 2015, but that the new                    draft instructions but not proposed as
                                                    require any projected data, the changes                 purpose codes associated with those                    changes and therefore had no specified
                                                    to the FR Y–14Q RCT schedule will be                    loans were proposed to be effective                    effective date. Commenters had several
                                                    implemented as proposed effective June                  March 31, 2016 and asked that the                      questions regarding the reporting of
                                                    30, 2016.                                               changes be implemented concurrently.                   these items. The Federal Reserve
                                                    Schedule G (PPNR)                                       In response to the aforementioned                      confirms that these items were
                                                                                                            comments and in consideration of the                   erroneously included in the draft
                                                       One commenter noted that the                         additional time needed to implement                    instructions, were not proposed to be
                                                    Federal Reserve should not eliminate                    changes, the changes related to disposed               added, and therefore will not be
                                                    the deposit funding threshold for                       loans and the syndicated pipeline will                 implemented. These items have been
                                                    submission of the Net Interest Income                   be effective September 30, 2016, and all               removed from the final FR Y–14
                                                    (NII) worksheet and require all                         other changes to the Corporate Loan and                instructions.
                                                    respondents to submit such schedules.                   Commercial Real Estate schedules
                                                    Specifically, the commenter stated that                 effective as-of June 30, 2016.                         Schedule H.1 (Corporate Loan)
                                                    requiring firms to submit the NII                          Commenters requested clarification                     Both commenters asked for guidance
                                                    templates would impose undue burden                     on the definition and purpose of                       regarding the intended difference
                                                    and offered an alternative of only                      disposed loans as it relates the                       between two of the five categories to be
                                                    completing the banking book assets and                  expansion of the loan population and                   added to the Credit Facility Purpose
                                                    liabilities rather than both trading book               the proposed Disposition Flag field.                   item, namely (1) non-purpose margin
                                                    and banking book. The Federal Reserve                   Specifically, they questioned whether                  lending collateralized by securities and
                                                    notes that the schedule separates out                   facility information should be reported                (2) other non-purpose lending
                                                    specific instructions related to trading                as-of the disposition date and if that                 collateralized by securities. One
                                                    and banking book expectations and the                   means capturing balances and data prior                commenter stated that per the
                                                    trading line items are already required                 to the actual payoff or charge-off of the              definition, a ‘‘non-purpose loan’’ cannot
                                                    to be completed for other regulatory                    facility. The Federal Reserve confirms                 be a margin loan. After considering the
                                                    reporting purposes (FR Y–9C).                           that the data should be reported as-of                 definition and types of loans to be
                                                    Furthermore, the underlying NII                         the date of disposition, not prior to the              reported in both proposed categories
                                                    reporting systems are already required                  payoff or charge-off of the facility.                  mentioned in the comment, the final FR
                                                    as part of separate supervisory                            In addition, one commenter                          Y–14 adds only one consolidated
                                                    expectations related to interest rate risk              recommended adding Disposition Flag                    category for ‘‘Non-purpose loans
                                                    identification. Finally, collecting this                values for when loans fall under the                   collateralized by securities’’ rather than
                                                    information will enhance the                            $1M reporting threshold, or shift from                 the two categories proposed.
                                                    comparability of assets and liabilities                 one loan schedule to another. In                          The Federal Reserve proposed
                                                    across BHCs and promote greater                         response, the final FR Y–14 adds two                   expanding the loan population to
                                                    consistency in supervisory evaluations.                 options to the Disposition Flag field. In              include non-purpose loans that are not
                                                    Therefore, the changes do not appear to                 addition, to accommodate the new item                  graded in conjunction with
asabaliauskas on DSK9F6TC42PROD with NOTICES




                                                    impose unnecessary burden and the                       for facilities shifting from one schedule              complementary changes to FR Y–14Q
                                                    final FR Y–14 implements the revisions                  to another, the final FR Y–14 adds an                  Schedules A.8, A.9, and M to reflect the
                                                    as proposed.                                            additional field to capture to which                   intention of the schedule and be
                                                       One commenter stated that the                        schedule the facility shifted.                         response to industry comments. One
                                                    Federal Register Notice did not indicate                   The Federal Reserve proposed                        commenter recommend that the
                                                    an effective date for the change in the                 expanding the options of the                           definition of non-purpose loans be
                                                    NII worksheet deposit funding                           Participation Flag item to include the                 revised to ‘‘loans collateralized by
                                                    threshold. The other commenter added                    Shared National Credit (SNC) program.                  securities and that the proceeds of such


                                               VerDate Sep<11>2014   18:26 Jan 20, 2016   Jkt 238001   PO 00000   Frm 00041   Fmt 4703   Sfmt 4703   E:\FR\FM\21JAN1.SGM   21JAN1


                                                    3418                         Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 13 / Thursday, January 21, 2016 / Notices

                                                    loans are not contractually restricted to               related to the mini-perm loan purpose                  commitments totaling $45 million (or
                                                    be used only to purchase or carry                       code on the CRE schedule (Schedule                     90%).
                                                    securities.’’ The same commenter                        H.2).                                                     Both commenters asked for
                                                    expressed that it was unclear whether                      Both commenters requested                           clarification regarding the removal of
                                                    non-graded loans for purchasing and                     clarification as to what was to be                     the requirement to only report legally
                                                    carrying securities are to be reported at               reported in the two new credit facility                binding commitments. Specifically, one
                                                    the facility level, and if so that this                 types proposed for Field 20 (Credit                    commenter asked for clarification
                                                    information is generally not readily                    Facility Type), ‘‘Fronting Loan’’ and                  regarding the definition of ‘‘legally
                                                    available for reporting.                                ‘‘Swingline’’. In response to comments,                binding’’ and asked whether all
                                                       The corporate loan population was                    the final FR Y–14 modifies Field 20                    uncommitted and/or unadvised lines on
                                                    amended to include non-purpose loans                    (Credit Facility Type) to include one                  the FR Y–14Q report should be included
                                                    collateralized by securities made for any               additional option called ‘‘Fronting                    or if the change was to allow for the
                                                    purpose other than purchasing or                        Exposure’’, as opposed to the two                      inclusion of exposures in the syndicated
                                                    carrying securities which are reportable                additional options proposed. The                       loan pipeline. The other commenter
                                                    in the relevant FR Y–9C categories                      Fronting Exposure option should be                     asked if by removing the legally binding
                                                    outlined in the instructions. Loans                     selected for credit facilities reported in             restriction to the loan population, the
                                                    reported in FR Y–9C, Schedule HC–C,                     the schedule that represent a BHC’s                    Board intended to report all facilities in
                                                    line item 9.b.(1) (Loans for purchasing                 exposure to fund certain obligations                   the syndicated loan pipeline or just
                                                    or carrying securities) should not be                   (e.g., swinglines or letters of credit) on             those facilities considered commitments
                                                    reported at the facility level in the                   behalf of other participant lenders. In                to commit based on a reporting
                                                    Corporate schedule. Accordingly, the                    addition, the instructions are revised to              company’s legal definition. The Federal
                                                    final FR Y–14 includes the definition as                indicate that for credit facilities which              Reserve confirms that the loan
                                                    proposed.                                               include a fronting exposure, BHCs                      population has been amended to
                                                       One commenter stated that scored                                                                            capture commitments as defined in the
                                                                                                            should report their pro-rata share of the
                                                    non-purpose loans are currently                                                                                FR Y–9C, Schedule HC–L. In addition,
                                                                                                            stated commitment amount as one
                                                    reported on FR Y–14M report and                                                                                the FR Y–14Q Corporate Loan schedule
                                                                                                            facility to the borrower and the fronting
                                                    requested confirmation that scored non-                                                                        (Schedule H.1) has been amended to
                                                                                                            obligations as separate credit facilities to
                                                    purpose loans are not included within                                                                          capture facilities in the syndicated loan
                                                                                                            each of the lending group participants.
                                                    ‘‘non-purpose loans that are not                                                                               pipeline including single-signed
                                                    graded.’’ The corporate loan population                    In regards to the proposed changes to               exposures, regardless of whether the
                                                    will be expanded as proposed to include                 the Credit Facility Type field, one                    BHC considers those facilities to be
                                                    both scored and graded non-purpose                      commenter also requested guidance on                   commitments. As per the FR Y–14Q,
                                                    loans which are reportable in the                       reporting facilities that have both a                  Corporate Loan schedule instructions,
                                                    relevant FR Y–9C line items indicated                   Swingline and LC Issuance limit. In                    BHCs should not report informal
                                                    in the Corporate Loan Schedule                          response to comments, the final FR Y–                  ‘‘advised lines.’’
                                                    (Schedule H.1) instructions. This                       14 instructions have been revised to                      Also in regards to the removal of the
                                                    change is intended to help ensure that                  indicate that for credit facilities which              requirement to report only legally
                                                    non-purpose commercial loans and                        include a fronting exposure, BHCs                      binding commitments, one commenter
                                                    loans for purchasing or carrying                        should report their pro-rata share of the              noted that the language in the proposed
                                                    securities are treated consistently across              stated commitment amount as one                        instructions for the Corporate Loan
                                                    institutions and the Federal Reserve                    facility to the borrower and the fronting              Schedule (H.1) was not consistent with
                                                    confirms that any non-purpose loans                     obligations as separate credit facilities to           that of the Commercial Real Estate (CRE)
                                                    reportable in other FR Y–9C line items                  each of the lending group participants.                Schedule (H.2) and asked if the
                                                    not specified in the Corporate Loan                     Fronting exposures are those that                      intention was to eliminate the legally
                                                    schedule instructions should continue                   represent a BHC’s exposure to fund                     binding restriction from both schedules.
                                                    to be reported on other FR Y–14                         certain obligations (e.g., swinglines or               The Federal Reserve agrees that there
                                                    schedules per the instructions of those                 letters of credit) on behalf of other                  should be consistency between the
                                                    schedules. As previously indicated, the                 participant lenders. For such exposures,               wholesale schedules, and the CRE
                                                    final FR Y–14 delays the effective date                 the BHC should report the new Fronting                 schedule (H.2) of the final FR Y–14 has
                                                    of this proposed change until June 30,                  Exposure option in the Credit Facility                 been revised to also remove the legally
                                                    2016.                                                   Type field. To address this, the general               binding language in alignment with the
                                                       One commenter asked for further                      instructions will have been updated to                 Corporate schedule (H.1).
                                                    details surrounding the reporting of the                include the following example: For                        Both commenters stated that it was
                                                    new Credit Facility Purpose (Field 22)                  example, consider a facility with $400                 unclear what type of lending is intended
                                                    code ‘‘bridge financing’’, including                    million committed balance where the                    to be captured in the syndicated loan
                                                    whether this code value only includes                   BHC is the agent bank and the BHC’s                    population and what is meant by
                                                    real estate financing loans and how it                  pro-rata share of the commitment is                    ‘‘closed and settled’’. In response, the
                                                    relates to the ‘‘mini-perm’’ loan purpose               10% or $40 million. Assume further that                Federal Reserve confirms that the loan
                                                    code recently added to the CRE                          the credit facility contains a $50 million             population should include syndicated
                                                    schedule (Schedule H.2). The Federal                    sublimit that the BHC, as agent, has an                loan commitments in the various stages
                                                    Reserve clarifies that bridge financing is              obligation to advance on behalf of                     of the syndication process, including
asabaliauskas on DSK9F6TC42PROD with NOTICES




                                                    not limited to only real estate financing               lending group participants which may                   single-signed exposures where the BHC
                                                    loans. Bridge financing is interim                      include swinglines, letters of credit and              has signed a commitment letter and has
                                                    financing, typically taken out for a                    other fronting obligations. In this                    extended the terms to the borrower,
                                                    period of 2 weeks to 3 years pending the                example, the agent BHC would report                    even if the borrower has not
                                                    arrangement of larger or longer-term                    one credit facility to the borrower with               countersigned. In response to the
                                                    financing. The ‘‘Bridge Financing’’                     a commitment of $40 million and would                  comment, the final FR Y–14 clarifies the
                                                    purpose code on the Corporate schedule                  report separate facilities to each of the              Syndicated Loan Flag field by including
                                                    (Schedule H.1) is not meant to be                       lending group participants with pro-rata               the following: ‘‘Closed and settled refers


                                               VerDate Sep<11>2014   18:26 Jan 20, 2016   Jkt 238001   PO 00000   Frm 00042   Fmt 4703   Sfmt 4703   E:\FR\FM\21JAN1.SGM   21JAN1


                                                                                 Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 13 / Thursday, January 21, 2016 / Notices                                             3419

                                                    to the final phase where loan documents                 requirement that NAICS codes be used                   Federal Reserve believes that renewal of
                                                    are fully executed and fully binding                    and the instructions remain as                         a creditworthy borrower is equivalent to
                                                    with post-closing selldown to all                       proposed.                                              prepayment of the existing line and
                                                    participants complete. Loans which                         In addition, one commenter pointed                  origination of a new line. For a borrower
                                                    have closed but are still pending                       out that the current instructions do not               who does not meet current credit
                                                    execution of final documentation by all                 reflect changes effective in the second                standards, the line renewal is equivalent
                                                    syndicate participants should remain in                 quarter of 2015 that revised the level at              to a type of loan modification: the
                                                    phase 3 ‘Closed but not settled’.’’                     which the BHC must report data on                      contractual terms of the line will be
                                                       One commenter asked for clarification                schedules L.1 and L.4. The Federal                     changed because the borrower has been
                                                    as to whether only those syndicated                     Reserve confirms that there has been no                identified as one who is likely to default
                                                    loans for which the respondents serves                  change to this requirement and that the                if the bank takes no action. Therefore,
                                                    as lead bank should be reported. The                    final instructions for these schedules                 those borrowers should be treated as
                                                    Federal Reserve confirms that any BHC                   will reflect the requirement as outlined               though they did not prepay, but instead,
                                                    which has signed a commitment letter                    in the current instructions.                           entered the amortization period of the
                                                    and extended terms to the borrower                         All proposed modifications to the                   HELOC with modified terms. To capture
                                                    should report the syndicated loans.                     Counterparty Schedule (Schedule L)                     the distinction between these two cases
                                                       Finally, one commenter stated that                   were proposed to be effective December                 and in response to the comment, the
                                                    information about these syndicated                      31, 2015. Given the general request to                 final FR Y–14 has been modified to add
                                                    pipeline commitments is generally not                   provide additional time to implement                   an additional code to the Modification
                                                    captured in a reporting company’s loan                  changes, the effective date of all                     Type field, Code 13 to represent the
                                                    accounting systems, but is maintained                   Counterparty schedule changes to the                   ‘‘HELOC Line Renewal (Regular)’’, and
                                                    ‘‘offline’’ and appears in analytical                   final FR Y–14 will be delayed until June               code 14 to represent ‘‘HELOC Line
                                                    documents and other artifacts. Thus,                    30, 2016                                               Renewal (loss mitigation strategy)’’. The
                                                    reporting companies would face a                                                                               instructions for the final FR Y–14 also
                                                    significant, on-going manual burden to                  FR Y–14M
                                                                                                                                                                   will be updated to reflect the additional
                                                    somehow systematically collect the                      Schedule A (First Lien) and Schedule B                 item codes and their definitions. Given
                                                    required detail on syndicated pipeline                  (Home Equity)                                          the general request to provide additional
                                                    commitments to support the requested                                                                           time to implement changes, this change
                                                    reporting, particularly at the level of                    Generally, commenters supported the
                                                                                                            addition of the ‘‘Serviced by Others’’                 will be effective in the final FR Y–14
                                                    detail required. Additionally, absent                                                                          beginning June 30, 2016
                                                    proposed changes for how to populate                    flag on the First Lien (Schedule A) and
                                                    correctly the Origination Date, Maturity                Home Equity (Schedule B) schedules.                       In the initial Federal Register Notice,
                                                    Date, and Committed Exposure Global                     Both commenters noted, however, that                   the Federal Reserve specifically
                                                    for pipeline loans, the Board has                       the title of the field, ‘‘SBO Flag’’,                  requested information on the collection
                                                    provided no guidance on which                           implied that the ‘‘Y’’ code should be                  of data related to the performance of a
                                                    Corporate Loan (Schedule H.l) fields                    defined as serviced by others and the                  first lien that is related to a junior lien
                                                    would be required at time of                            ‘‘N’’ code as serviced by the BHC rather               reported on the FR Y–14M Home Equity
                                                    submission. The other commenter                         than the definitions specified in the                  Schedule (Schedule B), including what
                                                    requested a delay in implementation of                  instructions. The Federal Reserve agrees               standards could make the item easier to
                                                    the disposed loans and syndicated                       that it would be more logical for the flag             report. In response to this request, one
                                                    pipeline items of two quarters to at least              codes in the instructions to be defined                commenter recommended that the
                                                    September 30, 2016. In consideration of                 as suggested by the commenter rather                   Performance of the First Lien on the
                                                    this feedback, the implementation of                    than as proposed, and the final FR Y–                  First Lien Schedule (Schedule A) and
                                                    changes related to disposed loans and                   14 instructions have been adjusted to                  Performance of Junior Liens on the
                                                    syndicated pipeline in the final FR Y–                  reflect this change. Given the general                 Home Equity Schedule (Schedule B)
                                                    14 will be delayed until September 30,                  request to provide additional time to                  fields be removed from the
                                                    2016.                                                   implement changes, final FR Y–14                       aforementioned FR Y–14M collections
                                                                                                            delays the effective date of this change               and that the Current Credit Bureau
                                                    Schedule L (Counterparty)                               until June 30, 2016.                                   Score, which is already being reported,
                                                       One commenter asked if it is                                                                                be used as a proxy to monitor any
                                                    acceptable for BHCs to use Global                       Schedule B (Home Equity)                               deterioration for evaluating performance
                                                    Industry Classification Standards (GICS)                   The Federal Reserve proposed adding                 and probability of default. The Federal
                                                    codes on this schedule as allowed in                    a new modification type, proposed code                 Reserve recognizes the cost and burden
                                                    Schedule H.1 (Corporate Loan), field 8,                 13 ‘‘HELOC Line Renewal’’ in Field 77                  expressed by the industry in supplying
                                                    in place of the North American Industry                 (Modification Type) on this schedule.                  these items and appreciates the
                                                    Classification System (NAICS) codes                     Field 77 instructs that the modification               feedback provided in response to the
                                                    indicated in the new column                             type should be reported for any loan                   request. The Federal Reserve agrees
                                                    instructions. The Federal Reserve notes                 that is currently operating under                      with the proposed suggestion to use
                                                    that the instructions for Schedule H.1,                 modified terms and should identify the                 current scores as a reasonably proxy,
                                                    field 8, also indicate that the NAICS                   specific terms that were altered through               and accordingly, the above-mentioned
                                                    code should be provided and only offer                  loss mitigation efforts. Both commenters               fields in the final FR Y–14 have been
asabaliauskas on DSK9F6TC42PROD with NOTICES




                                                    alternatives in the case the NAICS code                 questioned if all HELOC line renewals                  removed from the applicable schedules.
                                                    is not available. In addition, prior                    should be reported on this line or only                To ensure the information necessary is
                                                    submissions have shown that it is rare                  those completed through loss mitigation                available given this change, the
                                                    for firms to provide GICS instead of                    efforts.                                               instructions for the final FR Y–14 also
                                                    NAICS codes. To capture the greater                        The Federal Reserve appreciates this                require that the fields ‘Current Credit
                                                    level of granularity they make available,               feedback and agrees there is a                         Bureau Score Date’ and ‘Current Credit
                                                    particularly for financial institutions,                distinction between these two cases not                Bureau Score’ be updated at least one
                                                    the final FR Y–14 retains the                           captured in this item as proposed. The                 month within the quarter, and refreshed


                                               VerDate Sep<11>2014   18:26 Jan 20, 2016   Jkt 238001   PO 00000   Frm 00043   Fmt 4703   Sfmt 4703   E:\FR\FM\21JAN1.SGM   21JAN1


                                                    3420                         Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 13 / Thursday, January 21, 2016 / Notices

                                                    at least one month within every                           • Mail: General Services                                Obtaining Copies Of Proposals:
                                                    subsequent quarter. These changes will                  Administration, Regulatory Secretariat                 Requesters may obtain a copy of the
                                                    be effective beginning June 30, 2016.                   (MVCB), 1800 F Street NW.,                             information collection documents from
                                                                                                            Washington, DC 20405. ATTN: Ms.                        the General Services Administration,
                                                    Technical Clarifications
                                                                                                            Flowers/IC 9000–0068, Economic Price                   Regulatory Secretariat Division (MVCB),
                                                      Commenters asked for a number of                      Adjustment.                                            1800 F Street NW., Washington, DC
                                                    technical clarifications regarding                         Instructions: Please submit comments                20405, telephone 202–501–4755. Please
                                                    specific data items on the FR Y–14                      only and cite Information Collection                   cite OMB Control No. 9000–0068,
                                                    forms. These questions will be                          9000–0068, Economic Price Adjustment,                  Economic Price Adjustment, in all
                                                    addressed in the finalized version of the               in all correspondence related to this                  correspondence.
                                                    amended FR Y–14A/Q/M instructions.                      collection. Comments received generally                  Dated: January 15, 2016.
                                                      Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve             will be posted without change to http://
                                                                                                                                                                   Lorin S. Curit,
                                                    System, January 14, 2016.                               www.regulations.gov, including any
                                                                                                            personal and/or business confidential                  Director, Federal Acquisition Policy Division,
                                                    Robert deV. Frierson,                                                                                          Office of Governmentwide Acquisition Policy,
                                                                                                            information provided. To confirm                       Office of Acquisition Policy, Office of
                                                    Secretary of the Board.
                                                                                                            receipt of your comment(s), please                     Governmentwide Policy.
                                                    [FR Doc. 2016–01043 Filed 1–20–16; 8:45 am]             check www.regulations.gov,                             [FR Doc. 2016–01194 Filed 1–20–16; 8:45 am]
                                                    BILLING CODE P                                          approximately two to three days after
                                                                                                                                                                   BILLING CODE 6820–EP–P
                                                                                                            submission to verify posting (except
                                                                                                            allow 30 days for posting of comments
                                                    DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE                                   submitted by mail).                                    DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE
                                                                                                            FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Mr.
                                                    GENERAL SERVICES
                                                                                                            Michael O. Jackson, Procurement                        GENERAL SERVICES
                                                    ADMINISTRATION
                                                                                                            Analyst, Office of Governmentwide                      ADMINISTRATION
                                                                                                            Acquisition Policy, GSA, 202–208–4949
                                                    NATIONAL AERONAUTICS AND
                                                                                                            or email michaelo.jackson@gsa.gov.                     NATIONAL AERONAUTICS AND
                                                    SPACE ADMINISTRATION
                                                                                                            SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:                             SPACE ADMINISTRATION
                                                    [OMB Control No. 9000–0068; Docket 2016–
                                                    0053; Sequence 3]                                       A. Purpose                                             [OMB Control No. 9000–0026; Docket 2016–
                                                                                                                                                                   0053; Sequence 2]
                                                                                                              The FAR clause 16.203, Fixed-price
                                                    Information Collection; Economic                        contracts with economic price
                                                    Price Adjustment                                                                                               Information Collection; Change Order
                                                                                                            adjustment and associated clauses at                   Accounting
                                                    AGENCY: Department of Defense (DOD),                    52.216–2, 52.216–3, and 52.216–4,
                                                    General Services Administration (GSA),                  provide for upward and downward                        AGENCY:  Department of Defense (DOD),
                                                    and National Aeronautics and Space                      revision of the stated contract price                  General Services Administration (GSA),
                                                    Administration (NASA).                                  upon occurrence of specified                           and National Aeronautics and Space
                                                                                                            contingencies. In order for the                        Administration (NASA).
                                                    ACTION: Notice of request for an
                                                    extension to an existing OMB clearance.                 contracting officer to be aware of price               ACTION: Notice of request for public
                                                                                                            changes, the firm must provide                         comments regarding an extension to an
                                                    SUMMARY:   Under the provisions of the                  pertinent information to the                           existing OMB clearance.
                                                    Paperwork Reduction Act, the                            Government. The information is used to
                                                    Regulatory Secretariat Division will be                 determine the proper amount of price                   SUMMARY:   Under the provisions of the
                                                    submitting to the Office of Management                  adjustments required under the                         Paperwork Reduction Act, the
                                                    and Budget (OMB) a request to review                    contract.                                              Regulatory Secretariat Division will be
                                                    and approve an extension of a                                                                                  submitting to the Office of Management
                                                                                                            B. Annual Reporting Burden                             and Budget (OMB) a request to review
                                                    previously approved information
                                                    collection requirement concerning                         Respondents: 4,497.                                  and approve an extension of a
                                                    economic price adjustment.                                Responses Per Respondent: 1.                         previously approved information
                                                                                                              Annual Responses: 4,497.                             collection requirement concerning
                                                    DATES: Submit comments on or before                       Hours Per Response: 1.5.
                                                    March 21, 2016.                                                                                                change order accounting.
                                                                                                              Total Burden Hours: 6,746.
                                                    ADDRESSES: Submit comments                                                                                     DATES: Submit comments on or before
                                                    identified by Information Collection                    C. Public Comments                                     March 21, 2016.
                                                    9000–0068, Economic Price Adjustment                      Public comments are particularly                     ADDRESSES: Submit comments
                                                    by any of the following methods:                        invited on: Whether this collection of                 identified by Information Collection
                                                       • Regulations.gov: http://                           information is necessary; whether it will              9000–0026, Change Order Accounting,
                                                    www.regulations.gov.                                    have practical utility; whether our                    by any of the following methods:
                                                       Submit comments via the Federal                      estimate of the public burden of this                     • Regulations.gov: http://
                                                    eRulemaking portal by searching the                     collection of information is accurate,                 www.regulations.gov. Submit comments
                                                    OMB control number. Select the link                     and based on valid assumptions and                     via the Federal eRulemaking portal by
                                                    ‘‘Submit a Comment’’ that corresponds                   methodology; ways to enhance the                       inputting ‘‘Information Collection 9000–
asabaliauskas on DSK9F6TC42PROD with NOTICES




                                                    with ‘‘Information Collection 9000–                     quality, utility, and clarity of the                   0026, Change Order Accounting’’ under
                                                    0068, Economic Price Adjustment’’.                      information to be collected; and ways in               the heading ‘‘Enter Keyword or ID’’ and
                                                    Follow the instructions provided at the                 which we can minimize the burden of                    selecting ‘‘Search’’. Select the link
                                                    ‘‘Submit a Comment’’ screen. Please                     the collection of information on those                 ‘‘Submit a Comment’’ that corresponds
                                                    include your name, company name (if                     who are to respond, through the use of                 with ‘‘Information 9000–0026, Change
                                                    any), and ‘‘Information Collection 9000–                appropriate technological collection                   Order Accounting’’. Follow the
                                                    0068, Economic Price Adjustment’’ on                    techniques or other forms of information               instructions provided at the ‘‘Submit a
                                                    your attached document.                                 technology.                                            Comment’’ screen. Please include your


                                               VerDate Sep<11>2014   18:26 Jan 20, 2016   Jkt 238001   PO 00000   Frm 00044   Fmt 4703   Sfmt 4703   E:\FR\FM\21JAN1.SGM   21JAN1



Document Created: 2018-02-02 12:33:57
Document Modified: 2018-02-02 12:33:57
CategoryRegulatory Information
CollectionFederal Register
sudoc ClassAE 2.7:
GS 4.107:
AE 2.106:
PublisherOffice of the Federal Register, National Archives and Records Administration
SectionNotices
ActionOn September 16, 2015, the Federal Reserve published a notice in the Federal Register (80 FR 55621) requesting public comment for 60 days on the extension, with revision, of the FR Y-14A/Q/M. The Federal Reserve proposed to revise several schedules of the FR Y 14A/Q/M reports effective December 31, 2015, March 31, 2015 and June 30, 2016, and to implement an attestation requirement for LISSC firms as-of June 30, 2016. The comment period for this notice expired on November 16, 2015.
DatesDecember 31, 2015, June 30, 2016 and September 30, 2016.
ContactFederal Reserve Board Clearance Officer--Nuha Elmaghrabi--Office of the Chief Data Officer, Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, Washington, DC 20551 (202) 452-3829. Telecommunications Device for the Deaf (TDD) users may contact (202) 263-4869, Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, Washington, DC 20551.
FR Citation81 FR 3412 

2025 Federal Register | Disclaimer | Privacy Policy
USC | CFR | eCFR