Standard Instrument Approach Procedures, and Takeoff Minimums and Obstacle Departure Procedures; Miscellaneous Amendments
The FAA is issuing a final rule that removes certain redundant or underutilized ground-based nondirectional radio beacon (NDB) and VHF omnidirectional range (VOR) Standard Instr...
Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), Department of Transportation (DOT).
ACTION:
Final rule.
SUMMARY:
The FAA is issuing a final rule that removes certain redundant or underutilized ground-based nondirectional radio beacon (NDB) and VHF omnidirectional range (VOR) Standard Instrument Approach Procedures (SIAPs). On April 13, 2015, the FAA published a notice of proposed rulemaking to remove 736 procedures. After consideration of public comments and conducting an internal review, the FAA has decided to move forward with removing 334 procedures that did not receive public comment. The 198 procedures for which comments were received will be addressed in the future. The FAA also identified 191 procedures that were proposed for removal but that do not meet the criteria at this time. Those 191 procedures may be reevaluated at a later date; however, their removal is withdrawn from consideration in this rule. There are 13 procedures erroneously identified in the NPRM that were already in the process for removal and should not have been included in this proceeding. The FAA concluded that these procedures should continue in the separate proceeding and are not addressed in this final rule.
DATES:
This rule is effective December 10, 2015. The removal date of each SIAP, associated Takeoff Minimums, and ODP is as specified in the amendatory provisions.
ADDRESSES:
For information on where to obtain copies of rulemaking documents and other information related to this final rule, see “How To Obtain Additional Information” in the
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION
section of this document.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
For technical questions concerning this action, contact Mark D. Adams, Aeronautical Navigation Products, AJV-5, Aeronautical Information Services, Federal Aviation Administration, Air Traffic Organization, 6500 S. MacArthur
( printed page 69579)
Blvd. (MMAC), Bldg. 5, Room 104, Oklahoma City, OK 73169; Telephone (405) 954-9946; Email
AMC-ATO-IFP-Cancellations@faa.gov.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
Authority for This Rulemaking
The FAA's authority to issue rules on aviation safety is found in Title 49 of the United States Code. Subtitle I, Section 106 describes the authority of the FAA Administrator. Subtitle VII, Aviation Programs, describes in more detail the scope of the agency's authority.
This rulemaking is promulgated under the authority described in Subtitle VII, Part A, Subpart i, Section 40103, sovereignty and use of airspace, and Subpart iii, Section 44701, general requirements. Under these sections, the FAA is charged with prescribing regulations to regulate the safe and efficient use of the navigable airspace; to govern the flight, navigation, protection, and identification of aircraft for the protection of persons and property on the ground, and for the efficient use of the navigable airspace (49 U.S.C. 40103(b)), and to promote safe flight of civil aircraft in air commerce by prescribing regulations and minimum standards for other practices, methods, and procedures necessary for safety in air commerce and national security (49 U.S.C. 44701(a)(5)). This action is within the scope of that authority.
On June 27, 2014, the FAA published criteria for determining whether to retain existing SIAPs (79 FR 36576). Removing identified ground-based NDB and VOR SIAPs is an integral part of right-sizing the quantity and type of procedures in the National Airspace System (NAS). As new technology facilitates the introduction of area navigation (RNAV) instrument approach procedures, the number of procedures available in the NAS has nearly doubled over the past decade. The complexity and cost of maintaining the existing ground based navigational infrastructure while expanding RNAV capability is not sustainable.
On April 13, 2015, the FAA published a notice of proposed rulemaking (NPRM) proposing to remove certain SIAPs (80 FR 19577). The NPRM included a list of 736 procedures that were identified for cancellation and the comment period closed on May 28, 2015.
The following 13 SIAPs were proposed for cancellation in the NPRM. In reviewing the procedures and comments, the FAA realized that these 13 procedures were already being processed for cancellation and were at various stages. Additionally, the navigation facilities supporting a number of these procedures were either decommissioned or at various stages of that process. The inclusion of these procedures in the NPRM was in error, in that these procedures were already subject to prior agency commitments. The FAA notes three of these procedures received comment (VOR RWY 18 at Pryor Field Regional, Alabama (DCU); NDB RWY 14 at Montgomery County Airpark, Maryland (GAI); and NDB RWY 27 at Athens/Ben Epps, Georgia (AHN)) concerning lack of backup instrument flight procedures in case of instrument landing system failure, impacts to instrument flight training, and reduced airport access. The FAA confirms that for each of the three above affected procedures, the airports continue to maintain at least one other ground based procedure. In addition, there remain procedures available within a 20 nm radius of these airports for instrument flight training. The procedures are listed below with the associated
Federal Register
citation announcing the cancellation.
The FAA proposed to cancel 191 procedures listed in the following table. However, after further consideration and a reevaluation of the policy criteria described in the June 27, 2014, statement of policy, the FAA has determined that these procedures do not meet the criteria at this time. Therefore these procedures will remain in effect and are not included in this final rule; however the FAA may reevaluate these procedures at a later date.
State
Airport name
ID
Approach procedure
AK
BETTLES
BTT
VOR/DME RWY 01.
AK
SITKA ROCKY GUTIERREZ
SIT
VOR/DME-A.
AK
UNALAKLEET
UNK
VOR/DME-D.
AL
ANNISTON RGNL
ANB
NDB RWY 5.
AL
BESSEMER
EKY
VOR RWY 05.
AL
WALKER COUNTY-BEVILL FIELD
JFX
VOR/DME-A.
AR
WALNUT RIDGE RGNL
ARG
VOR-A.
AR
HOT SPRINGS/MEMORIAL FIELD
HOT
VOR Z RWY 05.
AR
WEST MEMPHIS MUNI
AWM
VOR/DME-A.
AR
BAXTER COUNTY
BPK
VOR-A.
( printed page 69580)
AR
JONESBORO MUNI
JBR
VOR RWY 23.
AR
NORTH LITTLE ROCK MUNI
ORK
VOR RWY 35.
AZ
BISBEE DOUGLAS INTL
DUG
VOR RWY 17.
AZ
CASA GRANDE MUNI
CGZ
VOR RWY 05.
AZ
GRAND CANYON NATIONAL PARK
GCN
VOR RWY 03.
CA
JACK MC NAMARA FIELD
CEC
VOR RWY 12, formerly VOR RWY 11.
CA
MERCED RGNL/MACREADY FIELD
MCE
VOR RWY 30.
CA
REDDING MUNI
RDD
VOR RWY 34.
CA
SAN BERNARDINO INTL
SBD
NDB RWY 06.
CA
NAPA COUNTY
APC
VOR RWY 06.
CA
BUCHANAN FIELD
CCR
VOR RWY 19R.
CA
CHINO
CNO
VOR RWY 26R.
CA
MC CLELLAN-PALOMAR
CRQ
VOR-A.
CA
LONG BEACH/DAUGHERTY FIELD
LGB
VOR OR TACAN RWY 30.
CA
CASTLE
MER
VOR/DME RWY 31.
CA
MODESTO CITY-CO-HARRY SHAM FLD
MOD
VOR/DME RWY 28R.
CA
OXNARD
OXR
VOR RWY 25.
CA
SACRAMENTO EXECUTIVE
SAC
VOR RWY 02.
CA
WATSONVILLE MUNI
WVI
VOR/DME-A.
CO
DURANGO-LA PLATA COUNTY
DRO
VOR/DME RWY 03.
CO
MONTROSE RGNL
MTJ
VOR/DME RWY 13.
CO
TELLURIDE RGNL
TEX
VOR/DME-A.
CT
DANBURY MUNI
DXR
VOR OR GPS-A.
CT
HARTFORD-BRAINARD
HFD
VOR-A.
CT
TWEED-NEW HAVEN
HVN
VOR RWY 02.
FL
NORTH PALM BEACH COUNTY GENERAL AVIATION
F45
VOR RWY 08R.
GA
WAYCROSS-WARE COUNTY
AYS
VOR-A.
GA
BRUNSWICK GOLDEN ISLES
BQK
VOR/DME-B.
GA
ATLANTA RGNL FALCON FIELD
FFC
NDB RWY 31.
GA
LEE GILMER MEMORIAL
GVL
NDB RWY 05.
GA
PERRY-HOUSTON COUNTY
PXE
VOR-A.
GA
EAST GEORGIA RGNL
SBO
NDB RWY 14.
GA
HENRY TIFT MYERS
TMA
VOR RWY 28.
IA
AMES MUNI
AMW
VOR RWY 31.
IA
COUNCIL BLUFFS MUNI
CBF
VOR-A.
IA
KEOKUK MUNI
EOK
NDB RWY 14.
IA
KEOKUK MUNI
EOK
NDB RWY 26.
IA
SHENANDOAH MUNI
SDA
VOR/DME RWY 12.
ID
JOSLIN FIELD-MAGIC VALLEY RGNL
TWF
VOR RWY 26.
IL
AURORA MUNI
ARR
VOR RWY 36.
IL
ALBERTUS
FEP
VOR RWY 24.
IL
LANSING MUNI
IGQ
VOR-A.
IL
GREATER KANKAKEE
IKK
VOR RWY 22.
IL
CHICAGO EXECUTIVE
PWK
VOR RWY 16.
IN
ANDERSON MUNI-DARLINGTON FIELD
AID
VOR-A.
IN
PUTNAM COUNTY
4I7
VOR/DME-A.
IN
KENTLAND MUNI
50I
VOR/DME RNAV OR GPS RWY 27.
IN
ANDERSON MUNI-DARLINGTON FIELD
AID
NDB RWY 30.
IN
WARSAW MUNI
ASW
VOR RWY 9.
IN
METTEL FIELD
CEV
VOR-A.
IN
DE KALB COUNTY
GWB
VOR OR GPS-A.
IN
CLARK RGNL
JVY
NDB RWY 18.
IN
PURDUE UNIVERSITY
LAF
VOR-A.
IN
LA PORTE MUNI
PPO
VOR-A.
KS
COLONEL JAMES JABARA
AAO
VOR-A.
KS
GREAT BEND MUNI
GBD
NDB RWY 35.
KS
RENNER FLD/GOODLAND MUNI/
GLD
VOR RWY 30.
KS
INDEPENDENCE MUNI
IDP
VOR-A.
KS
LAWRENCE MUNI
LWC
VOR/DME-A.
KY
TAYLOR COUNTY
AAS
VOR/DME-A.
LA
GEORGE R CARR MEMORIAL AIR FLD
BXA
VOR/DME-A.
LA
FALSE RIVER RGNL
HZR
NDB RWY 36.
MA
BEVERLY MUNI
BVY
VOR RWY 16.
MD
HAGERSTOWN RGNL-RICHARD A. HENSEN FIELD
HGR
VOR RWY 09.
MD
OCEAN CITY MUNI
OXB
VOR-A.
MI
HOUGHTON COUNTY MEMORIAL
CMX
VOR RWY 25.
MI
COLEMAN A YOUNG MUNI
DET
NDB RWY 15.
MI
COLEMAN A YOUNG MUNI
DET
VOR RWY 33.
MI
DELTA COUNTY
ESC
VOR RWY 36.
MI
GERALD R FORD INTL
GRR
VOR RWY 17.
MI
FORD
IMT
VOR RWY 31.
MI
KALAMAZOO/BATTLE CREEK INTL
AZO
VOR RWY 35.
MI
WEST MICHIGAN RGNL, formerly TULIP CITY
BIV
VOR-A.
MI
W K KELLOGG
BTL
NDB RWY 23R.
( printed page 69581)
MI
SAGINAW COUNTY H.W. BROWNE
HYX
VOR/DME-A.
MI
MENOMINEE-MARINETTE TWIN COUNTY
MNM
VOR-A.
MI
ST CLAIR COUNTY INTL
PHN
NDB RWY 04.
MI
PELLSTON RGNL AIRPORT OF EMMET COUNTY
PLN
VOR RWY 23.
MN
FALLS INTL
INL
VOR RWY 13.
MN
THIEF RIVER FALLS RGNL
TVF
VOR RWY 13.
MN
THIEF RIVER FALLS RGNL
TVF
VOR RWY 31.
MN
CHANDLER FIELD
AXN
VOR RWY 22.
MN
GRAND RAPIDS/ITASCA CO-GORDON NEWSTROM FLD
GPZ
VOR RWY 34.
MN
WARROAD INTL MEMORIAL
RRT
NDB RWY 31.
MN
SOUTH ST PAUL MUNI-RICHARD E. FLEMING FIELD
SGS
NDB-B.
MO
FARMINGTON RGNL
FAM
VOR/DME-A.
MO
KIRKSVILLE RGNL
IRK
VOR-A.
MO
MEXICO MEMORIAL
MYJ
VOR/DME RWY 24.
MS
GRENADA MUNI
GNF
NDB RWY 13.
MS
JOHN BELL WILLIAMS
JVW
NDB RWY 12.
NC
JOHNSTON COUNTY
JNX
NDB RWY 03.
NC
CLINTON-SAMPSON COUNTY
CTZ
VOR/DME-A.
NC
WAYNE EXECUTIVE JETPORT
GWW
VOR-A.
NC
HICKORY RGNL
HKY
VOR/DME RWY 24.
NC
HENDERSON-OXFORD
HNZ
NDB RWY 6.
NC
TRIANGLE NORTH EXECUTIVE
LHZ
VOR/DME-A.
NC
ALBERT J. ELLIS
OAJ
NDB RWY 5.
NC
WARREN FIELD
OCW
VOR/DME RWY 05.
ND
DEVILS LAKE RGNL
DVL
VOR RWY 31.
ND
HECTOR INTL
FAR
VOR OR TACAN RWY 36.
ND
GRAND FORKS INTL
GFK
VOR RWY 35L.
ND
JAMESTOWN RGNL
JMS
VOR RWY 31.
ND
MINOT INTL
MOT
VOR RWY 13.
ND
MINOT INTL
MOT
VOR RWY 31.
NE
BREWSTER FIELD
HDE
VOR/DME-A.
NH
SKYHAVEN
DAW
VOR/DME-A.
NH
DILLANT-HOPKINS
EEN
VOR RWY 02.
NH
LACONIA MUNI
LCI
NDB RWY 8.
NH
LEBANON MUNI
LEB
VOR RWY 25.
NJ
TETERBORO
TEB
VOR RWY 24.
NJ
CAPE MAY COUNTY
WWD
VOR-A.
NM
TUCUMCARI MUNI
TCC
VOR RWY 21.
NM
CAVERN CITY AIR TRML
CNM
VOR RWY 32L.
NM
GRANT COUNTY
SVC
VOR-A.
NV
RENO/TAHOE INTL
RNO
VOR-D.
NY
WATERTOWN INTL
ART
VOR RWY 07.
NY
REPUBLIC
FRG
NDB RWY 1.
NY
GENESEE COUNTY
GVQ
VOR/DME-A.
NY
BROOKHAVEN
HWV
VOR RWY 06.
NY
CHAUTAUQUA COUNTY/JAMESTOWN
JHW
VOR RWY 25.
OH
ASHLAND COUNTY
3G4
VOR-A.
OH
BELLEFONTAINE RGNL
EDJ
VOR/DME RWY 25.
OH
FAIRFIELD COUNTY
LHQ
VOR OR GPS-A.
OH
LORAIN COUNTY RGNL
LPR
VOR-A.
OH
MARION MUNI
MNN
VOR-A.
OH
OHIO STATE UNIVERSITY
OSU
NDB RWY 09R.
OH
BOLTON FIELD
TZR
NDB RWY 4.
OH
OHIO UNIVERSITY SNYDER FIELD
UNI
NDB RWY 25.
OH
NEWARK-HEATH
VTA
VOR-A.
OK
SUNDANCE AIRPARK
HSD
VOR RWY 17.
PA
SOMERSET COUNTY
2G9
NDB RWY 25.
PA
LANCASTER
LNS
VOR/DME RWY 08.
SC
GREENVILLE DOWNTOWN
GMU
NDB RWY 1.
SC
AIKEN MUNI
AIK
NDB RWY 25.
SC
ANDERSON RGNL
AND
VOR RWY 05.
SC
MARION COUNTY
MAO
VOR/DME-A.
SC
SUMTER MUNI
SMS
NDB RWY 23.
SD
ABERDEEN RGNL
ABR
VOR RWY 31.
SD
HURON RGNL
HON
VOR RWY 12.
TN
KNOXVILLE DOWNTOWN ISLAND
DKX
VOR/DME-B.
TN
MOORE-MURRELL
MOR
NDB RWY 5.
TN
UPPER CUMBERLAND RGNL
SRB
NDB RWY 04.
TN
TULLAHOMA RGNL/WM NORTHERN FIELD
THA
NDB RWY 18.
TX
DALHART MUNI
DHT
VOR RWY 17.
TX
BAY CITY MUNI
BYY
VOR/DME-A.
TX
C DAVID CAMPBELL FIELD-CORSICANA MUNI
CRS
VOR/DME-A.
TX
DEL RIO INTL
DRT
VOR-A.
( printed page 69582)
TX
DENTON MUNI
DTO
NDB RWY 18.
TX
ARLINGTON MUNI
GKY
VOR/DME RWY 34.
TX
SCHOLES INTL AT GALVESTON
GLS
VOR RWY 14.
TX
SAN MARCOS MUNI
HYI
NDB RWY 13.
TX
SKYLARK FIELD
ILE
VOR-A.
TX
PALESTINE MUNI
PSN
VOR/DME RWY 18.
TX
RUSK COUNTY
RFI
VOR/DME-A.
TX
SUGAR LAND RGNL
SGR
VOR/DME-A.
TX
SHEPPARD AFB/WICHITA FALLS MUNI
SPS
NDB RWY 33L.
TX
SHEPPARD AFB/WICHITA FALLS MUNI
SPS
VOR-D.
TX
COLLIN COUNTY RGNL AT MC KINNEY
TKI
VOR/DME-A.
TX
HUNTSVILLE MUNI
UTS
VOR/DME-A.
UT
DELTA MUNI
DTA
VOR RWY 35.
UT
CARBON COUNTY RGNL/BUCK DAVIS FIELD
PUC
VOR/DME RWY 01.
VA
VIRGINIA TECH/MONTGOMERY EXECUTIVE
BCB
NDB-A.
VA
ACCOMACK COUNTY
MFV
VOR/DME RWY 03.
VA
HANOVER COUNTY MUNI
OFP
VOR RWY 16.
VA
STAFFORD RGNL
RMN
VOR RWY 33.
VA
SHENANDOAH VALLEY RGNL
SHD
NDB RWY 05.
VI
CYRIL E KING
STT
VOR-A.
VT
EDWARD F KNAPP STATE
MPV
VOR RWY 35.
WA
SPOKANE INTL
GEG
VOR RWY 03.
WA
ARLINGTON MUNI
AWO
NDB RWY 34.
WA
RICHLAND
RLD
VOR/DME-A.
WA
FELTS FIELD
SFF
VOR RWY 04L.
WI
LAKELAND/NOBLE F. LEE MEM. FIELD
ARV
NDB RWY 28.
WI
BARABOO WISCONSIN DELLS
DLL
VOR-A.
WI
EAGLE RIVER UNION
EGV
VOR/DME RWY 04.
WI
TRI-COUNTY RGNL
LNR
VOR-A.
WI
JOHN H BATTEN
RAC
VOR RWY 04.
WI
SHEBOYGAN COUNTY MEMORIAL
SBM
VOR RWY 22.
WI
WAUKESHA COUNTY
UES
VOR-A.
WV
ONA AIRPARK
12V
VOR-A.
WV
FAIRMONT MUNI-FRANKMAN FIELD
4G7
VOR/DME-A.
Lastly, the FAA received comments on 198 SIAPs that are still under review. Once the agency has made a determination on those procedures, and if warranted, the FAA will issue a final rule cancelling any subject procedures. For the remaining 335 SIAPs proposed in the NPRM upon which no comments were received, the FAA has decided to proceed with cancellation of those procedures.
The Amendment
SIAPs and associated supporting data adopted or removed by the FAA are documented on FAA Forms 8260-3, 8260-4, and 8260-5, which are incorporated by reference under 5 U.S.C. 552(a), 1 CFR part 51, and 14 CFR part 97. The following procedures did not receive any comments and the FAA has determined that they should be removed consistent with FAA policy on maintaining instrument approach procedures in the NAS. Additionally, the list can be viewed on the Aeronautical Information Services IFP Announcements and Reports Web page at the following link,
https://www.faa.gov/air_traffic/flight_info/aeronav/procedures/reports/.
Conclusion
The FAA has determined that this final rule only involves an established body of technical regulations for which frequent and routine amendments are necessary to keep them operationally current. It, therefore—(1) is not a “significant regulatory action” under Executive Order 12866; (2) is not a “significant rule” under DOT Regulatory Policies and Procedures (44 FR 11034; February 26, 1979) and (3) does not warrant preparation of a regulatory evaluation as the anticipated impact is so minimal. For the same reason, the FAA certifies that this amendment will not have a significant economic impact on a substantial number of small entities under the criteria of the Regulatory Flexibility Act.
Additional Information
A. Availability of Rulemaking Documents
An electronic copy of rulemaking documents may be obtained from the Internet by—
Copies may also be obtained by sending a request to the Federal Aviation Administration, Office of Rulemaking, ARM-1, 800 Independence Avenue SW., Washington, DC 20591, or by calling (202) 267-9677. Persons requesting additional information must identify the docket or amendment number of this rulemaking.
All documents the FAA considered in developing this rule, including technical reports, may be accessed from the Internet through the Federal eRulemaking Portal referenced in item (1) above.
B. Comments Submitted to the Docket
Comments received may be viewed by going to
http://www.regulations.gov
and following the online instructions to search the docket number for this action. Anyone is able to search the electronic form of all comments received into any of the FAA's dockets by the name of the individual submitting the comment (or signing the comment, if submitted on behalf of an association, business, labor union, etc.).
( printed page 69583)
C. Small Business Regulatory Enforcement Fairness Act
The Small Business Regulatory Enforcement Fairness Act (SBREFA) of 1996 requires FAA to comply with small entity requests for information or advice about compliance with statutes and regulations within its jurisdiction. A small entity with questions regarding this document, may contact its local FAA official, or the person listed under the
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT
heading at the beginning of the preamble. To find out more about SBREFA on the Internet, visit
http://www.faa.gov/regulations_policies/rulemaking/sbre_act/.
Accordingly, pursuant to the authority delegated to me, Title 14, Code of Federal Regulations, Part 97 (14 CFR part 97) is amended by removing Standard Instrument Approach Procedures and/or Takeoff Minimums and Obstacle Departure Procedures effective at 0901 UTC on the dates specified, as follows:
PART 97—STANDARD INSTRUMENT APPROACH PROCEDURES
1. The authority citation for part 97 is revised to read as follows: