81_FR_902 81 FR 897 - Fisheries of the Exclusive Economic Zone Off Alaska; Bycatch Management in the Bering Sea Pollock Fishery

81 FR 897 - Fisheries of the Exclusive Economic Zone Off Alaska; Bycatch Management in the Bering Sea Pollock Fishery

DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration

Federal Register Volume 81, Issue 5 (January 8, 2016)

Page Range897-901
FR Document2016-00150

The North Pacific Fishery Management Council (Council) submitted Amendment 110 to the Fishery Management Plan for Groundfish of the Bering Sea and Aleutian Islands Management Area (FMP). If approved, Amendment 110 would improve the management of Chinook and chum salmon bycatch in the Bering Sea pollock fishery by creating a comprehensive salmon bycatch avoidance program. This proposed action is necessary to minimize Chinook and chum salmon bycatch in the Bering Sea pollock fishery to the extent practicable while maintaining the potential for the full harvest of the pollock total allowable catch within specified prohibited species catch limits. Amendment 110 is intended to promote the goals and objectives of the Magnuson-Stevens Fishery Conservation and Management Act, the FMP, and other applicable laws.

Federal Register, Volume 81 Issue 5 (Friday, January 8, 2016)
[Federal Register Volume 81, Number 5 (Friday, January 8, 2016)]
[Proposed Rules]
[Pages 897-901]
From the Federal Register Online  [www.thefederalregister.org]
[FR Doc No: 2016-00150]


-----------------------------------------------------------------------

DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE

National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration

50 CFR Part 679

RIN 0648-BF25


Fisheries of the Exclusive Economic Zone Off Alaska; Bycatch 
Management in the Bering Sea Pollock Fishery

AGENCY: National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS), National Oceanic and 
Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), Commerce.

ACTION: Notice of availability of fishery management plan amendments; 
request for comments.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: The North Pacific Fishery Management Council (Council) 
submitted Amendment 110 to the Fishery Management Plan for Groundfish 
of the Bering Sea and Aleutian Islands Management Area (FMP). If 
approved, Amendment 110 would improve the management of Chinook and 
chum salmon bycatch in the Bering Sea pollock fishery by creating a 
comprehensive salmon bycatch avoidance program. This proposed action is 
necessary to minimize Chinook and chum salmon bycatch in the Bering Sea 
pollock fishery to the extent practicable while maintaining the 
potential for the full harvest of the pollock total allowable catch 
within specified prohibited species catch limits. Amendment 110 is 
intended to promote the goals and objectives of the Magnuson-Stevens 
Fishery Conservation and Management Act, the FMP, and other applicable 
laws.

DATES: Comments must be received no later than March 8, 2016.

ADDRESSES: You may submit comments on this document, identified by 
NOAA-NMFS-2015-0081, by any of the following methods:
     Electronic Submission: Submit all electronic public 
comments via the Federal e Rulemaking Portal. Go to 
www.regulations.gov/#!docketDetail;D=NOAA-NMFS-2015-0081, click the 
``Comment Now!'' icon, complete the required fields, and enter or 
attach your comments.
     Mail: Submit written comments to Glenn Merrill, Assistant 
Regional Administrator, Sustainable Fisheries Division, Alaska Region 
NMFS, Attn: Ellen Sebastian. Mail comments to P.O. Box 21668, Juneau, 
AK 99802-1668.
    Instructions: Comments sent by any other method, to any other 
address or individual, or received after the end of the comment period, 
may not be considered by NMFS. All comments received are a part of the 
public record and will generally be posted for public viewing on 
www.regulations.gov without change. All personal identifying 
information (e.g., name, address), confidential business information, 
or otherwise sensitive information submitted voluntarily by the sender 
will be publicly accessible. NMFS will accept anonymous comments (enter 
``N/A'' in the required fields if you wish to remain anonymous).
    Electronic copies of Amendment 110 and the Environmental 
Assessment/Regulatory Impact Review/Initial Regulatory Flexibility 
Analysis prepared for this action (collectively the ``Analysis'') may 
be obtained from www.regulations.gov.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Gretchen Harrington, 907-586-7228.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: The Magnuson-Stevens Fishery Conservation 
and Management Act (Magnuson-Stevens Act) requires that each regional 
fishery management council submit any fishery management plan amendment 
it prepares to NMFS for review and approval, disapproval, or partial 
approval by the Secretary of Commerce. The Magnuson-Stevens Act also 
requires that NMFS, upon receiving a fishery management plan amendment, 
immediately publish a notice in the Federal Register announcing that 
the amendment is available for public review and comment. This notice 
announces that proposed Amendment 110 to the FMP is available for 
public review and comment.
    NMFS manages the pollock fishery in the exclusive economic zone of 
the Bering Sea and Aleutian Islands (BSAI) under the FMP. The Council 
prepared this FMP under the authority of the Magnuson-Stevens Act, 16 
U.S.C. 1801 et seq. Regulations implementing the FMP appear at 50 CFR 
part 679. General regulations governing U.S. fisheries also appear at 
50 CFR part 600.

The Bering Sea Pollock Fishery

    Amendment 110 would apply to owners and operators of catcher 
vessels, catcher/processors, motherships, inshore processors, and the 
six Western Alaska Community Development Quota

[[Page 898]]

(CDQ) Program groups participating in the pollock (Gadus chalcogrammus) 
fishery in the Bering Sea subarea of the BSAI. The pollock fishery is 
the largest single species fishery, by volume, in the United States. In 
2013, the value of this fishery was more than 1.329 billion dollars, 
the most recent year of complete data on wholesale value. In 2015, the 
pollock TAC was 1,310,000 metric tons (mt).
    The pollock fishery is managed under the American Fisheries Act 
(AFA) (16 U.S.C. 1851 note). In October 1998, Congress enacted the AFA, 
which ``rationalized'' the pollock fishery by identifying the vessels 
and processors eligible to participate in the fishery and allocating 
pollock among those eligible participants. For more information on the 
AFA, please see the final rule implementing the AFA (67 FR 79692, 
December 30, 2002).
    Under the AFA, 10 percent of the pollock total allowable catch 
(TAC) is allocated to the CDQ Program. After the CDQ Program allocation 
is subtracted, an amount needed for the incidental catch of pollock in 
other groundfish fisheries is subtracted from the TAC. In 2015, the CDQ 
allocation was 131,000 mt of pollock and the incidental catch allowance 
was 47,160 mt. The allocation of pollock to the CDQ Program is further 
allocated among the six non-profit corporations (CDQ groups) that 
represent the 65 communities eligible for the CDQ Program under section 
305(i)(1)(D) of the Magnuson-Stevens Act.
    The ``directed fishing allowance'' is the remaining amount of 
pollock, after subtraction of the CDQ Program allocation and the 
incidental catch allowance. The directed fishing allowance is then 
allocated among the AFA inshore sector (50 percent), the AFA catcher/
processor sector (40 percent), and the AFA mothership sector (10 
percent). Annually, NMFS further apportions the pollock allocations to 
the CDQ Program and the other three AFA sectors between two seasons--40 
percent to the A season (January 20 to June 10) and 60 percent to the B 
season (June 10 to November 1) (see Sec.  679.20(a)(5)(i)(B)(1)).
    The AFA allows for the formation of fishery cooperatives within the 
non-CDQ sectors. A purpose of these AFA cooperatives is to further 
subdivide each sector's or inshore cooperative's pollock allocation 
among participants in the sector or cooperative through private 
contractual agreements. The cooperatives manage these allocations to 
ensure that individual vessels and companies do not harvest more than 
their agreed upon share. The cooperatives also facilitate transfers of 
pollock among the cooperative members, enforce contract provisions, and 
participate in an intercooperative agreement to minimize non-Chinook 
salmon bycatch as well as an incentive plan agreement to minimize 
Chinook salmon bycatch.
    The inshore sector is comprised of catcher vessels eligible to 
deliver pollock to the seven eligible AFA inshore processors. Eligible 
catcher vessels may form inshore cooperatives associated with a 
particular inshore processor. NMFS permits the inshore cooperatives, 
allocates pollock to them, and manages these allocations through a 
regulatory prohibition against an inshore cooperative exceeding its 
pollock allocation.
    The AFA catcher/processor sector is comprised of the catcher/
processors and catcher vessels eligible under the AFA to deliver to 
catcher/processors. The AFA mothership sector is made up of three 
motherships and the catcher vessels eligible under the AFA to deliver 
pollock to these motherships. These sectors have formed cooperatives; 
however, NMFS does not manage the sub-allocations of pollock among the 
cooperative members. The cooperatives control the harvest by their 
member vessels so that the pollock allocation to the sector is not 
exceeded. However, NMFS monitors pollock harvest by all members of the 
catcher/processor sector and mothership sector. NMFS retains the 
authority to close directed fishing for pollock by a sector if vessels 
in that sector continue to fish once the sector's seasonal allocation 
of pollock has been harvested.

Salmon Bycatch in the Bering Sea Pollock Fishery

    Pollock is harvested with fishing vessels using trawl gear, which 
are large nets towed through the water by the vessel. Pollock can occur 
in the same locations as Chinook salmon and chum salmon. Consequently, 
Chinook salmon and chum salmon are incidentally caught in the nets as 
fishermen target pollock.
    Section 3 of the Magnuson-Stevens Act defines bycatch as fish that 
are harvested in a fishery, which are not sold or kept for personal 
use. Therefore, Chinook salmon and chum salmon caught in the pollock 
fishery are considered bycatch under the Magnuson-Stevens Act, the FMP, 
and NMFS regulations at 50 CFR part 679. Bycatch of any species, 
including discard or other mortality caused by fishing, is a concern of 
the Council and NMFS. National Standard 9 and section 303(a)(11) of the 
Magnuson-Stevens Act requires the Council to select, and NMFS to 
implement, conservation and management measures that, to the extent 
practicable, minimize bycatch and bycatch mortality.
    The bycatch of culturally and economically valuable species like 
Chinook salmon and chum salmon, which are fully allocated and, in some 
cases, facing conservation concerns, are categorized as prohibited 
species under the FMP and are the most regulated and closely managed 
category of bycatch. Pacific salmon, steelhead trout, Pacific halibut, 
king crab, Tanner crab, and Pacific herring are classified as 
prohibited species in the groundfish fisheries off Alaska. As a 
prohibited species, fishermen must avoid salmon bycatch and any salmon 
caught must either be donated to the Prohibited Species Donation 
Program under Sec.  679.26, or returned to Federal waters as soon as is 
practicable, with a minimum of injury, after an observer has determined 
the number of salmon and collected any scientific data or biological 
samples.

Chinook Salmon Bycatch

    The pollock fishery catches more than 95 percent of the Chinook 
salmon taken incidentally in the BSAI groundfish fisheries, based on 
data from 1992 through 2014. However, this percentage has declined in 
recent years with the decline in the amount of Chinook salmon caught in 
the pollock fishery. From 1992 through 2001, the average Chinook salmon 
bycatch in the pollock fishery was 32,482 fish per year. Bycatch 
increased substantially from 2002 through 2007, to an average of 74,067 
Chinook salmon per year. A historic high of approximately 122,000 
Chinook salmon was taken in the pollock fishery in 2007. However, since 
2007 Chinook salmon bycatch then declined substantially to an average 
of 15,500 Chinook salmon per year from 2008 to 2014. The decline is 
most likely due to a combination of factors, including changes in 
abundance and distribution of Chinook salmon and pollock, as well as 
changes in fleet behavior to avoid salmon bycatch.
    Chinook salmon taken in the pollock fishery originate from Alaska, 
the Pacific Northwest, and Canada. Estimates vary, but more than half 
of the Chinook salmon bycatch in the pollock fishery may be destined 
for western Alaska. Western Alaska includes the Bristol Bay, Kuskokwim, 
Yukon, and Norton Sound areas. Section 3.4 of the Analysis provides 
additional information about Chinook salmon biology, distribution, and 
stock

[[Page 899]]

assessments by river system or region (see ADDRESSES).

Chum Salmon Bycatch

    The pollock fishery catches over 95 percent of the chum salmon 
taken incidentally as bycatch in the BSAI groundfish fisheries. The 
pollock fishery catches chum salmon almost exclusively in the B season 
(after June 10). The pollock fishery has caught large numbers of chum, 
with a historic high of approximately 700,000 chum salmon taken in 
2005. Since then, bycatch levels have been quite variable, ranging from 
a low of 13,280 chum salmon in 2010 to a high of 309,646 chum salmon in 
2006. Average chum salmon bycatch from 2006 to 2014 was 115,190 chum 
salmon. In 2014, the pollock fishery caught 219,428 chum salmon.
    Genetic information indicates that the majority of the chum salmon 
caught in the pollock fishery are of Asian origin (approximately 60 
percent) while a smaller percentage (approximately 21 percent) 
originate from aggregate streams in western Alaska. Chum salmon from 
elsewhere in Alaska, the Pacific Northwest, and Canada comprise the 
remaining percentage of the bycatch (approximately 19 percent). While 
the genetics cannot differentiate hatchery-origin fish from wild Asian 
chum salmon, given the high proportion of Pacific Rim hatchery-released 
chum from Japan, much of the Asian origin chum observed in the bycatch 
is likely to be of Asian hatchery-origin. While Alaska chum salmon runs 
have indicated a history of volatility in run sizes, chum salmon stocks 
in Alaska are generally at higher levels of abundance than historical 
periods. Section 3.4 of the Analysis provides additional information 
about chum salmon biology, distribution, and stock assessments by river 
system or region (see ADDRESSES).

Importance of Salmon in Western Alaska

    The Council and NMFS have been concerned about the potential impact 
of Chinook and chum salmon bycatch on returns to western Alaska given 
the relatively large proportion of bycatch from these river systems 
that occurs in the pollock fishery. Chinook salmon and chum salmon 
support commercial, subsistence, sport, and personal use fisheries in 
their regions of origin. The Alaska Board of Fisheries adopts 
regulations through a public process to conserve salmon and to allocate 
salmon to the various users. The State of Alaska Department of Fish and 
Game manages the salmon commercial, subsistence, sport, and personal 
use fisheries. The first management priority is to meet spawning 
escapement goals to sustain salmon resources for future generations. 
The next priority is for subsistence use under both State and Federal 
law. Salmon is a primary subsistence food in some areas. Subsistence 
fisheries management includes coordination with U.S. Federal agencies 
where Federal rules apply under the Alaska National Interest Lands 
Conservation Act.
    In recent years of low Chinook salmon returns, the in-river harvest 
of western Alaska Chinook salmon has been severely restricted and, in 
some cases, river systems have not met escapement goals. Surplus fish 
beyond escapement needs and subsistence use are made available for 
other uses. Commercial fishing for Chinook salmon may provide the only 
source of income for many people who live in remote villages. Appendix 
A-4 of the Analysis provides an overview of the importance of 
subsistence salmon harvests and commercial salmon harvests (see 
ADDRESSES).

Management of Salmon Bycatch in the Bering Sea and Aleutian Islands

    Over the last 20 years, the Council and NMFS have implemented 
several management measures to limit salmon bycatch in the BSAI trawl 
fisheries. Management measures have focused on minimizing Chinook 
salmon bycatch, chum salmon bycatch, and non-Chinook salmon bycatch. 
Non-Chinook bycatch is a category that includes all salmon species 
except Chinook salmon, but is comprised predominantly by chum salmon.
    Most recently, NMFS implemented Amendment 84 to the FMP to address 
increases in Chinook salmon and non-Chinook (predominantly chum) salmon 
bycatch in the pollock fishery that were occurring despite PSC limits 
being reached and the closures of the Chinook Salmon Savings Area and 
Chum Salmon Savings Area (72 FR 61070, October 29, 2007) and Amendment 
91 to the FMP, which implemented a program to manage Chinook salmon 
bycatch that provides incentives for each vessel to avoid Chinook 
salmon at all times (75 FR 53026, August 30, 2010).
    Amendment 84 was implemented to enhance the effectiveness of salmon 
bycatch measures by exempting pollock vessels from Chinook Salmon 
Savings Area and Chum Salmon Savings Area closures if they participate 
in an intercooperative agreement (ICA) to reduce salmon bycatch. The 
ICA allowed vessels participating in the pollock fishery to use their 
internal cooperative structure to reduce Chinook salmon and non-Chinook 
salmon bycatch using a method called the voluntary rolling hotspot 
system. The ICA operates in lieu of a fixed area closure and is 
required to identify and close areas of high salmon bycatch and move 
vessels to other areas. Amendment 84 required that parties to the ICA 
include the AFA cooperatives, the six CDQ groups, at least one third 
party group, including any organizations representing western Alaskans 
who depend on salmon and have an interest in salmon bycatch reduction, 
and at least one entity retained to facilitate bycatch avoidance 
behavior and information sharing. All AFA cooperatives and CDQ groups 
participate in the ICA.
    Amendment 91 removed Chinook salmon bycatch from the Amendment 84 
program and established a separate program to manage Chinook salmon. 
Amendment 91 combined a limit on the amount of Chinook salmon that may 
be caught incidentally with a novel approach designed to minimize 
bycatch to the extent practicable in all years and prevent bycatch from 
reaching the limit in most years while providing the fleet the 
flexibility to harvest the pollock TAC.
    Amendment 91 established two PSC limits for the pollock fishery--
60,000 and 47,591 Chinook salmon. Under Amendment 91, the PSC limit is 
60,000 Chinook salmon if some or all of the pollock industry 
participates in an industry-developed contractual arrangement, called 
an incentive plan agreement (IPA) that establishes an incentive program 
to minimize bycatch at all levels of Chinook salmon abundance. 
Participation in an IPA is voluntary; however, any vessel or CDQ group 
that chooses not to participate in an IPA is subject to a restrictive 
opt-out allocation (also called a backstop cap). Since implementation, 
all AFA vessels have participated in an IPA.
    To ensure participants develop effective IPAs, participants provide 
the Council and NMFS annual reports that describe the efforts each IPA 
is taking to ensure that each vessel does its best to avoid Chinook 
salmon at all times while fishing for pollock and, that collectively, 
bycatch is minimized in each year. The IPA system is based on being 
flexible, responsive, and able to be tailored by each sector to fit its 
operational needs. The IPAs that impose rewards for avoiding Chinook 
salmon bycatch, and/or penalties for failure to avoid Chinook salmon 
bycatch at the vessel level, warrant setting the PSC limit at 60,000 
Chinook salmon. While the IPAs provide an incentive to minimize bycatch 
in all years to a level below the limit, a limit of 60,000 Chinook 
salmon

[[Page 900]]

provides the industry the flexibility to harvest the pollock TAC in 
high-abundance years when bycatch is extremely difficult to avoid.
    Under Amendment 91, the 47,591 Chinook salmon PSC limit applies 
fleet-wide if the industry does not form any IPAs. This PSC limit was 
the approximate 10-year average of Chinook salmon bycatch from 1997 to 
2006. The 47,591 PSC limit limits Chinook salmon bycatch in the pollock 
fishery if no other incentives, namely IPAs, are operating to minimize 
bycatch below this level.
    Both PSC limits are divided between the A and B seasons and 
allocated to AFA sectors, inshore cooperatives, and CDQ groups as 
transferable PSC allocations. Transferability of the PSC mitigates the 
variation in the encounter rates of salmon bycatch among sectors, 
inshore cooperatives, and CDQ groups, in a given season. It allows 
eligible participants to obtain a larger portion of the PSC allocation 
in order to harvest their pollock allocation or to transfer surplus PSC 
allocation to other entities. When a transferable PSC allocation is 
reached, the affected sector, inshore cooperative, or CDQ group must 
stop fishing for pollock for the remainder of the season even if its 
pollock allocation has not been fully harvested.
    The sector-level performance standard is an additional tool to 
ensure that the IPA is effective and that sectors do not fully harvest 
the Chinook salmon PSC allocations under the 60,000 Chinook salmon PSC 
limit in most years. For a sector to continue to receive Chinook salmon 
PSC allocations under the 60,000 Chinook salmon PSC limit, that sector 
may not exceed its annual threshold amount in any three years within 
seven consecutive years. If a sector fails this performance standard, 
it will permanently be allocated a portion of the 47,591 Chinook salmon 
PSC limit. The risk of bearing the potential adverse economic impacts 
of a reduction from the 60,000 PSC limit to the 47,591 PSC limit 
creates incentives for fishery participants to cooperate in an 
effective IPA.

Amendment 110 Management Measures

    In April 2015, the Council recommended Amendment 110 to the FMP to 
create a comprehensive salmon bycatch avoidance program for the pollock 
fishery that works more effectively than the current salmon bycatch 
programs to avoid Chinook salmon bycatch and Alaska-origin chum salmon 
bycatch. Amendment 110 would modify the existing Chinook salmon bycatch 
program to make it more effective at avoiding Chinook salmon and 
incorporate measures to avoid chum salmon into the IPAs. In particular, 
the Council expressed that it remains extremely important to ensure 
that the Chinook salmon bycatch program is working as intended and to 
evaluate whether the incentives are strong in times of historically low 
Chinook salmon abundance. Thus the management measures included in 
Amendment 110 focus on retaining the incentives to avoid Chinook salmon 
bycatch at all levels of abundance as intended by Amendment 91.
    The Council also expressed that it remains extremely important to 
provide the incentives to avoid Alaska-origin chum salmon while 
maintaining the flexibility to avoid Chinook salmon. The Council's 
action is designed to consider the importance of continued production 
of critical chum salmon runs in western Alaska by focusing on bycatch 
avoidance of Alaskan chum salmon runs. These runs have indicated a 
history of volatility in run sizes and an historic importance in the 
subsistence lifestyle of Alaskans. Additional protections to other chum 
stocks outside of Alaska are embedded in the Council's objective to 
avoid the high bycatch of chum salmon overall, recognizing that most 
non-Alaska chum salmon are likely from Asian hatcheries.
    Amendment 110, if approved, would--
     Incorporate chum salmon avoidance into the IPAs 
established under Amendment 91 to the FMP and remove the non-Chinook 
salmon bycatch reduction ICA program previously established under 
Amendment 84 to the FMP;
     modify the requirements for the content of the IPAs to 
increase the incentives for fishermen to avoid Chinook salmon; and
     reduce the Chinook salmon PSC limit and performance 
standard in years with low Chinook salmon abundance.

Incorporate Chum Salmon Avoidance Into the Incentive Plan Agreements

    Currently, Chinook salmon and chum salmon bycatch are managed under 
two different programs (Amendment 84 and Amendment 91). This has 
created inefficiencies and does not allow participants in the pollock 
fishery the flexibility to modify their harvest patterns and practices 
to effectively minimize both Chinook salmon and chum salmon bycatch. 
Adding chum salmon measures to the IPAs would make salmon bycatch 
management more effective, comprehensive, and efficient by increasing 
flexibility to respond to changing conditions and providing greater 
incentives to reduce bycatch of both salmon species. The chum salmon 
specific requirements in the implementing regulations for Amendment 84 
sometimes prevent fishery participants from making decisions to avoid 
Chinook salmon when the vessels are encountering both chum salmon and 
Chinook salmon.
    Amendment 110 would incorporate chum salmon avoidance into the IPAs 
established under Amendment 91. Chum salmon would no longer be managed 
under Amendment 84. However, Amendment 110 would maintain the current 
non-Chinook salmon PSC limit of 42,000 fish and the closure of the Chum 
Salmon Savings Area to pollock fishing when the PSC limit has been 
reached. Vessels that participate in an IPA would be exempt from the 
Chum Salmon Savings Area closure. The purpose of maintaining the non-
Chinook salmon PSC limit and the Chum Salmon Savings Area closure is to 
provide additional incentives for vessels to join an IPA and as back-
stop chum salmon measures for those vessels that choose not to 
participate in an IPA. Incorporating chum salmon into the IPAs meets 
the purpose and need for this action by providing measures to prevent 
high chum salmon bycatch, while allowing for participants in the 
pollock fishery the flexibility to avoid Alaska chum stocks and to 
adapt quickly to changing conditions through their coordinated 
management under the IPAs. In doing so, the Council intended to strike 
an appropriate balance between regulatory requirements and adaptive 
management for chum salmon bycatch.

Modify the IPAs To Increase the Incentives To Avoid Chinook Salmon

    Amendment 110 would modify the IPAs to increase the incentives for 
fishermen to avoid Chinook salmon. The Council and NMFS recognize that 
the IPAs were effective at providing incentives for each vessel to 
avoid Chinook salmon, but that additional measures are necessary to 
address higher Chinook salmon PSC rates observed during October (the 
last month when the pollock fishery is authorized to operate) and to 
address concerns with individual vessels that consistently have 
significantly higher Chinook salmon PSC rates relative to other vessels 
fishing at the same time. The Council and NMFS wanted to ensure the use 
of salmon excluder devices (i.e., gear modifications that are designed 
to exclude salmon bycatch while retaining pollock) and a rolling 
hotspot program. The new provisions described below are intended to 
provide an opportunity for IPAs to increase their responsiveness in

[[Page 901]]

October, and improve performance of individual vessels.

Reduce the Chinook Salmon Performance Standard and PSC Limit in Years 
of Low Chinook Salmon Abundance

    Amendment 110 would add a new lower Chinook salmon PSC limit and 
performance standard for the pollock fishery in years of low Chinook 
salmon abundance. The Council and NMFS considered a lower performance 
standard and PSC limit would be appropriate at low levels of Chinook 
salmon abundance in western Alaska to accommodate the fact that most of 
the Chinook salmon bycatch comes from western Alaska. These provisions 
work in conjunction with the change to the IPA requirements to ensure 
that Chinook salmon bycatch is avoided at all times, particularly at 
low abundance levels.
    Each year NMFS would determine whether Chinook salmon abundance was 
low based on information provided by the State of Alaska. Annually, the 
State would provide an index of abundance based on the post-season in-
river Chinook salmon run size for the Kuskokwim, Unalakleet, and Upper 
Yukon aggregate stock grouping. When this index is less than or equal 
to 250,000 Chinook salmon, then the new lower performance standard and 
low PSC limit would apply.
    In low Chinook salmon abundance years, NMFS would set the 
performance standard at 33,318 Chinook salmon and the PSC limit at 
45,000 Chinook salmon. NMFS would publish the lower PSC limit and 
performance standard in the annual harvest specifications. In years 
when abundance is above 250,000 Chinook salmon, NMFS would manage under 
the current 47,591 Chinook salmon performance standard and 60,000 
Chinook salmon PSC limit established under Amendment 91.
    The inclusion of a lower PSC limit and performance standard is 
based on the need for additional incentives to reduce bycatch when 
Chinook salmon stocks are critically low in order to minimize the 
impact of the pollock fishery on the salmon stocks. Any additional fish 
returning to Alaska rivers improves the ability to meet the escapement 
goals, which is necessary for long-term sustainability of Chinook 
salmon and the people reliant on salmon fisheries. While the 
performance standard is the operational limit in the IPAs, reducing the 
60,000 PSC limit is also appropriate given the potential for decreased 
bycatch reduction incentives should a sector exceed its performance 
standard before the PSC limit is reached. The reduced PSC limit is 
intended to encourage vessels to avoid bycatch in years of low 
abundance and to set a maximum permissible PSC limit that reduces the 
risk of adverse impact on stocks in western Alaska during periods of 
low abundance.
    NMFS is soliciting public comments on proposed Amendment 110 
through the end of the comment period (see DATES). NMFS intends to 
publish in the Federal Register and seek public comment on a proposed 
rule that would implement Amendment 110, following NMFS' evaluation of 
the proposed rule under the Magnuson-Stevens Act. All comments received 
by the end of the comment period on Amendment 110, whether specifically 
directed to the FMP amendment or the proposed rule, will be considered 
in the approval/disapproval decision on Amendment 110. Comments 
received after that date will not be considered in the approval/
disapproval decision on Amendment 110. To be considered, comments must 
be received, not just postmarked or otherwise transmitted, by the last 
day of the comment period.

    Authority: 16 U.S.C. 1801 et seq.

    Dated: January 5, 2016.
Emily H. Menashes,
Acting Director, Office of Sustainable Fisheries, National Marine 
Fisheries Service.
[FR Doc. 2016-00150 Filed 1-7-16; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 3510-22-P



                                                                             Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 5 / Friday, January 8, 2016 / Proposed Rules                                             897

                                                  of the closure or restriction, not to                   abide by restrictions established under                   • Mail: Submit written comments to
                                                  exceed 12 months.                                       this section is prohibited.                            Glenn Merrill, Assistant Regional
                                                     (5) Temporary closures or restrictions                                                                      Administrator, Sustainable Fisheries
                                                                                                          Karen Hyun,
                                                  related to the taking of fish and wildlife                                                                     Division, Alaska Region NMFS, Attn:
                                                  will extend only for as long as necessary               Deputy Assistant Secretary for Fish and
                                                                                                                                                                 Ellen Sebastian. Mail comments to P.O.
                                                                                                          Wildlife and Parks.
                                                  to achieve the purpose of the closure or                                                                       Box 21668, Juneau, AK 99802–1668.
                                                  restriction. These temporary closures                   [FR Doc. 2016–00022 Filed 1–7–16; 8:45 am]
                                                                                                                                                                    Instructions: Comments sent by any
                                                  and restrictions will be periodically re-               BILLING CODE 4333–15–P                                 other method, to any other address or
                                                  evaluated as necessary, at least every 3                                                                       individual, or received after the end of
                                                  years, to determine whether the                                                                                the comment period, may not be
                                                  circumstances necessitating the original                DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE                                 considered by NMFS. All comments
                                                  closure or restriction still exist and                  National Oceanic and Atmospheric                       received are a part of the public record
                                                  warrant continuation. A formal finding                  Administration                                         and will generally be posted for public
                                                  will be made in writing that explains                                                                          viewing on www.regulations.gov
                                                  the reasoning for the decision. When a                  50 CFR Part 679                                        without change. All personal identifying
                                                  closure is no longer needed, action to                                                                         information (e.g., name, address),
                                                  remove it will be initiated as soon as                  RIN 0648–BF25                                          confidential business information, or
                                                  practicable.                                                                                                   otherwise sensitive information
                                                     (6) The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service               Fisheries of the Exclusive Economic                    submitted voluntarily by the sender will
                                                  will maintain a list of all refuge closures             Zone Off Alaska; Bycatch Management                    be publicly accessible. NMFS will
                                                  and restrictions and will publish this                  in the Bering Sea Pollock Fishery                      accept anonymous comments (enter
                                                  list annually for public review.                        AGENCY:  National Marine Fisheries                     ‘‘N/A’’ in the required fields if you wish
                                                     (e) Permanent closures or restrictions.              Service (NMFS), National Oceanic and                   to remain anonymous).
                                                  Permanent closures or restrictions                      Atmospheric Administration (NOAA),                        Electronic copies of Amendment 110
                                                  relating to the use of aircraft,                        Commerce.                                              and the Environmental Assessment/
                                                  snowmachines, motorboats, or                            ACTION: Notice of availability of fishery              Regulatory Impact Review/Initial
                                                  nonmotorized surface transportation, or                 management plan amendments; request                    Regulatory Flexibility Analysis prepared
                                                  taking of fish and wildlife, will be                    for comments.                                          for this action (collectively the
                                                  effective only after allowing for the                                                                          ‘‘Analysis’’) may be obtained from
                                                  opportunity for public comment and a                    SUMMARY:   The North Pacific Fishery                   www.regulations.gov.
                                                  public hearing in the vicinity of the                   Management Council (Council)                           FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
                                                  area(s) affected and publication in the                 submitted Amendment 110 to the                         Gretchen Harrington, 907–586–7228.
                                                  Federal Register. Permanent closures or                 Fishery Management Plan for
                                                  restrictions related to the taking of fish              Groundfish of the Bering Sea and                       SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:    The
                                                  and wildlife would require consultation                 Aleutian Islands Management Area                       Magnuson-Stevens Fishery
                                                  with the State and affected Tribes and                  (FMP). If approved, Amendment 110                      Conservation and Management Act
                                                  Native Corporations.                                    would improve the management of                        (Magnuson-Stevens Act) requires that
                                                     (f) Notice. Emergency, temporary, or                 Chinook and chum salmon bycatch in                     each regional fishery management
                                                  permanent closures or restrictions will                 the Bering Sea pollock fishery by                      council submit any fishery management
                                                  be published on the U.S. Fish and                       creating a comprehensive salmon                        plan amendment it prepares to NMFS
                                                  Wildlife Service’s Web site at http://                  bycatch avoidance program. This                        for review and approval, disapproval, or
                                                  www.fws.gov/alaska/nwr/                                 proposed action is necessary to                        partial approval by the Secretary of
                                                  ak_sp_hunt_regs.htm. Additional means                   minimize Chinook and chum salmon                       Commerce. The Magnuson-Stevens Act
                                                  of notice reasonably likely to inform                   bycatch in the Bering Sea pollock                      also requires that NMFS, upon receiving
                                                  residents in the affected vicinity will                 fishery to the extent practicable while                a fishery management plan amendment,
                                                  also be provided where available, such                  maintaining the potential for the full                 immediately publish a notice in the
                                                  as:                                                     harvest of the pollock total allowable                 Federal Register announcing that the
                                                     (1) Publication in a newspaper of                    catch within specified prohibited                      amendment is available for public
                                                  general circulation in the State and in                 species catch limits. Amendment 110 is                 review and comment. This notice
                                                  local newspapers;                                       intended to promote the goals and                      announces that proposed Amendment
                                                     (2) Use of electronic media, such as                 objectives of the Magnuson-Stevens                     110 to the FMP is available for public
                                                  the Internet and email lists;                           Fishery Conservation and Management                    review and comment.
                                                     (3) Broadcast media (radio, television,                                                                        NMFS manages the pollock fishery in
                                                                                                          Act, the FMP, and other applicable
                                                  etc.); or                                                                                                      the exclusive economic zone of the
                                                                                                          laws.
                                                     (4) Posting of signs in the local                                                                           Bering Sea and Aleutian Islands (BSAI)
                                                  vicinity or at the Refuge Manager’s                     DATES: Comments must be received no                    under the FMP. The Council prepared
                                                  office.                                                 later than March 8, 2016.                              this FMP under the authority of the
                                                     (g) Openings. In determining whether                 ADDRESSES: You may submit comments                     Magnuson-Stevens Act, 16 U.S.C. 1801
                                                  to open an area to public use or activity               on this document, identified by NOAA–                  et seq. Regulations implementing the
                                                  otherwise prohibited, the Refuge                        NMFS–2015–0081, by any of the                          FMP appear at 50 CFR part 679. General
                                                  Manager will provide notice in the                      following methods:                                     regulations governing U.S. fisheries also
srobinson on DSK5SPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS




                                                  Federal Register and will, upon request,                   • Electronic Submission: Submit all                 appear at 50 CFR part 600.
                                                  hold a public meeting in the affected                   electronic public comments via the
                                                  vicinity and other location, as                         Federal e Rulemaking Portal. Go to                     The Bering Sea Pollock Fishery
                                                  appropriate, prior to making a final                    www.regulations.gov/                                     Amendment 110 would apply to
                                                  determination.                                          #!docketDetail;D=NOAA-NMFS-2015-                       owners and operators of catcher vessels,
                                                     (h) Except as otherwise specifically                 0081, click the ‘‘Comment Now!’’ icon,                 catcher/processors, motherships,
                                                  allowed under the provisions of this                    complete the required fields, and enter                inshore processors, and the six Western
                                                  part, entry into closed areas or failure to             or attach your comments.                               Alaska Community Development Quota


                                             VerDate Sep<11>2014   22:59 Jan 12, 2016   Jkt 238001   PO 00000   Frm 00019   Fmt 4702   Sfmt 4702   E:\FR\FM\08JAP1.SGM   08JAP1


                                                  898                        Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 5 / Friday, January 8, 2016 / Proposed Rules

                                                  (CDQ) Program groups participating in                   cooperatives also facilitate transfers of              requires the Council to select, and
                                                  the pollock (Gadus chalcogrammus)                       pollock among the cooperative                          NMFS to implement, conservation and
                                                  fishery in the Bering Sea subarea of the                members, enforce contract provisions,                  management measures that, to the
                                                  BSAI. The pollock fishery is the largest                and participate in an intercooperative                 extent practicable, minimize bycatch
                                                  single species fishery, by volume, in the               agreement to minimize non-Chinook                      and bycatch mortality.
                                                  United States. In 2013, the value of this               salmon bycatch as well as an incentive                    The bycatch of culturally and
                                                  fishery was more than 1.329 billion                     plan agreement to minimize Chinook                     economically valuable species like
                                                  dollars, the most recent year of complete               salmon bycatch.                                        Chinook salmon and chum salmon,
                                                  data on wholesale value. In 2015, the                     The inshore sector is comprised of                   which are fully allocated and, in some
                                                  pollock TAC was 1,310,000 metric tons                   catcher vessels eligible to deliver                    cases, facing conservation concerns, are
                                                  (mt).                                                   pollock to the seven eligible AFA                      categorized as prohibited species under
                                                     The pollock fishery is managed under                 inshore processors. Eligible catcher                   the FMP and are the most regulated and
                                                  the American Fisheries Act (AFA) (16                    vessels may form inshore cooperatives                  closely managed category of bycatch.
                                                  U.S.C. 1851 note). In October 1998,                     associated with a particular inshore                   Pacific salmon, steelhead trout, Pacific
                                                  Congress enacted the AFA, which                         processor. NMFS permits the inshore                    halibut, king crab, Tanner crab, and
                                                  ‘‘rationalized’’ the pollock fishery by                 cooperatives, allocates pollock to them,               Pacific herring are classified as
                                                  identifying the vessels and processors                  and manages these allocations through a                prohibited species in the groundfish
                                                  eligible to participate in the fishery and              regulatory prohibition against an                      fisheries off Alaska. As a prohibited
                                                  allocating pollock among those eligible                 inshore cooperative exceeding its                      species, fishermen must avoid salmon
                                                  participants. For more information on                   pollock allocation.                                    bycatch and any salmon caught must
                                                  the AFA, please see the final rule                        The AFA catcher/processor sector is                  either be donated to the Prohibited
                                                  implementing the AFA (67 FR 79692,                      comprised of the catcher/processors and                Species Donation Program under
                                                  December 30, 2002).                                     catcher vessels eligible under the AFA
                                                                                                                                                                 § 679.26, or returned to Federal waters
                                                     Under the AFA, 10 percent of the                     to deliver to catcher/processors. The
                                                                                                                                                                 as soon as is practicable, with a
                                                  pollock total allowable catch (TAC) is                  AFA mothership sector is made up of
                                                                                                                                                                 minimum of injury, after an observer
                                                  allocated to the CDQ Program. After the                 three motherships and the catcher
                                                                                                                                                                 has determined the number of salmon
                                                  CDQ Program allocation is subtracted,                   vessels eligible under the AFA to
                                                                                                                                                                 and collected any scientific data or
                                                  an amount needed for the incidental                     deliver pollock to these motherships.
                                                                                                                                                                 biological samples.
                                                  catch of pollock in other groundfish                    These sectors have formed cooperatives;
                                                  fisheries is subtracted from the TAC. In                however, NMFS does not manage the                      Chinook Salmon Bycatch
                                                  2015, the CDQ allocation was 131,000                    sub-allocations of pollock among the
                                                                                                                                                                    The pollock fishery catches more than
                                                  mt of pollock and the incidental catch                  cooperative members. The cooperatives
                                                  allowance was 47,160 mt. The                            control the harvest by their member                    95 percent of the Chinook salmon taken
                                                  allocation of pollock to the CDQ                        vessels so that the pollock allocation to              incidentally in the BSAI groundfish
                                                  Program is further allocated among the                  the sector is not exceeded. However,                   fisheries, based on data from 1992
                                                  six non-profit corporations (CDQ                        NMFS monitors pollock harvest by all                   through 2014. However, this percentage
                                                  groups) that represent the 65                           members of the catcher/processor sector                has declined in recent years with the
                                                  communities eligible for the CDQ                        and mothership sector. NMFS retains                    decline in the amount of Chinook
                                                  Program under section 305(i)(1)(D) of                   the authority to close directed fishing                salmon caught in the pollock fishery.
                                                  the Magnuson-Stevens Act.                               for pollock by a sector if vessels in that             From 1992 through 2001, the average
                                                     The ‘‘directed fishing allowance’’ is                sector continue to fish once the sector’s              Chinook salmon bycatch in the pollock
                                                  the remaining amount of pollock, after                  seasonal allocation of pollock has been                fishery was 32,482 fish per year.
                                                  subtraction of the CDQ Program                          harvested.                                             Bycatch increased substantially from
                                                  allocation and the incidental catch                                                                            2002 through 2007, to an average of
                                                  allowance. The directed fishing                         Salmon Bycatch in the Bering Sea                       74,067 Chinook salmon per year. A
                                                  allowance is then allocated among the                   Pollock Fishery                                        historic high of approximately 122,000
                                                  AFA inshore sector (50 percent), the                       Pollock is harvested with fishing                   Chinook salmon was taken in the
                                                  AFA catcher/processor sector (40                        vessels using trawl gear, which are large              pollock fishery in 2007. However, since
                                                  percent), and the AFA mothership                        nets towed through the water by the                    2007 Chinook salmon bycatch then
                                                  sector (10 percent). Annually, NMFS                     vessel. Pollock can occur in the same                  declined substantially to an average of
                                                  further apportions the pollock                          locations as Chinook salmon and chum                   15,500 Chinook salmon per year from
                                                  allocations to the CDQ Program and the                  salmon. Consequently, Chinook salmon                   2008 to 2014. The decline is most likely
                                                  other three AFA sectors between two                     and chum salmon are incidentally                       due to a combination of factors,
                                                  seasons—40 percent to the A season                      caught in the nets as fishermen target                 including changes in abundance and
                                                  (January 20 to June 10) and 60 percent                  pollock.                                               distribution of Chinook salmon and
                                                  to the B season (June 10 to November 1)                    Section 3 of the Magnuson-Stevens                   pollock, as well as changes in fleet
                                                  (see § 679.20(a)(5)(i)(B)(1)).                          Act defines bycatch as fish that are                   behavior to avoid salmon bycatch.
                                                     The AFA allows for the formation of                  harvested in a fishery, which are not                     Chinook salmon taken in the pollock
                                                  fishery cooperatives within the non-                    sold or kept for personal use. Therefore,              fishery originate from Alaska, the
                                                  CDQ sectors. A purpose of these AFA                     Chinook salmon and chum salmon                         Pacific Northwest, and Canada.
                                                  cooperatives is to further subdivide each               caught in the pollock fishery are                      Estimates vary, but more than half of the
srobinson on DSK5SPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS




                                                  sector’s or inshore cooperative’s pollock               considered bycatch under the                           Chinook salmon bycatch in the pollock
                                                  allocation among participants in the                    Magnuson-Stevens Act, the FMP, and                     fishery may be destined for western
                                                  sector or cooperative through private                   NMFS regulations at 50 CFR part 679.                   Alaska. Western Alaska includes the
                                                  contractual agreements. The                             Bycatch of any species, including                      Bristol Bay, Kuskokwim, Yukon, and
                                                  cooperatives manage these allocations to                discard or other mortality caused by                   Norton Sound areas. Section 3.4 of the
                                                  ensure that individual vessels and                      fishing, is a concern of the Council and               Analysis provides additional
                                                  companies do not harvest more than                      NMFS. National Standard 9 and section                  information about Chinook salmon
                                                  their agreed upon share. The                            303(a)(11) of the Magnuson-Stevens Act                 biology, distribution, and stock


                                             VerDate Sep<11>2014   22:59 Jan 12, 2016   Jkt 238001   PO 00000   Frm 00020   Fmt 4702   Sfmt 4702   E:\FR\FM\08JAP1.SGM   08JAP1


                                                                             Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 5 / Friday, January 8, 2016 / Proposed Rules                                              899

                                                  assessments by river system or region                   first management priority is to meet                   bycatch using a method called the
                                                  (see ADDRESSES).                                        spawning escapement goals to sustain                   voluntary rolling hotspot system. The
                                                                                                          salmon resources for future generations.               ICA operates in lieu of a fixed area
                                                  Chum Salmon Bycatch
                                                                                                          The next priority is for subsistence use               closure and is required to identify and
                                                     The pollock fishery catches over 95                  under both State and Federal law.                      close areas of high salmon bycatch and
                                                  percent of the chum salmon taken                        Salmon is a primary subsistence food in                move vessels to other areas.
                                                  incidentally as bycatch in the BSAI                     some areas. Subsistence fisheries                      Amendment 84 required that parties to
                                                  groundfish fisheries. The pollock fishery               management includes coordination with                  the ICA include the AFA cooperatives,
                                                  catches chum salmon almost                              U.S. Federal agencies where Federal                    the six CDQ groups, at least one third
                                                  exclusively in the B season (after June                 rules apply under the Alaska National                  party group, including any
                                                  10). The pollock fishery has caught large               Interest Lands Conservation Act.                       organizations representing western
                                                  numbers of chum, with a historic high                      In recent years of low Chinook salmon               Alaskans who depend on salmon and
                                                  of approximately 700,000 chum salmon                    returns, the in-river harvest of western               have an interest in salmon bycatch
                                                  taken in 2005. Since then, bycatch                      Alaska Chinook salmon has been                         reduction, and at least one entity
                                                  levels have been quite variable, ranging                severely restricted and, in some cases,                retained to facilitate bycatch avoidance
                                                  from a low of 13,280 chum salmon in                     river systems have not met escapement                  behavior and information sharing. All
                                                  2010 to a high of 309,646 chum salmon                   goals. Surplus fish beyond escapement                  AFA cooperatives and CDQ groups
                                                  in 2006. Average chum salmon bycatch                    needs and subsistence use are made                     participate in the ICA.
                                                  from 2006 to 2014 was 115,190 chum                      available for other uses. Commercial                      Amendment 91 removed Chinook
                                                  salmon. In 2014, the pollock fishery                    fishing for Chinook salmon may provide                 salmon bycatch from the Amendment
                                                  caught 219,428 chum salmon.                             the only source of income for many                     84 program and established a separate
                                                     Genetic information indicates that the               people who live in remote villages.                    program to manage Chinook salmon.
                                                  majority of the chum salmon caught in                   Appendix A–4 of the Analysis provides                  Amendment 91 combined a limit on the
                                                  the pollock fishery are of Asian origin                 an overview of the importance of                       amount of Chinook salmon that may be
                                                  (approximately 60 percent) while a                      subsistence salmon harvests and                        caught incidentally with a novel
                                                  smaller percentage (approximately 21                    commercial salmon harvests (see                        approach designed to minimize bycatch
                                                  percent) originate from aggregate                       ADDRESSES).                                            to the extent practicable in all years and
                                                  streams in western Alaska. Chum                                                                                prevent bycatch from reaching the limit
                                                  salmon from elsewhere in Alaska, the                    Management of Salmon Bycatch in the
                                                                                                                                                                 in most years while providing the fleet
                                                  Pacific Northwest, and Canada comprise                  Bering Sea and Aleutian Islands
                                                                                                                                                                 the flexibility to harvest the pollock
                                                  the remaining percentage of the bycatch                    Over the last 20 years, the Council                 TAC.
                                                  (approximately 19 percent). While the                   and NMFS have implemented several                         Amendment 91 established two PSC
                                                  genetics cannot differentiate hatchery-                 management measures to limit salmon                    limits for the pollock fishery—60,000
                                                  origin fish from wild Asian chum                        bycatch in the BSAI trawl fisheries.                   and 47,591 Chinook salmon. Under
                                                  salmon, given the high proportion of                    Management measures have focused on                    Amendment 91, the PSC limit is 60,000
                                                  Pacific Rim hatchery-released chum                      minimizing Chinook salmon bycatch,                     Chinook salmon if some or all of the
                                                  from Japan, much of the Asian origin                    chum salmon bycatch, and non-Chinook                   pollock industry participates in an
                                                  chum observed in the bycatch is likely                  salmon bycatch. Non-Chinook bycatch                    industry-developed contractual
                                                  to be of Asian hatchery-origin. While                   is a category that includes all salmon                 arrangement, called an incentive plan
                                                  Alaska chum salmon runs have                            species except Chinook salmon, but is                  agreement (IPA) that establishes an
                                                  indicated a history of volatility in run                comprised predominantly by chum                        incentive program to minimize bycatch
                                                  sizes, chum salmon stocks in Alaska are                 salmon.                                                at all levels of Chinook salmon
                                                  generally at higher levels of abundance                    Most recently, NMFS implemented                     abundance. Participation in an IPA is
                                                  than historical periods. Section 3.4 of                 Amendment 84 to the FMP to address                     voluntary; however, any vessel or CDQ
                                                  the Analysis provides additional                        increases in Chinook salmon and non-                   group that chooses not to participate in
                                                  information about chum salmon                           Chinook (predominantly chum) salmon                    an IPA is subject to a restrictive opt-out
                                                  biology, distribution, and stock                        bycatch in the pollock fishery that were               allocation (also called a backstop cap).
                                                  assessments by river system or region                   occurring despite PSC limits being                     Since implementation, all AFA vessels
                                                  (see ADDRESSES).                                        reached and the closures of the Chinook                have participated in an IPA.
                                                                                                          Salmon Savings Area and Chum Salmon                       To ensure participants develop
                                                  Importance of Salmon in Western                         Savings Area (72 FR 61070, October 29,                 effective IPAs, participants provide the
                                                  Alaska                                                  2007) and Amendment 91 to the FMP,                     Council and NMFS annual reports that
                                                     The Council and NMFS have been                       which implemented a program to                         describe the efforts each IPA is taking to
                                                  concerned about the potential impact of                 manage Chinook salmon bycatch that                     ensure that each vessel does its best to
                                                  Chinook and chum salmon bycatch on                      provides incentives for each vessel to                 avoid Chinook salmon at all times while
                                                  returns to western Alaska given the                     avoid Chinook salmon at all times (75                  fishing for pollock and, that collectively,
                                                  relatively large proportion of bycatch                  FR 53026, August 30, 2010).                            bycatch is minimized in each year. The
                                                  from these river systems that occurs in                    Amendment 84 was implemented to                     IPA system is based on being flexible,
                                                  the pollock fishery. Chinook salmon and                 enhance the effectiveness of salmon                    responsive, and able to be tailored by
                                                  chum salmon support commercial,                         bycatch measures by exempting pollock                  each sector to fit its operational needs.
                                                  subsistence, sport, and personal use                    vessels from Chinook Salmon Savings                    The IPAs that impose rewards for
srobinson on DSK5SPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS




                                                  fisheries in their regions of origin. The               Area and Chum Salmon Savings Area                      avoiding Chinook salmon bycatch, and/
                                                  Alaska Board of Fisheries adopts                        closures if they participate in an                     or penalties for failure to avoid Chinook
                                                  regulations through a public process to                 intercooperative agreement (ICA) to                    salmon bycatch at the vessel level,
                                                  conserve salmon and to allocate salmon                  reduce salmon bycatch. The ICA                         warrant setting the PSC limit at 60,000
                                                  to the various users. The State of Alaska               allowed vessels participating in the                   Chinook salmon. While the IPAs
                                                  Department of Fish and Game manages                     pollock fishery to use their internal                  provide an incentive to minimize
                                                  the salmon commercial, subsistence,                     cooperative structure to reduce Chinook                bycatch in all years to a level below the
                                                  sport, and personal use fisheries. The                  salmon and non-Chinook salmon                          limit, a limit of 60,000 Chinook salmon


                                             VerDate Sep<11>2014   22:59 Jan 12, 2016   Jkt 238001   PO 00000   Frm 00021   Fmt 4702   Sfmt 4702   E:\FR\FM\08JAP1.SGM   08JAP1


                                                  900                        Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 5 / Friday, January 8, 2016 / Proposed Rules

                                                  provides the industry the flexibility to                and incorporate measures to avoid                      both salmon species. The chum salmon
                                                  harvest the pollock TAC in high-                        chum salmon into the IPAs. In                          specific requirements in the
                                                  abundance years when bycatch is                         particular, the Council expressed that it              implementing regulations for
                                                  extremely difficult to avoid.                           remains extremely important to ensure                  Amendment 84 sometimes prevent
                                                     Under Amendment 91, the 47,591                       that the Chinook salmon bycatch                        fishery participants from making
                                                  Chinook salmon PSC limit applies fleet-                 program is working as intended and to                  decisions to avoid Chinook salmon
                                                  wide if the industry does not form any                  evaluate whether the incentives are                    when the vessels are encountering both
                                                  IPAs. This PSC limit was the                            strong in times of historically low                    chum salmon and Chinook salmon.
                                                  approximate 10-year average of Chinook                  Chinook salmon abundance. Thus the                        Amendment 110 would incorporate
                                                  salmon bycatch from 1997 to 2006. The                   management measures included in                        chum salmon avoidance into the IPAs
                                                  47,591 PSC limit limits Chinook salmon                  Amendment 110 focus on retaining the                   established under Amendment 91.
                                                  bycatch in the pollock fishery if no                    incentives to avoid Chinook salmon                     Chum salmon would no longer be
                                                  other incentives, namely IPAs, are                      bycatch at all levels of abundance as                  managed under Amendment 84.
                                                  operating to minimize bycatch below                     intended by Amendment 91.                              However, Amendment 110 would
                                                  this level.                                                The Council also expressed that it                  maintain the current non-Chinook
                                                     Both PSC limits are divided between                  remains extremely important to provide                 salmon PSC limit of 42,000 fish and the
                                                  the A and B seasons and allocated to                    the incentives to avoid Alaska-origin                  closure of the Chum Salmon Savings
                                                  AFA sectors, inshore cooperatives, and                  chum salmon while maintaining the                      Area to pollock fishing when the PSC
                                                  CDQ groups as transferable PSC                          flexibility to avoid Chinook salmon. The               limit has been reached. Vessels that
                                                  allocations. Transferability of the PSC                 Council’s action is designed to consider               participate in an IPA would be exempt
                                                  mitigates the variation in the encounter                the importance of continued production                 from the Chum Salmon Savings Area
                                                  rates of salmon bycatch among sectors,                  of critical chum salmon runs in western                closure. The purpose of maintaining the
                                                  inshore cooperatives, and CDQ groups,                   Alaska by focusing on bycatch                          non-Chinook salmon PSC limit and the
                                                  in a given season. It allows eligible                   avoidance of Alaskan chum salmon                       Chum Salmon Savings Area closure is to
                                                  participants to obtain a larger portion of              runs. These runs have indicated a                      provide additional incentives for vessels
                                                  the PSC allocation in order to harvest                  history of volatility in run sizes and an              to join an IPA and as back-stop chum
                                                  their pollock allocation or to transfer                 historic importance in the subsistence                 salmon measures for those vessels that
                                                  surplus PSC allocation to other entities.               lifestyle of Alaskans. Additional                      choose not to participate in an IPA.
                                                  When a transferable PSC allocation is                   protections to other chum stocks outside               Incorporating chum salmon into the
                                                  reached, the affected sector, inshore                   of Alaska are embedded in the Council’s                IPAs meets the purpose and need for
                                                  cooperative, or CDQ group must stop                     objective to avoid the high bycatch of                 this action by providing measures to
                                                  fishing for pollock for the remainder of                chum salmon overall, recognizing that                  prevent high chum salmon bycatch,
                                                  the season even if its pollock allocation               most non-Alaska chum salmon are                        while allowing for participants in the
                                                  has not been fully harvested.                           likely from Asian hatcheries.                          pollock fishery the flexibility to avoid
                                                     The sector-level performance standard                   Amendment 110, if approved,                         Alaska chum stocks and to adapt
                                                  is an additional tool to ensure that the                would—                                                 quickly to changing conditions through
                                                  IPA is effective and that sectors do not                   • Incorporate chum salmon                           their coordinated management under
                                                  fully harvest the Chinook salmon PSC                    avoidance into the IPAs established                    the IPAs. In doing so, the Council
                                                  allocations under the 60,000 Chinook                    under Amendment 91 to the FMP and                      intended to strike an appropriate
                                                  salmon PSC limit in most years. For a                   remove the non-Chinook salmon                          balance between regulatory
                                                  sector to continue to receive Chinook                   bycatch reduction ICA program                          requirements and adaptive management
                                                  salmon PSC allocations under the                        previously established under                           for chum salmon bycatch.
                                                  60,000 Chinook salmon PSC limit, that                   Amendment 84 to the FMP;                               Modify the IPAs To Increase the
                                                  sector may not exceed its annual                           • modify the requirements for the
                                                  threshold amount in any three years                                                                            Incentives To Avoid Chinook Salmon
                                                                                                          content of the IPAs to increase the
                                                  within seven consecutive years. If a                    incentives for fishermen to avoid                         Amendment 110 would modify the
                                                  sector fails this performance standard, it              Chinook salmon; and                                    IPAs to increase the incentives for
                                                  will permanently be allocated a portion                    • reduce the Chinook salmon PSC                     fishermen to avoid Chinook salmon.
                                                  of the 47,591 Chinook salmon PSC limit.                 limit and performance standard in years                The Council and NMFS recognize that
                                                  The risk of bearing the potential adverse               with low Chinook salmon abundance.                     the IPAs were effective at providing
                                                  economic impacts of a reduction from                                                                           incentives for each vessel to avoid
                                                                                                          Incorporate Chum Salmon Avoidance                      Chinook salmon, but that additional
                                                  the 60,000 PSC limit to the 47,591 PSC
                                                                                                          Into the Incentive Plan Agreements                     measures are necessary to address
                                                  limit creates incentives for fishery
                                                  participants to cooperate in an effective                  Currently, Chinook salmon and chum                  higher Chinook salmon PSC rates
                                                  IPA.                                                    salmon bycatch are managed under two                   observed during October (the last month
                                                                                                          different programs (Amendment 84 and                   when the pollock fishery is authorized
                                                  Amendment 110 Management Measures                       Amendment 91). This has created                        to operate) and to address concerns with
                                                     In April 2015, the Council                           inefficiencies and does not allow                      individual vessels that consistently have
                                                  recommended Amendment 110 to the                        participants in the pollock fishery the                significantly higher Chinook salmon
                                                  FMP to create a comprehensive salmon                    flexibility to modify their harvest                    PSC rates relative to other vessels
                                                  bycatch avoidance program for the                       patterns and practices to effectively                  fishing at the same time. The Council
srobinson on DSK5SPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS




                                                  pollock fishery that works more                         minimize both Chinook salmon and                       and NMFS wanted to ensure the use of
                                                  effectively than the current salmon                     chum salmon bycatch. Adding chum                       salmon excluder devices (i.e., gear
                                                  bycatch programs to avoid Chinook                       salmon measures to the IPAs would                      modifications that are designed to
                                                  salmon bycatch and Alaska-origin chum                   make salmon bycatch management more                    exclude salmon bycatch while retaining
                                                  salmon bycatch. Amendment 110 would                     effective, comprehensive, and efficient                pollock) and a rolling hotspot program.
                                                  modify the existing Chinook salmon                      by increasing flexibility to respond to                The new provisions described below are
                                                  bycatch program to make it more                         changing conditions and providing                      intended to provide an opportunity for
                                                  effective at avoiding Chinook salmon                    greater incentives to reduce bycatch of                IPAs to increase their responsiveness in


                                             VerDate Sep<11>2014   22:59 Jan 12, 2016   Jkt 238001   PO 00000   Frm 00022   Fmt 4702   Sfmt 4702   E:\FR\FM\08JAP1.SGM   08JAP1


                                                                             Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 5 / Friday, January 8, 2016 / Proposed Rules                                                     901

                                                  October, and improve performance of                     lower performance standard and low                     bycatch in years of low abundance and
                                                  individual vessels.                                     PSC limit would apply.                                 to set a maximum permissible PSC limit
                                                                                                             In low Chinook salmon abundance                     that reduces the risk of adverse impact
                                                  Reduce the Chinook Salmon                               years, NMFS would set the performance                  on stocks in western Alaska during
                                                  Performance Standard and PSC Limit in                   standard at 33,318 Chinook salmon and                  periods of low abundance.
                                                  Years of Low Chinook Salmon                             the PSC limit at 45,000 Chinook salmon.
                                                  Abundance                                                                                                        NMFS is soliciting public comments
                                                                                                          NMFS would publish the lower PSC                       on proposed Amendment 110 through
                                                     Amendment 110 would add a new                        limit and performance standard in the
                                                                                                                                                                 the end of the comment period (see
                                                  lower Chinook salmon PSC limit and                      annual harvest specifications. In years
                                                                                                                                                                 DATES). NMFS intends to publish in the
                                                  performance standard for the pollock                    when abundance is above 250,000
                                                                                                                                                                 Federal Register and seek public
                                                                                                          Chinook salmon, NMFS would manage
                                                  fishery in years of low Chinook salmon                                                                         comment on a proposed rule that would
                                                                                                          under the current 47,591 Chinook
                                                  abundance. The Council and NMFS                                                                                implement Amendment 110, following
                                                                                                          salmon performance standard and
                                                  considered a lower performance                                                                                 NMFS’ evaluation of the proposed rule
                                                                                                          60,000 Chinook salmon PSC limit
                                                  standard and PSC limit would be                                                                                under the Magnuson-Stevens Act. All
                                                                                                          established under Amendment 91.
                                                  appropriate at low levels of Chinook                       The inclusion of a lower PSC limit                  comments received by the end of the
                                                  salmon abundance in western Alaska to                   and performance standard is based on                   comment period on Amendment 110,
                                                  accommodate the fact that most of the                   the need for additional incentives to                  whether specifically directed to the
                                                  Chinook salmon bycatch comes from                       reduce bycatch when Chinook salmon                     FMP amendment or the proposed rule,
                                                  western Alaska. These provisions work                   stocks are critically low in order to                  will be considered in the approval/
                                                  in conjunction with the change to the                   minimize the impact of the pollock                     disapproval decision on Amendment
                                                  IPA requirements to ensure that                         fishery on the salmon stocks. Any                      110. Comments received after that date
                                                  Chinook salmon bycatch is avoided at                    additional fish returning to Alaska                    will not be considered in the approval/
                                                  all times, particularly at low abundance                rivers improves the ability to meet the                disapproval decision on Amendment
                                                  levels.                                                 escapement goals, which is necessary                   110. To be considered, comments must
                                                     Each year NMFS would determine                       for long-term sustainability of Chinook                be received, not just postmarked or
                                                  whether Chinook salmon abundance                        salmon and the people reliant on                       otherwise transmitted, by the last day of
                                                  was low based on information provided                   salmon fisheries. While the performance                the comment period.
                                                  by the State of Alaska. Annually, the                   standard is the operational limit in the                 Authority: 16 U.S.C. 1801 et seq.
                                                  State would provide an index of                         IPAs, reducing the 60,000 PSC limit is
                                                                                                                                                                   Dated: January 5, 2016.
                                                  abundance based on the post-season in-                  also appropriate given the potential for
                                                  river Chinook salmon run size for the                   decreased bycatch reduction incentives                 Emily H. Menashes,
                                                  Kuskokwim, Unalakleet, and Upper                        should a sector exceed its performance                 Acting Director, Office of Sustainable
                                                  Yukon aggregate stock grouping. When                    standard before the PSC limit is                       Fisheries, National Marine Fisheries Service.
                                                  this index is less than or equal to                     reached. The reduced PSC limit is                      [FR Doc. 2016–00150 Filed 1–7–16; 8:45 am]
                                                  250,000 Chinook salmon, then the new                    intended to encourage vessels to avoid                 BILLING CODE 3510–22–P
srobinson on DSK5SPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS




                                             VerDate Sep<11>2014   22:59 Jan 12, 2016   Jkt 238001   PO 00000   Frm 00023   Fmt 4702   Sfmt 9990   E:\FR\FM\08JAP1.SGM   08JAP1



Document Created: 2016-01-16 01:15:16
Document Modified: 2016-01-16 01:15:16
CategoryRegulatory Information
CollectionFederal Register
sudoc ClassAE 2.7:
GS 4.107:
AE 2.106:
PublisherOffice of the Federal Register, National Archives and Records Administration
SectionProposed Rules
ActionNotice of availability of fishery management plan amendments; request for comments.
DatesComments must be received no later than March 8, 2016.
ContactGretchen Harrington, 907-586-7228.
FR Citation81 FR 897 
RIN Number0648-BF25

2025 Federal Register | Disclaimer | Privacy Policy
USC | CFR | eCFR