80_FR_39863 80 FR 39731 - Magnuson-Stevens Fishery Conservation and Management Act Provisions; Fisheries of the Northeastern United States; Northeast Groundfish Fishery; Denial of Petition for Rulemaking for Gulf of Maine Cod

80 FR 39731 - Magnuson-Stevens Fishery Conservation and Management Act Provisions; Fisheries of the Northeastern United States; Northeast Groundfish Fishery; Denial of Petition for Rulemaking for Gulf of Maine Cod

DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration

Federal Register Volume 80, Issue 132 (July 10, 2015)

Page Range39731-39734
FR Document2015-16891

In response to the most recent stock assessment for Gulf of Maine cod, which indicated that the stock is at historically low abundance levels, a group of environmental organizations have requested that NMFS initiate rulemaking to make the following changes: prohibit commercial and recreational fishing for Gulf of Maine cod until the incidental fishing mortality does not exceed the acceptable biological catch limit; and limit catch, including discards, to the level that achieves the fishing mortality that meets rebuilding requirements, in accordance with Amendment 16 to the Northeast Multispecies Fishery Management Plan. After reviewing the petition and considering recent management measures we have implemented to prevent overfishing of Gulf of Maine cod and promote Gulf of Maine cod rebuilding efforts, we are denying the Petition for Rulemaking request.

Federal Register, Volume 80 Issue 132 (Friday, July 10, 2015)
[Federal Register Volume 80, Number 132 (Friday, July 10, 2015)]
[Proposed Rules]
[Pages 39731-39734]
From the Federal Register Online  [www.thefederalregister.org]
[FR Doc No: 2015-16891]


-----------------------------------------------------------------------

DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE

National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration

50 CFR Part 648

RIN 0648-XE008


Magnuson-Stevens Fishery Conservation and Management Act 
Provisions; Fisheries of the Northeastern United States; Northeast 
Groundfish Fishery; Denial of Petition for Rulemaking for Gulf of Maine 
Cod

AGENCY: National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS), National Oceanic and 
Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), Commerce.

ACTION: Notice of agency decision.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: In response to the most recent stock assessment for Gulf of 
Maine cod, which indicated that the stock is at historically low 
abundance levels, a group of environmental organizations have requested 
that NMFS initiate rulemaking to make the following changes: prohibit 
commercial and recreational fishing for Gulf of Maine cod until the 
incidental fishing mortality does not exceed the acceptable biological 
catch limit; and limit catch, including discards, to the level that 
achieves the fishing mortality that meets rebuilding requirements, in 
accordance with Amendment 16 to the Northeast Multispecies Fishery 
Management Plan. After reviewing the petition and considering recent 
management measures we have implemented to prevent overfishing of Gulf 
of Maine cod and promote Gulf of Maine cod rebuilding efforts, we are 
denying the Petition for Rulemaking request.

DATES: The petition for rulemaking was denied on June 4, 2015.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: William Whitmore, Fishery Policy 
Analyst, phone: 978-281-9182; email: [email protected].

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: A group of environmental organizations, 
including The Center for Biological Diversity, Greenpeace, SandyHook 
Life Foundation, and The Turtle Island Restoration Network, have 
requested that NMFS initiate rulemaking under the Administrative 
Procedure Act. The petitioners request that, because the most recent 
stock assessment for Gulf of Maine (GOM) cod indicates that the stock 
is at historically low abundance levels, NMFS initiate rulemaking to 
make the following changes: (1) Prohibit commercial and recreational 
fishing for GOM cod until the incidental fishing mortality does not 
exceed the acceptable biological catch (ABC) limit; and (2) limit 
catch, including discards, to the level that achieves the fishing 
mortality that meets rebuilding requirements (Frebuild), in 
accordance with Amendment 16 to the Northeast Multispecies Fishery 
Management Plan (FMP).
    We are denying the Petition for Rulemaking. The measures in 
Framework Adjustment 53 to the FMP (80 FR 25110; May 1, 2015), combined 
with other conservation and management measures we implemented for the 
recreational fishery (80 FR 25160; May 1, 2015), are expected to 
prevent catch from exceeding the ABC, prevent overfishing, and rebuild 
the GOM cod stock within the rebuilding period. Further, we intend to 
carefully monitor updated stock assessment information, which will be 
available later this year, and will adjust measures, if necessary, to 
address any changes to stock condition. We carefully considered the 
available information and determined that all of the management 
measures implemented in the Framework 53 final rule, along with 
corresponding recreational measures, and our continued close monitoring 
of the stock's condition, will provide sufficient protection for GOM 
cod to prevent overfishing and contribute to rebuilding consistent with 
the requirements of the Magnuson-Stevens Fishery Conservation and 
Management Act. These measures balance Magnuson-Stevens Act objectives, 
including achieving optimum yield and taking into account the needs of 
fishing communities, without compromising conservation objectives to 
prevent overfishing and rebuild the stock. In effect, therefore, 
Framework 53, combined with the other recreational measures, achieves 
exactly what the petition for rulemaking seeks. Moreover, Framework 53 
was developed and implemented through the preferred Regional Fishery 
Management Council process as intended by the Magnuson-Stevens Act. 
Accordingly, as described in more detail below, neither a Secretarial 
amendment nor an emergency action is necessary or warranted to further 
limit GOM cod mortality at this time.

Background

Petition Request

    In August 2014, the Northeast Fisheries Science Center updated the 
2012 benchmark GOM cod stock assessment. The assessment found that the 
GOM cod stock is overfished, subject to overfishing, and that the 
condition of the stock had declined

[[Page 39732]]

further from the 2012 assessment that was used as a basis for the 
revised rebuilding plan established in Framework 51. The 2014 
assessment showed historically low abundance and estimated that GOM cod 
was at only 3 percent of its rebuilding target. In response, on 
November 13, 2014, we issued interim measures (79 FR 67362) to limit 
cod mortality for the duration of the 2014 fishing year (which ended on 
April 30, 2015).
    We received a petition for rulemaking on March 3, 2015, largely in 
response to the results of the most recent GOM cod stock assessment, 
the interim measures to reduce GOM cod mortality, and the Council's 
recommended measures for long-term GOM cod protection in Framework 53. 
The petitioners requested that NMFS initiate rulemaking to limit GOM 
fishing mortality consistent with the specifications of the default ABC 
control rule implemented in Amendment 16. In support of their request, 
the petitioners contend that historic overfishing and mismanagement of 
the GOM cod stock have led to declines in landings and stock abundance, 
and resulted in changes to the stock's age structure (i.e., reduced the 
number of big, old, fat, fertile female fish), spawning locations, 
migratory behavior, and prey. They assert that because past GOM cod 
assessments have consistently overestimated cod spawning stock biomass 
and underestimated fishing mortality, managers should consider larger 
uncertainty buffers.
    The petitioners claim that the ongoing management regime for GOM 
cod has not successfully ended overfishing or promoted rebuilding of 
the GOM cod stock, and that the management measures proposed in 
Framework 53 will not support rebuilding by the end of the revised 
rebuilding plan deadline in 2024. Specifically, they claimed:
     The 2004 GOM cod rebuilding plan failed because the 
Council set catch limits to maximize fishing opportunity rather than 
promote stock conservation, and because the Council prolonged 
overfishing by choosing the maximum rebuilding timeline possible.
     The 2014 GOM cod interim measures did not temporarily 
address overfishing or allow for stock rebuilding, and were only 
projected to result in a 33-percent reduction in fishing mortality in 
spite of advice from the Council's Scientific and Statistical Committee 
(SSC) that a 75-percent reduction in fishing limits was necessary.
     The 386-mt GOM cod ABC recommended by the Council in 
Framework 53 is above the legal limit (i.e., 200 mt, the level of catch 
necessary to achieve a fishing mortality equal to Frebuild), 
and is unlikely to allow the stock to rebuild by 2024.
    To remedy the situation, the petitioners request that we prohibit 
commercial and recreational fishing for GOM cod until incidental 
fishing mortality does not exceed the ABC, and limit catch, including 
discards, to the level that achieves a fishing mortality rate that 
meets rebuilding requirements (Frebuild). In addition, the 
petitioners suggest that because proper accounting for dead discards 
may be one reason that cod failed to rebuild from 2004-2014, NMFS 
should increase observer coverage for the commercial fleet to 100 
percent to ensure that mortality of GOM cod is monitored and counted 
toward catch limits.

Framework 53

    While we were developing the GOM cod interim measures, the New 
England Fishery Management Council developed measures to end 
overfishing in the 2015 fishing year (beginning May 1, 2015) and for 
long-term measures to rebuild the GOM cod stock, consistent with the 
revised rebuilding program, as part of Framework 53. Framework 53, 
which was implemented May 1, 2015, includes a 75-percent reduction to 
the GOM cod catch limit compared to 2014, a prohibition on recreational 
possession of GOM cod, and seasonal area closures intended to protect 
spawning and reduce fishing mortality on GOM cod.
    Framework 53 also includes measures consistent with the goals of a 
revised 10-year rebuilding plan for GOM cod that was established in 
Framework 51 (79 FR 22421; April 22, 2014). The 10-year rebuilding 
program is intended to account for past performance of groundfish 
rebuilding programs and uncertainties in long-term catch projections by 
setting conservative catch levels in the early years of the program. 
This timeframe also provides flexibility to better address the needs of 
fishing communities compared to rebuilding programs that target an 
earlier end date.

Basis for Denial

    Section 304 of the Magnuson-Stevens Act provides the Secretary of 
Commerce with the authority to prepare and implement a fishery 
management plan if the Council fails to develop and submit a plan or 
amendment after a reasonable period of time that meets necessary 
conservation and management objectives. Or, the agency may put in place 
emergency regulations or interim measures to address an emergency or 
overfishing. An emergency rulemaking allows actions to prevent 
overfishing or economic loss or to preserve economic opportunity when 
the emergency results from recent, unforeseen events or recently 
discovered circumstances. An interim rule allows for measures that 
reduce overfishing for a limited time. The benefits of using the 
abbreviated rulemaking procedures associated with emergency rulemaking 
and interim measures must outweigh the value of advance notice, public 
comment, and deliberative consideration of the impacts on participants 
to the same extent as expected under the normal Council and full 
notice-and-comment rulemaking process.
    Rulemaking is not appropriate in this instance because it would 
unnecessarily replace the measures established in Framework 53 and the 
recreational measures put in place through the Council process. These 
measures achieve what the petition for rulemaking seeks. These measures 
balance Magnuson-Stevens Act objectives, including achieving optimum 
yield and taking into account the needs of fishing communities, without 
compromising conservation objectives to prevent overfishing and rebuild 
the stock. Therefore, neither a Secretarial amendment nor an emergency 
action is necessary or warranted at this time to further limit GOM cod 
mortality.

2004 Rebuilding Plan

    We do not agree with the petitioner's statements that the Council-
recommended catch levels for GOM cod during the 2004 rebuilding program 
were intended to maximize economic gain at the expense of the health of 
the stock. A 2008 stock assessment reviewed progress under the plan and 
concluded that the stock was not overfished but overfishing was 
occurring, and, based in part on a strong 2005 year class, the stock 
was expected to rebuild by 2014.
    We notified the Council about the lack of progress under the 2004 
rebuilding plan following the 2012 GOM cod benchmark assessment. We 
determined that inadequate progress under the 2004 rebuilding plan was 
due to a revised understanding of the condition of the stock since the 
2008 GOM cod assessment. In response to the new understanding of the 
status of the GOM cod stock, we worked with the Council to implement 
measures to reduce overfishing and revise the rebuilding plan as 
swiftly as possible though a 2012 interim action, and Frameworks 50 and 
51. These actions incorporated new information and lessons from past 
management approaches. Our review of the Council's

[[Page 39733]]

revised 2014 GOM cod rebuilding plan adopted in Framework 51 indicated 
that the Council addressed past rebuilding performance and accelerated 
the rebuilding timeline by setting more conservative catch limits in 
the early portion of the rebuilding program.

2014 Interim Action

    We reject the petitioners claim that the 2014 interim action 
insufficiently addressed the information provided in the updated 
assessment. One of our primary objectives of the interim action was to 
reduce overfishing by reducing GOM cod commercial and recreational 
catch. Given the mixed nature of the groundfish fishery and its 
interaction with other fisheries, this objective was analyzed in the 
context of not closing down the entire GOM, but to allow some 
harvesting of other groundfish stocks. We wanted to reduce GOM cod 
mortality while the Council developed more permanent measures in 
Framework 53. We determined it was unnecessary to try to prevent all 
fishing mortality for the remainder of the 2014 fishing year as the 
stock can rebuild even if subject to overfishing in 2014 as long as 
measures would be in place to prevent overfishing beginning in 2015. 
Achieving zero fishing mortality would have required closing all GOM 
fisheries, including those that do not target groundfish. The impacts 
of such measures would be substantial and impracticable. Such a closure 
was unwarranted to ensure effective cod conservation.

Framework 53 GOM Cod ABC

    Most recently, we considered public comment on and supporting 
analysis for Framework 53 and the 2015 recreational measures, and the 
best scientific information available in making the determination that 
an ABC of 386 mt was appropriate and consistent with the requirements 
of the Magnuson-Stevens Act and its National Standards. In light of 
current stock conditions, the 386 mt ABC is a 75-percent catch limit 
reduction compared to 2014, which is in addition to the 80-percent 
reduction implemented for the 2013-2014 fishing years. In total, the 
GOM cod catch limit has been reduced by 95 percent over the last 5 
years. Further, new recreational measures prohibit recreational 
fishermen from retaining any GOM cod. This is the first zero-retention 
prohibition on GOM cod for recreational fishermen. Detailed information 
that addresses the petitioners concerns about the GOM cod ABC and 
further justifies our decision to approve an ABC of 386 mt can be found 
in the Framework 53 final rule (see pages 25125-25127).
    We will continue to carefully consider management measures to 
promote timely rebuilding of the GOM cod stock. In an effort to closely 
monitor stock indicators, we reviewed the recent fall 2014 NEFSC bottom 
trawl survey indices. The fall survey indicated a small increase 
compared to 2012 and 2013; however, the general trend of survey 
indices, as well as recruitment, remains very low. While the updated 
survey information may provide an initial, and potentially positive, 
indication of improvement, it is difficult to anticipate the results of 
the full 2015 assessment. In any event, we plan to make necessary 
adjustments for the 2016 fishing year based on the upcoming 2015 stock 
assessment.

Incidental Fishing Mortality

    The petitioners request prohibiting fishing mortality until 
incidental mortality does not exceed the ABC. An ABC of 386 mt is 
expected to have substantial adverse economic impacts on groundfish 
vessels, and is below the estimate of incidental catch of GOM cod that 
occurred in the 2013 fishing year. In the 2013 fishing year, when the 
ACL was reduced by 80 percent, incidental catch was estimated to be 
approximately 500-600 mt. Beginning in the 2013 fishing year, sectors 
primarily used their GOM cod allocation to access other groundfish 
stocks. Multiple sources of information indicate a marked decline in 
directed fishing for GOM cod. With an additional 75-percent reduction 
beginning in the 2015 fishing year, the incentive to target GOM cod is 
virtually eliminated, and the fishery will be, in effect, a ``bycatch-
only'' fishery. Incidental catch is largely a function of the overall 
ACLs on other stocks. At such a low GOM cod catch limit, fishery 
operations will be greatly restricted, and in some cases eliminated. In 
addition, the recreational fishery will be prohibited from possessing 
any GOM cod. Under this incidental catch scenario, the GOM cod ABC is 
expected to severely restrict catch of other groundfish stocks, 
particularly GOM haddock, pollock, redfish, and some flatfish. Based on 
this information, the 386-mt ABC balances Magnuson-Stevens Act 
requirements of conservation and achieving optimum yield.

Monitoring and Catch Accounting

    The petitioners raised a concern that inaccurate accounting for 
catch could undermine conservation objectives for GOM cod. We share 
their concern, and available analyses suggest that an extremely low 
catch limit for GOM cod may create an economic incentive to misreport 
catch. If misreporting occurs, it could reduce the accuracy of catch 
apportionment. Information indicates that this incentive increases as 
the GOM cod catch limit is further reduced. To help ensure correct 
catch apportionment and compliance with the GOM cod ACL adopted in 
Framework 53, we also implemented an additional daily reporting 
requirement for common pool and sector vessels fishing in multiple 
broad stock areas on the same trip. This requirement is intended to 
help ensure accurate catch attribution and reduce the incentive for 
vessels to misreport.
    We do not share the petitioners' view that 100-percent observer 
coverage is necessary to monitor GOM cod fishing mortality. Rather, we 
apply at-sea monitoring coverage levels that we determine are necessary 
to monitor and enforce catch levels, or increase buffers to account for 
uncertainty in catch as part of the biennial quota-setting process. We 
have received similar comments on prior groundfish rulemakings 
requesting high levels of observer coverage for the commercial fishery 
since the implementation of Amendment 16. For the most part, commenters 
have generally asserted that the levels of monitoring we have 
implemented are inadequate without providing any specific justification 
or information to support their assertion.
    For sector trips, we have determined that 24-percent observer 
coverage is sufficient this fishing year, to the extent practicable in 
light of Magnuson-Stevens Act requirements, to reliably estimate catch 
for purposes of monitoring ACLs for groundfish stocks. This level of 
coverage is achieved through a combination of groundfish at-sea 
monitoring coverage and observer coverage furnished by the Northeast 
Fisheries Observer Program. Amendment 16 specified that at-sea 
monitoring coverage levels should be less than 100 percent, which 
requires estimations of the discard portion of catch and thus total 
catch. Amendment 16 also specified that the at-sea monitoring coverage 
levels should achieve a 30-percent coefficient of variation (CV). The 
level of observer coverage, ultimately, should provide confidence that 
the overall catch estimate is sufficiently accurate to ensure that 
sector fishing activities are consistent with National Standard 1 
requirements to prevent overfishing while achieving optimum yield. To 
that end, significant additional uncertainty buffers are established 
when setting ACLs that mitigate any lack of absolute precision and 
accuracy in estimating overall catch by sector vessels. Collectively, 
the current level of sector

[[Page 39734]]

observer coverage is providing more data for quota management and 
assessment science than was available to NMFS prior to implementation 
of Amendment 16.
    On February 18, 2014, in Oceana, Inc. v. Pritzker, 1:13-cv-00770 
(D.D.C. 2014), the Court upheld our use of a 30-percent CV standard to 
set sector observer coverage levels. In addition to upholding our 
determination of sufficient coverage levels, the Court noted that the 
current sector observer coverage is not the sole method of monitoring 
compliance with ACLs, there are many reporting requirements that 
vessels adhere to, and there are strong incentives for vessels to 
report accurately because each sector is held jointly and severally 
liable for overages and misreporting of catch and bycatch.

Conclusion

    We remain concerned about the status of GOM cod, but have 
determined that the current FMP, as adjusted by Framework 53, along 
with recreational measures and planned future Council and agency 
actions, provide the appropriate regulatory mechanisms for addressing 
the concerns regarding this stock that were raised in the petition for 
rulemaking. We will continue to carefully monitor stock indicators 
leading into the 2015 assessment to fully inform our re-evaluation of 
the GOM cod catch limit, and the need to balance conservation and 
management objectives. Therefore, we are denying this petition; no 
other rulemaking is necessary in response to the petition for 
rulemaking.

    Authority: 16 U.S.C. 1801 et seq.

    Dated: July 6, 2015.
Samuel D. Rauch III,
Deputy Assistant Administrator for Regulatory Programs, National Marine 
Fisheries Service.
[FR Doc. 2015-16891 Filed 7-9-15; 8:45 am]
 BILLING CODE 3510-22-P



                                                                               Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 132 / Friday, July 10, 2015 / Proposed Rules                                          39731

                                                    addressed to 445 12th Street SW.,                        DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE                                biological catch (ABC) limit; and (2)
                                                    Washington, DC 20554.                                                                                          limit catch, including discards, to the
                                                      42. People with Disabilities: To                       National Oceanic and Atmospheric                      level that achieves the fishing mortality
                                                                                                             Administration                                        that meets rebuilding requirements
                                                    request materials in accessible formats
                                                    for people with disabilities (braille,                                                                         (Frebuild), in accordance with
                                                                                                             50 CFR Part 648                                       Amendment 16 to the Northeast
                                                    large print, electronic files, audio
                                                    format), send an email to                                RIN 0648–XE008                                        Multispecies Fishery Management Plan
                                                    mailto:fcc504@fcc.gov or call the                                                                              (FMP).
                                                                                                             Magnuson-Stevens Fishery                                 We are denying the Petition for
                                                    Consumer & Governmental Affairs
                                                                                                             Conservation and Management Act                       Rulemaking. The measures in
                                                    Bureau at 202–418–0530 (voice), 202–                                                                           Framework Adjustment 53 to the FMP
                                                    418–0432 (tty).                                          Provisions; Fisheries of the
                                                                                                             Northeastern United States; Northeast                 (80 FR 25110; May 1, 2015), combined
                                                      43. Availability of Documents.                         Groundfish Fishery; Denial of Petition                with other conservation and
                                                    Comments and reply comments will be                      for Rulemaking for Gulf of Maine Cod                  management measures we implemented
                                                    publically available online via ECFS.84                                                                        for the recreational fishery (80 FR
                                                    These documents will also be available                   AGENCY:  National Marine Fisheries                    25160; May 1, 2015), are expected to
                                                    for public inspection during regular                     Service (NMFS), National Oceanic and                  prevent catch from exceeding the ABC,
                                                    business hours in the FCC Reference                      Atmospheric Administration (NOAA),                    prevent overfishing, and rebuild the
                                                    Information Center, which is located in                  Commerce.                                             GOM cod stock within the rebuilding
                                                    Room CY–A257 at FCC Headquarters,                        ACTION: Notice of agency decision.                    period. Further, we intend to carefully
                                                    445 12th Street SW., Washington, DC                                                                            monitor updated stock assessment
                                                                                                             SUMMARY:   In response to the most recent             information, which will be available
                                                    20554. The Reference Information
                                                                                                             stock assessment for Gulf of Maine cod,               later this year, and will adjust measures,
                                                    Center is open to the public Monday
                                                                                                             which indicated that the stock is at                  if necessary, to address any changes to
                                                    through Thursday from 8:00 a.m. to 4:30
                                                                                                             historically low abundance levels, a                  stock condition. We carefully
                                                    p.m. and Friday from 8:00 a.m. to 11:30
                                                                                                             group of environmental organizations                  considered the available information
                                                    a.m.                                                     have requested that NMFS initiate                     and determined that all of the
                                                    E. Additional Information                                rulemaking to make the following                      management measures implemented in
                                                                                                             changes: prohibit commercial and                      the Framework 53 final rule, along with
                                                      44. For additional information on this                 recreational fishing for Gulf of Maine                corresponding recreational measures,
                                                    proceeding, contact Maria Mullarkey,                     cod until the incidental fishing                      and our continued close monitoring of
                                                    Maria.Mullarkey@fcc.gov, of the Media                    mortality does not exceed the acceptable              the stock’s condition, will provide
                                                    Bureau, Policy Division, (202) 418–                      biological catch limit; and limit catch,              sufficient protection for GOM cod to
                                                    2120.                                                    including discards, to the level that                 prevent overfishing and contribute to
                                                                                                             achieves the fishing mortality that meets             rebuilding consistent with the
                                                    IV. Ordering Clauses
                                                                                                             rebuilding requirements, in accordance                requirements of the Magnuson-Stevens
                                                       45. Accordingly, it is ordered that,                  with Amendment 16 to the Northeast                    Fishery Conservation and Management
                                                    pursuant to the Twenty-First Century                     Multispecies Fishery Management Plan.                 Act. These measures balance Magnuson-
                                                    Communications and Video                                 After reviewing the petition and                      Stevens Act objectives, including
                                                    Accessibility Act of 2010, Public Law                    considering recent management                         achieving optimum yield and taking
                                                    111–260, 124 Stat. 2751, and the                         measures we have implemented to                       into account the needs of fishing
                                                    authority found in Sections 4(i), 4(j),                  prevent overfishing of Gulf of Maine cod              communities, without compromising
                                                    303, 330(b), 713, and 716 of the                         and promote Gulf of Maine cod                         conservation objectives to prevent
                                                    Communications Act of 1934, as                           rebuilding efforts, we are denying the                overfishing and rebuild the stock. In
                                                    amended, 47 U.S.C. 154(i), 154(j), 303,                  Petition for Rulemaking request.                      effect, therefore, Framework 53,
                                                    330(b), 613, and 617, this Second                        DATES: The petition for rulemaking was                combined with the other recreational
                                                    Further Notice of Proposed Rulemaking                    denied on June 4, 2015.                               measures, achieves exactly what the
                                                    is adopted.                                              FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:                      petition for rulemaking seeks. Moreover,
                                                                                                             William Whitmore, Fishery Policy                      Framework 53 was developed and
                                                       46. It is further ordered that the
                                                                                                             Analyst, phone: 978–281–9182; email:                  implemented through the preferred
                                                    Commission’s Consumer and
                                                                                                             William.Whitmore@noaa.gov.                            Regional Fishery Management Council
                                                    Governmental Affairs Bureau, Reference
                                                    Information Center, shall send a copy of                 SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:      A group of            process as intended by the Magnuson-
                                                                                                             environmental organizations, including                Stevens Act. Accordingly, as described
                                                    this Second Further Notice of Proposed
                                                                                                             The Center for Biological Diversity,                  in more detail below, neither a
                                                    Rulemaking in MB Docket No. 12–107,
                                                                                                             Greenpeace, SandyHook Life                            Secretarial amendment nor an
                                                    including the Initial Regulatory
                                                                                                             Foundation, and The Turtle Island                     emergency action is necessary or
                                                    Flexibility Analysis, to the Chief
                                                                                                             Restoration Network, have requested                   warranted to further limit GOM cod
                                                    Counsel for Advocacy of the Small
                                                                                                             that NMFS initiate rulemaking under                   mortality at this time.
                                                    Business Administration.
                                                                                                             the Administrative Procedure Act. The                 Background
                                                    Federal Communications Commission.                       petitioners request that, because the
mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS




                                                    Marlene H. Dortch,                                       most recent stock assessment for Gulf of              Petition Request
                                                    Secretary.                                               Maine (GOM) cod indicates that the                      In August 2014, the Northeast
                                                    [FR Doc. 2015–16323 Filed 7–9–15; 8:45 am]               stock is at historically low abundance                Fisheries Science Center updated the
                                                    BILLING CODE 6712–01–P
                                                                                                             levels, NMFS initiate rulemaking to                   2012 benchmark GOM cod stock
                                                                                                             make the following changes: (1) Prohibit              assessment. The assessment found that
                                                      84 Documents will generally be available               commercial and recreational fishing for               the GOM cod stock is overfished,
                                                    electronically in ASCII, Microsoft Word, and/or          GOM cod until the incidental fishing                  subject to overfishing, and that the
                                                    Adobe Acrobat.                                           mortality does not exceed the acceptable              condition of the stock had declined


                                               VerDate Sep<11>2014   17:25 Jul 09, 2015   Jkt 235001   PO 00000   Frm 00013   Fmt 4702   Sfmt 4702   E:\FR\FM\10JYP1.SGM   10JYP1


                                                    39732                      Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 132 / Friday, July 10, 2015 / Proposed Rules

                                                    further from the 2012 assessment that                    (i.e., 200 mt, the level of catch necessary           economic loss or to preserve economic
                                                    was used as a basis for the revised                      to achieve a fishing mortality equal to               opportunity when the emergency results
                                                    rebuilding plan established in                           Frebuild), and is unlikely to allow the               from recent, unforeseen events or
                                                    Framework 51. The 2014 assessment                        stock to rebuild by 2024.                             recently discovered circumstances. An
                                                    showed historically low abundance and                       To remedy the situation, the                       interim rule allows for measures that
                                                    estimated that GOM cod was at only 3                     petitioners request that we prohibit                  reduce overfishing for a limited time.
                                                    percent of its rebuilding target. In                     commercial and recreational fishing for               The benefits of using the abbreviated
                                                    response, on November 13, 2014, we                       GOM cod until incidental fishing                      rulemaking procedures associated with
                                                    issued interim measures (79 FR 67362)                    mortality does not exceed the ABC, and                emergency rulemaking and interim
                                                    to limit cod mortality for the duration of               limit catch, including discards, to the               measures must outweigh the value of
                                                    the 2014 fishing year (which ended on                    level that achieves a fishing mortality               advance notice, public comment, and
                                                    April 30, 2015).                                         rate that meets rebuilding requirements               deliberative consideration of the
                                                       We received a petition for rulemaking                 (Frebuild). In addition, the petitioners              impacts on participants to the same
                                                    on March 3, 2015, largely in response to                 suggest that because proper accounting                extent as expected under the normal
                                                    the results of the most recent GOM cod                   for dead discards may be one reason                   Council and full notice-and-comment
                                                    stock assessment, the interim measures                   that cod failed to rebuild from 2004–                 rulemaking process.
                                                    to reduce GOM cod mortality, and the                     2014, NMFS should increase observer                      Rulemaking is not appropriate in this
                                                    Council’s recommended measures for                       coverage for the commercial fleet to 100              instance because it would unnecessarily
                                                    long-term GOM cod protection in                          percent to ensure that mortality of GOM               replace the measures established in
                                                    Framework 53. The petitioners                            cod is monitored and counted toward                   Framework 53 and the recreational
                                                    requested that NMFS initiate                             catch limits.                                         measures put in place through the
                                                    rulemaking to limit GOM fishing                                                                                Council process. These measures
                                                                                                             Framework 53
                                                    mortality consistent with the                                                                                  achieve what the petition for
                                                    specifications of the default ABC control                   While we were developing the GOM                   rulemaking seeks. These measures
                                                    rule implemented in Amendment 16. In                     cod interim measures, the New England                 balance Magnuson-Stevens Act
                                                    support of their request, the petitioners                Fishery Management Council developed                  objectives, including achieving
                                                    contend that historic overfishing and                    measures to end overfishing in the 2015               optimum yield and taking into account
                                                    mismanagement of the GOM cod stock                       fishing year (beginning May 1, 2015)                  the needs of fishing communities,
                                                    have led to declines in landings and                     and for long-term measures to rebuild                 without compromising conservation
                                                    stock abundance, and resulted in                         the GOM cod stock, consistent with the                objectives to prevent overfishing and
                                                    changes to the stock’s age structure (i.e.,              revised rebuilding program, as part of                rebuild the stock. Therefore, neither a
                                                    reduced the number of big, old, fat,                     Framework 53. Framework 53, which                     Secretarial amendment nor an
                                                    fertile female fish), spawning locations,                was implemented May 1, 2015, includes                 emergency action is necessary or
                                                    migratory behavior, and prey. They                       a 75-percent reduction to the GOM cod                 warranted at this time to further limit
                                                    assert that because past GOM cod                         catch limit compared to 2014, a                       GOM cod mortality.
                                                    assessments have consistently                            prohibition on recreational possession
                                                                                                             of GOM cod, and seasonal area closures                2004 Rebuilding Plan
                                                    overestimated cod spawning stock
                                                    biomass and underestimated fishing                       intended to protect spawning and                        We do not agree with the petitioner’s
                                                    mortality, managers should consider                      reduce fishing mortality on GOM cod.                  statements that the Council-
                                                    larger uncertainty buffers.                                 Framework 53 also includes measures                recommended catch levels for GOM cod
                                                       The petitioners claim that the ongoing                consistent with the goals of a revised 10-            during the 2004 rebuilding program
                                                    management regime for GOM cod has                        year rebuilding plan for GOM cod that                 were intended to maximize economic
                                                    not successfully ended overfishing or                    was established in Framework 51 (79 FR                gain at the expense of the health of the
                                                    promoted rebuilding of the GOM cod                       22421; April 22, 2014). The 10-year                   stock. A 2008 stock assessment
                                                    stock, and that the management                           rebuilding program is intended to                     reviewed progress under the plan and
                                                    measures proposed in Framework 53                        account for past performance of                       concluded that the stock was not
                                                    will not support rebuilding by the end                   groundfish rebuilding programs and                    overfished but overfishing was
                                                    of the revised rebuilding plan deadline                  uncertainties in long-term catch                      occurring, and, based in part on a strong
                                                    in 2024. Specifically, they claimed:                     projections by setting conservative catch             2005 year class, the stock was expected
                                                       • The 2004 GOM cod rebuilding plan                    levels in the early years of the program.             to rebuild by 2014.
                                                    failed because the Council set catch                     This timeframe also provides flexibility                We notified the Council about the
                                                    limits to maximize fishing opportunity                   to better address the needs of fishing                lack of progress under the 2004
                                                    rather than promote stock conservation,                  communities compared to rebuilding                    rebuilding plan following the 2012
                                                    and because the Council prolonged                        programs that target an earlier end date.             GOM cod benchmark assessment. We
                                                    overfishing by choosing the maximum                                                                            determined that inadequate progress
                                                                                                             Basis for Denial                                      under the 2004 rebuilding plan was due
                                                    rebuilding timeline possible.
                                                       • The 2014 GOM cod interim                               Section 304 of the Magnuson-Stevens                to a revised understanding of the
                                                    measures did not temporarily address                     Act provides the Secretary of Commerce                condition of the stock since the 2008
                                                    overfishing or allow for stock                           with the authority to prepare and                     GOM cod assessment. In response to the
                                                    rebuilding, and were only projected to                   implement a fishery management plan if                new understanding of the status of the
                                                    result in a 33-percent reduction in                      the Council fails to develop and submit               GOM cod stock, we worked with the
mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS




                                                    fishing mortality in spite of advice from                a plan or amendment after a reasonable                Council to implement measures to
                                                    the Council’s Scientific and Statistical                 period of time that meets necessary                   reduce overfishing and revise the
                                                    Committee (SSC) that a 75-percent                        conservation and management                           rebuilding plan as swiftly as possible
                                                    reduction in fishing limits was                          objectives. Or, the agency may put in                 though a 2012 interim action, and
                                                    necessary.                                               place emergency regulations or interim                Frameworks 50 and 51. These actions
                                                       • The 386-mt GOM cod ABC                              measures to address an emergency or                   incorporated new information and
                                                    recommended by the Council in                            overfishing. An emergency rulemaking                  lessons from past management
                                                    Framework 53 is above the legal limit                    allows actions to prevent overfishing or              approaches. Our review of the Council’s


                                               VerDate Sep<11>2014   17:25 Jul 09, 2015   Jkt 235001   PO 00000   Frm 00014   Fmt 4702   Sfmt 4702   E:\FR\FM\10JYP1.SGM   10JYP1


                                                                               Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 132 / Friday, July 10, 2015 / Proposed Rules                                           39733

                                                    revised 2014 GOM cod rebuilding plan                       We will continue to carefully consider              misreport catch. If misreporting occurs,
                                                    adopted in Framework 51 indicated that                   management measures to promote                        it could reduce the accuracy of catch
                                                    the Council addressed past rebuilding                    timely rebuilding of the GOM cod stock.               apportionment. Information indicates
                                                    performance and accelerated the                          In an effort to closely monitor stock                 that this incentive increases as the GOM
                                                    rebuilding timeline by setting more                      indicators, we reviewed the recent fall               cod catch limit is further reduced. To
                                                    conservative catch limits in the early                   2014 NEFSC bottom trawl survey                        help ensure correct catch apportionment
                                                    portion of the rebuilding program.                       indices. The fall survey indicated a                  and compliance with the GOM cod ACL
                                                                                                             small increase compared to 2012 and                   adopted in Framework 53, we also
                                                    2014 Interim Action
                                                                                                             2013; however, the general trend of                   implemented an additional daily
                                                       We reject the petitioners claim that                  survey indices, as well as recruitment,               reporting requirement for common pool
                                                    the 2014 interim action insufficiently                   remains very low. While the updated                   and sector vessels fishing in multiple
                                                    addressed the information provided in                    survey information may provide an                     broad stock areas on the same trip. This
                                                    the updated assessment. One of our                       initial, and potentially positive,                    requirement is intended to help ensure
                                                    primary objectives of the interim action                 indication of improvement, it is difficult            accurate catch attribution and reduce
                                                    was to reduce overfishing by reducing                    to anticipate the results of the full 2015            the incentive for vessels to misreport.
                                                    GOM cod commercial and recreational                      assessment. In any event, we plan to                     We do not share the petitioners’ view
                                                    catch. Given the mixed nature of the                     make necessary adjustments for the                    that 100-percent observer coverage is
                                                    groundfish fishery and its interaction                   2016 fishing year based on the                        necessary to monitor GOM cod fishing
                                                    with other fisheries, this objective was                 upcoming 2015 stock assessment.                       mortality. Rather, we apply at-sea
                                                    analyzed in the context of not closing                                                                         monitoring coverage levels that we
                                                    down the entire GOM, but to allow                        Incidental Fishing Mortality                          determine are necessary to monitor and
                                                    some harvesting of other groundfish                         The petitioners request prohibiting                enforce catch levels, or increase buffers
                                                    stocks. We wanted to reduce GOM cod                      fishing mortality until incidental                    to account for uncertainty in catch as
                                                    mortality while the Council developed                    mortality does not exceed the ABC. An                 part of the biennial quota-setting
                                                    more permanent measures in                               ABC of 386 mt is expected to have                     process. We have received similar
                                                    Framework 53. We determined it was                       substantial adverse economic impacts                  comments on prior groundfish
                                                    unnecessary to try to prevent all fishing                on groundfish vessels, and is below the               rulemakings requesting high levels of
                                                    mortality for the remainder of the 2014                  estimate of incidental catch of GOM cod               observer coverage for the commercial
                                                    fishing year as the stock can rebuild                    that occurred in the 2013 fishing year.               fishery since the implementation of
                                                    even if subject to overfishing in 2014 as                In the 2013 fishing year, when the ACL                Amendment 16. For the most part,
                                                    long as measures would be in place to                    was reduced by 80 percent, incidental                 commenters have generally asserted that
                                                    prevent overfishing beginning in 2015.                   catch was estimated to be approximately               the levels of monitoring we have
                                                    Achieving zero fishing mortality would                   500–600 mt. Beginning in the 2013                     implemented are inadequate without
                                                    have required closing all GOM fisheries,                 fishing year, sectors primarily used their            providing any specific justification or
                                                    including those that do not target                       GOM cod allocation to access other                    information to support their assertion.
                                                    groundfish. The impacts of such                          groundfish stocks. Multiple sources of                   For sector trips, we have determined
                                                    measures would be substantial and                        information indicate a marked decline                 that 24-percent observer coverage is
                                                    impracticable. Such a closure was                        in directed fishing for GOM cod. With                 sufficient this fishing year, to the extent
                                                    unwarranted to ensure effective cod                      an additional 75-percent reduction                    practicable in light of Magnuson-
                                                    conservation.                                            beginning in the 2015 fishing year, the               Stevens Act requirements, to reliably
                                                                                                             incentive to target GOM cod is virtually              estimate catch for purposes of
                                                    Framework 53 GOM Cod ABC
                                                                                                             eliminated, and the fishery will be, in               monitoring ACLs for groundfish stocks.
                                                       Most recently, we considered public                   effect, a ‘‘bycatch-only’’ fishery.                   This level of coverage is achieved
                                                    comment on and supporting analysis for                   Incidental catch is largely a function of             through a combination of groundfish at-
                                                    Framework 53 and the 2015 recreational                   the overall ACLs on other stocks. At                  sea monitoring coverage and observer
                                                    measures, and the best scientific                        such a low GOM cod catch limit, fishery               coverage furnished by the Northeast
                                                    information available in making the                      operations will be greatly restricted, and            Fisheries Observer Program.
                                                    determination that an ABC of 386 mt                      in some cases eliminated. In addition,                Amendment 16 specified that at-sea
                                                    was appropriate and consistent with the                  the recreational fishery will be                      monitoring coverage levels should be
                                                    requirements of the Magnuson-Stevens                     prohibited from possessing any GOM                    less than 100 percent, which requires
                                                    Act and its National Standards. In light                 cod. Under this incidental catch                      estimations of the discard portion of
                                                    of current stock conditions, the 386 mt                  scenario, the GOM cod ABC is expected                 catch and thus total catch. Amendment
                                                    ABC is a 75-percent catch limit                          to severely restrict catch of other                   16 also specified that the at-sea
                                                    reduction compared to 2014, which is in                  groundfish stocks, particularly GOM                   monitoring coverage levels should
                                                    addition to the 80-percent reduction                     haddock, pollock, redfish, and some                   achieve a 30-percent coefficient of
                                                    implemented for the 2013–2014 fishing                    flatfish. Based on this information, the              variation (CV). The level of observer
                                                    years. In total, the GOM cod catch limit                 386-mt ABC balances Magnuson-                         coverage, ultimately, should provide
                                                    has been reduced by 95 percent over the                  Stevens Act requirements of                           confidence that the overall catch
                                                    last 5 years. Further, new recreational                  conservation and achieving optimum                    estimate is sufficiently accurate to
                                                    measures prohibit recreational                           yield.                                                ensure that sector fishing activities are
                                                    fishermen from retaining any GOM cod.                                                                          consistent with National Standard 1
mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS




                                                    This is the first zero-retention                         Monitoring and Catch Accounting                       requirements to prevent overfishing
                                                    prohibition on GOM cod for recreational                    The petitioners raised a concern that               while achieving optimum yield. To that
                                                    fishermen. Detailed information that                     inaccurate accounting for catch could                 end, significant additional uncertainty
                                                    addresses the petitioners concerns about                 undermine conservation objectives for                 buffers are established when setting
                                                    the GOM cod ABC and further justifies                    GOM cod. We share their concern, and                  ACLs that mitigate any lack of absolute
                                                    our decision to approve an ABC of 386                    available analyses suggest that an                    precision and accuracy in estimating
                                                    mt can be found in the Framework 53                      extremely low catch limit for GOM cod                 overall catch by sector vessels.
                                                    final rule (see pages 25125–25127).                      may create an economic incentive to                   Collectively, the current level of sector


                                               VerDate Sep<11>2014   17:25 Jul 09, 2015   Jkt 235001   PO 00000   Frm 00015   Fmt 4702   Sfmt 4702   E:\FR\FM\10JYP1.SGM   10JYP1


                                                    39734                      Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 132 / Friday, July 10, 2015 / Proposed Rules

                                                    observer coverage is providing more                      Atmospheric Administration (NOAA),                    Specifications Final Environmental
                                                    data for quota management and                            Commerce.                                             Impact Statement (Final EIS),
                                                    assessment science than was available                    ACTION: Proposed rule; request for                    Supplementary Information Report (SIR)
                                                    to NMFS prior to implementation of                       comments.                                             to the Final EIS, and the Initial
                                                    Amendment 16.                                                                                                  Regulatory Flexibility Analysis (IRFA)
                                                       On February 18, 2014, in Oceana, Inc.                 SUMMARY:    NMFS proposes regulations to              for the Gulf of Alaska Groundfish
                                                    v. Pritzker, 1:13–cv–00770 (D.D.C.                       reduce the maximum retainable amount                  Harvest Specifications for 2015 and
                                                    2014), the Court upheld our use of a 30-                 (MRA) of skates using groundfish and                  2016 (Harvest Specifications IRFA)
                                                    percent CV standard to set sector                        halibut as basis species in the Gulf of               prepared for this action are available
                                                    observer coverage levels. In addition to                 Alaska (GOA) from 20 percent to 5                     from http://www.regulations.gov or from
                                                    upholding our determination of                           percent. Reducing skate MRAs is                       the NMFS Alaska Region Web site at
                                                    sufficient coverage levels, the Court                    necessary to decrease the incentive for               http://alaskafisheries.noaa.gov.
                                                    noted that the current sector observer                   fishermen to target skates and slow the               FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
                                                    coverage is not the sole method of                       catch rate of skates in these fisheries.              Peggy Murphy, 907–586–7228.
                                                    monitoring compliance with ACLs,                         This proposed rule would enhance
                                                                                                                                                                   SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
                                                    there are many reporting requirements                    conservation and management of skates
                                                    that vessels adhere to, and there are                    and minimize skate discards in GOA                    Authority for Action
                                                    strong incentives for vessels to report                  groundfish and halibut fisheries. This                   NMFS manages the groundfish
                                                    accurately because each sector is held                   proposed rule is intended to promote                  fisheries in the exclusive economic zone
                                                    jointly and severally liable for overages                the goals and objectives of the                       of the GOA under the Fishery
                                                    and misreporting of catch and bycatch.                   Magnuson-Stevens Fishery                              Management Plan for Groundfish of the
                                                                                                             Conservation and Management Act, the                  Gulf of Alaska (FMP). The North Pacific
                                                    Conclusion
                                                                                                             Northern Pacific Halibut Act of 1982,                 Fishery Management Council (Council)
                                                      We remain concerned about the status                   the Fishery Management Plan for
                                                    of GOM cod, but have determined that                                                                           prepared the FMP under the authority of
                                                                                                             Groundfish of the Gulf of Alaska, and                 the Magnuson-Stevens Fishery
                                                    the current FMP, as adjusted by                          other applicable laws.
                                                    Framework 53, along with recreational                                                                          Conservation and Management Act
                                                                                                             DATES: Comments must be received no                   (Magnuson-Stevens Act), 16 U.S.C. 1801
                                                    measures and planned future Council                      later than August 10, 2015.
                                                    and agency actions, provide the                                                                                et seq. Regulations governing groundfish
                                                                                                             ADDRESSES: You may submit comments                    fishing in the GOA and implementing
                                                    appropriate regulatory mechanisms for
                                                                                                             on this document, identified by NOAA–                 the FMP appear at 50 CFR parts 600 and
                                                    addressing the concerns regarding this
                                                                                                             NMFS–2015–0015, by any of the                         679. The Council and NMFS manage
                                                    stock that were raised in the petition for
                                                                                                             following methods:                                    skates (Raja and Bathyraja species) as a
                                                    rulemaking. We will continue to
                                                                                                                • Electronic Submission: Submit all                groundfish species under the FMP.
                                                    carefully monitor stock indicators
                                                                                                             electronic public comments via the
                                                    leading into the 2015 assessment to                                                                            Background
                                                                                                             Federal e-Rulemaking Portal. Go to
                                                    fully inform our re-evaluation of the
                                                                                                             www.regulations.gov/                                     NMFS proposes to modify regulations
                                                    GOM cod catch limit, and the need to
                                                                                                             #!docketDetail;D=NOAA-NMFS-2015-                      that specify the MRA for skates in the
                                                    balance conservation and management
                                                                                                             0015, click the ‘‘Comment Now!’’ icon,                GOA. An MRA is the maximum amount
                                                    objectives. Therefore, we are denying
                                                                                                             complete the required fields, and enter               of a species closed to directed fishing
                                                    this petition; no other rulemaking is
                                                                                                             or attach your comments.                              (i.e., skate species) that may be retained
                                                    necessary in response to the petition for
                                                                                                                • Mail: Submit written comments to                 onboard a vessel. MRAs are calculated
                                                    rulemaking.
                                                                                                             Glenn Merrill, Assistant Regional                     as a percentage of the weight of catch of
                                                       Authority: 16 U.S.C. 1801 et seq.                     Administrator, Sustainable Fisheries                  each groundfish species or halibut open
                                                      Dated: July 6, 2015.                                   Division, Alaska Region NMFS, Attn:                   to directed fishing (the basis species)
                                                    Samuel D. Rauch III,                                     Ellen Sebastian. Mail comments to P.O.                that is retained onboard the vessel.
                                                    Deputy Assistant Administrator for                       Box 21668, Juneau, AK 99802–1668.                     MRAs assist in limiting catch of a
                                                    Regulatory Programs, National Marine                        Instructions: Comments sent by any                 species within its annual total allowable
                                                    Fisheries Service.                                       other method, to any other address or                 catch (TAC). Once the TAC for a species
                                                    [FR Doc. 2015–16891 Filed 7–9–15; 8:45 am]               individual, or received after the end of              is reached, retention of that species
                                                    BILLING CODE 3510–22–P                                   the comment period, may not be                        becomes prohibited and all catch of that
                                                                                                             considered by NMFS. All comments                      species must be discarded. NMFS closes
                                                                                                             received are a part of the public record              a species to directed fishing before the
                                                    DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE                                   and will generally be posted for public               entire TAC is taken to leave sufficient
                                                                                                             viewing on www.regulations.gov                        amounts of the TAC available for
                                                    National Oceanic and Atmospheric                         without change. All personal identifying              incidental catch. The amount of the
                                                    Administration                                           information (e.g., name, address),                    TAC remaining available for incidental
                                                                                                             confidential business information, or                 catch is managed by a species-specific
                                                    50 CFR Part 679                                          otherwise sensitive information                       MRA. MRAs are a management tool to
                                                    [Docket No. 150126078–5078–01]                           submitted voluntarily by the sender will              slow down the rate of harvest and
                                                                                                             be publicly accessible. NMFS will                     reduce the incentive for targeting a
mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS




                                                    RIN 0648–BE85                                            accept anonymous comments (enter ‘‘N/                 species closed to directed fishing.
                                                                                                             A’’ in the required fields if you wish to             NMFS has established a single MRA
                                                    Fisheries of the Exclusive Economic
                                                                                                             remain anonymous).                                    percentage for big skate (Raja
                                                    Zone Off Alaska; Revise Maximum
                                                                                                                Electronic copies of the draft                     binoculata), longnose skate (Raja rhina),
                                                    Retainable Amounts for Skates in the
                                                                                                             Environmental Assessment/Regulatory                   and for all remaining skate species
                                                    Gulf of Alaska
                                                                                                             Impact Review/Initial Regulatory                      (Bathyraja spp.). The skate MRA in the
                                                    AGENCY:  National Marine Fisheries                       Flexibility Analysis (collectively the                GOA is set at 20 percent. The proposed
                                                    Service (NMFS), National Oceanic and                     ‘‘Analysis’’), Alaska Groundfish Harvest              rule would reduce the MRA for skates


                                               VerDate Sep<11>2014   17:25 Jul 09, 2015   Jkt 235001   PO 00000   Frm 00016   Fmt 4702   Sfmt 4702   E:\FR\FM\10JYP1.SGM   10JYP1



Document Created: 2018-02-23 09:15:44
Document Modified: 2018-02-23 09:15:44
CategoryRegulatory Information
CollectionFederal Register
sudoc ClassAE 2.7:
GS 4.107:
AE 2.106:
PublisherOffice of the Federal Register, National Archives and Records Administration
SectionProposed Rules
ActionNotice of agency decision.
DatesThe petition for rulemaking was denied on June 4, 2015.
ContactWilliam Whitmore, Fishery Policy Analyst, phone: 978-281-9182; email: [email protected]
FR Citation80 FR 39731 
RIN Number0648-XE00

2025 Federal Register | Disclaimer | Privacy Policy
USC | CFR | eCFR